Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:23

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 10:46

Literally no one has shown any hate or aggression to women or indeed transwomen. Indeed the situation you’re discussing has literally never actually happened. This is totally your invention. You don’t need to defend any imaginary women who have been diagnosed male based on a chemeric cell…..

it is happening, hence the thread

OP posts:
Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 11:23

BMW6 · 06/04/2023 11:22

it is happening, that is why I am trying to explain the science to people a bit more. It has happened to a friend of mine, and it is very distressing

What's the story here?

The friend goes to a different school, and none of us know her.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:23

Untitledsquatboulder · 06/04/2023 10:49

I've had 4 sons. Still waiting for the genetic advantage for sports.

so you will most likely have Y chromosomes in cells in multiple parts of your body, but you are still female, and have no male advantage in sport. That is the whole point

However, if you are tested, you might show up as male, there is that chance. In which case, you would need to be tested again

OP posts:
BMW6 · 06/04/2023 11:22

it is happening, that is why I am trying to explain the science to people a bit more. It has happened to a friend of mine, and it is very distressing

What's the story here?

EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 11:21

Somanycats · 06/04/2023 11:20

Honestly I don't think there is a lot of ignorance around this. It's not new knowledge. As your outdated research papers quoted indicate. Why are you selling this as a new thing. Testing already takes this into account. I would have hoped anyone with a bsc in any science would be aware of this and anyone with an interest in trans issues.

And anyone with an interest in Women’s Sport!

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:21

AnotherDayAnotherView · 06/04/2023 10:49

OP do you remember this?

This is part of the problem, very simplified patterns taught at GCSE level, which is fine, as it give a good foundation to build on, but does not always represent the full reality, and people who don't take a subject any further are stuck with the GCSE over simplifications in their head for life- genetics isn't the only topic that this can be an issue in

OP posts:
EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 11:21

Mochudubh · 06/04/2023 11:13

I am not a geneticist (I do have Higher Biology, if that helps) and I'm finding this thread a bit bonkers. Who are these "people" the OP thinks believe that a single test, which finds a single cell, that contains a Y chromosome is enough to say "You're a man, on your crossbarred bike, mate"

I just can't see that happening in the real world.

Unsurprisingly, you are correct, It doesn’t!

Category eligibility is decided on more than one test and ultimate decisions are in the hands of The Court of Arbitration for Sport in Switzerland (who also rule on stuff like length of running blades for para athletes)

https://www.tas-cas.org/en/general-information/index/

OP seems to be trying to create outrage at all the stupid mean mummies who know what a man is and want fairness for female athletes (and most us are well aware that it’s not always a simple answer when it comes to athletes with a DSD, who are a completely different category to standard XY males who gender transition).

ZombieMumEB · 06/04/2023 11:21

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:02

what, by trying to explain some science, because people are harming our cause by showing ignorance of this science, and being hostile and aggressive with that ignorance?

What "cause" is this you speak of?

Have you seen this video footage? I suggest you watch the entire video.
https://twitter.com/MattWalshBlog/status/1643460289671892992?cxt=HHwWgMDUhaKb384tAAAA

https://twitter.com/MattWalshBlog/status/1643460289671892992?cxt=HHwWgMDUhaKb384tAAAA

Somanycats · 06/04/2023 11:20

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:01

because having the Y chromosome in your body does not make you male, which is the point of this thread - tackling this ignorance

Honestly I don't think there is a lot of ignorance around this. It's not new knowledge. As your outdated research papers quoted indicate. Why are you selling this as a new thing. Testing already takes this into account. I would have hoped anyone with a bsc in any science would be aware of this and anyone with an interest in trans issues.

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:20

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:17

because it happens

Come on Nimbostratus! Show us your sciency evidence!

ohdelay · 06/04/2023 11:20

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 11:18

The can start by simply observing their penis and that would provide confirmation in 99.99% of cases. And if you think that is invasive then you have no idea how drug testing in sport works.

☝

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:20

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 11:18

The can start by simply observing their penis and that would provide confirmation in 99.99% of cases. And if you think that is invasive then you have no idea how drug testing in sport works.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

Very true.

I'm swimming there is at least 2 people who watch you do your urine sample.

BMW6 · 06/04/2023 11:20

So OP your friend has tested as Male but is actually female? Not intersex?

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 11:19

Sorry back on the tangent of individuals with CAIS, I’ve always imagined they wouldn’t be very good at sport generally at an elite level, as testosterone is so closely linked to sporting prowess….. I haven’t looked into it at all but that was just my initial gut feeling. Am I wrong?

NecessaryScene · 06/04/2023 11:19

If the argument is "they shouldn't publish inconclusive results", then I think everyone here would agree with that, right?

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 11:19

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:17

because it happens

What has happened?

NecessaryScene · 06/04/2023 11:18

I mean, surely most reputable medical or sports testers would test more than once, especially if there was any doubt whatsoever, and they would not release the results, or even the fact of needing to test twice, to the public.

Yes, I'm struggling to see what the scenario is where "we've tested someone once, got a 'potentially male' result and we are performing more tests" becomes public.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:18

Iwasafool · 06/04/2023 10:44

Why do they test then? Surely officials can just look at athletes and know so doing tests seems a bit of a waste.

testing is blind

OP posts:
Kucinghitam · 06/04/2023 11:18

Who knew that I would forget the contents of my 4 year degree in molecular biology and genetics once I'd had sons eh?

@SmartHome Didn't you know that The Science says that you pushed your brains out along with the placenta?

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 11:18

The can start by simply observing their penis and that would provide confirmation in 99.99% of cases. And if you think that is invasive then you have no idea how drug testing in sport works.

lemonchiffonpie · 06/04/2023 11:17

This just makes woman who are defending womans rights look aggressive, and stupid

You're a geneticist, you say?

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:17

Mochudubh · 06/04/2023 11:13

I am not a geneticist (I do have Higher Biology, if that helps) and I'm finding this thread a bit bonkers. Who are these "people" the OP thinks believe that a single test, which finds a single cell, that contains a Y chromosome is enough to say "You're a man, on your crossbarred bike, mate"

I just can't see that happening in the real world.

Exactly.

Apparently trying to tell all is woman how we'd react to a stray Y chromosome and is saying we wouldn't react that way - makes us aggressive.

The irony on another woman trying to say how other woman think and silence them is lost on the OP.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:17

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 10:44

Im actuall amused and laughing at the moment rather than aggressive. LOL at a geneticist believing that foetal transfer in a mother would make them fail a genetic test to determine if they were male. LOL at the idea, planted by the OP, that athletics bodies are proposing looking for 1 Y chromosome in a sample of 100s of thousands of cells.

because it happens

OP posts:
bigbabycooker · 06/04/2023 11:17

OP, I just don't see why this is an issue.

I mean, surely most reputable medical or sports testers would test more than once, especially if there was any doubt whatsoever, and they would not release the results, or even the fact of needing to test twice, to the public. Due to patient confidentiality.

Take the Semenya case: most of the women on this thread do not accept that she should be competing with women. But most of them would accept that the IAAF massively fucked up by not having tested her before she became so famous and having released the fact of the matter that she was going for genetic tests to the general public. Tests should be done in privacy, with the outcome of those tests handled sensitively (but with respect for biology and fairness to all).

Why would anyone even know that someone had a rogue Y chromosome and there was a need to repeat a test? How would any of the uppity women you are calling out on this thread even know that extra testing was taking place?

Museya15 · 06/04/2023 11:17

What is your actual point?