Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out that one Y chromosome does not make you a male

512 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 09:53

In response to other posts insisting that one genetic test and one Y chromosome makes an athlete indisputably male with no room for error, I just want to point out that it not true.

There is always genetic exchange, for example, between a mother and baby, so anyone who has had a son will still have Y chromosomes in some cells in their body, and that will possibly show up in a genetic screening.

I am all for keeping men out of women's sport, and defining them genetically, but please lets not go over the top - one test does not prove you are male

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
sst1234 · 08/04/2023 11:29

More linguistic contortionism over what makes a man a man and a woman a woman. There are only two sexes. The absence of something regular from a man or a woman doesn’t make them something else. It just means they have an abnormality, but still a man or woman.

tractorreactor · 08/04/2023 11:01

My personal opinion is that only female/women can give birth. That's the measure I'd take when considering why a female may have a Y chromosome floating around. Shame it's all seemed to have become so complicated. No need for cheek swabs at all on mothers really is there...

Furries · 08/04/2023 00:54

If a poster is going to post conflicting info about who they are/what they do, then it’s tough luck if someone calls them out. Especially if they’re trying to shut down other opinions (or, more importantly, knowledge) down.

Troll-hunting guidelines must be a nightmare to enforce. I prefer troll-type posts to stand, and to see the arguments against them. But it’s a balance against giving the buggers “air-time”.

Anyway, good to see that OP must be feeling better after their surgery and able to post elsewhere (whilst inserting a caveat that hostility and aggression is expected). At least they’re cracking on with things.

Shelefttheweb · 08/04/2023 00:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 23:16

@PriamFarrl it wasn't at all like that, but I can't explain why it wasn't.

I had awareness of the OP before this thread.

PriamFarrl · 07/04/2023 23:02

See, I can understand recognising someone I know online, and then being able to say that I know they are who they say they are, but I don’t know how I would know that a friend knew them.

I can’t imagine reading this and then messaging a friend and saying
‘hey, do you know someone who chats shit online claiming to be a maths teacher and a geneticist?’
‘why yes I do. Well I know someone who is an adult woman who chats shit on anonymous forums and could be anywhere in the world but I’m not sure if she’s a geneticist, or a maths teacher’.
‘that’s her’.

Boomboom22 · 07/04/2023 22:58

Op is nearly 60 she said earlier so plenty of time for all her careers 🤣

WarningToTheCurious · 07/04/2023 22:19

DecayedStrumpet · 07/04/2023 19:56

This is such a weird thread.

OP - microchimerism is a thing
MN scientists - yeah we know
OP - my mate had one Y chromosome in a sample and got shamed and abused
MN - really? Normally they just investigate further. Tell us more.
OP - you're all ignorant and abusive <flounces>

OP <flounces> due to post op something or other resulting in an inability to type and thus fails to explain why their mate had fallen foul of those pesky Y chromosomes.

Meanwhile, OP has been busy on other threads at all hours helpfully explaining asexuality and the UK’s education system.

Mossstitch · 07/04/2023 22:17

titchy · 06/04/2023 10:20

Lol - best post in the thread!

👏👏💐

Kucinghitam · 07/04/2023 20:52

DecayedStrumpet · 07/04/2023 19:56

This is such a weird thread.

OP - microchimerism is a thing
MN scientists - yeah we know
OP - my mate had one Y chromosome in a sample and got shamed and abused
MN - really? Normally they just investigate further. Tell us more.
OP - you're all ignorant and abusive <flounces>

Grin

You missed out a few intermediate steps.

OP - I'm a Geneticist, dontcha know?
MN - Chinny reckon Hmm
OP - Not only that, but I'm the only MNer who has higher than GCSE Biology! <flounces again>

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 20:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I have no intention of losing my temper in the face of deliberate goading which cleverly skirts round the Talk Guidelines.

Have a pleasant evening.

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 20:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 20:07

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 19:57

Oh I’d that like “you wouldn’t know her, she doesn’t go here?” 😂😂😂

In the face of this insinuation that I'm a liar and digging for further details which I've declined to supply, I'm finding it difficult to remain civil.

matis · 07/04/2023 19:59

The op has certainly had an eclectic career.

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 19:57

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 19:49

No, you'd have to know someone who'd met her.

Oh I’d that like “you wouldn’t know her, she doesn’t go here?” 😂😂😂

DecayedStrumpet · 07/04/2023 19:56

This is such a weird thread.

OP - microchimerism is a thing
MN scientists - yeah we know
OP - my mate had one Y chromosome in a sample and got shamed and abused
MN - really? Normally they just investigate further. Tell us more.
OP - you're all ignorant and abusive <flounces>

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 19:49

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 19:47

So how do you know she’s female and not a school pupil? Cos you’d have to know somebody to know that wouldn’t you?

No, you'd have to know someone who'd met her.

Happylittlechicken · 07/04/2023 19:47

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:50

I didn't say I knew her.

Try reading properly.

So how do you know she’s female and not a school pupil? Cos you’d have to know somebody to know that wouldn’t you?

ArabellaScott · 07/04/2023 19:29

she's not a man or a school pupil

Bit outing.

itsgettingweird · 07/04/2023 19:18

Clymene · 07/04/2023 10:14

To my knowledge, the OP has identified as a geneticist, a secondary school maths teacher, and autism expert.

A veritable Mr Benn

More like Mr Bean Grin

OMG12 · 07/04/2023 18:23

PriamFarrl · 07/04/2023 13:11

How would you know that your friend has met the op?

Well I suppose it’s quite unique being a geneticist mathematician statistician teacher who has worked with sex offenders. Prob discussed this polymath in the pub? Waiting for next week to find out they work for NASA and have walked in the moon

HatchedInALaboratory · 07/04/2023 16:29

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:56

Or posters could observe the Talk Guidelines and report inconsistencies to MNHQ.

In any case I can't comment on her career or expertise if I wanted to. As I said, I know she's not a man or a school pupil.

Are you OPs cousin? 🤭

ATerrorofLeftovers · 07/04/2023 16:20

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 15:35

I've already said that I have no idea what her expertise in genetics is, if you bothered to read properly.

Oh, I do beg your pardon. I must have missed that post out of the twenty pages of the thread. What a terrible person I am. 🙄

So you vouch for OP being female, but nothing else, right?

And no doubt you fully understand why posters aren’t happy to take her assertions at face value, given the glaring inconsistencies in her claimed expertise. Seeing as only a fool would do so, in the circumstances. Right?

Not quite sure why you’re getting so snippy, quite honestly, in support of someone you say you don’t know, who’s behaved like a bit of an arse on the thread.

HatchedInALaboratory · 07/04/2023 16:19

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 16:10

Quite.

And if we reported every Mumsnetter who randomly talked shit we’d all have sore thumbs!

And if mumsnet deleted all those threads, there wouldn’t be many left to read some weeks. I presume that’s why they leave them up. The fantasists keep the site in business. 😬

EmotionalSupportHyena · 07/04/2023 16:10

SmartHome · 07/04/2023 16:08

Don't be so ridiculous. Nobody is "alleging" that this OP is a man or a school people. They're taking the piss out of someone making themselves look ridiculous and trying to lord it over other posters. I could give a shit what sex or age the OP is. Talking shit is talking shit.

Quite.

And if we reported every Mumsnetter who randomly talked shit we’d all have sore thumbs!

Swipe left for the next trending thread