Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 11:32

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:31

I cant write any more right now . I tried to keep up with the posts but they were coming too fast. I will try and catch up later, if there are not too many posts.

But I hope at least some people understand the results of testing a bit better now

You've enlightened us precisely zero and failed to provide any evidence of your claim that this is happening to people now. What a silly thread.

ZombieMumEB · 06/04/2023 11:32

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:27

so, mocking the fact that I am severely dyslexic, and typing one handed in bed after major surgery makes you feel good, does it? And why are you doing that exactly? Because I am pointing out that aggression and hostility is being directed at people who have done absolutly nothing wrong, and you respond to that with mockery.......

I dont care, I dont know why you think I would

I would not like to be that sort of person myself, though

Here is one of many many MANY examples of transwomen being aggressive and hostile.
https://twitter.com/BillboardChris/status/1643113696150048768

https://twitter.com/BillboardChris/status/1643113696150048768

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 11:32

OP, are you saying a friend of yours is an elite athlete and was tested as part of the routine sports testing?

OR are you saying a friend of yours had a genetic test and they found a Y chromosome? Because anyone having genetic testing is taken through a consent form before the test, and this kind of result is one possibility you are warned of.

Florissante · 06/04/2023 11:31

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:18

Exactly, but my point is, that the line is not necessarily one test, and the level of ignorance shown in people insisting that one test is all it takes, is unhelpful, and does nothing for our cause

"Our cause"? Who is "us", Kemosabe?

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 11:31

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:28

because I have witnessed it, including this week

Then surely you would give an account of this in your OP.
How can we understand what happened and where any fault lies if you don't say.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:31

I cant write any more right now . I tried to keep up with the posts but they were coming too fast. I will try and catch up later, if there are not too many posts.

But I hope at least some people understand the results of testing a bit better now

OP posts:
SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Xiaoxiong · 06/04/2023 11:30

What happened with your friend @Nimbostratus100 ?

I agree with you that a single test is insufficient. No test is infallible and testing technicians are human beings that could make a human error once in a while. The sports bodies should use the same process as they do with drugs testing - an A sample, and if that shows up positive for drugs/XY chromosomes then you test the B sample that is collected at another site/time. For 99.9% of athletes the A sample will give conclusive results and the B sample is there for the other 0.01% as a confirmation. The test isn't looking for a single Y chromosome, but the presence of a Y chromosome in the vast majority of sampled cells indicating a male sample.

We've all been through covid and remember the issues of false positives and negatives, so we should apply the same standards to testing athletes. The stakes can be so high if they are unfairly blamed for doping or being XY when they in fact aren't.

MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 11:29

Mangomingo · 06/04/2023 11:19

Sorry back on the tangent of individuals with CAIS, I’ve always imagined they wouldn’t be very good at sport generally at an elite level, as testosterone is so closely linked to sporting prowess….. I haven’t looked into it at all but that was just my initial gut feeling. Am I wrong?

Apparently a lot of CAIS people work as models because they tend to have very long thin frames with small hips and boobs 🤷🏼‍♀️ the condition certainly doesn't tend towards high athleticism.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 11:29

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:28

because I have witnessed it, including this week

Please do provide evidence.

violence is never acceptable and should be reported to the police.

DinaofCloud9 · 06/04/2023 11:29

As if you're a geneticist.

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:29

sorry, 'geneticist'

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:28

RegainingTheWill2023 · 06/04/2023 10:50

What basis do you have for predicting that GC women will react with aggression and hatred to any (incredibly rare) biological females idenfied as having y chromosomes?

because I have witnessed it, including this week

OP posts:
SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:27

No geneticist would actually believe that this mother of 4 sons would show up, in any test, as a male 😂🤣

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:27

titchy · 06/04/2023 10:47

I suspect OP is a "geneticist" rather than a geneticist.

so, mocking the fact that I am severely dyslexic, and typing one handed in bed after major surgery makes you feel good, does it? And why are you doing that exactly? Because I am pointing out that aggression and hostility is being directed at people who have done absolutly nothing wrong, and you respond to that with mockery.......

I dont care, I dont know why you think I would

I would not like to be that sort of person myself, though

OP posts:
bigbabycooker · 06/04/2023 11:27

(And by the way, in elite sports, it happens quite frequently that people need to be tested more than once - athletes produce an A and B sample as a matter of course after races and samples are rerequested if there is any potential for contamination or difficulties with the sample taken. The fact of retesting really wouldn't suggest anything genetic, unless someone made a big circus around it).

BMW6 · 06/04/2023 11:26

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:23

so you will most likely have Y chromosomes in cells in multiple parts of your body, but you are still female, and have no male advantage in sport. That is the whole point

However, if you are tested, you might show up as male, there is that chance. In which case, you would need to be tested again

So then you present yourself to a doctor with your birth certificate 🤔

ZombieMumEB · 06/04/2023 11:26

@Nimbostratus100 but what I am pointing out is that the reflex hate, hostility and aggression from people supposedly wanting to support women's rights, does not help in any way, and there needs to be far more understanding towards women who are found to have a Y chromosome show up in their testing

Only 1 side is hateful, hostile and aggressive. Look in the mirror mate.

MaireadMcSweeney · 06/04/2023 11:25

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:06

no, I am saying that a similar procedure is done in forensics, where it is accepted that finding a Y chromosome does not mean that the person who toughed that door handle was male.

Just as finding a Y chromosome in a sample from an athlete does not mean that the athlete is male

So as a 'geneticist' apparently, are you saying there is no reliable test to determine whether someone with female appearing genitalia actually has XY chromosomes? Because if that's the case it's important information and contrary to what I understood.

Or are you saying the tests are complicated and may need to be replicated to ensure reliability? Because that's not a revelation frankly, and your assumption that a) the general public would have access to early results and b) therefore get the pitchforks out for these athletes is...a stretch

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:25

What is happening/has happened that caused you, as the OP of this thread, to need to start this thread to tell us that people are being declared male on the basis of one Y chromosome being found?

AnotherDayAnotherView · 06/04/2023 11:25

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:21

This is part of the problem, very simplified patterns taught at GCSE level, which is fine, as it give a good foundation to build on, but does not always represent the full reality, and people who don't take a subject any further are stuck with the GCSE over simplifications in their head for life- genetics isn't the only topic that this can be an issue in

As you say it is the solid "good foundation" from which to build knowledge and understanding. As a biologist myself, as any good scientist would agree, you start with first principles and build from there. If as you state you are a "geneticist" then you already know that you are spouting pseudoscience.

Cantstaystuckforever · 06/04/2023 11:25

Fortunately though, microchimerism is both micro and primarily occurs in those who have given birth. This is a small minority of women athletes and even more importantly will mean that the athlete in question is demonstrably has a womb...
All guidelines have edge cases, that's ok so long as the number is minimal and there's a way to follow up and make a call - both of which is true here.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 11:25

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:21

This is part of the problem, very simplified patterns taught at GCSE level, which is fine, as it give a good foundation to build on, but does not always represent the full reality, and people who don't take a subject any further are stuck with the GCSE over simplifications in their head for life- genetics isn't the only topic that this can be an issue in

Well, luckily, a GCSE in biology isn’t enough to gain employment in Elite Sports Science testing.

Surely you know this? 🤣

NecessaryScene · 06/04/2023 11:24

so you will most likely have Y chromosomes in cells in multiple parts of your body, but you are still female, and have no male advantage in sport. That is the whole point

Yes - and humans will often contain cat DNA in various places, and may test positive for being a cat.

Maybe they don't specifically teach you this in GCSE biology, but that's not a failure of GCSE biology...

SmartHome · 06/04/2023 11:24

Yes, what exactly happened? How many stupid women that don't understand genetics were involved? What did they say to your friend? What elit sport does your friend do?

Swipe left for the next trending thread