Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Kucinghitam · 06/04/2023 10:57

A particularly "blind 'em with science"-y version of the univariate fallacy, this.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:56

PaterPower · 06/04/2023 10:54

The vast, vast, majority of elite female athletes will not have given birth at the start of their career (when they’re likely to be first tested).

And if they HAVE given birth then the tests are unnecessary.

pregnancy is just an example, there are other ways to swap genetic information, including male vanishing twin, sex with a man, abortion or miscarriage, etc.

And testing will be for everybody, because you cant insist on it for some, and not for others

OP posts:
MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 10:56

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:43

exactly, as their currently is

but what I am pointing out is that the reflex hate, hostility and aggression from people supposedly wanting to support women's rights, does not help in any way, and there needs to be far more understanding towards women who are found to have a Y chromosome show up in their testing

Hate and hostility? Love the hyperbole. All you've had is a lot of people going eh? Because you aren't making sense.

bluetongue · 06/04/2023 10:55

Putting talk of random cells with a Y chromosomes aside, what would the classification of someone with XY chromosomes and CAIS be? They are genetically male but are completely insensitive to testosterone so appear female.

YouJustDoYou · 06/04/2023 10:55

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:40

Yes of course, why are you saying "crack on" like that?

this is exactly what I mean by aggression.

Pointless, and unconstructive, and does nothing for womens cause at all, if the default response to anything and everything is aggression

😂"aggression"

MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 10:54

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:32

testing HAS to be done blind, drugs testing, genetic testing, all of it. That is a basic principle of fairness

Well ok that's fine but I still don't understand why that means the testing is unreliable or that they would be working with a few cells on a door handle?!

PaterPower · 06/04/2023 10:54

The vast, vast, majority of elite female athletes will not have given birth at the start of their career (when they’re likely to be first tested).

And if they HAVE given birth then the tests are unnecessary.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 10:51

Iwasafool · 06/04/2023 10:44

Why do they test then? Surely officials can just look at athletes and know so doing tests seems a bit of a waste.

Elite Athletes are constantly tested for doping, they have to wee in a pot while a doping agent watches!

Chromosomes will be looked at in blood & saliva tests for doping anyway (they have to check the sample against the athletes DNA on record to make sure it’s not a mix up or a deliberate substitution).

Chromosomes are just tightly coiled strands of DNA - whenever your DNA is tested, your chromosomes will be noted 🤷‍♀️

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:51

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:34

whats your point?

Forensic scientists may be working with a few cells on a door handle - dont you understand that?

Eh? What's your point 🤣🤣🤣🤷‍♀️

I very much doubt when trying to decide what sex category someone competes in for sport they'll be swabbing door handles

no, they are two completely different scenarios using the same procedure

"forensic" means related to crime.

A forensic science technician may have a sample of cells from a doorhandle and be analysing them to try and identify who has touched the door handle

Someone in sports screening will be using a similar procedure to analyse cells taken from an athlete

In neither case can it be assumed that the individual that the cells came from is male, just because Y chromosomes are found

OP posts:
AuContraire · 06/04/2023 10:50

Because men keep pretending to be women.

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 10:50

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:43

exactly, as their currently is

but what I am pointing out is that the reflex hate, hostility and aggression from people supposedly wanting to support women's rights, does not help in any way, and there needs to be far more understanding towards women who are found to have a Y chromosome show up in their testing

What basis do you have for predicting that GC women will react with aggression and hatred to any (incredibly rare) biological females idenfied as having y chromosomes?

JackGrealishsLegs · 06/04/2023 10:49

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:40

Yes of course, why are you saying "crack on" like that?

this is exactly what I mean by aggression.

Pointless, and unconstructive, and does nothing for womens cause at all, if the default response to anything and everything is aggression

Do you know what “crack on” means? Confused (Clue: it doesn’t mean “fuck off” or anything else remotely aggressive)

Untitledsquatboulder · 06/04/2023 10:49

I've had 4 sons. Still waiting for the genetic advantage for sports.

AnotherDayAnotherView · 06/04/2023 10:49

OP do you remember this?

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male
AuContraire · 06/04/2023 10:49

If a woman athlete has given birth to a male child, we can be 100% sure she is female.

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:47

Everyone involved in athletics knew Caster Semenya has a DSD, long before it was accepted as fact. I doubt CS has ever consented to a genetic test, they tested for testosterone levels, and boughed out of female athletics when it became clear the jig was up.

titchy · 06/04/2023 10:47

I suspect OP is a "geneticist" rather than a geneticist.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 10:46

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:11

I am all for keeping men out of womens sport, but ignorant hysteria does not help in any way, shape or form.

Abuse directed at an individual WOMAN because of a Y chromosome being detected in genetic testing is just repellent.

Being excluded from the female category isn’t abuse.

And it would never be done on the basis of a single test, the chromosomes are just a screening stage before further investigations and not all XY athletes are excluded from the female category, it depends on the reason the Y is present and if the Y resulted in a male puberty or not.

5ARD is very, very different to CAIS.

A girl who become an acquired chimeras due to bone marrow transplant will have Y chromosomes in a blood test (but not in a skin cell test). This would not exclude her from the female category in sports because she doesn’t have a DSD, she hasn’t had a male puberty and the donor’s blood cells make her no more male than she would be if she’d received a kidney from a male donor.

You really don’t seem like a geneticist 🤦‍♀️

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 10:46

Literally no one has shown any hate or aggression to women or indeed transwomen. Indeed the situation you’re discussing has literally never actually happened. This is totally your invention. You don’t need to defend any imaginary women who have been diagnosed male based on a chemeric cell…..

Iwasafool · 06/04/2023 10:44

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/04/2023 10:25

Let's be frank here, you can test all the dna you like, but your eyes will tell you what you need to know.

Someone who has a random Y floating round because they had sons is still going to look female because they are female.

Transwomen simply do not pass for women. Ever.

Why do they test then? Surely officials can just look at athletes and know so doing tests seems a bit of a waste.

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:44

Im actuall amused and laughing at the moment rather than aggressive. LOL at a geneticist believing that foetal transfer in a mother would make them fail a genetic test to determine if they were male. LOL at the idea, planted by the OP, that athletics bodies are proposing looking for 1 Y chromosome in a sample of 100s of thousands of cells.

BurningBright · 06/04/2023 10:44

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

This.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:43

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 10:35

And there will be an appeals process just as there is for drugs testing....
I fail to see a problem?

exactly, as their currently is

but what I am pointing out is that the reflex hate, hostility and aggression from people supposedly wanting to support women's rights, does not help in any way, and there needs to be far more understanding towards women who are found to have a Y chromosome show up in their testing

OP posts:
RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 10:41

Aggression???

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:40

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 10:35

In the future, all athletes will be tested or none, you cant test only people you don't like the look of

This would work out fine for female athletes. Crack on!

Yes of course, why are you saying "crack on" like that?

this is exactly what I mean by aggression.

Pointless, and unconstructive, and does nothing for womens cause at all, if the default response to anything and everything is aggression

OP posts: