Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BreviloquentBastard · 06/04/2023 10:27

Right, but no one is testing women who have recently given birth to male babies for microchimerism are they? That's a very small and specific incidence where a biological woman might have a Y chromosome and is completek

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:26

Who is saying they would only test one sample? That's bullshit. They test multiple swab sites. Are you seriously trying to tell me that every single epithelial cell in my body is now XY because I have had 3 sons? Rubbish. And there has been no proof that the fetal stem cells invade tissue then replicate anyway, they're largely detected in the mother's circulation. Not to mention that any athlete can presumably request a re-test if they show up as male. Which they wouldn't anyway as genetic testing results are given in percentage terms, so mine would be something like 99.9999% XX and 0.0001% XY, or whatever, as you well know as a geneticist. This isnt the gotcha you think it is, but I am encouraged to see TRAs resorting to actual human biology to try and prove that men can be women, or women men in my case!

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 10:26

Sorry, you think elite sports organisations trying to determine the sex of a woman who has been pregnant in order to see if she is eligible to compete (already absolutely not something that is ever going to happen, but I recognise we must make provision in the rules for all eventualities) will be working with door handles?

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:26

The levels of hostility and ignorance on this thread is exactly what I am talking about.

This just makes woman who are defending womans rights look aggressive, and stupid

How does that help?

OP posts:
MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 10:25

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:24

whats your point?

Forensic scientists may be working with a few cells on a door handle - dont you understand that?

What??
what does a door handle have to do with genetic testing of athletes who are believed to have a Y chromosome?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/04/2023 10:25

Let's be frank here, you can test all the dna you like, but your eyes will tell you what you need to know.

Someone who has a random Y floating round because they had sons is still going to look female because they are female.

Transwomen simply do not pass for women. Ever.

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 10:25

But if there’s any doubt, they’ll just test again won’t they?
So what’s the problem?

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:24

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:22

Yes but I'm pretty sure the penis and testes alongside that Y chromosome are a pretty big indicator.

whats your point?

Forensic scientists may be working with a few cells on a door handle - dont you understand that?

OP posts:
Noicant · 06/04/2023 10:23

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

😂

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:22

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:21

In forensics, it is well known that getting a sample with Y chromosomes in a DNA test does not necessarily mean you have DNA from a male, it is going to be the same in screening athletes.

Yes but I'm pretty sure the penis and testes alongside that Y chromosome are a pretty big indicator.

HatchedInALaboratory · 06/04/2023 10:22

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

🙌

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:21

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Excellent point well presented 👏

Giggorata · 06/04/2023 10:21

Grasping at straws much?

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:21

In forensics, it is well known that getting a sample with Y chromosomes in a DNA test does not necessarily mean you have DNA from a male, it is going to be the same in screening athletes.

OP posts:
titchy · 06/04/2023 10:20

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

Lol - best post in the thread!

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:20

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:18

I'm also a geneticist, what a surprise, and that is not how it works. They aren't integrated into my cheek cells and that's not what that study says. Genetic testing is perfectly aware of chimerism artifacts and finding 1 Y chromosome in sample from a woman that was 99.999 % X X would not lead to a diagnosis of male!

but it takes time and testing, that is what I am saying. YOu can get a sample when there are Y chromosomes, and you need to take another sample and test again.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:19

If all is mothers of sons are sporting all these Y chromosomes - how come none of us are walking around swinging our penises between our legs?!

You know exactly why and how males and females are defined by sex and why they are segregated in sports categories.

We really are spitting the tiniest of feathers now over this 🙄

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:18

dietcokelime · 06/04/2023 10:16

There's got to be a line somewhere - surely that's the point of testing in elite sport?

Exactly, but my point is, that the line is not necessarily one test, and the level of ignorance shown in people insisting that one test is all it takes, is unhelpful, and does nothing for our cause

OP posts:
SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:18

I'm also a geneticist, what a surprise, and that is not how it works. They aren't integrated into my cheek cells and that's not what that study says. Genetic testing is perfectly aware of chimerism artifacts and finding 1 Y chromosome in sample from a woman that was 99.999 % X X would not lead to a diagnosis of male!

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:17

titchy · 06/04/2023 10:09

So they could randomly appear in every single cheek cell that was swabbed, while non-chimera (ie your own) cells were miraculously avoided?

yes. All your cheek cells are clones of each other. If the original of a cell line, 1, or 5 or 30 years ago, had a male chromosome, all the decedents would too.

OP posts:
dietcokelime · 06/04/2023 10:16

There's got to be a line somewhere - surely that's the point of testing in elite sport?

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:16

JennieTheZebra · 06/04/2023 10:13

Effectively we’re discussing “one drop” policy ie a single Y chromosome does not make you a man, especially if you’ve had male babies/had a male twin. However, that isn’t really the issue at hand?

no, the issue at hand is people reacting out of ignorance to genetic testing of athletes, and acting as if it is so cut and dried that one test can be definitive, when it might not.

Looking and acting stupid does not help

Sometimes it takes more than one test, and sometimes it takes time

OP posts:
JennieTheZebra · 06/04/2023 10:13

Effectively we’re discussing “one drop” policy ie a single Y chromosome does not make you a man, especially if you’ve had male babies/had a male twin. However, that isn’t really the issue at hand?

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:11

GarlicGrace · 06/04/2023 10:03

Good effort, @Nimbostratus100, but blood tests do not sample one single cell. Microchimerism is just that - micro. A few foetal cells that made it across the barrier that's supposed to keep them out (which may prove something of a theme in this thread!)

Keep reaching for ever more arcane theories on why we cannot define a woman.

I am all for keeping men out of womens sport, but ignorant hysteria does not help in any way, shape or form.

Abuse directed at an individual WOMAN because of a Y chromosome being detected in genetic testing is just repellent.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread