Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
YouJustDoYou · 06/04/2023 12:54

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/04/2023 12:53

Hahahaha just at the point you were asked to explain what happened to your friend. Great timing.

That darn scientific logical reality, stops them in their tracks every time. Pesky facts

YouJustDoYou · 06/04/2023 12:53

FatFucker · 06/04/2023 12:44

I normally can't be assed with these type of threads as they are so obviously TRAs, but this one is just hilarious!!

He's meant to be a geneticist, who's had a female friend who wasn't allowed to race as she tested as male!

I'm loving it! I knew NOTHING about genetics but suspect a hell of lot more than the OP, after reading some of the really interesting PPs.

Oh, for sure, this never happened to the op 😂

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/04/2023 12:53

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 11:31

I cant write any more right now . I tried to keep up with the posts but they were coming too fast. I will try and catch up later, if there are not too many posts.

But I hope at least some people understand the results of testing a bit better now

Hahahaha just at the point you were asked to explain what happened to your friend. Great timing.

Genevieva · 06/04/2023 12:53

@Shelefttheweb Truly inspired! Love your comment.

Barbecuebeans · 06/04/2023 12:50

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 10:26

The levels of hostility and ignorance on this thread is exactly what I am talking about.

This just makes woman who are defending womans rights look aggressive, and stupid

How does that help?

Hahaha. You're talking about women on this thread being aggressive and stupid, when

a) you don't know they're women
b) you're the only one throwing out insults and not engaging with reasoned points.

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 12:50

I have to say, I am impressed that OP hung around to try and argue their point. Most TRAs drop what they presume is a gotcha and then leave, especially when women disagree (aka ‘are aggressive and hysterical’)

EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 12:49

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 12:45

This may freak OP out even more; my body contains cow DNA, and tomato DNA, and lettuce DNA, and wheat DNA, and….

Ooooh! It’s lunchtime already!

monsteramunch · 06/04/2023 12:47

Are you going to say any athlete can enter the woman's game, if they claim to have given birth in the past?

Look at the logistics of it! All anyone would have to do is make that claim, free pass to woman's sport!

If someone can produce medical records they gave birth, to back up their claim they have done so, that would seem like a pretty logical way to satisfy burden of proof.

ZombieMumEB · 06/04/2023 12:46

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 12:45

This may freak OP out even more; my body contains cow DNA, and tomato DNA, and lettuce DNA, and wheat DNA, and….

You win the thread.

IfIHadAHeart · 06/04/2023 12:46

I just want to say thank you, OP.

I’ve been having a bit of a shit time of late, and have really struggled to find anything to smile about. This thread has had me chuckling away. I’m not sure that’s what you intended when posting it…

I would love to hear more about your background in genetics, just so I can steer my DC towards a different university etc.

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 12:45

This may freak OP out even more; my body contains cow DNA, and tomato DNA, and lettuce DNA, and wheat DNA, and….

monsteramunch · 06/04/2023 12:45

this is exactly what I mean by aggression.

You think the phrase "crack on" is aggressive?

Goodness.

FatFucker · 06/04/2023 12:44

I normally can't be assed with these type of threads as they are so obviously TRAs, but this one is just hilarious!!

He's meant to be a geneticist, who's had a female friend who wasn't allowed to race as she tested as male!

I'm loving it! I knew NOTHING about genetics but suspect a hell of lot more than the OP, after reading some of the really interesting PPs.

user1492757084 · 06/04/2023 12:44

Couple a DNA test with a questionnaire including a question,
"Have you ever been pregnant or given birth?"
That should increase the accuracy.

PriOn1 · 06/04/2023 12:42

The problem is the attitudes of some women, who dont really understand the genetics, reacting so angrily to athletes who need more than one test.

Ah yes. Those famous cases where testing for sex has occurred, it has been reported in the Daily Mail that a single Y chromosome has been found, and women have reacted angrily in a public way.

Presumably OP (and the poster who spuriously introduced the Daily Mail) can show the tweets or other social media posts where this unlikely sequence of events occurred?

YouJustDoYou · 06/04/2023 12:42

I love how so many TRAs suddenly become either "medical personnel" or "biologists" to "prove" their viewpoint 😂

Hankunamatata · 06/04/2023 12:40

Surely if there is an issue with cheek swab test then they follow up with blood test.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 06/04/2023 12:40

titchy · 06/04/2023 12:37

I'm a geneticist and so's my wife!

You’re not a geneticist, you’re a very naughty…

hold on, let me check your karyotype…

….

Mumsnetter!

Onegingerhead · 06/04/2023 12:40

So it’s actually normal PCR they do, not qPCR? Either way it would give an extremely,extremely thin Y chr band in case of microchimerism methinks. Similar to low level contamination.
No idea how they actually do the test, but would be interesting to design one that takes the (potential) issue into equation. But prolly it already exists

Kucinghitam · 06/04/2023 12:40

LangClegsInSpace · 06/04/2023 12:26

This thread was brought to you live from the 100m strawman hurdling event.

Superb!! Grin

Genevieva · 06/04/2023 12:39

Gotta love Monty Python :-)

titchy · 06/04/2023 12:37

I'm a geneticist and so's my wife!

Genevieva · 06/04/2023 12:37

Unlike drugs testing, genetic testing for athlete is not a common practice. Indeed, genetic tests are not widely used to prove someone's biological sex in any area of life. The reason is obvious - unless someone has problematic clinical symptoms that suggest a DNA test is necessary, it simply isn't necessary. Biological sex is physically apparent. Whether someone has a second X or a Y chromosome has a large and obvious impact on our physiology. With this in mind, your post seems pointless.

Shelefttheweb · 06/04/2023 12:36

Onegingerhead · 06/04/2023 12:21

And if I have a son and a male cat, will I test as a tomcat?

molecular biologist here

You might if they are swabbing your door knobs after you petted the cat.

daisy1765 · 06/04/2023 12:35

the OP is a geneticist? HmmHmm
Yeah, obviously.