Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ditalini · 06/04/2023 10:40

It's getting to hysteria levels of desperation now.

We've had a thread where there was "concern" that insisting on single sex toilets would lead to men pretending to be transmen.

Now "concern" that genetic testing of athletes could lead to women with a twin brother or mothers of sons being banned from competition.

"Don't look there women! Look over here! There's nothing behind the screen."

ShipSpace · 06/04/2023 10:40

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

😂😂

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:38

Dinopawus · 06/04/2023 10:36

Wait. So as the mother of a son, instead of taking a pay cut to work part time and finding myself on the career slow track, I could have dug out a few residual Y chromosomes, waved them around and got a pay rise?

Fuck me. Another way I’ve been doing it wrong all these years.

🤣🤣👏

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:38

Yes it can happen in women that, as far as they know, have never been pregnant. Thought to be due to early miscarriages. That paper also speculates that it can happen from sexual intercourse with a male. We are talking tiny, tiny amount of male cells though in comparison to the overall cell count of a female, which is why this hysteria from the OP about genetic testing for athletes in nonsense. Genetic chimerism is actually quite common, but the results would express that. And me having a few cells floating around from my sons, or even derived from those cells, would not make me show up as male in a genetic test. Because they will be a tiny, tiny, tiny proportion of my cell count and not every single one of the cells from the swab sites will be a foetal-derived one, if any.

It's a fascinating subject though, as they seem to be concentrated in injury sites in mice, so there is speculation that it is an evolutionary mechanism that evolved whereby the foetus sends helpful stem cells to repair damage in the mother to further the chance of her survival long enough to nurture the offspring to maturity. I quite like the idea of some payback for all this months of carrying them around!

titchy · 06/04/2023 10:38

I'm not understanding the problem OP. As smarthomenhas said, they're not looking for one Y, they're looking for a Y in 99% of cells in the sample. A few stray Ys due to micro chimerism isn't evidence of incorrect sex testing. They don't just test one individual cell. There also doesn't appear to be evidence that chimera cells replicate so again, not possible that a random sample could contain nothing but chimeras.

And tests are relatively cheap and quick these days, so testing twice isn't really a biggie.

There is no problem here at all - sex can be determined by swabbing and testing. Easily.

JulieHoney · 06/04/2023 10:37

You seem to be shouting at us over some silly straw man argument.

Who do you think is doing this “one Y chromosome in one cell means a person is male” stuff you are on about?

Microchimerism isn’t some sort of Gotcha.

Dinopawus · 06/04/2023 10:36

Wait. So as the mother of a son, instead of taking a pay cut to work part time and finding myself on the career slow track, I could have dug out a few residual Y chromosomes, waved them around and got a pay rise?

Fuck me. Another way I’ve been doing it wrong all these years.

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:36

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:26

The levels of hostility and ignorance on this thread is exactly what I am talking about.

This just makes woman who are defending womans rights look aggressive, and stupid

How does that help?

Not entirely convinced it's certain posters who look aggressive and stupid.

Well not the ones you are accusing anyway 🤣

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 10:35

And there will be an appeals process just as there is for drugs testing....
I fail to see a problem?

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 10:35

In the future, all athletes will be tested or none, you cant test only people you don't like the look of

This would work out fine for female athletes. Crack on!

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:34

whats your point?

Forensic scientists may be working with a few cells on a door handle - dont you understand that?

Eh? What's your point 🤣🤣🤣🤷‍♀️

I very much doubt when trying to decide what sex category someone competes in for sport they'll be swabbing door handles

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 10:33

Women really aren't the ones looking stupid and aggressive here.
Sports testing is not the same as forensic testing after swabbing a door handle at a crime scene.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:32

MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 10:30

Why would the technician have no idea where the sample has come from?
im trying to follow your argument but really struggling here. Are we still talking about testing specific athletes believed to have 46XY DSD?

testing HAS to be done blind, drugs testing, genetic testing, all of it. That is a basic principle of fairness

OP posts:
Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 10:32

It sounds like you’re really concerned that mothers might be accidentally excluded from elite athletic competition. Is that your main worry here?

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 10:32

lets not respond with aggression and hostility to someone who doesn't get a clear answer first time- that is all
You are preaching about and accusing people of something that hasn't happened 🙄

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:31

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/04/2023 10:25

Let's be frank here, you can test all the dna you like, but your eyes will tell you what you need to know.

Someone who has a random Y floating round because they had sons is still going to look female because they are female.

Transwomen simply do not pass for women. Ever.

The whole point of blind testing is the technician does not know who the test comes from, or what they look like.

In the future, all athletes will be tested or none, you cant test only people you dont like the look of

OP posts:
MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 10:30

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:28

because much of the process is the same, in both cases, the technician has a small cell sample, with no knowledge of who it has come from and are testing it to make deductions.

Finding a Y chromosome is not enough for either the forensic investigator, or the athletic screener to deduce the sample has definitely come from a male

Why would the technician have no idea where the sample has come from?
im trying to follow your argument but really struggling here. Are we still talking about testing specific athletes believed to have 46XY DSD?

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 10:30

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:26

The levels of hostility and ignorance on this thread is exactly what I am talking about.

This just makes woman who are defending womans rights look aggressive, and stupid

How does that help?

Honestly, we aren’t the ones looking stupid here.

randomchap · 06/04/2023 10:30

Forgive my ignorance, but could this happen when the mother loses a baby in early pregnancy? Or does the mother have to carry them for some time before it can happen?

If a single DNA test isn't enough to keep women's sports for women, then what else could be done?

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:30

They're not looking for one Y chromosome! They're looking for a Y chromosome detected in 99.999% of cells!

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:29

JennieTheZebra · 06/04/2023 10:28

This largely comes down to DSDs/intersex and, as they’ve asked specifically not to be included in trans arguments, that part should probably be dropped. DSDs will always be present in sexually dimorphic species.
Those people arguing that pregnancy renders the argument moot should probably be made aware that microchimerism can appear in utero due to the presence of a male twin, although it’s rarer.
As for testing, surely the solution is to take two swabs from very different body parts. If the first swab is inconclusive then process the second swab?

exactly what I am saying, two tests may be needed, lets not respond with aggression and hostility to someone who doesn't get a clear answer first time- that is all

And I suspect, for cost and time reasons, the two tests are unlikely to be done simultaneously.

OP posts:
MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 10:29

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/04/2023 10:25

Let's be frank here, you can test all the dna you like, but your eyes will tell you what you need to know.

Someone who has a random Y floating round because they had sons is still going to look female because they are female.

Transwomen simply do not pass for women. Ever.

Nor, frankly, do the 42XY athletes who have been winning women's sports. I acknowledge that masculine women exist and are 100% women but caster semenya, dutee chand and Margaret wambui have male physiques. It's quite clear they have male levels of testosterone impacting their physical development.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:28

MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 10:25

What??
what does a door handle have to do with genetic testing of athletes who are believed to have a Y chromosome?

because much of the process is the same, in both cases, the technician has a small cell sample, with no knowledge of who it has come from and are testing it to make deductions.

Finding a Y chromosome is not enough for either the forensic investigator, or the athletic screener to deduce the sample has definitely come from a male

OP posts:
JennieTheZebra · 06/04/2023 10:28

This largely comes down to DSDs/intersex and, as they’ve asked specifically not to be included in trans arguments, that part should probably be dropped. DSDs will always be present in sexually dimorphic species.
Those people arguing that pregnancy renders the argument moot should probably be made aware that microchimerism can appear in utero due to the presence of a male twin, although it’s rarer.
As for testing, surely the solution is to take two swabs from very different body parts. If the first swab is inconclusive then process the second swab?

BreviloquentBastard · 06/04/2023 10:28

*completely irrelevant to the issue. Stop being goady.