Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Codlingmoths · 06/04/2023 11:04

Is it more important to you to try and tell other people they are stupid, or to use the benefit of your extensive education and inform people more about the complexity of genetic testing? Because most of your posts shout the former.

they can tell a lot from one test, and you are being misleading. When I had the nipt, which is testing on blood , they don’t call and say well baby might be a girl or perhaps that’s because you’re a girl and baby is a boy so sorry we’ll just never know. Nor do they call and say so baby is a boy or maybe you’re a boy congratulations!! But we had better do another test.

imagine you’re talking to colleagues from another field. Imagine they are not stupid. Imagine they fully comprehend false positives etc. Take a deep breath and try again. or just shout you are all stupid if that’s really your goal.

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 11:04

Are you going to say any athlete can enter the woman's game, if they claim to have given birth in the past?

Any midwife can tell if a woman has given birth or not, by examining the cervix.

I don't know what makes you a geneticist, but you have made several errors in your claims on this thread, and then got angry when people have pointed them out.
I'm going to make a suggestion. Look up 'forced teaming', 'logical fallacies' and 'passive aggression'. If that makes you feel angry, let it pass, then come back and read it again. Then look into them.

This isn't about sides. Its about how we can order society fairly.

NecessaryScene · 06/04/2023 11:04

So is this whole thread basically

"This idea that I've just had that we could do genetic testing based on a single cell sample is dumb?"

because having the Y chromosome in your body does not make you male, which is the point of this thread - tackling this ignorance

This is mind-bogglingly obvious, just as having sperm in your body also doesn't make you male. Can we do that thread too?

"AIBU to point out that containing sperm doesn't make you male?"

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:04

Who exactly is ignorant of the fact that having a single, or a few cells with a Y chromosome in them in a normal female doesn't make you a man? I knew that.

YouJustDoYou · 06/04/2023 11:03

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:02

I can give a real life example of DNA and genetics.

My ds has a neuromuscular disability. He has a missence gene on a chromosome. It's the BSCL2 gene.

I have been discovered to have the same fault. I do not have the disability.

The only other person who has the same genetic fault that's been discovered worldwide has a similar yet different diagnosis of a neurological disorder to ds.

So if you blind tested the 3 of us then technically I would be classed as disabled and could be a para athlete like ds.

Except I can't. Mainly because the other actual characteristics required to be diagnosed with the disability aren't there in my case.

But they'd know what the lab tests indicate because you can't just dismiss something by a single genetics test.

The same way you can't assume someone is male because of 1 Y chromosome that's crossed into the dna. You use the fact you have someone which a penis and visible adams Apple in front of you.

This.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:02

Giggorata · 06/04/2023 10:21

Grasping at straws much?

what, by trying to explain some science, because people are harming our cause by showing ignorance of this science, and being hostile and aggressive with that ignorance?

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 06/04/2023 11:02

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:40

Yes of course, why are you saying "crack on" like that?

this is exactly what I mean by aggression.

Pointless, and unconstructive, and does nothing for womens cause at all, if the default response to anything and everything is aggression

You’ve got to be kidding, no serious person could type this.

YouJustDoYou · 06/04/2023 11:02

Are you drunk op? Bit early for that...

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:02

I can give a real life example of DNA and genetics.

My ds has a neuromuscular disability. He has a missence gene on a chromosome. It's the BSCL2 gene.

I have been discovered to have the same fault. I do not have the disability.

The only other person who has the same genetic fault that's been discovered worldwide has a similar yet different diagnosis of a neurological disorder to ds.

So if you blind tested the 3 of us then technically I would be classed as disabled and could be a para athlete like ds.

Except I can't. Mainly because the other actual characteristics required to be diagnosed with the disability aren't there in my case.

But they'd know what the lab tests indicate because you can't just dismiss something by a single genetics test.

The same way you can't assume someone is male because of 1 Y chromosome that's crossed into the dna. You use the fact you have someone which a penis and visible adams Apple in front of you.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 06/04/2023 11:02

I find the presence of a dick and balls is pretty conclusive, personally. No need to go delving around in chromosomes. Other clues also exist….

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male
Theunamedcat · 06/04/2023 11:02

Bio men can't give birth so how is this an issue? Surely a few questions such as have you ever been pregnant with a boy would suffice?

BungleandGeorge · 06/04/2023 11:01

titchy · 06/04/2023 10:20

Lol - best post in the thread!

I agree, some people have a knack for pointing out the obvious 😆

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:01

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:19

If all is mothers of sons are sporting all these Y chromosomes - how come none of us are walking around swinging our penises between our legs?!

You know exactly why and how males and females are defined by sex and why they are segregated in sports categories.

We really are spitting the tiniest of feathers now over this 🙄

because having the Y chromosome in your body does not make you male, which is the point of this thread - tackling this ignorance

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 06/04/2023 11:00

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:26

The levels of hostility and ignorance on this thread is exactly what I am talking about.

This just makes woman who are defending womans rights look aggressive, and stupid

How does that help?

It makes you seem like a lunatic #sorrynotsorry. As someone else said the cock and balls plus the Y chromosome is enough for me to keep a man out of women’s sports. In fact having or having ever had a cock and balls is enough for me, I don’t require the chromosome testing. Eunuchs are still men 🤷‍♀️

Mynameisntrelevant · 06/04/2023 11:00

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

I'm with you on that! Seems clear cut!!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/04/2023 10:59

Really interested in this Op @Nimbostratus100

If you’ve had a son and have these chimera cells, does it make any difference to you? Hormonally or in any other way?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 06/04/2023 10:59

anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body

It IS definitely true that a lot of people who have had a son will still have Y chromosomes in cells throughout their bodies for the rest of their lives - around 50% of them, in fact....

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:59

SNWannabe · 06/04/2023 10:19

Ummm, if you've carried and birthed a baby boy...I would say that has cleared up any question of "are you male or female?" anyway...surely? I am not a geneticist though.

sure, but it is not always possible to prove, is it, and people do lie.

Are you going to say any athlete can enter the woman's game, if they claim to have given birth in the past?

Look at the logistics of it! All anyone would have to do is make that claim, free pass to woman's sport!

OP posts:
Merrymouse · 06/04/2023 10:58

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:07

I am a geneticist, and that is exactly how it works

This worries me.

Do you mean you are on a course and you have just learned about microchimerism?

L1ttledrummergirl · 06/04/2023 10:58

This thread is funny. The premise that a mother, who has carried a baby in her womb, birthed the baby through her vagina must be a male because of 1 cell of y chromosome out of how ever many thousands, is frankly laughable.

It shouldn't be though, because currently we are expected to believe that a male bodied person with a penis and no womb, with many xy chromosomes and cells, with large muscle mass and high testosterone is female.

Both are frankly ridiculous. I don't get a feel of aggression from this thread, just disbelief that anyone would actually think that a biological mother could be a male.

weightymatters73 · 06/04/2023 10:58

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:08

this is exactly what I am pointing out, they do, and could well appear in your cheek cells

When I started studying maths, I was given a (very old) book called "Lies, damned lies, and statistics" - It was about how statistics are used to bend the truth in politics, marketing and advertising....

It was a fascinating book that you would do well to read.

The key word you are missing here is "MICRO".... You are bending the truth to suit a narrative that just isn't true....The odd Y chromosome could be in an XX chromosome person if they have XY babies, and yes they might possibly be in one of the cheek cells BUT it is such an infinitesimally small number compared to the XX as to be utterly irrelevant.... We are not frogs, no one is switching sex.

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:58

Untitledsquatboulder · 06/04/2023 10:49

I've had 4 sons. Still waiting for the genetic advantage for sports.

Me too! Strangely, I found my ability to run competitively diminished after carrying around 3 massive babies for 27 months and spending 3 years breastfeeding 😄

Still, I'm sure there are elite athletes out there who have managed to squeeze out 4 sons before the age of 30 who are still competing and will be glad the OP is pointing out that they are definitely not male just in cases a solitary Y chromosome shows up in their testing.

I'm sure this will be a useful gotcha for male athletes, with male physiques who are wanting to compete in women's sport - I can just see Lia Thomas saying, no I'm not actually a man, I've given birth to a son and that's why I switched from men's competion a couple of years ago. And I'm sure it will instantly earn them everyone's respect, instead of people seeing them as mediocre males who can't hack it in men's events.

DameKatyDenisesClagnuts · 06/04/2023 10:57

Also a geneticist, can also confirm that this isn't how it works

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 10:57

no, they are two completely different scenarios using the same procedure

"forensic" means related to crime.

A forensic science technician may have a sample of cells from a doorhandle and be analysing them to try and identify who has touched the door handle

Someone in sports screening will be using a similar procedure to analyse cells taken from an athlete

In neither case can it be assumed that the individual that the cells came from is male, just because Y chromosomes are found

I'm aware of what forensics is. I'm not stupid.

But your equating 2 types of testing as one of the same thing.

A forensic scientist is testing a sample blind - because they have no idea who the person is that touched the door handle. They are investigating the crime.

A lab technician will be testing a sample blind (if what you say is true.) however - the person who requested the sample isn't blind to the physical characteristics of the person they've requested the sample from.

If they have a mother who's birthed a son in front of them they will know it's a woman. Being it only woman that can give birth. And they don't just rely on x and Y chromosomes in sport anyway. Testosterone levels play a huge part.

Even woman competing as woman have to have levels of testosterone below a certain level. Hence the blind drugs testing they do. The person ordering the test may know they have a woman in front of them - but that woman can fail the testosterone levels test due to synthetic hormone taking.

Doesn't stop them being a woman. Bans them from competing as one though.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:57

JackGrealishsLegs · 06/04/2023 10:49

Do you know what “crack on” means? Confused (Clue: it doesn’t mean “fuck off” or anything else remotely aggressive)

ok, if I misread your tone, sorry, but it did come across as if it was trying to score points somehow, when we are on the same side

OP posts: