Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:16

ditalini · 06/04/2023 10:40

It's getting to hysteria levels of desperation now.

We've had a thread where there was "concern" that insisting on single sex toilets would lead to men pretending to be transmen.

Now "concern" that genetic testing of athletes could lead to women with a twin brother or mothers of sons being banned from competition.

"Don't look there women! Look over here! There's nothing behind the screen."

no, concern over them facing hatred and aggression, and accusations and suspicion that is totally unwarranted

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:16

They won't be testing chromosomes based on the basis of how the individual presents any more than they only test athletes who look stoned

Well no.

But they also won't be disqualifying athletes who have a stray Y chromosome on the basis they are male either.

That's the point isn't it.

And they do know where the samples come from even if the lab testing do it anonymously.

You get the results of your own urine sample returned to you and there's an appeals process. My ds is in elite sport.

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:16

Yes who are all these stupid women that don't understand genetics. Show us the evidence that loads of women (or men) have been going around saying this:

*The problem is the attitudes of some women, who dont really understand the genetics, reacting so angrily to athletes who need more than one test.

People simply need to understand that sometimes women are found to have Y chromosomes in their bodies*

You've made it up haven't you? I'd be appalled if anyone did one test for anything. Repeatability is a pretty basic prereq that anyone who has been to school and done GCSE level science would know.

Who knew that I would forget the contents of my 4 year degree in molecular biology and genetics once I'd had sons eh?

Kucinghitam · 06/04/2023 11:16

But I still believe the "reacting so angrily to athletes who need more than one test" here is a strawwoman being attacked. Who's doing this?

To be fair, if OP thinks the commonly-used phrase "crack on" is aggressive... 🤷🏻‍♀️

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:15

ShipSpace · 06/04/2023 10:40

😂😂

what is it about this science that you find funny?

OP posts:
RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 11:14

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:13

it is happening, that is why I am trying to explain the science to people a bit more. It has happened to a friend of mine, and it is very distressing

What has happened?

NecessaryScene · 06/04/2023 11:14

The problem is the attitudes of some women, who dont really understand the genetics, reacting so angrily to athletes who need more than one test.

Partly in answer to a previous question - those people would not be who the OP supposes - women with a few XY cells from a pregnancy. They wouldn't fail the initial test.

But this scenario would apply to CAIS athletes, who do truly have (~100%) XY chromosomes, but who are not restricted in the rules. The rules deem that XY chromosomes with complete testosterone insensitivity is a small enough advantage to compete as female.

But I still believe the "reacting so angrily to athletes who need more than one test" here is a strawwoman being attacked. Who's doing this?

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:13

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 10:32

lets not respond with aggression and hostility to someone who doesn't get a clear answer first time- that is all
You are preaching about and accusing people of something that hasn't happened 🙄

it is happening, that is why I am trying to explain the science to people a bit more. It has happened to a friend of mine, and it is very distressing

OP posts:
Mochudubh · 06/04/2023 11:13

I am not a geneticist (I do have Higher Biology, if that helps) and I'm finding this thread a bit bonkers. Who are these "people" the OP thinks believe that a single test, which finds a single cell, that contains a Y chromosome is enough to say "You're a man, on your crossbarred bike, mate"

I just can't see that happening in the real world.

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:12

Oh you think we'll all be up in arms because someone who is a woman is competing as a woman but may have a stray Y chromosome.

For the love of god. Give us some credit.

We have an issue with males, penis and testosterone made males want to say they are a woman and compete in the woman's category.

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 11:12

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:10

But nimbostratus why would they test a woman who presents physically as woman and was born a woman to see if she had a stray Y chromosome to compete as a woman?

They won't be testing chromosomes based on the basis of how the individual presents any more than they only test athletes who look stoned

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 06/04/2023 11:12

This thread is starting to remind me of the bit in the Father Ted raffle episode, where Ted feels the need to announce very clearly at the start that it does sometimes happen that the organisers will win the raffle - before the point that he made turns out to be very convenient for what happens next.

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:12

Er, I don't think it's the men and women that want to keep men out of women's sport that are showing ignorance of science mate. It the India Willoughbys et al that spent 40 years as a man then decided one day that they had become women and magically grew a cervix overnight that maybe should have paid a bit more attention in Biology.

As I said though, as a scientist, it is quite encouraging to see activists actually engage with biological reality for once. It will not be the gotcha they think it is though. As any actual scientist would know (and a PP pointed out the univariate fallacy), exceptions dont invalidate the rules, someone born with one leg doesn't mean humans aren't bipedal Yadda Yadda. You know this OP, give it up.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 11:11

bluetongue · 06/04/2023 10:55

Putting talk of random cells with a Y chromosomes aside, what would the classification of someone with XY chromosomes and CAIS be? They are genetically male but are completely insensitive to testosterone so appear female.

Sporting federations work off a category called ‘Sport Sex’ which is slightly different to biological sex and nothing to do with legal sex.

At the moment CAIS athletes are allowed to compete in the Women’s category as they haven’t benefited from a male (testosterone driven) puberty.

However, these rules will no doubt be reviewed in future as we come to understand more about stuff like the impact of the menstrual cycle on female athletes training and competition (CAIS athletes don’t have menstrual cycles) and whether the observed difference in height/arm span etc gives an unfair advantage (CAIS people are, on average, taller than XX female people, as one of the two genes that determine adult height is on the Y chromosome, and obvs, XX females don’t have that gene).

At the moment the benefit of the doubt is still with CAIS athletes but it’s not the same for 5ARD athletes (who are often ambiguous at birth but become obviously male at puberty and in some cases, can father children).

Having a Y doesn’t automatically get an athlete disqualified, it just means further clarification is necessary and there is a tribunal type system to for athletes to challenge decisions made on their category eligibility.

It’s all pretty complicated and OP has got the wrong end of the stick as to what ‘sport sex’ is defined by.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:11

randomchap · 06/04/2023 10:30

Forgive my ignorance, but could this happen when the mother loses a baby in early pregnancy? Or does the mother have to carry them for some time before it can happen?

If a single DNA test isn't enough to keep women's sports for women, then what else could be done?

yes, it can happen after an early loss

And in sport, the simple answer after a Y chromosome is found in a sample from a female, is just to test a few more times, so it can be clearly established they are genetically female, with chimerisms.

That isnt really a problem, in itself

The problem is the attitudes of some women, who dont really understand the genetics, reacting so angrily to athletes who need more than one test.

People simply need to understand that sometimes women are found to have Y chromosomes in their bodies

That would include many, if not most of the women on here, at some place, somewhere, in small amounts

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:10

But nimbostratus why would they test a woman who presents physically as woman and was born a woman to see if she had a stray Y chromosome to compete as a woman?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 06/04/2023 11:09

’only a very few Y chromosomes, honest’.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male
BMW6 · 06/04/2023 11:09

I think the OP could start an argument in an empty room..........

IncompleteSenten · 06/04/2023 11:09

I think we can safely say that people can tell the difference between that small exchange and a biological adult male. Don't worry.

NecessaryScene · 06/04/2023 11:07

Finding Y chromosomes is not conclusive, but the reaction from some women, out of ignorance, is to react as if it is.

You seem to misunderstand what the initial test is. They're not looking for "a single Y chromosome in any cell" as if searching for contamination.

They're looking for the entire genetic makeup being XY.

Which they will - because it's a lot easier! - be done on HUGE sample of cells.

If there were a few XY "contamination" cell in there it wouldn't show up. They're looking for people with 99.9% XY cells. Not people with 0.001% ones.

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:07

because having the Y chromosome in your body does not make you male, which is the point of this thread - tackling this ignorance

But having a penis does.

You have a penis. You are male. You compete on the male category.

You don't have a penis. You are female. With possibly 1 Y chromosome. With lower testosterone levels. You compete as a female.

There are a few anomalies and these should be treated with respect and on a case by case basis.

But these are as few and far between as trans people wanting to compete in sport.

And the whole elite sporting body should not change for a few anomalies that can be dealt with as they arise.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:06

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 10:26

Sorry, you think elite sports organisations trying to determine the sex of a woman who has been pregnant in order to see if she is eligible to compete (already absolutely not something that is ever going to happen, but I recognise we must make provision in the rules for all eventualities) will be working with door handles?

no, I am saying that a similar procedure is done in forensics, where it is accepted that finding a Y chromosome does not mean that the person who toughed that door handle was male.

Just as finding a Y chromosome in a sample from an athlete does not mean that the athlete is male

OP posts:
RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 11:06

L1ttledrummergirl · 06/04/2023 10:58

This thread is funny. The premise that a mother, who has carried a baby in her womb, birthed the baby through her vagina must be a male because of 1 cell of y chromosome out of how ever many thousands, is frankly laughable.

It shouldn't be though, because currently we are expected to believe that a male bodied person with a penis and no womb, with many xy chromosomes and cells, with large muscle mass and high testosterone is female.

Both are frankly ridiculous. I don't get a feel of aggression from this thread, just disbelief that anyone would actually think that a biological mother could be a male.

To be fair to the OP that's not what she's arguing.
She's predicting that we will all get the pitchforks out the moment a y chromosome is detected. And she feels the need to tell us that some of those may indeed be female.
The fact that there is no evidence of aggression and the likelihood of a stray y chromosome is minute seems to have passed her by.

Eyerollcentral · 06/04/2023 11:05

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:02

what, by trying to explain some science, because people are harming our cause by showing ignorance of this science, and being hostile and aggressive with that ignorance?

To what end? What do you think women don’t understand? What do you hope to achieve? Do you think trans women should be allowed to play women’s sports?

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:04

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 10:25

But if there’s any doubt, they’ll just test again won’t they?
So what’s the problem?

it isn't a problem for the testing, no, they will just test more, which is fine

The problem is the abuse and suspicion directed at women who end up needing the further testing

Finding Y chromosomes is not conclusive, but the reaction from some women, out of ignorance, is to react as if it is.

OP posts: