Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist people bring their own food to a family picnic?

239 replies

moosmum21 · 06/04/2023 11:53

The extended family wants a picnic tomorrow, although half of the guest list is tentative. No one is willing to help buy or prepare anything for the picnic, so my MIL suggested that I prepare it, and we all split the bill equally.

Conscious that everyone is time and cash poor and not wanting to waste lots of food if half don’t show up, I suggested that we all prepare packed lunches for ourselves, which was met with a complaint: "That’s not a picnic; that’s a meal deal in a park”.
I know that if I were to prepare a picnic and split the cost of the ingredients equally amongst all the attendees as suggested, there would be bill shock and squabbling.
I could prepare the picnic and sink the cost, wholly or by charging a modest contribution fee. I enjoy cooking (no one else in the family does!), and we are moderately well off compared to the rest of the family – it’s not a huge imposition. But I don’t want to set up the expectation that I’ll just cater and pay for every barbecue, picnic, holiday, and party. I’m also still apparently holding a grudge over the Christmas cake incident (a family member stopped by when I was making a Christmas cake for my family, told me that she hoped I was making her one, and then insisted I’d have to make cakes for other family members, so they didn’t feel left out. She neglected to mention that no one in the family likes Christmas cake, so most of it was wasted!) AIBU to stick firm with the suggestion that we bring our own food? Or should I let go of the grudge, prepare a lovely picnic, and sink the cost so we can all have a peaceful day out?

OP posts:
ShandaLear · 06/04/2023 12:48

Surely everyone just brings a thing - some sausage rolls, scotch eggs, a quiche, sandwiches, fruit, cheese and a few baguettes, and you have a picnic buffet type of thing. Every once can bring their own drinks. I wouldn’t expect to go on a picnic and have someone cater it unless it was a birthday party or something similar.

thecrispfiend · 06/04/2023 12:48

This happens in my family, DB just expects my mum to cater for all which she does - even tho Sis and I bring stuff to share she over compensates for DB (who btw brings his own 3 kids, partner and partners 3 kids!) and turns up with nothing it drives me bonkers

Teatime55 · 06/04/2023 12:46

Don’t do this. Most stuff you eat at picnics you can just buy and cut up. The only thing you might want to make specifically is sandwiches.
I’m sure they could all pop to a shop and buy sausage rolls, crisps, a cake etc. not exactly hard.

Eddielizzard · 06/04/2023 12:45

Jog on MIL. Those who don't want to bring food can sort themselves out. What a cheek!

FranksOcean · 06/04/2023 12:45

YANBU, I’d cancel

Dobby123456 · 06/04/2023 12:44

A picnic: Everybody prepares their own food and brings it to eat outside.
A meal deal in a park: When people who couldn't be bothered to prepare their own picnic stop off at tescos on the way.
Someone preparing all the food for other people's families to eat in the park: Just really cheeky.

Genevieva · 06/04/2023 12:44

Say you are staying out of it. You are happy to meet up and fit in with what everyone else wants to do - walk or walk followed by a meal - but you don't have time to cater for everyone and you don't want to get involved in any disagreements. They can let you know when they have decided when and where to meet and whether or not you should bring your own picnic or thermos of tea.

ZirihePevzig · 06/04/2023 12:44

Send out a message that says
"I don't mind catering but I hate wasting food and too many people are only saying a tentative yes rather than a firm yes, so if I cater then there could be loads of waste. If you are definitely coming then paypal/BACS me £10 per head for who will definitely be there, and I will make sure that is spent on a variety of lovely food and drink. Anyone who doesn't contribute money by 16:00 can obviously still come but needs to bring with them an apppropriate quantitiy of food/drink to contribute to what is on-offer, so that we aren't trying to share out food for 8 people between 16."

That way it's not a packed-lunch in the park, but anyone who wants to swing by without having paid in advance can bring an M&S tub of sausage rolls or antipasti and you won't run out of food.

QuickNameChangeForMeToday · 06/04/2023 12:43

Maray1967 · 06/04/2023 12:31

Perfect response. No way would I be doing all this catering for the in-laws who volunteer me!!

Absolutely this. Alternatively would walk after lunch then coffee and cake if that’s more affordable for all?

Skyeheather · 06/04/2023 12:42

Sounds like SIL1 wants a day out but doesn't want to spend any money/can't afford to. Sounds like she might complain when you tell her what her share is? Or will end up not paying?

Can you not just have an afternoon in the park, so everyone has lunch at home beforehand. Find a park with a cafe or ice cream van for anyone that wants a treat.

Shinyandnew1 · 06/04/2023 12:39

They are a bunch of CF!

Say, ‘ok then, if you don’t want a ‘meal deal in the park’, let’s meet at X for a walk at 11 and people who want to eat, can go to X restaurant afterwards and those who don’t, can just go straight home. We can all pay for ourselves that way.

No way would I be catering for everyone-it really sound like they’ll pay!

mondaytosunday · 06/04/2023 12:38

Every picnic I've been to with other people we all agree to bring something, like one person will bring a couple big salads, another sausage rolls, another a few different drink options and so on. So each of you bring a dish big enough to share.
Totally unreasonable for you to do all the prep then try and get money out of people, and if everyone only brings what they eat that's not very fun.
However, overall I'm impressed you think the weather will be nice enough for a picnic (if you live in the UK).

HelpsHeal · 06/04/2023 12:34

I known it's a bit of a boring MN post but presumably there are some of DH/FIL/BILs....

SheilaFentiman · 06/04/2023 12:33

Maray1967 · 06/04/2023 12:31

Perfect response. No way would I be doing all this catering for the in-laws who volunteer me!!

I also agree with @Xiaoxiong - if you suggest one SIL brings quiche to share, one pizza etc, what’s the betting you are the only person bringing enough for all??

wantmorenow · 06/04/2023 12:33

This programme https://to-do.live.com/tasks/ says you can write a to do list and share. Maybe there are other easier apps that have this function too.

Share a list of things to bring and each member of family takes it as their to do item - everyone can see what's been agreed and no hidden surprises or miscommunication about who was supposed to bring crisps etc.

Either that or just say no - I would say no. You just can't argue with or please difficult CF people

Microsoft To Do

Microsoft To Do

https://to-do.live.com/tasks

avocadotofu · 06/04/2023 12:32

Xiaoxiong · 06/04/2023 12:21

I'd text back "happy with MIL's walk and bite to eat idea, or each family bringing their own picnic, just let me know what you decide!"

I'd go with this reply. I think you need to start saying no. And definitely don't feel bad about it, they sound ridiculous.

Maray1967 · 06/04/2023 12:31

Xiaoxiong · 06/04/2023 12:21

I'd text back "happy with MIL's walk and bite to eat idea, or each family bringing their own picnic, just let me know what you decide!"

Perfect response. No way would I be doing all this catering for the in-laws who volunteer me!!

avocadotofu · 06/04/2023 12:28

People seriously can't sort their own food for a picnic? Seriously?! I would not agree to organise a picnic for everyone. If your MIL thinks it's a good idea why doesn't she sort it?

AdoraBell · 06/04/2023 12:27

Say you don’t have time to prepare food for everyone, you’ll do the food for your own family. Repeat like a broken record.

Heronwatcher · 06/04/2023 12:26

Plus this is VERY VERY normal
amongst non CF people, if I was invited to a picnic I’d assume I’d be bringing my own food unless asked to do otherwise. I’d bring enough for my kids and me, plus maybe some bits to share around like crisps, mini rolls, fruit etc.

Thelastunicorns · 06/04/2023 12:26

YANBU. We do regular picnics with the in-laws - usually PIL, and DH’s siblings with their partners and children.

It’s so much easier for everyone to bring their own stuff, particularly with younger children. We also bring a few extra treats to share between the group, eg we might bring a cake, SIL might bring cheese & crackers etc, but generally everyone contributes equally.

Ktime · 06/04/2023 12:25

Xiaoxiong · 06/04/2023 12:23

I wouldn't even entertain the "everyone bring a dish" idea if OP is the only one who cooks. It's likely she'll turn up with something amazing that everyone will scoff and they'll bring 2 greggs sausage rolls to go round 15 people.

Good point!

HelpsHeal · 06/04/2023 12:25

If MIL's preference is to have a meal out and that suits you, I might be inclined to say something like

"As we don't seem to be able to organise the picnic together, shall we revert to plan A and find a restaurant?"

If SIL doesn't want that she needs to step up.

I think they'll all be surprised at the cost of providing a "nice" picnic and you'll have problems there, even if you were inclined to do it.

Heronwatcher · 06/04/2023 12:24

No way! The basic issue is that your extended family apparently “want” a picnic but can’t be arsed to lift a finger to achieve this! I’d simply say “we will be in x park/ area from x time tomorrow, would be lovely to see you, you’re welcome to bring your own picnic to join us or there is a cafe at y and a shop at z.” Don’t get into spending loads of money and time when half the people won’t turn up and the others will then quibble about the money. If your MIL wants to arrange catering herself for all the others she knows where you’lol be.

Xiaoxiong · 06/04/2023 12:23

I wouldn't even entertain the "everyone bring a dish" idea if OP is the only one who cooks. It's likely she'll turn up with something amazing that everyone will scoff and they'll bring 2 greggs sausage rolls to go round 15 people.