Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my SIL treading on my toes with my adult children?

309 replies

SebHH · 06/04/2023 07:24

For context- my SIL has no children of her own. I’m close to her though have struggled a bit over the years with her being slightly blurry with boundaries, I’ve experienced her as intrusive at times (though in a well intentioned way). She lives in the same town as us and as my adult children who are all in their early 20s and who all live independently.
My SIL will ask my children around for supper without asking us. I know it’s silly but it makes me feel like she’s stealing them away from me, it makes me feel displaced/competitive… My own sisters, who similarly live in the same town and who have children of their own would be involved with mine but would only see them if we were all gathering together… the same with me and their adult children. I wouldn’t see them independently of my sisters…
I don’t know whether with my SIL she is just doing things a different way, different from how my family do things but not unreasonable… or whether there is something a bit odd about it…
AIBU to feel aggrieved??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rikitiki78 · 10/04/2023 17:45

I think your history with her is influencing your feelings. Do you feel as if she’s attempting to form close relationships with your children and exclude you, thereby
usurping your closeness to them? You’re feeling threatened.

mustgetoffmn · 10/04/2023 09:53

This is obviously something to do with your relationship with SIL. Maybe you don’t properly like/trust her? You need to focus on that. Not a good idea to involve anyone else in that feeling. Friends or family

Mrsgreen100 · 09/04/2023 20:24

It’s positive for them better around at your SIL
than out getting trashed like most 20 year olds .
I hear that you feel excluded, my childless aunt used to drag me all over the place she was very lonely I see now, I know it upset my mother, who was very controlling etc
Go with it the more adults in their lives the better in the long run
It’s part of growing up to avoid parents tbh

Whiteroomjoy · 09/04/2023 09:13

Oh good I hope my SIL doesn’t feel same way! My niece and nephew and their spouses come to mine a lot- lunch, tea( dinner) or just a cuppa. I’ve been with my niece or “ niece in law” on visits out. They’re all in late 20s and such lovely people. I’d be flattered you raised such lovely humans that SIL loves their company so much😊

my 2 adult sons live over 200 miles away. they can’t pop round like that. But the cousins meet up occasionally when they want t IPs to my sons cities and need free bed and breakfast, and my son is dog sitting for my niece, close to my home, later this year- I only found out incidentally but frankly why should I need to know and I think it’s lovely they want to hang out with each other. They lived a long way apart as small kids and have only got close in later tens, which makes it even nicer

having family bonds that extend through generations helps gel family relationships- it doesn’t take anything from you, Op. They will benefit from having good social connections with older adults as well as their peer group.

BellePeppa · 09/04/2023 08:56

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 21:00

@BellePeppa they are her adult children in their early 20s and how she feels is how she feels and it’s not for us to judge.
Have a lovely Easter.

Then why has she posted on here asking if she’s being unreasonable if it’s not to judge?

BlueHeelers · 09/04/2023 08:49

AIBU to feel aggrieved??

YABU - and what a nasty way to think of your sister in law - your children’s aunt.

She wants to have an adult relationship with her nephews/nieces. Instead of thinking how this is a wonderful enrichment of your DCs’ lives, you snark.

I am a niece and an aunt. The relationship of aunt to niece/nephews is a really precious one. Close family but not a parent. It can be really important for DC. And my closest aunt is a huge comfort to me in facing my mother’s final illness. Theyhave a lifelong relationship that I love seeing.

Tomkirkman · 09/04/2023 05:25

Kennykenkencat · 09/04/2023 04:37

The thing is saraclara that whilst you say no one can take you being a mum away. The role can be altered to someone who just gave birth.

I personally don’t have contact with my own mother. The fact is she is still my mother but I haven’t seen her for 40+ years

If you swap absent father with childless sister then you might understand

There have been threads about fathers who have not had any responsibility for their children. Left everything up to the mother who has had to compromise their job/career and ended up poorer because of it but then the father is the one the children as adults are having meals with and going out with and the mother can’t compete with what the other person has amassed whilst she was the one being responsible for the children.

Seb I can see that as adults the children can have dinner with who ever they want but if you are feeling it in your gut that something is off especially as you say she has a habit of blurring the boundaries then I would examine why and take note of your gut.

There are loads of things that on the surface look perfectly acceptable but our gut tells us deep down they are not

You can’t compare an aunt to absent father. No idea why you have put the qualifier of childless. Because and aunt was never their parent. Bringing up the children with the mother, was never an aunt’s responsibility. The Aunt never had legal or moral parental responsibility.

2 (present but separated) parents of children often don’t get on. That doesn’t automatically mean the children have to take sides and it doesn’t automatically mean one is right.

The fact that you seem to be attaching some negativity to this because she doesn’t have kids is really really odd. women without don’t go around trying to snatch adult children away from their parents.

Flipping an Aunt (‘childless’ or not) into the position of a parent doesn’t work at all.

My relationship with my parents, aunts, siblings, cousins have evolved as I have grown up. It’s not the same as when I was a child. They are now adult relationships and mine to manage. I would find it entirely bizarre if my Dad (mum died recently) felt he needed to be involved in every interaction with my mums sisters.

I don’t like one of my cousins, my mum adored her. I found her to be manipulative. She often visited my mum, called her and spent time with her. I had no issue because my mum had her own relationship with her. I didn’t feel displaced or that my cousin was trying to steal my mum or pretend to be her daughter. I wouldn’t have dreamed of telling my cousin I must be involved in their interactions.

Kennykenkencat · 09/04/2023 04:37

saraclara · 06/04/2023 10:25

@shiningstar2 and@Kennykenkencat can you explain why you'd feel that way? Because I simply can't get it. I have plenty of insecurities of my own, but when it comes to my kids, I'm their mum. There's nothing that changes that. Its pretty much the only thing in life that no-one can take away or threaten. So it makes no odds to me how close any other family member is to them, because at the end of the day, I'm their mum.

My insecurity as a widowed mum of adults, is who will be there for them if anything happens to me. So the closer their relationships with other people who love them, the better.

The thing is saraclara that whilst you say no one can take you being a mum away. The role can be altered to someone who just gave birth.

I personally don’t have contact with my own mother. The fact is she is still my mother but I haven’t seen her for 40+ years

If you swap absent father with childless sister then you might understand

There have been threads about fathers who have not had any responsibility for their children. Left everything up to the mother who has had to compromise their job/career and ended up poorer because of it but then the father is the one the children as adults are having meals with and going out with and the mother can’t compete with what the other person has amassed whilst she was the one being responsible for the children.

Seb I can see that as adults the children can have dinner with who ever they want but if you are feeling it in your gut that something is off especially as you say she has a habit of blurring the boundaries then I would examine why and take note of your gut.

There are loads of things that on the surface look perfectly acceptable but our gut tells us deep down they are not

uncomfortablydumb53 · 08/04/2023 15:47

It's perfectly normal for adult children to visit independently of you.
Do you feel threatened by your SiL?
They might love her more than you?
I think it's lovely they like your SiLs company
I have 3 adult DS's and I'm happy if they're happy

RosaBonheur · 08/04/2023 14:16

Honestly I think it's lovely that she makes an effort to maintain a close relationship with her adult nieces and nephews, and that they apparently want that relationship with her. Unless there's some massive back story here, I can't see how this is anything other than beneficial for both your kids and her. In any case, your kids are adults and they don't need your permission to see any friends or family they want.

Manthide · 08/04/2023 14:13

I've been thinking of my only SiL and her relationship with my 4 dc. If I never saw her - and especially her dh - I'd be very happy. My 2 eldest dds invited her and her dc to their weddings and it was fine (she couldn't go to dd1's in the end because of covid). I was polite but that was it - she lives 2000 miles from me. I'd certainly rather they had a relationship with her than me and hopefully the older ones can recognise her shallow, manipulate behaviour but that's on them. She is their only aunt. They tend to communicate with their 2 cousins who are also now adult as her English isn't very good. Generally though I encourage family relationships as we're not a big family.

Kaiserchief · 08/04/2023 13:34

GullibleMuM · 08/04/2023 11:36

Being an auntie is wonderful and it’s lovely she has enjoyed their company. Your feelings are understandable but recognize them and put them to one side. I love spending time with my nieces and nephews. Some are still kids, some adults. I wish they wanted to see me more x

Aww make sure you ask to see them often - my kids would love to see my sister more (we have a small family) but she’s very busy. They ask a lot just after they’ve seen her but stop asking after a while 😞

zingally · 08/04/2023 13:10

You're being ridiculous.

I'd personally be pleased if my adult children were having a family relationship with (presumably) another sensible and interested adult.

T1Dmama · 08/04/2023 11:56

I think it’s lovely that your kids have a good relationship with their aunt.
My niece js currently visiting all of us without her parents and is staying with family here in the U.K. for a year. (My sister lives abroad)
Your children can visit their friends without you, why is visiting their own Aunt an issue?? It is jealous and possessive behaviour OP.

GullibleMuM · 08/04/2023 11:36

Being an auntie is wonderful and it’s lovely she has enjoyed their company. Your feelings are understandable but recognize them and put them to one side. I love spending time with my nieces and nephews. Some are still kids, some adults. I wish they wanted to see me more x

KettrickenSmiled · 08/04/2023 10:50

Mendholeai · 07/04/2023 19:58

If it’s sneaky and she is disrespectful about you behind your back and/or trying to assume the role of parent or main care giver/confidant then no, it’s not good.

If she’s lonely and enjoys their company then not so much.

My nephew is round regularly as he does a sport near me- he often talks about his mum (who clearly adores him and he her). I always talk positively about her and try to give him some perspective. I also don’t try to be his mum. It’s just boundaries.

Could you talk it out with her?

Why have you boiled this down to a binary choice between sneaky & lonely?

Does it not occur to you that the most likely scenario is neither of these?
Just a non-sneaky, not-lonely aunt, enjoying the company of her younger extended family.

KettrickenSmiled · 08/04/2023 10:46

AllyArty · 07/04/2023 19:20

I think she is wrong to exclude u. How does yr husband feel? Would she do this if she had her own children? Probably not!

You haven't RTFT have you? It's full of PP, saying they do just this with theor own nieces & nephews.

Sorry to shock you - but some of those PP are PARENTS themselves.

But don't let that stop you leveraging a misogynistic trope about childfree women, huh?

Erictheavocado · 08/04/2023 10:42

I have relationships with my aunts from both sides, that are not dependent on my mum knowing every time we see each other or with her being included in the invitation. I am an adult. I do not have to ask my mum's permission to see my relatives whenever it suits us. My mum, like you, seems put out about it even though she enjoys relationships with them that don't include me. And, get ready to really have your mind blown OP, my own DC's, who are adults with their own homes and families, also have their own relationships with my aunts ( so their great aunts) and I am not usually included in their invitations. Guess what? I am happy that my family are able to have those adult relationships with each other, and that when the time comes that DH and I are no longer around, they have a good family around them to support them through any difficult moments.

InSpainTheRain · 08/04/2023 09:57

YABVU unless there is a bid back story.

wellstopdoingitthen · 08/04/2023 07:02

My adult nieces & nephew visit me without their parents' permit. It's lovely. I'm not 'stealing' them!

Kaiserchief · 08/04/2023 06:59

I think it’s lovely that she wants to have a relationship with them. My sister lives a mile away and sees my kids once a month, if that.

Wavinggoodbyetoo · 08/04/2023 04:00

My recently deceased Aunt was one of the most inspiring and wonderful women I have ever met. I loved her and would visit if in the area.

I also love my DM with whom I have a special bond.

OP, it doesn’t have to be something to fear. If my own DM had queried a visit I would have wondered if she’d lost it.

fatchilli123 · 07/04/2023 23:01

She's a proper aunty, I like her . Wish I was nearer my nieces so I could be like that too. Aunty privilege I would say to entertain nieces and nephews. Nice that they like her enough to entertain her feeding them . A lot of families don't get on so well so this is heart-warming 🥰

AncientBallerina · 07/04/2023 22:29

This lady is your husband’s sister? Therefore a blood relative of your children. I see my aunt without my mum - in fact she’s a hell of a lot nicer to me than my mum. And my daughters see my sister without me - I’m glad they have an independent relationship with other adults in the family who care about them. There should be no no problem here.

PaperwhiteTheGhost · 07/04/2023 22:18

I mean... I see my niece without my sister and she's 6!

Swipe left for the next trending thread