Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Transgender 'athletes'

440 replies

HappyHippo1234 · 06/04/2023 00:38

To start off - I have no issue with trans people at all. The only issue I have is transgender females (male to female) competing in women sports.

Yes, they may have been taking hormones and they have lost some muscle and gained some fat. But, they have stronger bones and bigger spines, hands, feet, lungs and hearts. Basically trans females have an advantage over biological females.

What I absolutely HATE about the situation, it the trans athletes attitude, it honestly disgusts me. Did they never take biology as teenagers or learn about puberty?
For them to sit there with their wins and say that they have no advantage just p*sses me off. Are they stupid or ignorant? There's no way they don't know they have an advantage. Do they not realise they are taking wins away from girls and woman who have spent their whole lives training for a sport only for it to be taken away from someone who was a mediocre male.

Look at Lia Thomas, she was somewhere in the 400-500th best college male swimmer or something like that. She is now trans and BAM she is number 1 and winning everything.

It just annoys me to no end. Especially the trans woman who you can tell that they KNOW they have a major advantage and are cheating the system and then sit there with a SMUG GRIN on their faces. I mean every Caitlyn Jenner said it's wrong.

Sorry for the rant. My DD15 has been upset all week as on the weekend another girl beat all the girls by a huge stretch in her cross country meet (her team is usually 1st but were bumped to 2nd). At first everyone thought this girl was great, until one mom heard the group the girl was with discussing the results and how it was great for the team that this girl came out as trans and was boosting their results etc! Fair to say that news travelled quickly and there were MANY parents complaining to officials. But surprise surprise nothing was done about it. So at the award giving ceremony everyone waited as everything up to 1st place was given out and as soon as they got to the 1st team, I would say 95% of people walked away. It felt harsh but necessary!
(Also the girl was 16 and had only recently transitioned from what we could gather and when you actually looked at her you could tell she had gone through at least some portion of male puberty). Again nothing against the girl just don't think she could compete.

And to get around all these discrimination lawsuits, I think they should change the categories! Have an XX category and an XY category, that why there is no debate and no 'discrimination' as you can't identify as XY if you are XX! (And then also have an open category where trans, non-binary etc. can compete).

SORRY THAT WAS SO LONG. NOW FOR THE VOTE:

YABU - Trans (XX) women are woman and should be allowed to compete with XY women, even though they scientifically have an advantage.

YANBU - They will always have an advantage and so should not compete with XY women.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
Helleofabore · 07/04/2023 08:02

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:44

Not a men's rights activist
Understand rationale behind female sports
Don't think mixed sports is best way to meet societal objectives in all cases
Don't think mixed sports is necessarily an aberration in other cases
Think it should be left to sporting associations to decide
Understand that discrimination is an ongoing issue
Understand difference between equality and equity. Don't accept that equity is not political. Don't think anyone has monopoly on defining 'fairness'.
Believe that sex matters, and has always mattered
Believe that this holds true in many settings - sports, but also the workplace.
Charge of hypocrisy still stands - Second wave had it (broadly) right. Third wave went off track. The backlash and ensuing GC movement is dominated by rabid, ill-informed and hate-filled rhetoric. Trans issues are mental health issues. Treating them as women's rights issues is, in my view, a strategic mistake.

“Second wave had it (broadly) right. Third wave went off track. The backlash and ensuing GC movement is dominated by rabid, ill-informed and hate-filled rhetoric. Trans issues are mental health issues. Treating them as women's rights issues is, in my view, a strategic mistake.”

I am going back through this bonkers thread, as I tend to do and realised why this post bothered me.

What this person has done here is show just how ignorant they are about this topic. But also clarified in my mind that this really was someone posting from a men’s rights activist view point (even though they didn’t seem to understand that they did).

Any person who understands the basics of the different waves of feminism understands that most of the people that others label ‘gender critical feminists’ are second wave feminists!

I picked up in another thread a sledge about ‘intersectionality’ and didn’t process that until during the night these posts all started to come together and really prove who this poster was and what they thought they were achieving.

And it is rather surprising that posters shaming other posters for their supposed hate, don’t seem to have once addressed the hate that was apparent in this persons posts. I am still going through the thread so I might find posts telling this poster off for their tone, for their transphobic points that were there.

Maybe those hypocritical posters who were so focused on tone policing and trying to portray women as coming from a place of hate will look at their own oversight and understand why posters reject the fuckwittery of shaming us for our ‘tone’.

MargaretThursday · 06/04/2023 20:57

My suggestion is we have a bio men, bio women and a trans category.

Now if the transwomen are right, then we'll find all the categories won by the transmen.
If a transwoman has no advantage over a bio woman, then by the same thinking, a transman should have no disadvantage against a bio man.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 20:48

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 06/04/2023 19:39

‘Off putting’??! Grin

It’s not ‘off putting’ in the slightest. At least not for you.

You said you were hiding the thread way back at the beginning - but you have literally been glued to it, refreshing it, reading it, posting on it the entire way through.

’Off putting’? Pffft. You love it.

I reckon if readers can’t cut through / scroll past the quips and push back against misogynist posters to read some excellent posts from posters with knowledge and understanding about this topic and instead focus on the ‘tone’ the information is delivered then they aren’t really interested in the topic.

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 06/04/2023 19:39

Changeau · 06/04/2023 15:27

I'm sure you all mean well but the pages and pages of self congratulatory faux outrage are so wearing to read. I think I agree with most of you in practice, but the clever clever sneery tone is just so off putting at least to me, and there does seem to be a little gang here just waiting to pounce on anyone who doesn't fully agree with you. It's not much different to the pro-trans lobby in tone.

‘Off putting’??! Grin

It’s not ‘off putting’ in the slightest. At least not for you.

You said you were hiding the thread way back at the beginning - but you have literally been glued to it, refreshing it, reading it, posting on it the entire way through.

’Off putting’? Pffft. You love it.

YouSetTheTone · 06/04/2023 18:28

If someone had a banned substance slipped into their drink unwittingly before they ran, they’d still be banned if they failed a doping test.
The intent doesn’t matter - they’ve still cheated.

Whether or not someone is ‘genuine’ trans (whatever genuine trans means) they’re still cheating if they play sport in the incorrect sex category.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 18:25

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 17:40

How were trans people included here that makes you believe that it was “a good example of genuine trans athletes helping to create a solution.”

Because from what I remember, the core of this decision was based on the Sports council’s work from 2021 from the link below, a survey covering 3000+ people which returned around 80% that members believed that the women’s category be protected and one on ones of a range of people. Some of which were trans athletes.

https://www.sportengland.org/news/new-guidance-transgender-inclusion-domestic-sport-published

“I think posters here may have forgotten or not realised that trans athletes were involved in this decision”

So, do you have any evidence that male trans people positively influenced the British triathlon’s policy? I can assure you that many posters here who have been following what has been happening in female sports categories have not ‘forgotten’ and we most certainly realised ‘trans people’ were consulted. however, I have not seen that male trans people were involved in positively shaping the policy.

For instance, I seem to remember Jon Pike was one of the first people to start discussing ‘open’ categories as a solution. And swimming (FINA) adopted it before British Triathlon did. So that was not a new concept.

Let’s not forget that a team of very dedicated women, from athletes to biologists to feminists and many more ,campaigned and used the research available to present to Sport England who made their guidance in 2021. It was rather controversial at the time I recall, and many of those women involved have experienced negative impacts from doing so. Particularly people such as Sharron Davies. I believe some men were also involved in those presentations.

Then over the past 3-5 years there have been a growing number of women putting themselves on the line to even get to make presentations to decision makers. Remember in 2015, the IOC did not include any female athletes in the process to make decisions about the female sport categories. So much work had to be done by women to get heard or even have their opinions considered and not dismissed as transphobic.

So, finally by the time Triathlon starts to make their move, and it was gutsy at the time considering World Athletics took a long time to state they had concerns too and were publicly stating that changes had to be made, but by the time Triathlon announced they were reviewing , a huge amount of work had been done already. They utilised that past effort.

If you have any information on which trans athletes actually worked with British Triathlon to shape this policy towards protection of female sports categories, I would be interested to know. Those trans people should be applauded if they positively shaped this policy.

Or are you just repeating the news that male trans people were consulted and you have drawn the conclusion that they positively supported the protection of the female category? But that you don’t actually know this to be true.

In fact, reading up on the reaction, trans people and allies seem to feel they were ignored. One ally complained that British Triathlon included Fair Play for Women who have been very actively campaigning and not ‘anti-trans’ at all (they are very inclusive of females who haven’t doped on testosterone but are trans in the female category and they are encouraging males who are trans to compete as males).

But no, I haven’t seen any support for the British Triathlon from the usual LGBT groups.

So, I am happy to see something that shows that there was some male trans people who positively supported this policy and had positive input.

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 17:53

But HAS parasports got it right? It seems pretty arbitrary to most.

Para sport always reviews the way it classifies athletes and how they compete.

But a poster above said para sport had found a way for athletes to compete fairly so proving males and females can compete together.

Except I personally don't think that argument stands up to what the poster seems to be getting at as males and females compete separately - but against athletes who are assessed to have the same level as disability.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 17:40

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:29

You mentioned one sport while forgetting the huge effort that has gone into that Triathlon decision. It seems to be you who is missing the 'nuance' here

What makes you think I didn't understand or "forgot" the huge effort that went into this decision? I think posters here may have forgotten or not realised that trans athletes were involved in this decision- which is a good example of genuine trans athletes helping to create a solution.

How were trans people included here that makes you believe that it was “a good example of genuine trans athletes helping to create a solution.”

Because from what I remember, the core of this decision was based on the Sports council’s work from 2021 from the link below, a survey covering 3000+ people which returned around 80% that members believed that the women’s category be protected and one on ones of a range of people. Some of which were trans athletes.

https://www.sportengland.org/news/new-guidance-transgender-inclusion-domestic-sport-published

“I think posters here may have forgotten or not realised that trans athletes were involved in this decision”

So, do you have any evidence that male trans people positively influenced the British triathlon’s policy? I can assure you that many posters here who have been following what has been happening in female sports categories have not ‘forgotten’ and we most certainly realised ‘trans people’ were consulted. however, I have not seen that male trans people were involved in positively shaping the policy.

For instance, I seem to remember Jon Pike was one of the first people to start discussing ‘open’ categories as a solution. And swimming (FINA) adopted it before British Triathlon did. So that was not a new concept.

Let’s not forget that a team of very dedicated women, from athletes to biologists to feminists and many more ,campaigned and used the research available to present to Sport England who made their guidance in 2021. It was rather controversial at the time I recall, and many of those women involved have experienced negative impacts from doing so. Particularly people such as Sharron Davies. I believe some men were also involved in those presentations.

Then over the past 3-5 years there have been a growing number of women putting themselves on the line to even get to make presentations to decision makers. Remember in 2015, the IOC did not include any female athletes in the process to make decisions about the female sport categories. So much work had to be done by women to get heard or even have their opinions considered and not dismissed as transphobic.

So, finally by the time Triathlon starts to make their move, and it was gutsy at the time considering World Athletics took a long time to state they had concerns too and were publicly stating that changes had to be made, but by the time Triathlon announced they were reviewing , a huge amount of work had been done already. They utilised that past effort.

If you have any information on which trans athletes actually worked with British Triathlon to shape this policy towards protection of female sports categories, I would be interested to know. Those trans people should be applauded if they positively shaped this policy.

Or are you just repeating the news that male trans people were consulted and you have drawn the conclusion that they positively supported the protection of the female category? But that you don’t actually know this to be true.

The guidance is accompanied by a series of supporting documents and is the result of extensive research and consultation.

New guidance for transgender inclusion in domestic sport published | Sport England

Sport England and the other home nations' sports councils publish their Guidance for Transgender Inclusion in Domestic Sport.

https://www.sportengland.org/news/new-guidance-transgender-inclusion-domestic-sport-published

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 17:13

It's interesting that Mark's vast experience in coding gives him elite insight into the differences in how men and women think and express themselves (and surprise surprise, the conclusion he insinuates is that women are irrational)... and yet despite pages of evidence and explanation, he can't understand what the difference would be in a boxing ring or golf course.

DOBARDAN · 06/04/2023 17:02

YANBU
Male borns competing in women/girl's sports isn't fair, for so many reasons and, as a woman or girl, how humiliating and scary to be in the same changing/shower areas with them. It's a disgraceful state of affairs and I'm very worried about the kind of society females are having to live in. I am able to opt out of swimming/gym/changing rooms but not everyone can, and why should they give up an activity or sport which they enjoy? In any case, what about mixed wards in hospitals and jails, no chance of opting out in those places. It feels as if women and girls have absolutely no places where they can feel safe, have privacy and dignity when in various states of undress and there is no fairness in sports with males competing against females. You really couldn't make it up.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 16:47

A puberty blocked male may still have a height advantage and may still have skeletal proportions and leverage and hip placement that may carry advantages.

There is also some discussion around some male patients replenishing their bone density whereas females who have taken puberty blockers do not. So bone density if they are regained will be at a male level (if I remember correctly).

There is also the issue around the issues of the fibre thickness within female brains. I suspect that male brains will continue to develop thicker fibres not affected by testosterone. So those males don’t take on the same risks as female athletes.

Males of any age do not have to deal with the menstrual cycle and pregnancy.

while I suspect for now the definition will be males with pubertal advantages, I suspect that in the future that research will show there will be advantages that are not derived from testosterone and those athletes will also be excluded.

Again, the question that needs to be asked is what other athlete from outside a protected category is to be included into a protected category that should exclude them? Including those athletes that have lowered performance due to a medical treatment or through deliberately shaping their body at particular way?

Why should this group of males be rewarded or compensated through access to female sports categories?

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 16:43

Even if a male born athlete hasn't gone through puberty, that's a place that's been taken from a female born athlete. It's reducing opportunities for born girls in favour of born boys.

It might make for a fair race, but it's still inequality.

Happylittlechicken · 06/04/2023 16:34

But if a boy doesn’t go through male puberty, that would be because he had been given puberty blockers at primary school. Are you really suggesting it’s ok to give children dangerous, life altering drugs before they’ve even reached secondary school?

Animalsoffartingwood · 06/04/2023 16:30

I have no issue if the transgender woman has not been through male puberty, there is little to no advantage over female athletes in that scenario.

That can't be right. When my children were born we had different percentiles to follow depending on their sex, with males being significantly bigger on average. Boys also have mini testosterone growth spurts before puberty. Height+power will equal an advantage, no?

Then you need to factor in even if they were exactly the same physically, girls have societal barriers and expectations to overcome and boys have more opportunity both now and historically.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 16:28

Changeau · 06/04/2023 15:27

I'm sure you all mean well but the pages and pages of self congratulatory faux outrage are so wearing to read. I think I agree with most of you in practice, but the clever clever sneery tone is just so off putting at least to me, and there does seem to be a little gang here just waiting to pounce on anyone who doesn't fully agree with you. It's not much different to the pro-trans lobby in tone.

Yes you have made it clear about how you feel about other MNers throughout the thread.

You even agreed with the post that was deleted for clearly making a false negative generalisation. You don’t like the way people, most of us women, post. You have your own prejudices about how you believe women should behave, including how we should interact with someone who clearly has not got women and girl’s needs as their priority and makes not only ludicrous false assertions about feminism, but repeatedly doubled down on harmful misinformation despite having it pointed out how harmful that misinformation was.

Did you seek to clear up the misinformation that females should be competing, even in boxing, with males? If you did, I am sorry that I missed it, what argument did you use? Did it work because that poster doubled down on boxing and then brought in golf….

Redebs · 06/04/2023 16:20

Naunet · 06/04/2023 13:29

Is there some new fetish doing the rounds at the moment for men to come on to Mumsnet and make a total laughing stock of themselves?!

I could get behind that one.

They usually pay good money for that, I've heard 😳

Redebs · 06/04/2023 16:18

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 16:12

And I'm still waiting for the answer of how para sport has got it right by proving males and females can compete against each other when para athletes compete depending on their level of disability - in separate male and female categories.

But HAS parasports got it right? It seems pretty arbitrary to most.

SinnerBoy · 06/04/2023 16:17

Oh, I missed that particular misguided pronouncement.

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 16:12

And I'm still waiting for the answer of how para sport has got it right by proving males and females can compete against each other when para athletes compete depending on their level of disability - in separate male and female categories.

SinnerBoy · 06/04/2023 16:07

I haven't noticed any false outrage, just lots of people taking the piss out of someone who's posted a stream of unevidenced and poorly understood, erm, words.

Changeau · 06/04/2023 16:04

SquidwardBound · 06/04/2023 15:52

Oh good. Someone has come to fill the void left by mark in policing our shrill, irrational tone.

nice laydees know that you catch more flies with honey, don’t you harpies realise?

Yeah, this bollocks.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 15:55

Changeau · 06/04/2023 15:27

I'm sure you all mean well but the pages and pages of self congratulatory faux outrage are so wearing to read. I think I agree with most of you in practice, but the clever clever sneery tone is just so off putting at least to me, and there does seem to be a little gang here just waiting to pounce on anyone who doesn't fully agree with you. It's not much different to the pro-trans lobby in tone.

“I think I agree with most of you in practice”

And where are the points that you disagree?

SquidwardBound · 06/04/2023 15:52

Oh good. Someone has come to fill the void left by mark in policing our shrill, irrational tone.

nice laydees know that you catch more flies with honey, don’t you harpies realise?

1Week · 06/04/2023 15:36

Changeau · 06/04/2023 15:27

I'm sure you all mean well but the pages and pages of self congratulatory faux outrage are so wearing to read. I think I agree with most of you in practice, but the clever clever sneery tone is just so off putting at least to me, and there does seem to be a little gang here just waiting to pounce on anyone who doesn't fully agree with you. It's not much different to the pro-trans lobby in tone.

I don't think tone makes that much difference really - the root is, it's unfair, whether we say it nicely or not.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 15:30

Changeau · 06/04/2023 15:27

I'm sure you all mean well but the pages and pages of self congratulatory faux outrage are so wearing to read. I think I agree with most of you in practice, but the clever clever sneery tone is just so off putting at least to me, and there does seem to be a little gang here just waiting to pounce on anyone who doesn't fully agree with you. It's not much different to the pro-trans lobby in tone.

Why do you think our outrage is false?

Swipe left for the next trending thread