Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Transgender 'athletes'

440 replies

HappyHippo1234 · 06/04/2023 00:38

To start off - I have no issue with trans people at all. The only issue I have is transgender females (male to female) competing in women sports.

Yes, they may have been taking hormones and they have lost some muscle and gained some fat. But, they have stronger bones and bigger spines, hands, feet, lungs and hearts. Basically trans females have an advantage over biological females.

What I absolutely HATE about the situation, it the trans athletes attitude, it honestly disgusts me. Did they never take biology as teenagers or learn about puberty?
For them to sit there with their wins and say that they have no advantage just p*sses me off. Are they stupid or ignorant? There's no way they don't know they have an advantage. Do they not realise they are taking wins away from girls and woman who have spent their whole lives training for a sport only for it to be taken away from someone who was a mediocre male.

Look at Lia Thomas, she was somewhere in the 400-500th best college male swimmer or something like that. She is now trans and BAM she is number 1 and winning everything.

It just annoys me to no end. Especially the trans woman who you can tell that they KNOW they have a major advantage and are cheating the system and then sit there with a SMUG GRIN on their faces. I mean every Caitlyn Jenner said it's wrong.

Sorry for the rant. My DD15 has been upset all week as on the weekend another girl beat all the girls by a huge stretch in her cross country meet (her team is usually 1st but were bumped to 2nd). At first everyone thought this girl was great, until one mom heard the group the girl was with discussing the results and how it was great for the team that this girl came out as trans and was boosting their results etc! Fair to say that news travelled quickly and there were MANY parents complaining to officials. But surprise surprise nothing was done about it. So at the award giving ceremony everyone waited as everything up to 1st place was given out and as soon as they got to the 1st team, I would say 95% of people walked away. It felt harsh but necessary!
(Also the girl was 16 and had only recently transitioned from what we could gather and when you actually looked at her you could tell she had gone through at least some portion of male puberty). Again nothing against the girl just don't think she could compete.

And to get around all these discrimination lawsuits, I think they should change the categories! Have an XX category and an XY category, that why there is no debate and no 'discrimination' as you can't identify as XY if you are XX! (And then also have an open category where trans, non-binary etc. can compete).

SORRY THAT WAS SO LONG. NOW FOR THE VOTE:

YABU - Trans (XX) women are woman and should be allowed to compete with XY women, even though they scientifically have an advantage.

YANBU - They will always have an advantage and so should not compete with XY women.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 09:21

other people will cheat to win, won't they.

Well that makes it OK, then!

Why bother having rules at all?

SoupDragon · 06/04/2023 09:20

I've said this before on other threads but personally I don't have a problem with this. Sport should be a meritocracy, the best should win. I think dividing things up by gender is as wrong as dividing them by race or sexuality.

@Dotjones so you are basically saying that women should not bother competing in sports. The fastest/strongest will always be a man.

MarshaBradyo · 06/04/2023 09:18

It seems to be the wrong way round XX are women XY are male trans women

But I’d say vast majority agree they should be segregated by sex

Naunet · 06/04/2023 09:15

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:04

I don't. And haven't said that I do. I've pointed out that British Triathlon have done good research in this area and have introduced an Open category. I've said I wouldn't have turned my back on the imaginary athlete in the OP. I've said my dd routinely played football against boys in league football. And I've said that there's no room for nuance on mumsnet.

There’s no room for nuance when it comes to men in women’s sport.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:14

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 08:47

@SoupDragon but other people will cheat to win, won't they.

You'll lose out on a promotion because the bosses niece will get it. You'll lose your no claims bonus because someone drives like a dick on a roundabout so it's seen as a 50/50 claim. You'll lose out on all sorts of things through life because of other people's actions.

Is a biological boy in sport one of those things that should never even happen in the first place? Of course it is. But Op didn't even know it was a boy until their parent bragged.

So, not knowing that it was a male who beat the girls makes it ok? Lesson learned.

Just a lesson to learn that you cannot win all the time.

Why do you want to make it even harder for someone to win in what is supposed to be a fair situation though?

And you bring up valid points, so why are you adding to the opportunities for people to miss out on opportunities instead of making sure that the opportunities out there are as fair as possible?

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 09:14

Either a person can change from being a man to being a woman, in which case they should be treated as a woman just as much as someone born a woman is.

Actually no. Even if a man could become a woman and lose all his male athletic advantage (which he can't, as you know), he still shouldn't be allowed to compete as a woman.

It's the difference between fairness and equality. Once born males can take spaces for females, the men have all the men's opportunities plus whichever ones they choose to take from women. Women have only the smaller number that's left over.

If there are ten competing spaces for male swimmers and ten for female ones, then a man who chooses to become a woman takes an extra opportunity at the cost of the women. Born boys now get 11 chances and born girls get 9. The actual race itself may be fair, since the boy is now a girl, but the process is not equal, because the opportunities have been rigged in favour of born boys.

Sport should be a meritocracy, the best should win. I think dividing things up by gender is as wrong as dividing them by race or sexuality. Some athletes have a natural advantage over others

And this is just bollocks because the male advantage over females is so comprehensive (more haemoglobin, more testosterone, more fast twitch muscle etc etc) that if we don't sex segregate, there'll be no women champions and actually a lot more securely injured women. Melanin in your skin doesn't confer these sorts of advantages, but I think you know that.

Yes, some people are better built for athletics than others, but the male advantage outweighs it all when it comes to otherwise equivalent women. There's a reason Michael Phelps, a man, is said to have the perfect swimmer's body. Some women are built very well for it but none of them can be as perfect as a man who was always better built for broad shoulders, narrow hips, huge wingspan and flipper sized hands and feet.

Bamboux · 06/04/2023 09:13

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:04

I don't. And haven't said that I do. I've pointed out that British Triathlon have done good research in this area and have introduced an Open category. I've said I wouldn't have turned my back on the imaginary athlete in the OP. I've said my dd routinely played football against boys in league football. And I've said that there's no room for nuance on mumsnet.

That (possibly imaginary) athlete is a cheat.

They didn't win the race. They 'won' by cheating, depriving a genuine athlete of a winning place.

They 'won' like someone who has taken performance-enhancing drugs, bribed a judge, intimidated a witness, stolen an exam paper, or kneecapped an opponent.

Why would you stand and applaud them?

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 09:13

ThomasinaLivesHere · 06/04/2023 09:04

It seems unfair that trans women cannot compete in their chosen sport that they may have dedicated their lives to

Professional sport is unforgiving to lots of people. If you’re short you’ll never be a rower or basketball player no matter how well you train etc. There are lots and lots of examples like this.

Very true.

You only need to visit gymnastics, dance, athletics and swimming clubs etc to see that every body puts in the same hours of training and yet physiology does have an impact. That's same sex bs same sex. It's recognised. Yet they don't seem to be able to accept that physiology also implies to when people claim to be a different gender. Especially when you consider gender doesn't have a definition - it's just a stereotype of how a biological sex presents.

Everyone can compete in their chosen sport.

You just have to compete fairly.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:10

Changeau · 06/04/2023 08:52

My dd played against boys teams for years. It's quite normal for younger footballers to play in mixed teams.

A large Australian study found that even at the age of 6 years old boys have physical advantages over girls.

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:09

KittiesInsane · 06/04/2023 09:05

Is our local kids’ football setup really unusual? They’ve had transgirls playing on the boys’ teams for a while. No suggestion that they should join the (pretty good) girls’ league, as far as I know. Just all the other kids told to use their new names and not tease. The kids get to train and compete amongst appropriate peers, which is surely much of the point of sport.

At least one, I know, quietly reverted to his birth name in late teens. That’s surely a more difficult option if you’ve not retained a pool of friends throughout.

I don’t know what the exact position is once they get older, but surely a 16 year old can only legally be their birth sex anyway, so there’s no problem with them competing as that sex.

We have definitely had more trans boys playing in the boys teams than transgirls in the girls team (I can think of four trans boys playing boys football locally and not a single transgirl playing)

TrashyPanda · 06/04/2023 09:08

PSNonsense · 06/04/2023 08:45

'and I think it's a good life lesson for her that she won't always win and sometimes life's unfair.'

With all due respect, if there was any a statement that should be directed at transwomen, this is it!

How right you are!

why should our daughters have to accept blatant prejudice?

women were second-class citizens for far too long.
women fought for their rights. Now they have to fight to keep these rights.
any diminution affects all women.

KittiesInsane · 06/04/2023 09:08

Dot Jones, the problem is that several hundred men/boys would place above all the women/girls in everything where body strength matters. How depressing never to have a fair competition for our own sex.

Why shouldn’t women have fair sport?

ThomasinaLivesHere · 06/04/2023 09:08

I think dividing things up by gender is as wrong as dividing them by race or sexuality

But biological sex has marked differences on how you perform physically. Being attracted to same sex or having darker/lighter skin doesn’t.

Serena Williams is amazing but wouldn’t win anything in an open competition with men.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 06/04/2023 09:06

Of course you are right to be angry for your girls. They have been robbed by a cheat.

( and from what is emerging post competition, not all of the new ‘females’ are unmoved by the changing rooms.)

AIBU - Transgender 'athletes'
AIBU - Transgender 'athletes'
KittiesInsane · 06/04/2023 09:05

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 08:32

No one wants to see a trans kid excluded

They aren't and never have been. They just need to compete in their correct sex class.

Is our local kids’ football setup really unusual? They’ve had transgirls playing on the boys’ teams for a while. No suggestion that they should join the (pretty good) girls’ league, as far as I know. Just all the other kids told to use their new names and not tease. The kids get to train and compete amongst appropriate peers, which is surely much of the point of sport.

At least one, I know, quietly reverted to his birth name in late teens. That’s surely a more difficult option if you’ve not retained a pool of friends throughout.

I don’t know what the exact position is once they get older, but surely a 16 year old can only legally be their birth sex anyway, so there’s no problem with them competing as that sex.

Dotjones · 06/04/2023 09:04

I've said this before on other threads but personally I don't have a problem with this. Sport should be a meritocracy, the best should win. I think dividing things up by gender is as wrong as dividing them by race or sexuality. Some athletes have a natural advantage over others - you rarely see successful jockeys that are over 6ft tall for example - it's unfair, but it's life. Scrap the gender division altogether and the "transwomen in women's sport" argument goes away.

On the wider societal issue we simply need to answer this question: can a man become a woman and a woman become a man? It's a simple yes/no answer. As a society we need to decide and then the "transwomen in women's sport" problem goes away.

Either a person can change from being a man to being a woman, in which case they should be treated as a woman just as much as someone born a woman is. Access to women's facilities, sports etc. Or they can't in which case they shouldn't be able to change their pronouns or birth certificates.

The problems we currently have are because we haven't answered this simple question. The idea that a man can become a woman in some regards but not others is ludicrous. If they're not considered fully a woman then they're not a woman. If they are considered fully a woman, they shouldn't be treated differently to a woman.

Maybe there should just be a referendum and we could be done with it.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 06/04/2023 09:04

It seems unfair that trans women cannot compete in their chosen sport that they may have dedicated their lives to

Professional sport is unforgiving to lots of people. If you’re short you’ll never be a rower or basketball player no matter how well you train etc. There are lots and lots of examples like this.

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:04

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/04/2023 08:53

So why do you feel biological males should compete against biological women, knowing there are differences that give them an unfair advantage?

I don't. And haven't said that I do. I've pointed out that British Triathlon have done good research in this area and have introduced an Open category. I've said I wouldn't have turned my back on the imaginary athlete in the OP. I've said my dd routinely played football against boys in league football. And I've said that there's no room for nuance on mumsnet.

sashh · 06/04/2023 09:03

Changeau · 06/04/2023 08:47

Do one please, you know trans athletes do not want their own category

And this is a good example of why this site is so completely toxic about trans people. Absolutely no discussion allowed. Any deviation from the mumsnet party line (trans people are cheats and liars) means abuse. I'm glad I hid the Feminism topic and I'm glad I have the opportunity to hide this thread too.

OK I'll bite.

Have any trans women tried to set up their own category in any sport?

PSNonsense · 06/04/2023 09:02

@Naunet quite!

1Week · 06/04/2023 09:02

Changeau · 06/04/2023 08:47

Do one please, you know trans athletes do not want their own category

And this is a good example of why this site is so completely toxic about trans people. Absolutely no discussion allowed. Any deviation from the mumsnet party line (trans people are cheats and liars) means abuse. I'm glad I hid the Feminism topic and I'm glad I have the opportunity to hide this thread too.

I think what she said is true.
They don't want their own category
Otherwise they'd campaign for them, wouldn't they. Probably get a lot of support too.

itsgettingweird · 06/04/2023 09:00

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 08:39

So once trans women have accepted that they cannot compete fairly in races with biological women, that they cannot enter protected spaces solely for the use of biological women like bathrooms, changing spaces and domestic abuse refuges etc (all perfectly reasonable) are we happy or at least accepting enough to call them by their chosen female name, respect their choice to present superficially as a woman (whatever that means) ? Not all trans folk are rapists, violent, fetishists are they ? Surely if you know and like the trans person or they are a random person you meet for a second there's nothing wrong with going along with their wishes and addressing them as she...or are people wholly opposed to the idea of trans people and have no intention of going along with it all ?

We have a transwoman living very close.

She's amazing. She spends hours on manicures, make up, dresses like Bet Lynch from Corrie and wears heels I'd die trying to walking in.

I call her her name, I compliment her perfectly manicured nails and always ask her how she gets her wig hair so perfectly curled (mines naturally curly but never looks that good!).

But would I accept her competing against other woman in Sport.

No. But she also doesn't agree with it.

She also uses accessible toilets as she says she understand why woman would feel uncomfortable with someone of male sex in woman's only spaces.

I have a lot of respect for her. But she is t biologically female nor does she claim to be.

TrashyPanda · 06/04/2023 08:59

Changeau · 06/04/2023 06:54

Well, they have been consulted in Triathlon and the rules have been changed. Sorry that you can't seem to grasp that this is a good thing for women as your post seemed very dismissive of this progress? Almost as if you can't wait to ignore it and just default to criticising trans people?

That is one sport.

it is good for women in that sport. Obviously

meanwhile, in other non-Triathalon events, there are no such rules.

which is not good for women athletes.

sorry you cant understand this.

Theunamedcat · 06/04/2023 08:59

Changeau · 06/04/2023 08:47

Do one please, you know trans athletes do not want their own category

And this is a good example of why this site is so completely toxic about trans people. Absolutely no discussion allowed. Any deviation from the mumsnet party line (trans people are cheats and liars) means abuse. I'm glad I hid the Feminism topic and I'm glad I have the opportunity to hide this thread too.

Everytime they were offered it was refused third spaces are not the goal here