Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
matis · 07/04/2023 13:49

I'm so confused. I thought the op was a teacher?

Clymene · 07/04/2023 13:49

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 13:38

I contacted MNHQ in the light of submitting several reports of troll hunting.

I don't know enough about genetics to comment on whether the OP is right or wrong though my instinct is that she's wrong and several posters have argued that point effectively.

However she can be wrong without being what some posters are accusing her of.

She's variously said she's a maths teacher, a geneticist and a virologist. All those things can't be true at once.

SerafinasGoose · 07/04/2023 13:46

Well. This thread has been quite the embarrassment, hasn't it?

For the record I'm not a geneticist. And I still know not one homo sapien in the history of recorded modern humans has ever possessed a body capable of producing both large and small gametes.

And as a PP wittily points out, if you've ever given birth that's pretty unassailable evidence of your (immutable) sex.

Claiming scientific expertise simply to make a prize Charlie of yourself really would make me want to name-change and/or disappear. Ouch ...

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 13:38

I contacted MNHQ in the light of submitting several reports of troll hunting.

I don't know enough about genetics to comment on whether the OP is right or wrong though my instinct is that she's wrong and several posters have argued that point effectively.

However she can be wrong without being what some posters are accusing her of.

MarshaBradyo · 07/04/2023 13:31

It doesn’t really matter if the op is female. The pp contacting mnhq to say this means very little.

It’s pretty clear the op gives a variety of professions for whatever reason and is making something up along the way

Pixiedust1234 · 07/04/2023 13:29

I have noticed on MN that if you give statements of facts then they really do need to be backed up. A person saying "because I said so" isn't really helpful in a discussion.

Just so we are clear, this post isn't aimed at anyone in particular. An opinion is personal, facts need to be able to be confirmed by others.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 13:27

TBF, women are not immune to posting poorly thought through comments online!

I have no problem accepting OP is a real, non troll-y human, even an adult female human, but I remain utterly baffled as to how someone can be so stubbornly wrong in the face of irrefutable evidence.

I don’t expect people to admit it or apologise when they are wrong (slinking away is fine!) but continually arguing up is down and grass is blue is something you usually only see in teenagers (who finally admit they were in the wrong when they get to 23-25 ish 😆)

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 13:19

PriamFarrl · 07/04/2023 13:11

How would you know that your friend has met the op?

I'm not prepared to elaborate on that on here. It's potentially outing, as I said. I have though passed the relevant information to MNHQ given the troll hunting on the thread.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 13:16

FatFucker · 07/04/2023 13:09

*FatFucker
I normally can't be assed with these type of threads as they are so obviously TRAs, but this one is just hilarious!!

He's meant to be a geneticist, who's had a female friend who wasn't allowed to race as she tested as male!

I'm loving it! I knew NOTHING about genetics but suspect a hell of lot more than the OP, after reading some of the really interesting PPs.*

The OP is female. Whether you agree with her or not.


Yeah of course they are 🙄

Yes. She is.

PriamFarrl · 07/04/2023 13:11

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 12:54

If you really want to know, I have a good real life friend of many years who has met the OP.

How would you know that your friend has met the op?

FatFucker · 07/04/2023 13:09

*FatFucker
I normally can't be assed with these type of threads as they are so obviously TRAs, but this one is just hilarious!!

He's meant to be a geneticist, who's had a female friend who wasn't allowed to race as she tested as male!

I'm loving it! I knew NOTHING about genetics but suspect a hell of lot more than the OP, after reading some of the really interesting PPs.*

The OP is female. Whether you agree with her or not.


Yeah of course they are 🙄

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 12:54

Pixiedust1234 · 07/04/2023 12:52

ilovesooty · Yesterday 13:20
Shelefttheweb · Yesterday 13:16
How can you be sure?
Show quote history
I know.

??? How do you know if you don't know them in rl?

If you really want to know, I have a good real life friend of many years who has met the OP.

Pixiedust1234 · 07/04/2023 12:52

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 12:43

I didn't claim to know her in RL personally.

ilovesooty · Yesterday 13:20
Shelefttheweb · Yesterday 13:16
How can you be sure?
Show quote history
I know.

??? How do you know if you don't know them in rl?

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 12:43

SmartHome · 07/04/2023 11:56

True. Probably a university Easter project.

Although some othe random person claims to know them in RL. Seems they've recovered enough now form the general anaesthetic to post a new thread about being asexual (strange thing to prioritise when recovering from surgery?), but not enough to come back to this other thread they started and explain what happens to their friend.

I didn't claim to know her in RL personally.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 12:40

SmartHome · 07/04/2023 11:56

True. Probably a university Easter project.

Although some othe random person claims to know them in RL. Seems they've recovered enough now form the general anaesthetic to post a new thread about being asexual (strange thing to prioritise when recovering from surgery?), but not enough to come back to this other thread they started and explain what happens to their friend.

I’ve encountered the poster before - was adamant about a small fact that was easily proven wrong via government docs posted online and refused to budge when shown the evidence (repeatedly).

SmartHome · 07/04/2023 11:56

True. Probably a university Easter project.

Although some othe random person claims to know them in RL. Seems they've recovered enough now form the general anaesthetic to post a new thread about being asexual (strange thing to prioritise when recovering from surgery?), but not enough to come back to this other thread they started and explain what happens to their friend.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 11:40

SmartHome · 07/04/2023 11:24

I think OP is some sort of ChatGPT Turing test testing.

I thought they just regurgitate pre existing info?
I reckon a Chatbot would be a lot more accurate than OP!

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 11:28

youshouldnthaveasked · 07/04/2023 10:36

What about the balls and penis they were born with? You are being utterly ridiculous

Not 100% sure what you mean, but while the OP is clearly confused, people with various specific congenital conditions (CAIS, Swyers) develop as externally female, despite having a Y chromosome.

This is very rare and has nothing to do with what the OP is talking about.

SmartHome · 07/04/2023 11:24

I think OP is some sort of ChatGPT Turing test testing.

Calling · 07/04/2023 11:21

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 17:47

Except she says she's a maths teacher

A geneticist maths teacher, methinks 🕵️‍♀️.... certainly a special person.

TheShellBeach · 07/04/2023 10:38

ATerrorofLeftovers · 07/04/2023 10:34

Same thing in the OP on that thread about how much hostility they’re expecting, but they’re posting anyway.

Maybe OP is a masochist.

youshouldnthaveasked · 07/04/2023 10:36

What about the balls and penis they were born with? You are being utterly ridiculous

ATerrorofLeftovers · 07/04/2023 10:34

ditalini · 07/04/2023 10:27

Op is currently identifying as asexual and promoting the wearing of special rings for this community on a new thread.

Op is renaissance person.

Same thing in the OP on that thread about how much hostility they’re expecting, but they’re posting anyway.

Clymene · 07/04/2023 10:34

noblegiraffe · 07/04/2023 10:22

And a science teacher and virologist.

Ooh I didn't know about those!

Quite the portfolio career

ditalini · 07/04/2023 10:27

Clymene · 07/04/2023 10:14

To my knowledge, the OP has identified as a geneticist, a secondary school maths teacher, and autism expert.

A veritable Mr Benn

Op is currently identifying as asexual and promoting the wearing of special rings for this community on a new thread.

Op is renaissance person.