Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you've experienced reactions like this( tantrums basically from adults)when you have suddenly decided to have decent boundaries?

111 replies

malificent7 · 06/04/2023 08:57

When explaining to fiance's ex that she wasn't coming to our wedding ceremony, only the after party, she stopped talking to me for a good few months and is still off with me now.

When explaining to my friend that now my dd is a teen she choses her own friends nowadays rather than play with her dd ( who was mean to my dd). Apparently my dd is horrid...much stomping and bleating.

Why are people so entitled?

I think I have been a people pleaser forever and now, mid 40s I suddenly want boundaries and people do not like it at all.

Luckily my dd has superb boundaries as we can see above and I applaud her.

Any other examples please welcome!

OP posts:
ScotsBluebell · 06/04/2023 13:41

Have twice experienced middle aged men throwing ALL their toys out of the pram in meetings when someone expressed very mild disagreement. One was a head teacher who had been fibbing to parents and the local authority. He threw a literal tantrum, shouting and throwing himself about like a two year old. The other was an even older man at a community council meeting who drummed his feet on the floor and yelled at everyone when (very politely) challenged. Extraordinary.

Charlottewebsbabies · 06/04/2023 13:39

My sd wasn't getting on with her mother (I can't say I blame her-her mother is a nutter-i don't say that about another woman
lightly,but I've been on the receiving end for years)

Anyway,sd told us she was moving in with us

I redecorated the spare room made it cosy and welcomed her

She walked in,told her dad it was a shithole and gave him a list of stuff she wanted for the room-nothing cost less than £50-she wanted a new bed,bedding,plants,candles-it was a long list

I put up with this-but refused to buy anything that was on this damn list-her dad agreed with me and told her this

After about a month of her living with us,she was unbelievably rude to me,made endless demands,would make the biggest mess known to man and would just walk off,she would break stuff and either ignore it or deny it,blocked the toilet everyday,would demand (say) almond milk and bagels but not touch them until they went off,shed eave every light/the heating on and leave the house,would appear to demand money and demand to choose what to have for dinner every night-it was soul destroying-nothing was good enough

We both work full time and we both got sick of this fast-coming home to a shithole,not of pur making was soul crushing,then we'd find broken stuff laying around and then we'd have to unblock the lav-everyday

I made the mistake of saying that as she was almost 18,she should be getting a job

Cue a shit ton on tears,playing us off with her mother,(endless phone calls screaming at me to work longer hours and give sd more money-mother is on benefits herself and hasnt worked for well over 20 years)shit stirring the pot with my narc (I'm nc with them) family,showing up at my work to scream at me and just stirring the pot with everyone I know-thankfully,they all told her to get back in her box,so she's gone further afield with her poison

I put my foot down and told her 'job or leave'

Her exact words where 'YOU have to pay my way until I marry a rich man,I'm not getting a job!'

3 weeks later she was back living with her mother-I'm the evil bitch in all this

A week after that she came back to my house thinking I wasn't in let herself in with a key she'd had cut and had a shock at seeing me

A massive row later she did leave the spare key but has done nothing but stir the pot with my family,slagged me off to everyone I know,told everyone i hit her,(i didnt)rings her dad only when she wants something that benefits herself,has done revenge porn against me and I know she's posted dog shit through my letterbox

All because I told her to get a job and pay her own way-and stood up to her when she refused

And she still doesn't have a job

Ktime · 06/04/2023 13:36

Just to add having a holiday let was not something I’d ever wanted to do (but I’d ended up doing the turn rounds anyway).

Why are you doing the work for a holiday let he wanted?

Ktime · 06/04/2023 13:36

Isheabastard · 06/04/2023 13:22

We have a holiday house we rent out and as it was empty my husband decided to organise a rugby watching weekend with 4 other mates. This was a blokes only thing.

He asked me to make up all the beds, so I asked if they could bring their own bedding. I’d been relentlessly doing all the bed changing, washing and cleaning and turning around the house for holiday lets for 5 years.

He called me lazy and said it would only take a few minutes. He then got cross and said he’d do it himself (best result for me). Only he then decided to ask everyone to bring their own bedding.

Just to add having a holiday let was not something I’d ever wanted to do (but I’d ended up doing the turn rounds anyway).

Is your husband always this selfish and lazy? Does he not benefit from the holiday let money too?

I would appraise how much you do for this man and if he is worth it.

RampantIvy · 06/04/2023 13:33

Maybe it is because DH and I have such clear boundaries good bullshit radar we don't actually know anyone who behaves like this. Perhaps they avoid us, or they don't ask for anything unreasonable because they know the answer will be no.

Isheabastard · 06/04/2023 13:22

We have a holiday house we rent out and as it was empty my husband decided to organise a rugby watching weekend with 4 other mates. This was a blokes only thing.

He asked me to make up all the beds, so I asked if they could bring their own bedding. I’d been relentlessly doing all the bed changing, washing and cleaning and turning around the house for holiday lets for 5 years.

He called me lazy and said it would only take a few minutes. He then got cross and said he’d do it himself (best result for me). Only he then decided to ask everyone to bring their own bedding.

Just to add having a holiday let was not something I’d ever wanted to do (but I’d ended up doing the turn rounds anyway).

MoongazyHare · 06/04/2023 13:21

Perimenopause is a great time for realising that you just don’t have to put up with people’s shit any longer. It’s very empowering!

OMalleytheAlleyyCat · 06/04/2023 13:15

Ah, I've got one -

My mum brought her poodle with her for the first time to visit myself and my baby (we live quite far apart).

The dog made me very nervous, barking and growling at baby because my mum was cutesy-cooing him. The dog was jealous. He's notoriously bad with children and other dogs and generally poorly behaved.

This was mid November and I told mum not to bring this dog with her for Christmas. I don't want my baby's first Christmas to be about keeping them apart.

Oh the dramatics. How could I? What short notice. How selfish, how awful.

I told her to grow up (I later apologised for that).

Recently we were chatting about it and she said;

"Well...it wasn't what you said [the dog can't come], it was the way you said it"

I asked "How did I say it?"

She said "Well...you said yourself you were rude, you apologised" and she changed the subject.

See, what she did there was reframe the incident as her having a strop because I was rude to her, rather than me being rude to her because she was having a strop.

Fairyliz · 06/04/2023 13:05

I don’t know my daughter always seemed to have tantrums which obviously worried me tremendously and quite often embarrassed me. She always has very fixed ridged ideas of how things should be done. Eg in your examples there are certain people who ‘should’ be invited to a wedding, irrespective of whether or not you like them. If you always see friend A at 7pm on Thursday that should always happen, even if they had some sort of family crisis going on.
She’s recently in her 20’s been diagnosed with ASD which accounts for the rigid thinking and meltdowns when things don’t go to plan.

Hankunamatata · 06/04/2023 12:58

saraclara · 06/04/2023 12:43

I think it depends how you express your boundaries. I had a friend who sent me an email in the middle of the night, angrily expressing her boundary (that I had no idea was an issue) in such an abrupt and unpleasant way, that I was absolutely distraught. Without going into any details, she'd never once expressed, even subtly, that anything was wrong.

I didn't throw a tantrum, in fact I apologised (even though I couldn't see what I was apologising for) but she still ceased contact with me and though it's years later, it still hurts.

So yes, if you're going to express a boundary, don't wait until you're infuriated and express it bluntly or in a way that could be hurtful.
If you do it in the early days, calmly and pleasantly, it's fine.

Urgh I had an ex friend do this to me. I apologise but she cut contact. Then she tried to reconnect when she found out I was pregnant a couple of years later. I couldn't forgive at that point as she had hurt me too much.

Hankunamatata · 06/04/2023 12:55

malificent7 · 06/04/2023 09:46

Sorry he's not going to contribute as much to my wedding as he is to my sister's. I don't mind...it comes with strings, but it hurt. I have distanced myself and told him he should have made a spreadsheet!

Suppose depends, for example if he paid for you to go through uni but your sister didn't go to uni.

DiscontinuedModelHusband · 06/04/2023 12:48

DW has (finally) realised that she doesn't have to bend herself in half to appease her DM anymore.

has started wearing what she wants, seeing who she wants, parenting our DC how she wants, having fun for herself occasionally.

the spite and venom that this has brought forth is pretty disgusting, coming from an 80+ year old self-proclaimed "Christian".

saraclara · 06/04/2023 12:43

I think it depends how you express your boundaries. I had a friend who sent me an email in the middle of the night, angrily expressing her boundary (that I had no idea was an issue) in such an abrupt and unpleasant way, that I was absolutely distraught. Without going into any details, she'd never once expressed, even subtly, that anything was wrong.

I didn't throw a tantrum, in fact I apologised (even though I couldn't see what I was apologising for) but she still ceased contact with me and though it's years later, it still hurts.

So yes, if you're going to express a boundary, don't wait until you're infuriated and express it bluntly or in a way that could be hurtful.
If you do it in the early days, calmly and pleasantly, it's fine.

Newpuppymummy · 06/04/2023 12:31

I had a friend who lives 250 miles away. She invited us to a summer party that she was having. We travel down and stayed over the night before. On the morning of the party my daughter had a rash which friend decided to diagnose as chickenpox. She had already had chickenpox. I took her to the chemist who said it was allergic reaction from playing on grass the day before which made sense. Friend says we aren’t allowed at the party but can be in the upstairs bedroom. Her reason was that even though we knew it wasn’t chickenpox her guests might think it was and leave. We left and not spoken to her since.

LakeTiticaca · 06/04/2023 12:26

Why has your fiancé's ex been invited to your wedding party?

Theunamedcat · 06/04/2023 12:18

Yup watching it play out in real time right now withy ex and our eldest he ignored and emotionally manipulated him for years I warned ex prioritise your kids or they won't prioritise you first to go was ds2 fine he has sen that's his excuse for why he won't see him but ds1 has increasingly put himself first this year and the messages back have gone from ok sweetheart see you next time to "ok" that's it now normally withdrawal of affection is a trigger that sends ds running in a panic this time he is like....meh

Ingrowncrotchhair · 06/04/2023 12:10

Waterlooville · 06/04/2023 09:05

With both of the examples you gave it sounds like the people involved were coming to terms with life changing stages (becoming an ex, children growing up) rather than being stroppy about a particular event. You could try being a bit more empathetic. You shouldn't have done anything different in either scenario but you could try thinking more about why they might behave disproportionately.

Nope.

Echobelly · 06/04/2023 12:08

A few years agoMIL demanded that I invite BIL's family (4 people) to dinner that night (when I was in the office at the time) when she found they weren't invited, or else they wouldn't come.

Told her probably best that they didn't come. She was upset as she thought BIL would be offended not to be invited (he wouldn't be). You know what, if she'd asked nicely and not taken offence on someone else's behalf, I might have found a way to accommodate. But a bad-tempered dinner that had happened under duress what not have been fun for anyone.

hopeishere · 06/04/2023 12:04

BIL is a massive tantrum thrower if he doesn't get his own way / is called out over his behaviour.

Jonei · 06/04/2023 12:03

forrestgreen · 06/04/2023 12:00

When a relative didn't speak to me for weeks because I wouldn't let her smoke in my garden - weeks!
Apparently I'd been disrespectful, nope I was just very clear!

Why wouldn't you let them smoke in your garden? As long as the mess is cleared away I can't see that it would matter outside?

Jonei · 06/04/2023 12:01

I guess people just don't like change. They'll get used to it though. Or not.

forrestgreen · 06/04/2023 12:00

When a relative didn't speak to me for weeks because I wouldn't let her smoke in my garden - weeks!
Apparently I'd been disrespectful, nope I was just very clear!

DPMismyfavouritecolour · 06/04/2023 11:56

Had this with a so called friend (now ex-friend), but she doesn't really have friends, she has pets who hang around for her crumbs, it's never on an equal footing. Ended up in the same residents' group and neighbours, long story, but anyway, a meeting was called for every flat occupier to discuss various things. I refused to attend as one of the other residents was an utter arse and we'd fallen out completely by that point. When I said no, I'm not going, she sat there whining, 'but you HAVE TO!!' so I just kept repeating no and ignored her meltdown. If you're reading this, G, I have a screen shot of that time you tracked me down on social media to swear at me because you didn't like my withdrawing from a conversation. You need therapy.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/04/2023 11:55

Why does someone always try to make excuses for people who are rude/selfish/entitled/CFs? (‘Oh, they might have MH ishoos, be having a bad day, etc.).
Often makes me think that people who post such stuff have themselves v likely been guilty of that sort of behaviour - hence the need to makes excuses for it.

dramalessllama · 06/04/2023 11:37

billy1966 · 06/04/2023 10:50

The key thing to remember when you are a people pleaser with little boundaries is you are in effect waving a flag to all users.

They come straight for you and are hugely attracted to you, because of your potential use to them....that's all.

Less obvious friends slowly do the boiling frog analogy when they recognise that you are someone with little respect for themselves, will run around after others, be used etc.

It's simply too tempting. They can't help using you and being demanding.

These people are not friends, they don't respect you, and often they privately sneer at you, and how easily you are used.

That is the reason they disappear when you do enforce boundaries, they never really liked you in the first place and only stuck around because you served a purpose.

That is the reason that people pleasers shoot themselves in the foot.

Bending over backwards for people who could care less about them, probably sneer at them, and disappear the first time they are inconvenienced.

All in all people pleasers are huge wasters of their own time, ultimately spending years of their precious lives bent out of shape being used by people who don't even like them.

Really sad.

Peri menopause is often a wake up call and the penny drops for many.

Funny how often they admit to being happier for the first time in their lives.

This is brilliant!