Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SmartHome · 07/04/2023 16:08

Don't be so ridiculous. Nobody is "alleging" that this OP is a man or a school people. They're taking the piss out of someone making themselves look ridiculous and trying to lord it over other posters. I could give a shit what sex or age the OP is. Talking shit is talking shit.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 16:05

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 15:59

Surely one report is enough? You already posted that MNHQ are aware so multiple reports about the same thing will just waste staff time.

I'm sure MNHQ were the best judges of that.

ArabellaScott · 07/04/2023 16:03

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

100%.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 15:59

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:56

Or posters could observe the Talk Guidelines and report inconsistencies to MNHQ.

In any case I can't comment on her career or expertise if I wanted to. As I said, I know she's not a man or a school pupil.

Surely one report is enough? You already posted that MNHQ are aware so multiple reports about the same thing will just waste staff time.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:56

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 15:51

Especially when it’s so easy to change MN username.

If you are going to post all sorts of contradictory claims about your career on a single website you should either expect other website users to recall your previous claims and question you about the contradictions or you should have the wherewithal to at least try and conceal your myriad of reinvented backstories!

Or posters could observe the Talk Guidelines and report inconsistencies to MNHQ.

In any case I can't comment on her career or expertise if I wanted to. As I said, I know she's not a man or a school pupil.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 15:51

MarshaBradyo · 07/04/2023 14:28

Tbf it is a bit of a gaff to confidently state you’re a geneticist when other posts say not

Especially when it’s so easy to change MN username.

If you are going to post all sorts of contradictory claims about your career on a single website you should either expect other website users to recall your previous claims and question you about the contradictions or you should have the wherewithal to at least try and conceal your myriad of reinvented backstories!

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:50

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 15:46

But you said you knew her. Surely you’d know is she was a geneticist or not?

I didn't say I knew her.

Try reading properly.

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 15:46

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:35

I've already said that I have no idea what her expertise in genetics is, if you bothered to read properly.

But you said you knew her. Surely you’d know is she was a geneticist or not?

matis · 07/04/2023 15:44

And then call yourself a geneticist.

(Posted too soon)

matis · 07/04/2023 15:43

Geneticist. Statistician. Maths teacher. And worked with sex offenders.

It's not honest to portray yourself as a geneticist when you state that you're a statistician who worked with genetics.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:38

I've said that I know she's not a man or a school pupil, both of which have been alleged.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:35

ATerrorofLeftovers · 07/04/2023 14:39

Amazing. So can you actually confirm that the OP is the geneticist they are claiming to be? And also a maths teacher?

It’s important. Because they’ve come on here claiming specialist, professional knowledge in a way that is seeking to persuade others on the basis of that apparent expertise. So it’s entirely in order for others to question their story when there are glaring inconsistencies, not only in what they’re alleging to be true, but also in their own back story, which they are leaning on to claim expert status.

I've already said that I have no idea what her expertise in genetics is, if you bothered to read properly.

Merrymouse · 07/04/2023 15:34

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 13:38

I contacted MNHQ in the light of submitting several reports of troll hunting.

I don't know enough about genetics to comment on whether the OP is right or wrong though my instinct is that she's wrong and several posters have argued that point effectively.

However she can be wrong without being what some posters are accusing her of.

There is a difference between simply being wrong, and being wrong but representing yourself as somebody who has expertise.

Annoyingwurringnoise · 07/04/2023 14:48

Wasn’t there an extensive career working with sex offenders as well

matis · 07/04/2023 14:41

And a virologist and a statistician.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 07/04/2023 14:39

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 13:19

I'm not prepared to elaborate on that on here. It's potentially outing, as I said. I have though passed the relevant information to MNHQ given the troll hunting on the thread.

Amazing. So can you actually confirm that the OP is the geneticist they are claiming to be? And also a maths teacher?

It’s important. Because they’ve come on here claiming specialist, professional knowledge in a way that is seeking to persuade others on the basis of that apparent expertise. So it’s entirely in order for others to question their story when there are glaring inconsistencies, not only in what they’re alleging to be true, but also in their own back story, which they are leaning on to claim expert status.

MarshaBradyo · 07/04/2023 14:28

Tbf it is a bit of a gaff to confidently state you’re a geneticist when other posts say not

Kucinghitam · 07/04/2023 14:26

Posters who start inflammatory threads blatantly parading their self-identified expertise in something, and furiously accusing everyone who disagrees with them as toxic evil ignoramuses, are going to face questions about said "expertise."

Maybe if being questioned on this is such a distressing experience, don't start a thread on that very basis?

Onegingerhead · 07/04/2023 14:16

Clymene · 07/04/2023 13:49

She's variously said she's a maths teacher, a geneticist and a virologist. All those things can't be true at once.

In theory she could be science teacher who picked some random bits of knowledge here and there.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 14:07

Clymene · 07/04/2023 13:49

She's variously said she's a maths teacher, a geneticist and a virologist. All those things can't be true at once.

So if you think she isn't posting in good faith you can report.

I really don't understand why people feel the need to pick posters apart in public.

LangClegsInSpace · 07/04/2023 14:05

She has also said she does 'a huge amount for child slaves'.

Some people just have very busy, full lives, I guess.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 07/04/2023 14:00

She's variously said she's a maths teacher, a geneticist and a virologist. All those things can't be true at once.

Maybe she's read a few things on Facebook and decided it makes her an expert

WarningToTheCurious · 07/04/2023 13:57

Clymene · 07/04/2023 13:49

She's variously said she's a maths teacher, a geneticist and a virologist. All those things can't be true at once.

A maths teacher that didn’t know that you can still do AS levels …

SerafinasGoose · 07/04/2023 13:52

NB. And that's the genuine ones.

SerafinasGoose · 07/04/2023 13:51

Pixiedust1234 · 07/04/2023 13:29

I have noticed on MN that if you give statements of facts then they really do need to be backed up. A person saying "because I said so" isn't really helpful in a discussion.

Just so we are clear, this post isn't aimed at anyone in particular. An opinion is personal, facts need to be able to be confirmed by others.

An anatomist, not to mention medical doctor with a reasonably high SM profile has been known to use this argument. It runs along the lines of 'I am right, because I'm a scientist and have the credentials to prove it, and human sex exists on a spectrum because I say so and because .... clownfish'.

IME, it's your actual arguments (not citing ancient, already-debunked research) which stand or fall by their own merit or lack of same.

Saying 'I'm a scientist' gives you no additional clout if what you're talking about is so obviously complete balderdash. It also makes you look very silly, and leads people to the inevitable conclusion that you're perhaps not the authority in your discipline you like to think you are.

Academics are as good as their last research project or peer-reviewed piece of research. When they try this approach I really do cringe for them.