Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 07/04/2023 10:27

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

Superb post

Thelnebriati · 07/04/2023 10:26

IDK, if I was courting negative comments online I might start to wonder if I had a humiliation fetish or something.

noblegiraffe · 07/04/2023 10:22

And a science teacher and virologist.

Clymene · 07/04/2023 10:14

To my knowledge, the OP has identified as a geneticist, a secondary school maths teacher, and autism expert.

A veritable Mr Benn

sashh · 07/04/2023 10:04

If you have a bone marrow transplant your blood DNA becomes that of your donor, but that does not make you a clone of your donor.

PriamFarrl · 07/04/2023 10:04

Going right back to the opening post, the OP says this:

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

What posts?
Who has said this?
Has there ever been a case of someone being declared male on account of one single Y chromosome?

SmartHome · 07/04/2023 10:03

Yes. Anyone believing themselves to be female who hadn't started periods (for any reason) by 17/18 would be having extensive medical investigations, in the West, and anyone from a poorer country with less access to healthcare would get it when they presented to a sporting governing body now to register to take part in a sport now as there is more awareness of what people were doing in Africa and India - scouting for men with DSDs to put in female sports.

Females with DSDs wouldn't be showing up for elite male sports.

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 10:03

Very rare instances by puberty you would know.

if you lived in a country where you have access to testing and scans.

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 09:58

Sceptic1234 · 07/04/2023 09:24

.....very rare but it can happen in complete androgen sensitivity. Biological male fetus with total inability to respond to testosterone. At birth, external genitalia look female. Some testosterone is normally metabolized to oestrogen ... this can be enough to drive breast development female body shape. These people will have no idea they are not biologically female until periods don't appear at puberty. This condition is very, very rare. Most cases of androgen insensitivity has some residual capacity to respond to testosterone.

And yes.....I spent years doing research into steroid hormones. Now retired and out of date.

So even in those very. Very rare instances by puberty you would know.

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 09:57

Again, a DSD is only one reason why somebody might not start periods at the normal time. There are other reasons including low body weight, hormone imbalance. It should be investigated, for health reasons primarily - certainly if somebody is involved in high level competition.

Annoyingwurringnoise · 07/04/2023 09:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Florissant · 07/04/2023 09:49

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 16:23

haha! I'm back, but not much point in answering any of this, as it is just the same things I've already answered being repeated over and over...

I dont think anyone scanning through this thread would have any difficulty identifying the ignorance and aggression that I was referring to though.

Still, I expect there are at least some readers who understand better now.

I understood right from the beginning that you don't know what you're talking about. Your further posts have only confirmed that.

SmartHome · 07/04/2023 09:47

Even the few people with CAIS would know they had a DSD by puberty when periods didn't appear, before they became athletes. Genetic testing would confirm it. Also, DSDs are rare. Even the countries that were prepared to cheat and recruit male people from impoverished baxkgrounds with DSDs to put into elite women's athletics managed to come up with, what, 6 or 7 people? In an entire generation of athletes. They can no longer do so as there is so much more scrutiny now. People knew for years that CS was male and people will notice if another male looking athlete who has never had a period shows up. Testosterone levels would be picked up in males the other DSDs that do go through male puberty

The whole 'what about DSDs' is another strawman distraction technique from the TRAs. Extremely rare, obvious, easy to test for and has absolutely nothing to do with genetically normal men in women's sport - like Lia Thomas, the NZ weightlifter and all the rest of they. All of whom are genetically typical XY men.

Inertia · 07/04/2023 09:42

What I don’t understand is how all these hostile, aggressive, hysterical rampaging women the OP speaks of are getting access to confidential laboratory tests.

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 09:39

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 09:36

Science isn’t the problem, but scientists can be

I don’t think the OP has displayed any evidence that they are a scientist.

I’m not sure that they have even looked this up on Wikipedia.

But they say they’re a geneticist therefore it must be true! They have used big words and everything

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 09:37

Kucinghitam · 07/04/2023 09:29

You're as much a geneticist as I am King Charles.

Ah, but the OP identified as a geneticist, so you see that makes it so Wink Last week the OP identified as a maths teacher, which was therefore also true.

She also identified that none of us silly MN wims have anything higher than GSCE Biology, so that also becomes reality, and we all to be greatly impressed by science-y gobbledegook being bestowed upon our fluffy pram-filled heads by greater intelligences.

This Is The Way.

….The Truth and the Life (John 14:6) It’s almost like this is some kind of new religion, complete with indoctrination, apologetics, inquisitions and heresies punishable by (social media and career) death. Like Christianity it fucks over women, has little basis in fact. Is driven by a lust for power and money, children are abused and is blindly followed by believers.

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 09:36

Science isn’t the problem, but scientists can be

I don’t think the OP has displayed any evidence that they are a scientist.

I’m not sure that they have even looked this up on Wikipedia.

Sceptic1234 · 07/04/2023 09:34

.....forget a lot of stuff that was once second nature.

Whoops hit send.

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 09:34

And there are various reasons why somebody who is biologically female wouldn’t have periods.

Sceptic1234 · 07/04/2023 09:33

Very true....retained internal testes have a huge risk of developing malignant tumours.

Cant stress enough....complete androgen insensitivity is very rare.

I am retired and out of date now. The sad thing about getting out of date with a complex subject like this is that it happens very quickly, and you

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 09:30

These people will have no idea they are not biologically female until periods don't appear at puberty.

which will almost certainly be investigated in a country with universal healthcare, but not necessarily in a country without, as it isn’t life threatening.

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 09:29

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 08:43

I don’t think science is the problem here.

Science isn’t the problem, but scientists can be

Kucinghitam · 07/04/2023 09:29

You're as much a geneticist as I am King Charles.

Ah, but the OP identified as a geneticist, so you see that makes it so Wink Last week the OP identified as a maths teacher, which was therefore also true.

She also identified that none of us silly MN wims have anything higher than GSCE Biology, so that also becomes reality, and we all to be greatly impressed by science-y gobbledegook being bestowed upon our fluffy pram-filled heads by greater intelligences.

This Is The Way.

Star Wars Disney Plus GIF by Disney+
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 07/04/2023 09:28

It would be really helpful if you would tell us what your friend experienced and what aggressive reactions you witnessed?
As this thread stands, you have clarified nothing.

OP clearly hasn't thought of a good story to go with the claim yet.

Helleofabore · 07/04/2023 09:25

I think I remember Dr Emma Hilton tweeting about how sometimes the cells can be in bone marrow. It was a wonderful thought that you might carry part of every feotus with you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread