Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think growing up poor can result in more fear of risk?

59 replies

ForestOfTea · 06/04/2023 09:22

I grew up in the 80s in a household full of love but intermittently lacking in money (with retrospect, based on the amount of baked beans consumed, probably lacking in money more than I realised at the time)

Growing up I was always anxious about loosing things, as mum was clear they couldn’t be replaced, so I was super careful with school jumpers/pens etc.

Now I am older and have a good income, but still have a great fear about loosing things which I’ve realised is disproportionate to others- for example, on the beach I worry about leaving things unattended, whilst friends who grew up richer happily leave stuff.

This extends to other things too- I need to get to trains etc with plenty of time, even though if I missed it now I could afford to buy another ticket.

And to job opportunities- if there is an amazing job with a higher salary but it’s a fixed term contract, I am afraid to leave the stability of my lower (but still well-paid) job whilst colleagues who grew up richer jump at the opportunity, sure of parental parachutes/other opportunities.

Or, rather than being a remnant of growing up poor, is this just ‘me’ and I’d be risk-adverse regardless?

OP posts:
Badbudgeter · 06/04/2023 11:29

I grew up poor and am very risk averse too. I can’t even play the lottery. Possibility of a life changing sum for a couple of quid. All I can see is the giving up of money for nothing in return.

FourTeaFallOut · 06/04/2023 11:25

I suppose it's true for some but I grew up in similar circumstances and I wouldn't say I was risk adverse, infact, in my twenties and thirties my risk taking behaviour leaned between bold and reckless and I'm terrible at losing stuff.

I guess my childhood taught me that being poor wouldn't be the end of my world. Each time I rolled the dice I was confident I could start again from scratch if required.

I have become more conservative about risk as I've aged but that has far more to do with the deleterious effect of living with a chronic illness which bites more and more as the years go by.

housemaus · 06/04/2023 11:23

Depends on personality - both DH and I grew up extremely poor. I am a careful worrying risk-averse type and he is a 'fuck it I never had spare money or a safety net as a child so why not enjoy it now' type (subconsciously, mostly).

ForestOfTea · 06/04/2023 11:19

I really want to have your outlook @Whattodonut - it would make life so much nicer. And ironically due to saving/ working continuously since age of 14/not expanding my lifestyle/expectations as I’ve weren’t more I am (nearly) at the stage where I could, in theory, ‘insure’ myself and be my own safety net…. But instead I find myself investing in another safety harness to keep attached to the trapeze!

OP posts:
LadyMcLadyface · 06/04/2023 11:08

My DH grew up relatively poor (central European country during Communism) and is very risk averse when it comes to spending, buying anything on credit etc., is much more of a saver than I am (my parents are financially comfortable and to my knowledge this was the case for my whole childhood). So I think it can definitely have an impact.

Makesense12 · 06/04/2023 11:01

Yes and no. It can make people go the other way as nothing to loose. I know both types and wealthy people fearful of loosing their money and scared to take risks

RosaGallica · 06/04/2023 10:59

It’s certainly true, although I find the middle class attitudes, that it is somehow wrong to have fear of risk, extremely annoying. Most of the world is not western middle class - ergo it is their attitude towards risk that is the unhealthy one. Time and age has something to do with it too - risk and risk takers only started to be worshipped in the late 80s and especially in the 90s.

Whattodonut · 06/04/2023 10:57

Completely! I grew up in a well off house. (I was about to write comfortable but that would show we were pretty well off!)
I realised the other day that I don't fear boring jobs because I will just leave. And because I will get another job soon enough and everything will be fine. Because it always has. In my early 20s I had a few years of a series of temping jobs. Sometimes I was short on the rent and paid for petrol by cheque because it gave me 3 days to find the money. I used my overdraft but always paid it back. Life was text book hand to mouth but it didn't really stress me out. I felt like there was always a safety net for my trappeezing!

DH grew up in a council house. His family aren't poor but they were less secure. And it shows. He is bored in his job. He could become a contractor and take much more interesting jobs. But he is thinking on making sure DC and I and the house are safe. It isn't worth the risk. Whereas I think he should because being bored 9hours a day is not worth it.

Inaea · 06/04/2023 10:55

Definitely. I’ve met several men who made a lot of money in risky tech start-ups that went well, and something they all had in common was wealthy parents. They could afford to throw several years of money and effort into something that might flop because the safety net was always there. Now they boast about how you “have to take risks in life.”

My parents were very tight for money and while I buy my share of tat, I’m extremely risk-averse in my life choices.

ForestOfTea · 06/04/2023 10:54

So many things here that I relate to! My DH was bemused to find my mums kitchen resembles a small corner shop with multiples of many things- but think this is similar to @JudyRudy’s example- not that my dad disappeared, but that there were periods of less money so my mum ‘squirreled’ in the good periods in anticipation of the bad. Also that you often save money by buying in multiples!

I also find it harder to get rid of things than my DH (who grew up with more money)- whilst his attitude is it’s not needed and if you need it in the future we can buy another, my thought is always store it as in the future I might not have the money to buy another. I’ve improved on this front slightly by Re-framing it to if I don’t need it now I should donate to charity then someone who does need it can have it and the charity can make money, which helps as I then believe karma will help me find another in the future if I do need it.

To @HeyDemonsItsYaGirl - I totally conform to your average person would see moving to a non-permanent job as a bad move, but as you progress higher in many careers the ‘spring boards’ to get you higher still are often the fixed term or temporary opportunities… and I increasing see that the inability of those from poorer backgrounds to jump onto these (along with less ability to pay for self development to help career progression, such as additional qualifications or networking opportunities that involve shelling out for drinks in expensive locations) as reasons why progression is more limited for those who don’t come from money.

OP posts:
glowyhighway · 06/04/2023 10:38

fairypeasant · 06/04/2023 09:32

It's your personality.

I grew up poor. I also probably have ADHD. I'm the complete opposite of you. However, even though I could afford nice things, I don't get them, because I'd only lose them.

Different people are different. Some people are rich because they're careful.

Yes, personality plays a part, but clearly so do circumstances!

For example, my mum and I are both extreme worriers. Because she grew up in poverty, a great deal of her worrying is directed towards career and money (despite the fact that both my mum and dad are in the top tier of earners in the country, and in very stable fields).

I never wanted for anything material in my childhood. So all my worrying has never even touched career and money – I can't relate to any of OP's examples at all – but I've found lots of other things to worry about 😂

TheMoth · 06/04/2023 10:31

Massively. It's part of the reason I became a teacher. Didn't know what to do after uni. Spent a year doing shit jobs, then panicked into teacher training, because I was already 22 and needed a stable job, rather than drifting about to find what I really wanted to do.

I also live in fear of losing my job and being thought lazy. When dh was made redundant a few years ago, my reaction was out of all proportion. Especially as he found another job quite quickly.

JudgeRudy · 06/04/2023 10:13

Of course it influences. I get angry when I hear people talk about how they built a business empire from scratch....like Richard Branson for example. ...but he borrowed a few grand from a relative and if it went wrong the consequences would be so different.
I also think having children makes a difference. Maybe I'd risk my home, but would I risk my children's.

Your upbringing definitely influences. My grandad used to go away for a month every year and leave my nan with no income. She would squirrel away food leading up to it. My mum's retired now but she still has a fear she'll be without food. We regularly find 8 year old tins, or 20 kilos of pasta. It's engraved.

NumberTheory · 06/04/2023 10:11

My experience has been that I’ve become more risk averse as I’ve got more well off. It may be to do with maturing, but it feels more like it’s to do with having more to lose now.

DandledASandle · 06/04/2023 10:11
  • meant to say: You don't have to have grown up rich to be careful about leaving stuff unattended on a beach, but that doesn't mean your reluctance to take risk doesn't stem from your own experiences of growing up poor.
DandledASandle · 06/04/2023 10:09

I think it must be multi-factorial. It's natural for the situation you grew up in to inform the person you become, but there is a complex interaction between your genes, what happens to your family and how you learn to respond to it. You can be a risk taker or not whether you have money or not. You don't have to have grown up rich to be careful about leaving stuff unattended on a beach.

Eg do you play the lottery? If you don't have much money you can say "yes, I really need that win" or "no, can't spare the cash". Different responses to the same situation. You might have been brought up to have the latter response, but either is a common and normal response to not having much money, and indeed a lot of lottery players are on lower incomes.

IhearyouClemFandango · 06/04/2023 10:08

It’s a known fact/study isn’t it? I’m sure I read a book/article about how poverty massively increases risk averse behaviour because you’re not used to having a safety net, whether that is savings or family who can afford to help. As a result people who grow up poor tend to have higher baseline stress levels for the same reason.

Halfull · 06/04/2023 10:07

I’m 47 and I still live in fear of ‘losing my job’. I’ve been permanently employed since Uni too.

I also have a pathological fear of being branded lazy so regularly run at everything at 100% till I burn out. Drives my lovely OH mad. I genuinely don’t know how financially secure I would have to be to not worry.

I am convinced it’s a product of growing up not exactly in poverty but certainly bloody surrounded by it. Think more MC people don’t quite understand the risk, if you don’t see the risk you can’t have the fear?

JudgeRudy · 06/04/2023 10:05

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 06/04/2023 09:43

I wouldn't got from a permanent contract to a fixed term contract for example.

Do others consider this unusually risk-averse? I think an average person would consider it a bad move.

Yes all things being equal you'd stick, but a 6 month fixed term in a better job could be a springboard to better things.....or 6 months out of work! If you're poor with no savings 3 months of unemployment could mean losing your home.

stayathomer · 06/04/2023 10:02

Grew up in an average income house but we went poor poor for years when I was a sahm and I do it all now, panic about spending, worry about losing things, over analysing every little thing, and I talk waaaayyy too much about costs etc (oh my god it costs x? That’s x percentage of the electricity bill, or a food shop, or the cost of 4 tee shirts for the kids… etc etc!) it’s horrible

JE17 · 06/04/2023 09:58

I'm exactly the same as you, I'll never shake it off. I've got a "look after the pennies" attitude even though I'm very much aware of how comfortable family life is for us in comparison to many.

CreationNat1on · 06/04/2023 09:57

I grew up in a wealthy but risky household, always an attitude of what's the new project/devil may care. There would be annoyance if something wasn't as successful as originally anticipated, but that was a dent to the ego rather than any brutal personal impact. Total roller-coaster, almost like winning the lottery then losing at the casino, always drama, always changes from one investment to another, big holidays, big tax bills, big stresses, big party blow outs.

However my mother grew up poor and even though has been pretty hard working and well off all her life, she would be enraged if she didn't get the full value out of something or lost something. She doesn't and wouldn't buy a designer handbag.

I m now relatively self made(ish) rich, as in I ve earned my own money buy I guess it's easier to do that when you ve grown up with this (delusional) iron clad belief that if you work hard and get stuck in, you ll make money.

I ve always, always worked, but I realise now, that blind belief is only possible when there is an endless stream of money coming into the household and even if you loose 100k in an investment, we ll all just carry on regardless, there was no mortgage growing up, there was always an alternative and lots of different (of varying successes) money steams.

Regardless of the above I m not a big spender, expensive clothes are a waste. I always prioritise paying off bills before luxuries, to the extent I pay off mortgages before spending on my lifestyle. I shop in Lidl and tesco, I go to a cheap local hairdressers.

But I jump from any job that is toxic. I have no pension. I don't like fawning, false narratives or inauthenticity. All of these personality traits mean, I m a bit volatile when it comes to work, it doesn't bother me one bit to leave a pensionable job, I hate feeling trapped...... I may not live long as a pensioner, and I don't mind relying on myself, I don't need a golfing old age, I can do something else. I can live frugally if I need to.

I guess my wanton spirit of freedom comes from a very financially liberal household. I've sometimes not gotten a job, because I ve previously left pensionable jobs. On the other hand, the diving straight into the deep end mentality, has also helped me in my career, I have a diverse skillset in my field, not pigeonholed into one workspace all my life.

In one way I m super sensible, pay off all loans, never have an overdraft, always earning, in another way I m reckless, leave jobs, with nothing to go and gave to start again. I always pay for myself in between jobs.... Savings.

However I m starting to realise it gets more difficult to get jobs as you age, and also I probably need to cop on and spend at least 10 years paying into a pension....... Fuck it.

Wenfy · 06/04/2023 09:55

JaceLancs · 06/04/2023 09:47

Growing up poor has left me with fear over ending up the same and during times when I have been poor I was very cautious
It hasn’t made me risk averse although I am a worrier and tend to weigh up decisions especially career wise
As a child I never felt I had enough of anything so now I tend towards excess
We only ever had one pair of shoes at a time - in those days PE kit including pumps were supplied by the school so thankfully didn’t need even those - so now I have shoes for every occasion in every colour and treat myself to designer shoes every now and again

I also grew up poor (relative poverty in the UK) while DH grew up in absolute poverty abroad. We are more likely to take measured risks and assess the value of things before we buy them and this applies to both of our families too. Everyone I know who was dirt poor (ie those of us who skipped PE because we didn’t have vests or only wore pants during our periods or didn’t have clean ones) has done fairly well for themselves by taking massive risks even if it is in illegal areas (eg drug dealing)z

BCBird · 06/04/2023 09:54

I grew up poor but realistically so were my friends. If someone as,my definition of -rich, two.parents working and had a car or had their own house the were the exception in my circle. I have a threshold re money in my mind re expenditure. I spend money on things but baulk st big things. I would say the biggest influence my background has had on my spending as an adult is when I bought my house. I bought something I could easily afford as I am extremely cautious but with hindsight wish I'd had advice and bought something more expensive so I could downsize. Oh well

Wenfy · 06/04/2023 09:52

There is evidence to suggest that growing poor actually increases risk taking behaviour. It’s partly why poor boys join gangs, or start investing (penny shares / investments are a huge thing right now), or set up businesses. It’s also why poor women and girls are more likely to have problems in pregnancy - eg smoking, drinking etc.