Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Transgender 'athletes'

440 replies

HappyHippo1234 · 06/04/2023 00:38

To start off - I have no issue with trans people at all. The only issue I have is transgender females (male to female) competing in women sports.

Yes, they may have been taking hormones and they have lost some muscle and gained some fat. But, they have stronger bones and bigger spines, hands, feet, lungs and hearts. Basically trans females have an advantage over biological females.

What I absolutely HATE about the situation, it the trans athletes attitude, it honestly disgusts me. Did they never take biology as teenagers or learn about puberty?
For them to sit there with their wins and say that they have no advantage just p*sses me off. Are they stupid or ignorant? There's no way they don't know they have an advantage. Do they not realise they are taking wins away from girls and woman who have spent their whole lives training for a sport only for it to be taken away from someone who was a mediocre male.

Look at Lia Thomas, she was somewhere in the 400-500th best college male swimmer or something like that. She is now trans and BAM she is number 1 and winning everything.

It just annoys me to no end. Especially the trans woman who you can tell that they KNOW they have a major advantage and are cheating the system and then sit there with a SMUG GRIN on their faces. I mean every Caitlyn Jenner said it's wrong.

Sorry for the rant. My DD15 has been upset all week as on the weekend another girl beat all the girls by a huge stretch in her cross country meet (her team is usually 1st but were bumped to 2nd). At first everyone thought this girl was great, until one mom heard the group the girl was with discussing the results and how it was great for the team that this girl came out as trans and was boosting their results etc! Fair to say that news travelled quickly and there were MANY parents complaining to officials. But surprise surprise nothing was done about it. So at the award giving ceremony everyone waited as everything up to 1st place was given out and as soon as they got to the 1st team, I would say 95% of people walked away. It felt harsh but necessary!
(Also the girl was 16 and had only recently transitioned from what we could gather and when you actually looked at her you could tell she had gone through at least some portion of male puberty). Again nothing against the girl just don't think she could compete.

And to get around all these discrimination lawsuits, I think they should change the categories! Have an XX category and an XY category, that why there is no debate and no 'discrimination' as you can't identify as XY if you are XX! (And then also have an open category where trans, non-binary etc. can compete).

SORRY THAT WAS SO LONG. NOW FOR THE VOTE:

YABU - Trans (XX) women are woman and should be allowed to compete with XY women, even though they scientifically have an advantage.

YANBU - They will always have an advantage and so should not compete with XY women.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
KittiesInsane · 06/04/2023 09:42

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:34

Mixed teams are fine until 16 or 18 I can't remember (was 16 but I think it got changed to 18 but not 100% sure)

Ah, thanks. I’m out of touch (mine were never much into football).

MarshaBradyo · 06/04/2023 09:39

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 09:35

In most sports where there is clear physiological advantage from some criterion, that sport is competed for by category.

Combat sports are divided into weight classes. There are 17 divisions in boxing. You'd never match a flyweight with a heavyweight.
Many sports are divided into age classes. You'd never put a 9-yr old gymnast up against a 16-yr old.
For a long time, many sports were split into 2 categories. Men and Non-Men (aka Women). Then, in 1960 the inaugural Paralympic games added new categories for many Olympic sports and there are now 10 categories of disability with hundreds of sub-categories depending on the sport and the nature of the impairment. All of these new categories were in addition to the existing one - Non-men (the original special category created to allow more fair participation by half the human population who were disadvantaged by their biology from competing in an 'Open' category).

None of these divisions are perfectly fair. Even within existing divisions there are latent advantages for particular characteristics. Most rowers tend to have a similar body shape. As do most jockeys. People without that body shape are unlikely to progress to elite levels, regardless of how hard they train.

Sometimes a sport's rules and scoring methodologies change and this results in a visible change in body shape of the competitors who podium (e.g. gymnasts - Simone Biles has a very different body shape than Nadia Comaneci, and it's only partly explained by training. Banning the skills that relied on hyper-extension and scoring more highly skills that emphasise power and strength also helped drive this change). Sometimes societal changes do the same. Access and participation by sectors of society that were historically excluded from sports have seen phenomenal changes in the physical appearance of elite athletes. Compare and contrast Margaret Court with Serena Williams.

Bleating that 'it's not fair because athletes born male are heavier' misses the point. Half the athletes born female are also heavier than the other half. What is needed to address this issue is for each sport's governing association to consider what the fairest way to divide the human population is, to ensure their sport remains accessible, and competitive, and safe, for the greatest number of participants. That is pretty much what they are all trying to do.
This will involve many factors - economic, social, legal, as well as sex. It's really not just about sex. And yes, along the way, there'll be some instances where the outcomes will be ones that society doesn't like - and things will evolve.

Bleating that 'it's not fair

When people post like this you know the rest is going to be male centric and trying to excuse gender ideology

Segregate by sex as a basic requirement. If other divisions are needed that’s no issue.

PSNonsense · 06/04/2023 09:39

Race and who you are attracted to doesn't have an impact on sporting ability.

Whether you are born male or female does. It's not difficult to understand or it shouldn't be. Got to wonder sometimes.

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:38

FA changed the age limit for mixed teams to 18 a few.years ago. Was seen as a good thing as it benefitted girls to play with and against boys. However, with the rise of girls football, in practice there are now very few mixed teams or leagues post 16.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:36

For anyone interested, although this link has not been updated recently, here are some of the sports where female athletes have lost against male athletes.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4175263--No-Trans-Olympian-List-of-women-and-girls-disadvantaged-in-sport-resource-thread?latest=0

In fact, here is a current thread about a male who holds a large % of the Canadian female weighlifting records in the categories they compete it. And how unhappy that male was that another male smashed their record while competing under the current rules. You really could not make this up.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4777101-canada-has-its-trans-weight-lifting-policy-shown-up-for-the-sham-it-is?page=1

‘No Trans Olympian’ List of women and girls disadvantaged in sport - resource thread | Mumsnet

Mumsnet makes parents' lives easier by pooling knowledge, advice and support on everything from conception to childbirth, from babies to teenagers.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4175263--No-Trans-Olympian-List-of-women-and-girls-disadvantaged-in-sport-resource-thread?latest=0

Naunet · 06/04/2023 09:36

Bamboux · 06/04/2023 09:32

Yes, @Dotjones is saying that women's sports should not exist.

With a side order of racism.

I think dividing it up by species is just as bad as racism and sexism and we should let all animals in. I want to see a bear fight a man in MMA. Why not? The best should win. Right @Dotjones ?

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 09:35

For anyone who thinks males should compete in female sports categories, do you understand why there is a female sport’s category? It is only to allow female sports people to have fair competition.

Yes.

It is not to reassure the competitors that we know they're women.

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 09:35

In most sports where there is clear physiological advantage from some criterion, that sport is competed for by category.

Combat sports are divided into weight classes. There are 17 divisions in boxing. You'd never match a flyweight with a heavyweight.
Many sports are divided into age classes. You'd never put a 9-yr old gymnast up against a 16-yr old.
For a long time, many sports were split into 2 categories. Men and Non-Men (aka Women). Then, in 1960 the inaugural Paralympic games added new categories for many Olympic sports and there are now 10 categories of disability with hundreds of sub-categories depending on the sport and the nature of the impairment. All of these new categories were in addition to the existing one - Non-men (the original special category created to allow more fair participation by half the human population who were disadvantaged by their biology from competing in an 'Open' category).

None of these divisions are perfectly fair. Even within existing divisions there are latent advantages for particular characteristics. Most rowers tend to have a similar body shape. As do most jockeys. People without that body shape are unlikely to progress to elite levels, regardless of how hard they train.

Sometimes a sport's rules and scoring methodologies change and this results in a visible change in body shape of the competitors who podium (e.g. gymnasts - Simone Biles has a very different body shape than Nadia Comaneci, and it's only partly explained by training. Banning the skills that relied on hyper-extension and scoring more highly skills that emphasise power and strength also helped drive this change). Sometimes societal changes do the same. Access and participation by sectors of society that were historically excluded from sports have seen phenomenal changes in the physical appearance of elite athletes. Compare and contrast Margaret Court with Serena Williams.

Bleating that 'it's not fair because athletes born male are heavier' misses the point. Half the athletes born female are also heavier than the other half. What is needed to address this issue is for each sport's governing association to consider what the fairest way to divide the human population is, to ensure their sport remains accessible, and competitive, and safe, for the greatest number of participants. That is pretty much what they are all trying to do.
This will involve many factors - economic, social, legal, as well as sex. It's really not just about sex. And yes, along the way, there'll be some instances where the outcomes will be ones that society doesn't like - and things will evolve.

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:34

KittiesInsane · 06/04/2023 09:33

Ok, maybe it is unusual then. What’s the rationale for transboys playing with the boys, though? How is that allowed? Legally and physically, they’re still girls, surely, if under 16 (or is it 18)?

Mixed teams are fine until 16 or 18 I can't remember (was 16 but I think it got changed to 18 but not 100% sure)

KittiesInsane · 06/04/2023 09:33

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:09

We have definitely had more trans boys playing in the boys teams than transgirls in the girls team (I can think of four trans boys playing boys football locally and not a single transgirl playing)

Ok, maybe it is unusual then. What’s the rationale for transboys playing with the boys, though? How is that allowed? Legally and physically, they’re still girls, surely, if under 16 (or is it 18)?

Bamboux · 06/04/2023 09:32

SoupDragon · 06/04/2023 09:20

I've said this before on other threads but personally I don't have a problem with this. Sport should be a meritocracy, the best should win. I think dividing things up by gender is as wrong as dividing them by race or sexuality.

@Dotjones so you are basically saying that women should not bother competing in sports. The fastest/strongest will always be a man.

Yes, @Dotjones is saying that women's sports should not exist.

With a side order of racism.

Bamboux · 06/04/2023 09:31

SoupDragon · 06/04/2023 09:25

Why can't Usain Bold identify as a 10 year old and thrash everyone at sports day? It would be no different.

When Roots Manuva did it , it was a joke. And the kids booed him.

I guess @Changeau would find that unkind. They should have applauded.

roots manuva - witness the fitness

roots manuva

https://youtu.be/NDWgtB_MD24

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:29

You mentioned one sport while forgetting the huge effort that has gone into that Triathlon decision. It seems to be you who is missing the 'nuance' here

What makes you think I didn't understand or "forgot" the huge effort that went into this decision? I think posters here may have forgotten or not realised that trans athletes were involved in this decision- which is a good example of genuine trans athletes helping to create a solution.

PSNonsense · 06/04/2023 09:29

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 09:28

@PSNonsense I agree with you though ? Argue with yourselves if you could.

So what's your argument then? Other than calling people paranoid?

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:29

For anyone who thinks males should compete in female sports categories, do you understand why there is a female sport’s category? It is only to allow female sports people to have fair competition.

Think about what other category boundaries you would be happy to accept

A 25 year old competing against a 10 year old?

A 25 year old competing against a 85 year old?

A person who had 90% vision competing with someone with 5% vision ?

A person who was a professional standard athlete competing in a novice only event ?

A bicycle with an electric engine competing against a 100% human powered bicycle in the Tour de France?

If you have said yes to any of these, why? if you have said no, then why would you accept a male with pubertal advantages in a female sports category?

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 09:28

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 09:25

We all see what you're insinuating blatantly accusing us of, but it's nil points for you, I'm afraid.
Not paranoid much. Certainly not welcoming to discussion no ?

Oh, I see, it's because I called out your attempt at deflection and irrelevant accusation. Thanks, I was scratching my head at that one.

Be grateful, it gave you the excuse you needed to completely ignore the rest of the post.

On with the show.

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 09:28

@PSNonsense I agree with you though ? Argue with yourselves if you could.

PSNonsense · 06/04/2023 09:27

Siege mentality = majority believes in common sense, i.e sport should be fair.

PSNonsense · 06/04/2023 09:26

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 09:22

@ReneBumsWombats sorry but you are paranoid. No one can ask any kind of question and they are treated with suspicion and anger. This is precisely why people are fearful of asking anything because there is always aggression. It's like you're having an imaginary argument in your heads constantly and think people are trying to catch you out. Siege mentality. No one on this thread has called anyone far right or suggested anyone is anti trans..

The 9th post in did. It's now been deleted, hopefully for the use of the word 'cis'.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:26

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:04

I don't. And haven't said that I do. I've pointed out that British Triathlon have done good research in this area and have introduced an Open category. I've said I wouldn't have turned my back on the imaginary athlete in the OP. I've said my dd routinely played football against boys in league football. And I've said that there's no room for nuance on mumsnet.

And I've said that there's no room for nuance on mumsnet.

The nuance is that male athletes can compete in male sports categories. That male athletes are not 'banned' from sports if they identify as the opposite sex.

You mentioned one sport while forgetting the huge effort that has gone into that Triathlon decision. It seems to be you who is missing the 'nuance' here.

You twisted another poster's post which was talking about males who do want to compete in female categories to attempt to shame them by framing their post as if that poster was saying 'all' males with trans identities wanting to compete in female categories. The nuance is, that if you spent time discussing the issue as we have, you will know that we KNOW there are male competitors who won't compete in the female category out of fairness..

But you seem to lack to the ability to acknowledge that while some sports have now made policies that protect the female categories of sports, it is only at particular levels for some sports and there are other sports who have not yet made that decision.

So, many of us have been involved in girls and womens sports, many of us have been campaigning on this issue. It has meant that while these decisions have been made, there have been women and girls who have missed out, and sometimes when they have missed out it has very negatively impacted their future.

The decision to allow males to compete in female sports categories should never have been made. It was made and it was made without female athletes contribution. It has taken a very long time to roll this very poor decision back.

I can keep telling you all the 'nuance' that you seem to think that posters haven't considered. Many of the posters on here know a great deal about it and can supply as much nuance as you would like.

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 09:25

We all see what you're insinuating blatantly accusing us of, but it's nil points for you, I'm afraid.
Not paranoid much. Certainly not welcoming to discussion no ?

SoupDragon · 06/04/2023 09:25

Why can't Usain Bold identify as a 10 year old and thrash everyone at sports day? It would be no different.

SoupDragon · 06/04/2023 09:24

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 08:47

@SoupDragon but other people will cheat to win, won't they.

You'll lose out on a promotion because the bosses niece will get it. You'll lose your no claims bonus because someone drives like a dick on a roundabout so it's seen as a 50/50 claim. You'll lose out on all sorts of things through life because of other people's actions.

Is a biological boy in sport one of those things that should never even happen in the first place? Of course it is. But Op didn't even know it was a boy until their parent bragged.

I had sporty DSs (rugby) and the thought of them competing against girls would have been ridiculous and cheating. Even they recognised that at 16! It's a shame adults can't see it.

I bet the only reason the OP didn't realise is because she didn't think it would happen. The default is to assume they are all biologically female. With hindsight, it's always blindingly obvious when they aren't.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 09:23

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 09:22

@ReneBumsWombats sorry but you are paranoid. No one can ask any kind of question and they are treated with suspicion and anger. This is precisely why people are fearful of asking anything because there is always aggression. It's like you're having an imaginary argument in your heads constantly and think people are trying to catch you out. Siege mentality. No one on this thread has called anyone far right or suggested anyone is anti trans..

What have I said to indicate I am paranoid?

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 09:22

@ReneBumsWombats sorry but you are paranoid. No one can ask any kind of question and they are treated with suspicion and anger. This is precisely why people are fearful of asking anything because there is always aggression. It's like you're having an imaginary argument in your heads constantly and think people are trying to catch you out. Siege mentality. No one on this thread has called anyone far right or suggested anyone is anti trans..