Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you survive on 1k?

485 replies

coffeeanteac · 06/04/2023 08:55

If you had £1000 left after the main bills.

Could you survive on £1000 for food amd petrol and everything else takeaways, gifts, fun.

DH thinks most families couldn't. I think it should be ok. There are only 3 of us and we all live about three miles away from work and school.

OP posts:
milafawny · 06/04/2023 14:58

OopsAnotherOne · 06/04/2023 14:39

I'm in a different situation in that I'm in my early 20s and still live with my parents as I'm saving for my own house, plus I don't have children to provide for like other posters do. But yes, I would LOVE £1000 after bills to live on and currently survive on much less.

My salary is just over £1600 per month but after tax/pension/NI my take home is around £1370. £600 immediately goes into my savings account, I then pay £350 rent to my parents to cover my portion of outgoing bills and any food of theirs that I eat. The remaining £420 ish is then for me to buy food/groceries, petrol, car insurance/tax, paying my mobile phone bill and other bills. I often have £100-£200 spare at the end of each month from this amount that then goes into my savings too.

I can survive on this but also I can't afford to live a life of luxury. I don't go for meals out, have a packed lunch every day at work, drive a 2009 car, all my clothes are from the charity shop and I don't have any beauty treatments such as hair or nails. Any days out I go on are cheap/free and I just live within my means really, I don't have any debts and if I can't afford something I'll save up for it and buy it when I can afford it.

My finances would also be much tighter if I owned a home and had to pay in full for the council tax/utilities/mortgage rather than just my 1/3rd share from a household of 3 adults. It would also be a struggle for me to support a child on this income too but I could make it work if necessary (although I don't plan to have kids for at least 5 years). I can't really afford to get a mortgage of my own until my salary increases (which it will do when I qualify in the profession I'm training in) but living on much less than £1000 to cover petrol and food etc is completely possible and a lot of people live on this, and much less, each month rather happily.

Lol. Its not a different situation thats a very unique privileged situation that most people do not have ever in their lifetime. £350 for rent must cover all your bills and most of food if you still have a spare £200 to put in saving on top of the £600 you already save. Your situation is so far removed from normal life and not comparable at all.

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 14:41

@OopsAnotherOne don't try and compare finances with others here when you're saving £6-800 a month.

OopsAnotherOne · 06/04/2023 14:39

I'm in a different situation in that I'm in my early 20s and still live with my parents as I'm saving for my own house, plus I don't have children to provide for like other posters do. But yes, I would LOVE £1000 after bills to live on and currently survive on much less.

My salary is just over £1600 per month but after tax/pension/NI my take home is around £1370. £600 immediately goes into my savings account, I then pay £350 rent to my parents to cover my portion of outgoing bills and any food of theirs that I eat. The remaining £420 ish is then for me to buy food/groceries, petrol, car insurance/tax, paying my mobile phone bill and other bills. I often have £100-£200 spare at the end of each month from this amount that then goes into my savings too.

I can survive on this but also I can't afford to live a life of luxury. I don't go for meals out, have a packed lunch every day at work, drive a 2009 car, all my clothes are from the charity shop and I don't have any beauty treatments such as hair or nails. Any days out I go on are cheap/free and I just live within my means really, I don't have any debts and if I can't afford something I'll save up for it and buy it when I can afford it.

My finances would also be much tighter if I owned a home and had to pay in full for the council tax/utilities/mortgage rather than just my 1/3rd share from a household of 3 adults. It would also be a struggle for me to support a child on this income too but I could make it work if necessary (although I don't plan to have kids for at least 5 years). I can't really afford to get a mortgage of my own until my salary increases (which it will do when I qualify in the profession I'm training in) but living on much less than £1000 to cover petrol and food etc is completely possible and a lot of people live on this, and much less, each month rather happily.

Throughalookingglass · 06/04/2023 14:30

A pp mentioned the mortgage. Rising interest rates is something you have no control over unless you are on a fixed rate? . Our electricity/gas bill is now £500 a month when last year it was £350. What happens if you need go replace your shower/washing machine/dishwasher?

There will be people from all walks of life, some who choose to live frugally and others who have no other choice.

I remember reading a thread where about a poster said she didn’t flush the toilet in her house and instead plodded upstairs with a bucket of water she had washed up the crockery in. She seemed very happy with her lot and if it’s a lifestyle choice and you prefer watching savings increase in the bank, it is very different to not having the money to spend and the choice being made for you.

TMess · 06/04/2023 14:24

No. We eat and drive too much.

diflasu · 06/04/2023 14:18

If budgeting with spread sheet and note book is to inconvenient there are money app out there. Keeping track will help give you the information you need to make an informed decision for your family.

More drastically - mortgage payment holidays or switching to interest only mortgages might give breathing space for set periods with obvious downsides - I knew one family who did first so more time with young child and another family do interest only while doing up a house then switched.

https://www.theguardian.com/money/2021/jan/09/budgeting-apps-best-money-personal-finance-tools

Budgeting apps: the best options for tracking your money on the go

The lowdown on the pros, cons and fees involved if you want to use such personal finance tools

https://www.theguardian.com/money/2021/jan/09/budgeting-apps-best-money-personal-finance-tools

diflasu · 06/04/2023 14:08

it’s an awful position to put yourself in voluntarily.

The Op is talking about £1000 a month after all big bills paid - though she would have to cover food and petrol from it.

So it's nowhere near as bad as we went though - though her DD is older so more likely to notice and downturns in lifestyle.

Just depends on where their money is going currently - and what if any cut backs they are willing to adjust to and what kind of cushion they already have with savings.

JaneFondue · 06/04/2023 14:08

CoL is a fraught topic these days! I think it's unwise to look at other people and try to do as they do, because we all have different needs.

coffeeanteac · 06/04/2023 14:06

Thanks all some interesting perspectives from no to its a fortune.

Thanks to everyone who posted even those that think I am scrooge Mcduck when in reality I am on an average salary in a basic house with nightmare parking.

But yes I am lucky to have this.

OP posts:
JaneFondue · 06/04/2023 14:00

Yes I could. But that's because we
Don't eat meat or processed food. Food and groceries is about £85 a week for 3.
Don't drink
Don't run a car.
Don't have young DC who need clothes and shoes
Don't do beauty treatments
Buy in charity shops.
Entertainment is free museums or galleries rather than pub

Throughalookingglass · 06/04/2023 13:59

though stress on us was at times unbearable

This is very true. Being stressed when you get post. Losing sleep because you are awake worrying about unexpected expenses. Cutting Christmas down to a minimum. Saying no to your kids activities and all the times they are asked to bring in £10 and £20 pounds for school trips. Saying no to hosting birthday parties and no to invitations because you can’t buy gifts. Problems with cars which arise unexpectedly and body several hundred to repair. Cutting out hairdressers appts and it would be out rather than reducing, family occasions, days out - even simple days out include coffee or ice cream, new shoes just to replace so a need rather than a want. Then an unexpected bill such as tv licence lands on your floor.
it’s an awful position to put yourself in voluntarily.
But as it is for two years, can you save frantically so you have a buffer for the above type of expenses? I would t try to do it unless I had £5-10K in the bank to fall back on.

Supernova23 · 06/04/2023 13:57

AFTER outgoings? LOL. I'm lucky if I have a couple of hundred quid after all outgoings, and that all goes on food given the current rip off prices. I'd be in heaven with £1000 to spend. Never going to happen though.

coffeeanteac · 06/04/2023 13:51

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 06/04/2023 12:26

Ps. I don’t spend ridiculous amounts on coffees and lunches in the week. I take pack-ups and have access to a kettle and microwave at work for coffees, cuppa-soups etc. I’m used to ‘cutting my cloth according to ?? Whatever!’ Not everyone is.

We do too never buy work lunch out. Always take food.

OP posts:
inloveandmarried · 06/04/2023 13:49

I thought you meant before bills! After bills yes, living the dream.

diflasu · 06/04/2023 13:24

so no money to save/ have for holidays or emergencies. And what about the months where we need school uniform, clothes or new shoes.

Ideally why ideally you need to have some left to save end of each month or savings already.

School uniform buying, present for birthdays/Christmas, food shopping frequent happens over many months for us - often using credit card to smooth payments out - we save all year in holiday fund. Some of that's predictable - school uniform will be needed - others out the blue fridge packing up.

I've been picking up and putting things aside for when eldest leaves home - earliest this September for university - and still expect we'll have unexpected bills there - so trying to make sure I get books for college and GCSE for other bit earlier than usual.

At least here the a possible pay off it better pay two years down the line and probably better job satisfaction - there's an end in sight.

We getting the pay off now of DH doing having similar in early 30s - a decade plus later- though we had a number of unexpected set backs and it was bloody hard - now though we have more money than if he hadn't. The kids were very young and more oblivious though stress on us was at times unbearable - it did eventually pay off.

coffeeanteac · 06/04/2023 13:22

WitheredandOld · 06/04/2023 11:38

So out of the 1000 still comes food, petrol, kid’s activities, insurance and so on? I wouldn’t choose that no but clearly if I had to I’d make it work.

Not insurance. Daughter is 15 so has different activities these days no more karate etc but do pay her gym membership £12.

OP posts:
RJ57 · 06/04/2023 12:54

@coffeeanteac Its doable, but it grinds you down and can be a source of considerable anxiety.

Fuel will be about £100 a month
Food is about £600 a month for 4 with pets (and that's Aldi / Lidl)

Then there's clothes, repairs, treats (a takeway costs about £25 and that's a big chunk of your remaining money), car service, saving up for replacement white goods / car, presents / Christmas etc etc.

It is doable - I've done it for the last three years - but its not pleasant long term. It seemed fine at first, but the reality of having bugger all spare and not being able to have a massage or a holiday or new clothes or brand name food really gets to you.

Hopefully you've an upper time limit on how long you're going to do this for (I've not read any updates if you've said), because long term its a bit miserable and you might end up resentful. I certainly can't afford a holiday or a fancy phone or a nice new car or a meal out. When something "goes wrong" it can be a lot of stress to not be able to sort it. You'll also have to get used to DIY.

Annon1234 · 06/04/2023 12:54

I see these all the time and think we genuinely would struggle. £300 a month on food, and granted we have high fuel costs of around £400 a month. So £300 for the ‘fun stuff’ including clothes, any maintenance etc isn’t much. A year or so back we were working off a similar budget and found it really tough

Flyinggeesei234 · 06/04/2023 12:38

bringincrazyback · 06/04/2023 11:18

Bloody hell, check your privilege OP.

@bringincrazyback do you think the OP
is not entitled to post with this question? What’s your threshold for it being Ok? £300? £900? what?

Greenfree · 06/04/2023 12:33

In theory I could, in practice I always go over my budget though. I'd have to be very strict with my spending

Flyinggeesei234 · 06/04/2023 12:33

Andanotherone01 · 06/04/2023 09:37

Rather early for a stealth boast

It’s really not a stealth boast. £1k after bills is possible, but not comfortable by any means.

Do you think only those scraping by are allowed to post?

FiguringLifeOutOneFuckUpAtATime · 06/04/2023 12:33

AuntMarch · 06/04/2023 11:53

Why would you assume they aren't?
My UC claim on top of working only takes me just over this amount, and that is because there's a childcare element. I won't get that extra bit (because I won't need it) once my son is in school so this will be about my total income.

Yeah that's with me working part time around the kids and universal credit. I'm looking at increasing my hours/changing job now my youngest has started school, but it's not a massive amount to live on. I also know that my rent is reasonable in comparison to many others in the current situation.

MsVestibule · 06/04/2023 12:31

If you take out food and petrol, that's only £100pw. That's to cover eating out, clothes, haircuts, birthday and Christmas presents, new household appliances, pet extras, holidays, new phones every few years. We don't have an extravagant lifestyle but we'd really struggle on that. Definitely wouldn't be able to afford any type of holiday.

Harrysutton · 06/04/2023 12:30

It’s not a badge of honour to say you can/ can’t live on that amount. I have no idea why people have taken it so personally.

we would really struggle. To break it down there would be

food- £600 a month
petrol- £100 a month
daughter dance lessons - £100
sons cricket subs and gear - £50
hair for all of us - £120

so no money to save/ have for holidays or emergencies. And what about the months where we need school uniform, clothes or new shoes.

Phos · 06/04/2023 12:28

Yea of course!