Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Sceptic1234 · 07/04/2023 09:24

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 07:46

But it’s not like people are walking round unaware of having DSD as TRAs would have us believe.

.....very rare but it can happen in complete androgen sensitivity. Biological male fetus with total inability to respond to testosterone. At birth, external genitalia look female. Some testosterone is normally metabolized to oestrogen ... this can be enough to drive breast development female body shape. These people will have no idea they are not biologically female until periods don't appear at puberty. This condition is very, very rare. Most cases of androgen insensitivity has some residual capacity to respond to testosterone.

And yes.....I spent years doing research into steroid hormones. Now retired and out of date.

cherriestort · 07/04/2023 09:21

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

A very fair point!

Sceptic1234 · 07/04/2023 09:15

aurynne · 07/04/2023 08:50

I am another geneticist, and I can confirm the OP is not one. Perhaps a student who happened to read the research articles about residual fetal cells in mothers and got all excited about it, but definitely not a geneticist, because the OP very obviously, and embarrassingly, lacks any deeper knowledge in genetics that would easily allow her(?) to put that article in context.

OP, please stop embarrassing yourself.

Residual fetal cells in mothers are few and far between. They would not come up in a genetic test. They would not invade other tissues and start replicating.

Cells in a cheek have been formed and differentiated many years before that person becomes a mother. The great majority of cells in an adult body have gone through a process of differentiation and barely replicate anymore, unless it is for repairing an injury. So no, a residual fetal cell won't form a "chunk" of cells inside a person's cheek to the point that a cheek swab would show fetal cells. if that happened, then the problem would not only be Y chromosomes appearing... if the woman had a baby girl instead of a boy, then the genetic test could show a completely different person whatsoever. No, it doesn't happen..

A hand touching a door know does not leave "cells" behind unless it's covered in bodily fluids or has an open wound. Forensic science would look for fingerprints on the door, not "cells".

You're as much a geneticist as I am King Charles.

Very true..... only very minor point is that nucleoted blood cells can occaisionally become incorporated and functioning bone marrow. As you say....makes no difference if the baby is make or female. I have similar post above.....former colleague used to go on about this all the time!

MaireadMcSweeney · 07/04/2023 08:53

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 07:46

But it’s not like people are walking round unaware of having DSD as TRAs would have us believe.

No, but they do use it to enter female sports categories and beat women...that's the issue under discussion isn't it?

aurynne · 07/04/2023 08:50

I am another geneticist, and I can confirm the OP is not one. Perhaps a student who happened to read the research articles about residual fetal cells in mothers and got all excited about it, but definitely not a geneticist, because the OP very obviously, and embarrassingly, lacks any deeper knowledge in genetics that would easily allow her(?) to put that article in context.

OP, please stop embarrassing yourself.

Residual fetal cells in mothers are few and far between. They would not come up in a genetic test. They would not invade other tissues and start replicating.

Cells in a cheek have been formed and differentiated many years before that person becomes a mother. The great majority of cells in an adult body have gone through a process of differentiation and barely replicate anymore, unless it is for repairing an injury. So no, a residual fetal cell won't form a "chunk" of cells inside a person's cheek to the point that a cheek swab would show fetal cells. if that happened, then the problem would not only be Y chromosomes appearing... if the woman had a baby girl instead of a boy, then the genetic test could show a completely different person whatsoever. No, it doesn't happen..

A hand touching a door know does not leave "cells" behind unless it's covered in bodily fluids or has an open wound. Forensic science would look for fingerprints on the door, not "cells".

You're as much a geneticist as I am King Charles.

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 08:43

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 07:28

You have won the argument really. I think this thread just shows exactly why we shouldn’t just blindly belief scientists- common sense should always prevail. Scientists have agendas too.

I don’t think science is the problem here.

QuinkWashable · 07/04/2023 08:17

This thread was resolved on the first page by SNWannabe:

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 07:54

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 16:23

haha! I'm back, but not much point in answering any of this, as it is just the same things I've already answered being repeated over and over...

I dont think anyone scanning through this thread would have any difficulty identifying the ignorance and aggression that I was referring to though.

Still, I expect there are at least some readers who understand better now.

Yep we all understand the “I’m a scientist” foot stomping counts for did all when it comes to reality😂.

you realise that just because someone disagrees with you it doesn’t make them aggressive.

most are just laughing because you are missing the blindingly obvious. Why would anyone in their right mind think someone who has been pregnant and given birth is a man. TBH at this point there’s nothing to do but laugh

thegrain · 07/04/2023 07:49

Don't forget to go visiting your neighbours gardens. Have a great day. Meow.

Clymene · 07/04/2023 07:48

PriamFarrl · 07/04/2023 07:44

I wonder how people get through life if they see ‘crack on’ and just generally being disagreed with as being aggressive.

Some people live a very rich fantasy life so don't engage much in the real world

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 07:46

MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 16:46

46XY DSD
this is from the NHS website
People with this disorder can have female appearing genitals however they have much much higher levels of testosterone than a female so when they go through puberty they masculinise the way boys do.

But it’s not like people are walking round unaware of having DSD as TRAs would have us believe.

PriamFarrl · 07/04/2023 07:44

I wonder how people get through life if they see ‘crack on’ and just generally being disagreed with as being aggressive.

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 07:44

Awesome! Off to spend the day lounging around before demanding food. Stuff work, that’s for the non-cat people.

thegrain · 07/04/2023 07:42

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 00:55

My cat licked me!! Am I now part cat? This is truly truly the thread that keeps on giving

Yes, yes you are.

Clymene · 07/04/2023 07:41

Sorry see someone else has already said that. What a busy life you lead!

thegrain · 07/04/2023 07:41

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

Ha! Thats so true

Clymene · 07/04/2023 07:40

You're a geneticist? I thought you were a teacher

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 07:37

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 17:47

Except she says she's a maths teacher

Maybe she’s a biology teacher who self identifies as a maths teacher on Thursdays??? Bloody hell, I can’t believe the bigotry here😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂, all these Cis geneticists and Cis maths teachers excluding her from their specialist areas just because she doesn’t seem to have a clue.

TBH in all seriousness I’m concerned this person will be pushing this uneducated shit on kids.

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 07:28

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

You have won the argument really. I think this thread just shows exactly why we shouldn’t just blindly belief scientists- common sense should always prevail. Scientists have agendas too.

ZombieMumEB · 07/04/2023 04:46

caringcarer · 07/04/2023 01:45

If a chromosome test on a female athlete showed a Y chromosome they could test another sample cell and also do a scan to look for internal organs, ovaries and a womb or testes either external or internal ones like Casta Semenya has.

No No No!

That's not the story the TRA's want to tell.

They want to scare women into believing that every single female athlete will be subject to a genital inspection before each competition.

SinnerBoy · 07/04/2023 02:45

Happylittlechicken · Today 00:55

My cat licked me!! Am I now part cat?

I wouldn't worry, unless you start pooing in the flowerbeds and scratching fence posts.

caringcarer · 07/04/2023 01:45

If a chromosome test on a female athlete showed a Y chromosome they could test another sample cell and also do a scan to look for internal organs, ovaries and a womb or testes either external or internal ones like Casta Semenya has.

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 00:55

My cat licked me!! Am I now part cat? This is truly truly the thread that keeps on giving

Furries · 06/04/2023 22:23

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 16:23

haha! I'm back, but not much point in answering any of this, as it is just the same things I've already answered being repeated over and over...

I dont think anyone scanning through this thread would have any difficulty identifying the ignorance and aggression that I was referring to though.

Still, I expect there are at least some readers who understand better now.

Am so glad that you put this thread in AIBU.

So yes, hopefully there are lots of readers who understand better now (thanks to all of those who have responded to your posts).

Just to clarify, as a reader, there was no ignorance or aggression in 99% of the posts (rough guess - I’m not a mathematician).

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 20:30

You haven't answered anything and I, for one, am as much in the dark about the reason you started this thread as I was when I first read it.

I thought it was quite clear why OP started the thread; if it is impossible to tell some women from men then we should let men play women’s sport if they want to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread