Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Transgender 'athletes'

440 replies

HappyHippo1234 · 06/04/2023 00:38

To start off - I have no issue with trans people at all. The only issue I have is transgender females (male to female) competing in women sports.

Yes, they may have been taking hormones and they have lost some muscle and gained some fat. But, they have stronger bones and bigger spines, hands, feet, lungs and hearts. Basically trans females have an advantage over biological females.

What I absolutely HATE about the situation, it the trans athletes attitude, it honestly disgusts me. Did they never take biology as teenagers or learn about puberty?
For them to sit there with their wins and say that they have no advantage just p*sses me off. Are they stupid or ignorant? There's no way they don't know they have an advantage. Do they not realise they are taking wins away from girls and woman who have spent their whole lives training for a sport only for it to be taken away from someone who was a mediocre male.

Look at Lia Thomas, she was somewhere in the 400-500th best college male swimmer or something like that. She is now trans and BAM she is number 1 and winning everything.

It just annoys me to no end. Especially the trans woman who you can tell that they KNOW they have a major advantage and are cheating the system and then sit there with a SMUG GRIN on their faces. I mean every Caitlyn Jenner said it's wrong.

Sorry for the rant. My DD15 has been upset all week as on the weekend another girl beat all the girls by a huge stretch in her cross country meet (her team is usually 1st but were bumped to 2nd). At first everyone thought this girl was great, until one mom heard the group the girl was with discussing the results and how it was great for the team that this girl came out as trans and was boosting their results etc! Fair to say that news travelled quickly and there were MANY parents complaining to officials. But surprise surprise nothing was done about it. So at the award giving ceremony everyone waited as everything up to 1st place was given out and as soon as they got to the 1st team, I would say 95% of people walked away. It felt harsh but necessary!
(Also the girl was 16 and had only recently transitioned from what we could gather and when you actually looked at her you could tell she had gone through at least some portion of male puberty). Again nothing against the girl just don't think she could compete.

And to get around all these discrimination lawsuits, I think they should change the categories! Have an XX category and an XY category, that why there is no debate and no 'discrimination' as you can't identify as XY if you are XX! (And then also have an open category where trans, non-binary etc. can compete).

SORRY THAT WAS SO LONG. NOW FOR THE VOTE:

YABU - Trans (XX) women are woman and should be allowed to compete with XY women, even though they scientifically have an advantage.

YANBU - They will always have an advantage and so should not compete with XY women.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
AlecTrevelyan006 · 06/04/2023 11:45

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 11:15

Li Wenwen? Caster Semenya? Where do you draw the line? Who else are you prepared to erase/negate because they don't match your views?

The arguments for separating boxers to ensure safety are clear. Currently it's split by sex first and weight second. If the boxing governing bodies can devise categories based on weight first and testosterone levels second (or whatever else they come up with) and thereby allow men and women to compete together in a way that is inclusive and also safe, why would anyone ideologically oppose it?

There's no safety issue in women and men playing golf together. There's no impact on their final score, or handicap. The male advantage in golf drive (from the article @Helleofabore shared - thank you - I can't actually read them as fast as you are citing them, but I do try to keep up) means it is more likely that male golfers will get to the green in fewer strokes, but shot accuracy, club selection, stroke technique and putting ability are still very significant factors. If they weren't, all the golf champions would look like wrestlers, and guess what - they don't.

The only reason GC's would want to prevent men and women playing golf together is because they fear the glory would flow disproportionately towards men. They want to ring-fence and capture a share of the podium finishes, medals and prize money - ideally one that delivers a 50:50 split by sex. But that's not equivalent to a 50:50 split by talent, or effort, or any other sporting criterion. It is just as arbitrary as insisting on a split by height. And it is a political choice, not a 'natural' one. Men have subsidised women's grass roots and competitive sports for years, because society deemed it equitable. GCs who aren't prepared to include trans people at all on a point of principle are just pulling the ladder up behind them - and the greatest irony of all is that women still have such a long way to go to achieve equality (never mind equity).

u r bonkers

georgarina · 06/04/2023 11:45

thegrain · 06/04/2023 06:39

I guess I'm just thinking I'd never pretend to be a bloke to get all the advantages they get. But yeah good point? Who am I to assume other's moral compass. I'm probably far to naive. Like there's people who identify as women in prison who were considered male when they committed their offence. Maybe that's to get into a women prison. I don't really know enough about it so best to ignore me and point me in the direction of useful resources!

Top athletes can get college scholarships, sponsorships, etc. There is a lot to be gained when you can automatically become #1.

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:43

Considering most sporting bodies are starting to come out and make policies that male born people can't compete in woman's categories ( in most circumstances) I think the few that disagree need to be taking it up with the sporting bodies.

Not the millions of people who agree with the sporting bodies decisions.

SquidwardBound · 06/04/2023 11:40

So you think that people don’t get to comment on the - often highly political, and with real implications in terms of the exclusion of women and girls - policies of governing bodies?

Do you realise how ‘now calm down ladies. Just accept that all these male-dominated bodies just know better than you. Stop getting yourselves so upset. It’s unladylike!’ you sound?

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 11:38

Mark19735 Both the Gender Recognition Act and The Equality Act recognise sports as a sex affected activity, and allow single sex sports for reasons of safety and fairness.

If you want to change the law, you get on with doing that.

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 11:37

SquidwardBound · 06/04/2023 11:27

presumably @Mark19735 doesn’t agree with para sport either. Because, after all, it’s just bitter people who don’t want all the glory and money going to able bodied men. 🤦🏻‍♀️

You've just made my point better than I've been trying to.

There's nothing wrong with para sport. It relies on a professional sports governing body deciding what criteria make participation fair. Those bodies are saying that there are circumstances in which people born male can participate in the same categories as people born female. Why's that so hard to understand?

Do you get equally upset at the Paralympics when some competitors have an amputation above the knee and others have an amputation below the knee? I'm sure it's a hot topic in the A3/A4/A5 categorisation conferences and for the participants affected, but does anyone on MN post about it?

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 11:35

Mark's posts are long and slightly pompous, with an air of "come now ladies, let's be reasonable", but the actual substance of them is the same old "what about DSDs", "but Serena Williams is better than most men" and "but inclusivity" nonsense that has already been torn asunder a zillion times on this thread alone.

I'd give him the benefit of the doubt but I've seen him before.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 11:34

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 11:15

Li Wenwen? Caster Semenya? Where do you draw the line? Who else are you prepared to erase/negate because they don't match your views?

The arguments for separating boxers to ensure safety are clear. Currently it's split by sex first and weight second. If the boxing governing bodies can devise categories based on weight first and testosterone levels second (or whatever else they come up with) and thereby allow men and women to compete together in a way that is inclusive and also safe, why would anyone ideologically oppose it?

There's no safety issue in women and men playing golf together. There's no impact on their final score, or handicap. The male advantage in golf drive (from the article @Helleofabore shared - thank you - I can't actually read them as fast as you are citing them, but I do try to keep up) means it is more likely that male golfers will get to the green in fewer strokes, but shot accuracy, club selection, stroke technique and putting ability are still very significant factors. If they weren't, all the golf champions would look like wrestlers, and guess what - they don't.

The only reason GC's would want to prevent men and women playing golf together is because they fear the glory would flow disproportionately towards men. They want to ring-fence and capture a share of the podium finishes, medals and prize money - ideally one that delivers a 50:50 split by sex. But that's not equivalent to a 50:50 split by talent, or effort, or any other sporting criterion. It is just as arbitrary as insisting on a split by height. And it is a political choice, not a 'natural' one. Men have subsidised women's grass roots and competitive sports for years, because society deemed it equitable. GCs who aren't prepared to include trans people at all on a point of principle are just pulling the ladder up behind them - and the greatest irony of all is that women still have such a long way to go to achieve equality (never mind equity).

I draw the line where World Athletics seems to drawing the line.

At the moment, any male who has experienced any benefit from male puberty should not be eligible to compete with female athletes in a female sports category. I do expect that there will be in time research to clarify whether or not males who don't process testosterone (CAIS) have any advantage at all. They may do and this needs to be researched.

You are now trying to politically utilise people with Differences of Sex Development to progress your argument.

Caster Semenya is a male who has experienced male puberty. They have known they are male for a long time. They have 5-ARD. they were specifically targeted by a talent scout because it was known that that part of the country that Semenya grew up had athletes with this condition.

Is Li Wenwen someone who also has a DSD? Are they trans? Why have you brought Li Wenwen into the discussion?

"Who else are you prepared to erase/negate because they don't match your views?"

'My views'? Really? You have not produced anything that supports your argument beyond attacking feminists, making transphobic statements and repeating some men's rights activist discussion points.

I am not 'erasing' anyone. I am saying that male people compete with male people. They are not 'banned'. They are not 'erased'.

You keep resorting to emotional manipulation to make your point.

It is not just about safety. It is about fairness. The reality is even the OIC has conceded that it can't be 'fair'. The inclusion aspect though is also not supported. Because no other category will allow a person from a category of athlete that has advantages to enter into a category set aside to protect the competition of the athletes in that category.

"If the boxing governing bodies can devise categories based on weight first and testosterone levels second (or whatever else they come up with) and thereby allow men and women to compete together in a way that is inclusive and also safe, why would anyone ideologically oppose it?"

Read the facts. This will not happen! It is never going to be safe if a male boxer is physically punching a female boxer. Tell us by what magic will this happen?

'There's no safety issue in women and men playing golf together. There's no impact on their final score, or handicap."

There is impact on the final score and handicap. Do you understand how a golf swing works and the muscles, and the skeleton work to swing a golf club?

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 11:34

G*ood
*
Sigh.

I pointed out that in a thread where posters are concerned about what's happening in women and girls sports other posters have accused us of paranoia, just accept it because life isn't fair anyway, it's not that big a problem.

I think this is gaslighting.

Can we move on or do you still need to police my use of the English language? Or maybe you'd like to tell me to shut up again?

MarshaBradyo · 06/04/2023 11:30

Treating them as women's rights issues is, in my view, a strategic mistake

This is madness. Of course determining who gets to compete in female sports is a women’s rights issue.

Are you male? I’m guessing so. Your posts feel typically male centred and with no thought to women and girls.

KittiesInsane · 06/04/2023 11:28

Oh give over, Mark. If you're male, 'looking for the nuance' is a nice hobby, isn't it? Something to do, smugly, without any real-life effects.

I could swear that some blokes think that being male is a virtue, an achievement, rather than the luck of the draw.

SquidwardBound · 06/04/2023 11:27

presumably @Mark19735 doesn’t agree with para sport either. Because, after all, it’s just bitter people who don’t want all the glory and money going to able bodied men. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 11:25

The only reason GC's would want to prevent men and women playing golf together is because they fear the glory would flow disproportionately towards men.

Your entire argument is that men and women have different strengths in golf; and those arguments all support keeping the game single sex.

Golf if not not single sex because women demanded single sex golf. Its because traditionally, women were excluded from playing the game at all, and men were furious at being forced to include us.

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 11:24

"And that is transphobic. Did you realise that?"

FACT!

Or maybe not. I do appreciate that some people would insist that statement was transphobic. But the NHS website says "gender dysphoria is not a mental illness, but some people may develop mental health problems because of gender dysphoria". So yes, trans issues are mental health issues.

But you keep policing what is and what isn't correct and proper in your world view. I'll keep looking for the nuance and pointing out the massive holes in your arguments. You might hate me for it ... but consider it training for the bigger battles that are yet to come. There's more Emma Watsons than Victoria Smiths and the former are still being born whilst the latter are dying out. The quality of the arguments needs to improve if you want to change people's minds.

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 11:23

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:29

For anyone who thinks males should compete in female sports categories, do you understand why there is a female sport’s category? It is only to allow female sports people to have fair competition.

Think about what other category boundaries you would be happy to accept

A 25 year old competing against a 10 year old?

A 25 year old competing against a 85 year old?

A person who had 90% vision competing with someone with 5% vision ?

A person who was a professional standard athlete competing in a novice only event ?

A bicycle with an electric engine competing against a 100% human powered bicycle in the Tour de France?

If you have said yes to any of these, why? if you have said no, then why would you accept a male with pubertal advantages in a female sports category?

Love this.

Very well presented.

SquidwardBound · 06/04/2023 11:22

Li Wenwen? Caster Semenya? Where do you draw the line? Who else are you prepared to erase/negate because they don't match your views?

DSD is a completely different issue to transgender. Transgender people do not have a disorder of sexual development.

The hyperbole about erasing and negating is ridiculous. Having people compete in fair, sex based categories is not ‘erasure’.

Personally, I think that DSD should be treated through the kind of para sport measures. It’s not appropriate for athletes with DSDs to compete in standard sex categories because of their disorder of sexual development. But they are not a homogenous group - the specific characteristics of their DSD make all the difference. Para sport processes are designed to enable fair competition where that is the case.

But, none of that has anything to do with transgender. How someone wants to identify is not comparable to a DSD.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 11:17

That Australian research has been used quite a few times. Here for example, although probably not an official piece of research:

https://www.swansea.ac.uk/media/Swan-Linx%20Swansea%20Schools%27%20Fitness%20Fun%20Day%20feedback%20report%20(2015).pdf

Swan-Linx
Fitness Fun Day Report (2015)

this lists the results of Year 5 & 6 girls vs boys.

https://www.swansea.ac.uk/media/Swan-Linx%20Swansea%20Schools'%20Fitness%20Fun%20Day%20feedback%20report%20(2015).pdf

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 11:15

Li Wenwen? Caster Semenya? Where do you draw the line? Who else are you prepared to erase/negate because they don't match your views?

The arguments for separating boxers to ensure safety are clear. Currently it's split by sex first and weight second. If the boxing governing bodies can devise categories based on weight first and testosterone levels second (or whatever else they come up with) and thereby allow men and women to compete together in a way that is inclusive and also safe, why would anyone ideologically oppose it?

There's no safety issue in women and men playing golf together. There's no impact on their final score, or handicap. The male advantage in golf drive (from the article @Helleofabore shared - thank you - I can't actually read them as fast as you are citing them, but I do try to keep up) means it is more likely that male golfers will get to the green in fewer strokes, but shot accuracy, club selection, stroke technique and putting ability are still very significant factors. If they weren't, all the golf champions would look like wrestlers, and guess what - they don't.

The only reason GC's would want to prevent men and women playing golf together is because they fear the glory would flow disproportionately towards men. They want to ring-fence and capture a share of the podium finishes, medals and prize money - ideally one that delivers a 50:50 split by sex. But that's not equivalent to a 50:50 split by talent, or effort, or any other sporting criterion. It is just as arbitrary as insisting on a split by height. And it is a political choice, not a 'natural' one. Men have subsidised women's grass roots and competitive sports for years, because society deemed it equitable. GCs who aren't prepared to include trans people at all on a point of principle are just pulling the ladder up behind them - and the greatest irony of all is that women still have such a long way to go to achieve equality (never mind equity).

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 11:13

For anyone interested in the sports advantages found in the Australian study here it is. There is a Greek study that shows similar results too.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22021354/

I have read it back when it was first released, but it is now paywalled. In it they picked up that even at 9 years old boys out performed girls in sports.

The Greek study was the one that showed that even at 6 years old boys out performed girls at sports.

Normative health-related fitness values for children: analysis of 85347 test results on 9-17-year-old Australians since 1985 - PubMed

This study provides the most up-to-date sex- and age-specific normative centile values for the health-related fitness of Australian children that can be used as benchmark values for health and fitness screening and surveillance systems.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22021354

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 11:02

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 11:00

Goodchat yes I know and according to my understanding of the term I'm correct.

Where was the gaslighting in the quote you posted?

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 11:01

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:44

Not a men's rights activist
Understand rationale behind female sports
Don't think mixed sports is best way to meet societal objectives in all cases
Don't think mixed sports is necessarily an aberration in other cases
Think it should be left to sporting associations to decide
Understand that discrimination is an ongoing issue
Understand difference between equality and equity. Don't accept that equity is not political. Don't think anyone has monopoly on defining 'fairness'.
Believe that sex matters, and has always mattered
Believe that this holds true in many settings - sports, but also the workplace.
Charge of hypocrisy still stands - Second wave had it (broadly) right. Third wave went off track. The backlash and ensuing GC movement is dominated by rabid, ill-informed and hate-filled rhetoric. Trans issues are mental health issues. Treating them as women's rights issues is, in my view, a strategic mistake.

"The backlash and ensuing GC movement is dominated by rabid, ill-informed and hate-filled rhetoric."

Oh dear again.

So, you agree that no males should be competing in female sports categories.

You just don't like the way some women discuss it?

You have ignored the many informed posters on this thread because obviously to you they are "rabid, ill-informed and hate-filled', yet you posted some offensive stuff in your post that readers can see for themselves.

"Trans issues are mental health issues."

And that is transphobic. Did you realise that?

"Treating them as women's rights issues is, in my view, a strategic mistake."

So, treating a group of male people seeking access into the spaces and opportunities that were set up to protect the interests of all female people, of all genders, to continue to strive to overcome the impact of millennia of negative sexist discrimination and to meet the needs of female people should not have been treated as a 'women's rights issue'.

I suspect you actually don't understand the "GC movement" at all. I suspect that you have a rather prejudiced view on this and it has led you to post posts where you do present as a men's rights activist, despite your claims that you are not.

Those paragraphs about female tennis players and males boxing female boxers were very enlightening. Thanks.

I am pretty sure that most readers see that your idea of a 'strategic mistake' amounts to you showing your prejudices rather than you having an informed contribution on this thread to make.

Equalitea · 06/04/2023 11:01

Silentmama · 06/04/2023 01:42

Why can't trans men and trans women - compete against trans athletes - its fairer that way,

Bit like if I ran a race and said 'I felt older' than I was - I could not identify in an older bracket to do better could 1

This seems like a good idea!

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 11:00

Goodchat yes I know and according to my understanding of the term I'm correct.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:51

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:12

Society today prioritises inclusion. When it's SEND kids and kids with ADHD in mainstream classrooms, the MN massive takes a very different view on what 'fairness' is.

If societal rule number one is that every individual should be able to compete in their chosen sport somewhere (the inclusion principle).
And societal and environmental factors mean that there are currently only two divisions within which an adult can compete - men's or women's.
Then the judgment should really be, in which division is it most fair for that individual to compete in?
I don't see why it should be so outrageous for the medical and sporting experts who make these assessments to decide that sometimes that means people born in one sex should compete alongside people born in the other.
In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).
That'd see men and women competing together in many divisions, but also it would be more nuanced, and more fair - right?

If you want perfect fairness, then sure, let's have 7 billion categories and we can all have a gold medal. That's the illogical end point of intersectionality. But every single point before that absurd outcome requires some choice or judgment of how you define fairness - and that definition will result in some people not getting 'their' gold.

If you take a hard line, ultra competitive, winner-takes-all approach, then there should just be one category - an open one. But the people justifying women's sports as a separate division are loathe to acknowledge that it is having a very limited and specific definition of 'fairness' that creates this issue in the first place.

And the hypocrisy is rank. The same people will also argue that women should be paid the same for winning a best of three sets tennis match (watched by about a million people) than a man winning a best of five sets tennis match (watched by 3 million people). I guess fairness means something different when you're looking to smash the glass ceiling than it does when you are punching down to someone who is mentally ill and struggling to find their place in the world.

"Society today prioritises inclusion. When it's SEND kids and kids with ADHD in mainstream classrooms, the MN massive takes a very different view on what 'fairness' is."

Just highlighting this for all readers to see.

So, including children in a classroom where special accommodations can be made and are made somehow should be the basis for allowing male people to enter into female sport's categories?

"If societal rule number one is that every individual should be able to compete in their chosen sport somewhere (the inclusion principle)."

And every individual can compete in their chosen sport. A male can compete in with the other male people.

I asked upthread and I will ask again. What other male people who inhibit their sports performance either through taking medication or deliberately changing their body to be weaker and to change shape should be accepted into female sports categories? Why is this group of males different?

Would you accept a 25 year old competing with the under 12 year olds for inclusion?

Would you accept a 25 year old competing with the over 85 year olds for inclusion?

Would you accept a fully sighted person competing with the people with no sight at all for inclusion?

Would you accept a professional level athlete competing with the amateur in an amateur event for inclusion?

Would you accept a bike with an electric motor competing in the Tour de France for inclusion?

"If you want perfect fairness, then sure, let's have 7 billion categories and we can all have a gold medal. That's the illogical end point of intersectionality."

No, that is hyperbole that you are trying to use to convince readers that sports is inherently unfair so give everyone their own event. And no one is saying that one female body doesn't have advantages over another female body. I don't believe I have ever read anything that denies that at all.

The difference is, that the best female athletes cannot compete with male advantages.

And no. A male who is mediocre in performance should not be considered 'fair competition' for a well trained, and talented female athlete. There is a fucking reason that Laurel Hubbard, a 40 something male with recent injuries beat out much younger women. And that there were no equal 40 something female there to beat them in the competition to get the spot on the team.

#nothankyou

SquidwardBound · 06/04/2023 10:48

Animalsoffartingwood · 06/04/2023 10:35

She also uses accessible toilets as she says she understand why woman would feel uncomfortable with someone of male sex in woman's only spaces.

Well I am afraid I don't applaud this. It's just asking a different group to be pushed aside (disabled) instead of women.

Men who dress as women have two options.

  1. Remain in their own sex category and expand the bandwidth of what it means to be male. Ditto changing rooms, toilets and prisons.

  2. If they can't accept that they belong in male spaces or feel 'scared' they can campaign for third spaces and in the meantime self exclude and get the true experience of what it's like to be a woman, urinary leash, missing out on sports, government not listening to them or providing for them. How affirming.

Everything else is unfair to woman and girls at best and a gift to sexual predators and men who want to humiliate women at worst.

I agree.

It’s not up to women to fix male humans problems with other male humans.

Swipe left for the next trending thread