Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my SIL treading on my toes with my adult children?

309 replies

SebHH · 06/04/2023 07:24

For context- my SIL has no children of her own. I’m close to her though have struggled a bit over the years with her being slightly blurry with boundaries, I’ve experienced her as intrusive at times (though in a well intentioned way). She lives in the same town as us and as my adult children who are all in their early 20s and who all live independently.
My SIL will ask my children around for supper without asking us. I know it’s silly but it makes me feel like she’s stealing them away from me, it makes me feel displaced/competitive… My own sisters, who similarly live in the same town and who have children of their own would be involved with mine but would only see them if we were all gathering together… the same with me and their adult children. I wouldn’t see them independently of my sisters…
I don’t know whether with my SIL she is just doing things a different way, different from how my family do things but not unreasonable… or whether there is something a bit odd about it…
AIBU to feel aggrieved??

OP posts:
AllyArty · 07/04/2023 21:00

@BellePeppa they are her adult children in their early 20s and how she feels is how she feels and it’s not for us to judge.
Have a lovely Easter.

BellePeppa · 07/04/2023 20:47

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 20:42

@BellePeppa I wouldn’t use the words ‘parental interference’. What makes you think the OP would be interfering? Nothing in her post suggests that she is the interfering type. My rational conclusion from reading a post in which the OP uses words like ‘struggled, blurred boundaries and intrusive’ about her SIL indicates to me that she hasn’t always had the easiest relationship with her. If her children enjoy going to their aunts for dinner then that is great. If her SIL enjoys having her brothers children for dinner then that is great too. If the OP uses words about her SILs invites like ‘stealing, displaced and competitive’ then that is not great.

If they were children she may feel displaced but they are adults. Adults can make their own decisions who they see and when. My mum didn’t really gel with my aunt but she never worried or resented the fact I spent time with her. I went on holiday with her as a teenager (I never went away with just my mum) and she was far more of a confidante than my mum, but my mum was still my mum and my aunt was always an aunt, I never muddled them up.

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 20:42

@BellePeppa I wouldn’t use the words ‘parental interference’. What makes you think the OP would be interfering? Nothing in her post suggests that she is the interfering type. My rational conclusion from reading a post in which the OP uses words like ‘struggled, blurred boundaries and intrusive’ about her SIL indicates to me that she hasn’t always had the easiest relationship with her. If her children enjoy going to their aunts for dinner then that is great. If her SIL enjoys having her brothers children for dinner then that is great too. If the OP uses words about her SILs invites like ‘stealing, displaced and competitive’ then that is not great.

MysteryBelle · 07/04/2023 20:13

Mendholeai · 07/04/2023 19:58

If it’s sneaky and she is disrespectful about you behind your back and/or trying to assume the role of parent or main care giver/confidant then no, it’s not good.

If she’s lonely and enjoys their company then not so much.

My nephew is round regularly as he does a sport near me- he often talks about his mum (who clearly adores him and he her). I always talk positively about her and try to give him some perspective. I also don’t try to be his mum. It’s just boundaries.

Could you talk it out with her?

I agree with this. Op, it may be that your instincts are telling you something. Try to figure out exactly what sil has said and done in the past, if anything, that makes you feel weird about this. Then you can judge whether or not you’re reasonable in your concerns.

Spiderboy · 07/04/2023 20:07

You’re being beyond unreasonable. Please be so grateful your children have people in their lives who care about their wellbeing and want to check in with them. They have their own individual relationships without you. If anything your siblings relationships with your kids sounds more superficial

BellePeppa · 07/04/2023 20:03

Mendholeai · 07/04/2023 19:58

If it’s sneaky and she is disrespectful about you behind your back and/or trying to assume the role of parent or main care giver/confidant then no, it’s not good.

If she’s lonely and enjoys their company then not so much.

My nephew is round regularly as he does a sport near me- he often talks about his mum (who clearly adores him and he her). I always talk positively about her and try to give him some perspective. I also don’t try to be his mum. It’s just boundaries.

Could you talk it out with her?

They’re adults, I doubt she’s trying to be the main care giver. And so what if she’s a confidante or even the main one. I talked to my aunt (childless, unmarried if that’s of any relevance) about all sorts of stuff I’d never talk to my mum about.

There are some posters on here with very strange views of aunts and their adult nieces and nephews. 😵‍💫

Mendholeai · 07/04/2023 19:58

If it’s sneaky and she is disrespectful about you behind your back and/or trying to assume the role of parent or main care giver/confidant then no, it’s not good.

If she’s lonely and enjoys their company then not so much.

My nephew is round regularly as he does a sport near me- he often talks about his mum (who clearly adores him and he her). I always talk positively about her and try to give him some perspective. I also don’t try to be his mum. It’s just boundaries.

Could you talk it out with her?

BellePeppa · 07/04/2023 19:56

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 19:20

I think she is wrong to exclude u. How does yr husband feel? Would she do this if she had her own children? Probably not!

Huh? How is she wrong to see her adult nieces and nephews without parental interference. Please explain as it’s nonsensical to anyone with any logic.

Selttan · 07/04/2023 19:46

I hang out with my niece just us all the time. We are planning an overseas holiday together next year.

It never occurred to me to invite my sister. My relationship with my niece is separate from my relationship with my sister.

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 19:34

Imo it is a form of exclusion. I think it is important to know how your other half feels about something especially when (a) it bothers u and (b) it concerns his sister.

Ifinkyourefreaky · 07/04/2023 19:29

I think you answered your own question here when you stated 'I know it's silly'

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 19:27

On the grounds of exclusion. And no I don’t invite my mum to anything any more because she is dead.

ReadersD1gest · 07/04/2023 19:27

Weathermonger · 07/04/2023 19:09

I know I'm going against the flow here but I think I understand where you are coming from. My SIL (who has children similar ages to mine) can be very interfering and manipulative and took it upon herself to talk my daughter into going to a different University (much further from home) and my son into buying a car he couldn't afford. This was all done without our knowledge with instructions to not tell us because "we wouldn't understand and it would only upset us" In each case they regretted what they ended up doing and my SIL blew it off as she was "only trying to help". My kids are in their twenties now and still meet up with my SIL, but no longer listen to any of her "advice".

Maybe it was a good life lesson for them, in not doing what you don't want to do, just because someone else tells you to 🤷🏻‍♀️
She probably did them a favour, unbeknownst to herself.

ReadersD1gest · 07/04/2023 19:24

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 19:20

I think she is wrong to exclude u. How does yr husband feel? Would she do this if she had her own children? Probably not!

Not being included is not the same as being excluded. She's not wrong at all, and what does it matter how op's husband feels?!

Feemie · 07/04/2023 19:23

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 19:20

I think she is wrong to exclude u. How does yr husband feel? Would she do this if she had her own children? Probably not!

On what possible grounds is she ‘wrong’? Do you insist on your mummy being invited to every social occasion before you accept?

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 19:20

I think she is wrong to exclude u. How does yr husband feel? Would she do this if she had her own children? Probably not!

Feemie · 07/04/2023 19:16

Weathermonger · 07/04/2023 19:09

I know I'm going against the flow here but I think I understand where you are coming from. My SIL (who has children similar ages to mine) can be very interfering and manipulative and took it upon herself to talk my daughter into going to a different University (much further from home) and my son into buying a car he couldn't afford. This was all done without our knowledge with instructions to not tell us because "we wouldn't understand and it would only upset us" In each case they regretted what they ended up doing and my SIL blew it off as she was "only trying to help". My kids are in their twenties now and still meet up with my SIL, but no longer listen to any of her "advice".

But that’s a fairly mad comparison. The OP’s SIL has made no attempt to interfere or unduly influence teenagers on major life decisions or purchases. She has done absolutely nothing ‘wrong’ other than issue the OP’s adult children invitations to dinner without including said adult children’s mother in the invitation.

MaryBeardsShoes · 07/04/2023 19:12

YAB absolutely mental. Your ADULT children can have a relationship with who ever they want. If you’re not happy with your relationships with your own kids then you need to look to yourself not blame your SIL.

Weathermonger · 07/04/2023 19:09

I know I'm going against the flow here but I think I understand where you are coming from. My SIL (who has children similar ages to mine) can be very interfering and manipulative and took it upon herself to talk my daughter into going to a different University (much further from home) and my son into buying a car he couldn't afford. This was all done without our knowledge with instructions to not tell us because "we wouldn't understand and it would only upset us" In each case they regretted what they ended up doing and my SIL blew it off as she was "only trying to help". My kids are in their twenties now and still meet up with my SIL, but no longer listen to any of her "advice".

mnisannoyingAF · 07/04/2023 18:58

I take my nieces and nephew out and don't ask my brother. Didn't think it was weird.'I think he likes that we get on.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 07/04/2023 18:56

I seriously had to check the date of OP's post because I thought it might be some weird Mumsnet-related April Fool that everyone had missed!

Whaeanui · 07/04/2023 18:33

SebHH · 06/04/2023 12:41

I don’t mean she should ask our permission, rather that we aren’t part of the invitation

Are you ever invited over? Either by yourselves or with the kids?

Indoorcatmum · 07/04/2023 18:31

You are wildly unreasonable.

If you die, wouldn't you rather they had a solid relationship with a family member who could be a support?

So weird!

WhiteBloatus · 07/04/2023 18:31

OP be glad for your kids she goes to some much effort to have a meaningful relationship with them, and glad for her that she has them in her life, and don’t be insecure- you are still, and always will be, their mum and their number one lady :)

ILoveEYFS · 07/04/2023 18:24

My adult DC spend a lot of time with my DSis2 (no kids). Not so much with DSis1 (kids) but they have a different relationship. DN spend a fair amount of time with DSis2 too as well as here with me. The cousins are really close and always have been and will spend time round each others places too.