Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Transgender 'athletes'

440 replies

HappyHippo1234 · 06/04/2023 00:38

To start off - I have no issue with trans people at all. The only issue I have is transgender females (male to female) competing in women sports.

Yes, they may have been taking hormones and they have lost some muscle and gained some fat. But, they have stronger bones and bigger spines, hands, feet, lungs and hearts. Basically trans females have an advantage over biological females.

What I absolutely HATE about the situation, it the trans athletes attitude, it honestly disgusts me. Did they never take biology as teenagers or learn about puberty?
For them to sit there with their wins and say that they have no advantage just p*sses me off. Are they stupid or ignorant? There's no way they don't know they have an advantage. Do they not realise they are taking wins away from girls and woman who have spent their whole lives training for a sport only for it to be taken away from someone who was a mediocre male.

Look at Lia Thomas, she was somewhere in the 400-500th best college male swimmer or something like that. She is now trans and BAM she is number 1 and winning everything.

It just annoys me to no end. Especially the trans woman who you can tell that they KNOW they have a major advantage and are cheating the system and then sit there with a SMUG GRIN on their faces. I mean every Caitlyn Jenner said it's wrong.

Sorry for the rant. My DD15 has been upset all week as on the weekend another girl beat all the girls by a huge stretch in her cross country meet (her team is usually 1st but were bumped to 2nd). At first everyone thought this girl was great, until one mom heard the group the girl was with discussing the results and how it was great for the team that this girl came out as trans and was boosting their results etc! Fair to say that news travelled quickly and there were MANY parents complaining to officials. But surprise surprise nothing was done about it. So at the award giving ceremony everyone waited as everything up to 1st place was given out and as soon as they got to the 1st team, I would say 95% of people walked away. It felt harsh but necessary!
(Also the girl was 16 and had only recently transitioned from what we could gather and when you actually looked at her you could tell she had gone through at least some portion of male puberty). Again nothing against the girl just don't think she could compete.

And to get around all these discrimination lawsuits, I think they should change the categories! Have an XX category and an XY category, that why there is no debate and no 'discrimination' as you can't identify as XY if you are XX! (And then also have an open category where trans, non-binary etc. can compete).

SORRY THAT WAS SO LONG. NOW FOR THE VOTE:

YABU - Trans (XX) women are woman and should be allowed to compete with XY women, even though they scientifically have an advantage.

YANBU - They will always have an advantage and so should not compete with XY women.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
MarshaBradyo · 06/04/2023 10:29

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:12

Society today prioritises inclusion. When it's SEND kids and kids with ADHD in mainstream classrooms, the MN massive takes a very different view on what 'fairness' is.

If societal rule number one is that every individual should be able to compete in their chosen sport somewhere (the inclusion principle).
And societal and environmental factors mean that there are currently only two divisions within which an adult can compete - men's or women's.
Then the judgment should really be, in which division is it most fair for that individual to compete in?
I don't see why it should be so outrageous for the medical and sporting experts who make these assessments to decide that sometimes that means people born in one sex should compete alongside people born in the other.
In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).
That'd see men and women competing together in many divisions, but also it would be more nuanced, and more fair - right?

If you want perfect fairness, then sure, let's have 7 billion categories and we can all have a gold medal. That's the illogical end point of intersectionality. But every single point before that absurd outcome requires some choice or judgment of how you define fairness - and that definition will result in some people not getting 'their' gold.

If you take a hard line, ultra competitive, winner-takes-all approach, then there should just be one category - an open one. But the people justifying women's sports as a separate division are loathe to acknowledge that it is having a very limited and specific definition of 'fairness' that creates this issue in the first place.

And the hypocrisy is rank. The same people will also argue that women should be paid the same for winning a best of three sets tennis match (watched by about a million people) than a man winning a best of five sets tennis match (watched by 3 million people). I guess fairness means something different when you're looking to smash the glass ceiling than it does when you are punching down to someone who is mentally ill and struggling to find their place in the world.

Do you want males in female sports

Why?

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:28

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:12

Society today prioritises inclusion. When it's SEND kids and kids with ADHD in mainstream classrooms, the MN massive takes a very different view on what 'fairness' is.

If societal rule number one is that every individual should be able to compete in their chosen sport somewhere (the inclusion principle).
And societal and environmental factors mean that there are currently only two divisions within which an adult can compete - men's or women's.
Then the judgment should really be, in which division is it most fair for that individual to compete in?
I don't see why it should be so outrageous for the medical and sporting experts who make these assessments to decide that sometimes that means people born in one sex should compete alongside people born in the other.
In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).
That'd see men and women competing together in many divisions, but also it would be more nuanced, and more fair - right?

If you want perfect fairness, then sure, let's have 7 billion categories and we can all have a gold medal. That's the illogical end point of intersectionality. But every single point before that absurd outcome requires some choice or judgment of how you define fairness - and that definition will result in some people not getting 'their' gold.

If you take a hard line, ultra competitive, winner-takes-all approach, then there should just be one category - an open one. But the people justifying women's sports as a separate division are loathe to acknowledge that it is having a very limited and specific definition of 'fairness' that creates this issue in the first place.

And the hypocrisy is rank. The same people will also argue that women should be paid the same for winning a best of three sets tennis match (watched by about a million people) than a man winning a best of five sets tennis match (watched by 3 million people). I guess fairness means something different when you're looking to smash the glass ceiling than it does when you are punching down to someone who is mentally ill and struggling to find their place in the world.

Can you tell me a male tennis player that had to make the decision about whether to carry their pregnancy or not?

"In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).
That'd see men and women competing together in many divisions, but also it would be more nuanced, and more fair - right?
"

Your rhetoric here is intent on allowing harm to female athletes based on your own lack of information.

The punch power difference is one of those advantages that is very clear to remain very high after testosterone suppression. It is about leverage. It is about muscle type. It is about bone density. It is also about female brains and how they are prone to damage because of fragile brain fibres.

You are ludicrously repeated unsubstantiated trope from somewhere else on the internet. And you are spreading misinformation that is harmful to all females.

PSNonsense · 06/04/2023 10:26

In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).

Ah yes, because it just comes down to testosterone levels doesn't it. Nothing else 🙄.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:23

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:12

Society today prioritises inclusion. When it's SEND kids and kids with ADHD in mainstream classrooms, the MN massive takes a very different view on what 'fairness' is.

If societal rule number one is that every individual should be able to compete in their chosen sport somewhere (the inclusion principle).
And societal and environmental factors mean that there are currently only two divisions within which an adult can compete - men's or women's.
Then the judgment should really be, in which division is it most fair for that individual to compete in?
I don't see why it should be so outrageous for the medical and sporting experts who make these assessments to decide that sometimes that means people born in one sex should compete alongside people born in the other.
In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).
That'd see men and women competing together in many divisions, but also it would be more nuanced, and more fair - right?

If you want perfect fairness, then sure, let's have 7 billion categories and we can all have a gold medal. That's the illogical end point of intersectionality. But every single point before that absurd outcome requires some choice or judgment of how you define fairness - and that definition will result in some people not getting 'their' gold.

If you take a hard line, ultra competitive, winner-takes-all approach, then there should just be one category - an open one. But the people justifying women's sports as a separate division are loathe to acknowledge that it is having a very limited and specific definition of 'fairness' that creates this issue in the first place.

And the hypocrisy is rank. The same people will also argue that women should be paid the same for winning a best of three sets tennis match (watched by about a million people) than a man winning a best of five sets tennis match (watched by 3 million people). I guess fairness means something different when you're looking to smash the glass ceiling than it does when you are punching down to someone who is mentally ill and struggling to find their place in the world.

Oh dear.

And the hypocrisy is rank. The same people will also argue that women should be paid the same for winning a best of three sets tennis match (watched by about a million people) than a man winning a best of five sets tennis match (watched by 3 million people).

Are you a mens right's activist then?

Do you actually understand why female's have their own sports ? Do you understand equity?

Has anyone tested the female tennis players to see if they have the capability to perform at the same level for five sets without injuring themselves?

Have you understood how hard female tennis players have had to work to get recognised as being as high a performing players as male players and that they still encounter negative sexist discrimination?

Do you understand female athletics at all?

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:16

Here is the hip diagram. If the share token doesn't work look it up on the archive site (that I cannot link to but you can find it)

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3081c8c0-af7c-11ec-8b8c-0207c0fd6104?shareToken=dfc4c5b36b407a8e0ccc2133e718b121

Alternatively archive today/u4oSa

The article is titled: If you believe in fair competition, Emily Bridges should not be racing Laura Kenny

The Times & The Sunday Times

News and opinion from The Times & The Sunday Times

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3081c8c0-af7c-11ec-8b8c-0207c0fd6104?shareToken=dfc4c5b36b407a8e0ccc2133e718b121

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:12

Society today prioritises inclusion. When it's SEND kids and kids with ADHD in mainstream classrooms, the MN massive takes a very different view on what 'fairness' is.

If societal rule number one is that every individual should be able to compete in their chosen sport somewhere (the inclusion principle).
And societal and environmental factors mean that there are currently only two divisions within which an adult can compete - men's or women's.
Then the judgment should really be, in which division is it most fair for that individual to compete in?
I don't see why it should be so outrageous for the medical and sporting experts who make these assessments to decide that sometimes that means people born in one sex should compete alongside people born in the other.
In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).
That'd see men and women competing together in many divisions, but also it would be more nuanced, and more fair - right?

If you want perfect fairness, then sure, let's have 7 billion categories and we can all have a gold medal. That's the illogical end point of intersectionality. But every single point before that absurd outcome requires some choice or judgment of how you define fairness - and that definition will result in some people not getting 'their' gold.

If you take a hard line, ultra competitive, winner-takes-all approach, then there should just be one category - an open one. But the people justifying women's sports as a separate division are loathe to acknowledge that it is having a very limited and specific definition of 'fairness' that creates this issue in the first place.

And the hypocrisy is rank. The same people will also argue that women should be paid the same for winning a best of three sets tennis match (watched by about a million people) than a man winning a best of five sets tennis match (watched by 3 million people). I guess fairness means something different when you're looking to smash the glass ceiling than it does when you are punching down to someone who is mentally ill and struggling to find their place in the world.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:12

https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2020/11/06/bjsports-2020-102329

Timothy A Roberts, Joshua Smalley, Dale Ahrendt

Effect of gender affirming hormones on athletic performance in transwomen and transmen: implications for sporting organisations and legislators

Summary The 15–31% athletic advantage that transwomen displayed over their female counterparts prior to starting gender affirming hormones declined with feminising therapy. However, transwomen still had a 9% faster mean run speed after the 1 year period of testosterone suppression that is recommended by World Athletics for inclusion in women’s events.

It is interesting reading as it also leaves the suggestion that even after 3 years advantage still exists.

And Sean Ingle’s take on it.

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2020/dec/07/study-suggests-ioc-adjustment-period-for-trans-women-may-be-too-short

https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2020/11/06/bjsports-2020-102329

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:11

From Ross Tucker on this study above:

Over a decade (14.4 yrs average) of T-suppression, and TW have VO2max 20% higher, grip strength 19% higher & skeletal mass 40% than women. More evidence that male biology persists long after T is removed. Another piece of the same puzzle, albeit from a cross-sectional study.

The cross-sectional bit is important - the study hasn't (like over a dozen others) tracked people from Day zero onwards, so the differences are a 'snapshot' rather than a 'movie', if that makes sense? Means you don't know how those TW began, 14.4 yrs earlier, but the finding of quite large differences compared to women (20% or more) is striking, because a) they either began as typically representative of males, and lost some, but retained significant advantages vs women, or b) they began well below men, and lost hardly any advantages. In either case, the end point, over a decade later, is biological differences compared to women that will create performance implications. Of interest, the mass retention and VO2max advantage mean that relative VO2max (ml/kg/min) ends up similar, which means in some sports (weight-determined) the performance implication may differ - sometimes very large, sometimes smaller, as in some categories within endurance sports.

But zero? Unlikely, because cardio function, FFM & strength are greater. Important paper, showing striking biological 'persistence' 14 yrs on.
Two further thoughts on the study. First, the TW vs women differences in muscle mass and strength remain large (20%) after more than a decade of T suppression. One year vs ten, biology "persists". Second, add training to the mix and TW and women would obviously get stronger.

You could TRY to argue that women would get stronger relatively more than TW (you'd have a job on your hands to explain why this would be, but anyway). More likely is that the differences - TW vs women - would persist or even increase with the addition of training. What this study confirms is that non-trained TW retain biological differences with performance implications after 14 years of T suppression. You'd have to believe that W could make up these gaps with training to believe in fairness in sport. That is, trained W = non-trained TW = fair!

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:10

https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2022/09/01/bjsports-2021-105400.info

New study from Brazil

Cardiopulmonary capacity and muscle strength in transgender women on long-term gender-affirming hormone therapy: a cross-sectional study

Leonardo Azevedo Mobilia Alvares, Marcelo Rodrigues Santos, Francis Ribeiro Souza, Lívia Marcela Santos, Berenice Bilharinho de Mendonça, Elaine Maria Frade Costa, Maria Janieire Nazaré Nunes Alves, Sorahia Domenice

Conclusion
In this small cohort of non-athlete TW, who were previously exposed to male pubertal development and underwent long-term oestrogen therapy, we identified higher grip strength and VO2 peak levels than in non-athlete CW, but these same parameters were lower compared with non-athlete CM.

These findings add new insights to the sparse information available on a highly controversial topic about the participation of TW in physical activities. Future studies involving transgender athletes that account for and quantify variable exposure times to pubertal development and assess muscle cell metabolism are needed to elucidate the effects of long-term GAHT on TW sports performance.

https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2022/09/01/bjsports-2021-105400.info

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:09

https://idrottsforum.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/devineetal221129.pdf

"When Ideology Trumps Science: A response to the Canadian Centre for Ethics in Sport’s Review on Transwomen Athletes in the Female Category"

Cathy Devine, Emma Hilton, Leslie Howe, Miroslav Imbrišević, Tommy Lundberg, Jon Pike

Independent Scholar; University of Manchester; University of Saskatchewan; Open University (UK); Karolinska Institutet

29 November 2022

This response was put together to address a published document about the 'ethical' considerations for males with trans identities to compete in female sports categories.

https://idrottsforum.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/devineetal221129.pdf

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:07

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33289906/

This above is the review of 13 studies from Dr Emma Hilton and Tommy Lundberg.

bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2021/02/28/bjsports-2020-103106

And Harper's study that reached similar conclusions to Hilton and Lundberg.

https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2021/02/28/bjsports-2020-103106

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:05

This session from SBS Australia might be interesting for some readers. In particular, that person in the thumbnail below is Mianne Baggar. Who successfully had the women's golf tournaments opened to males like Baggar. They now understand the damage to women's golf they have done (not necessarily said here, but I have watched quite a few of their panel appearances and they now fully understand the issues that they did not understand before).

There is also a great segment with Dr David Handelsman who is one of Australia's testosterone experts.

Gender Games: Trans women and sport | Full Episode | SBS Insight

Do transgender women belong in women’s sports? On Gender Games, we hear from transwomen and female athletes about inclusion, fairness and safety. Can sports ...

https://youtu.be/STX1GCxYEIc

Inaea · 06/04/2023 10:05

Of course they know, they’re just pretending they don’t.

Lia Thomas chose the new name “Lia[r]”for a reason…

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:03

Yeah you're probably right to be fair @SoupDragon, because she did say once they knew it was fairly obvious.

It's funny that's it's rarely women transitioning to men who compete in high level sports...

Naunet · 06/04/2023 09:59

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:47

"Half the athletes born female are also heavier than the other half. "

There are many advantages that a male of a similar weight will have over a female of a similar weight. For instance a male's grip strength, which is pertinent in many sports. A male in the lowest 25% for grip strength will still have a stronger grip than 90% of female people.

Then there are skeletal advantages. Higher bone density, different leverage points. Including Q angles in hips that create a difference. Then there are the different muscles. The list goes on.

Let's not forget that female brains have more delicate brain fibres and that makes them more prone to damage. Imagine the damage that is done by impact with a male body part that has come at that head with all the advantages that male bodies have. Speed due to length of leg, due to different muscle types that allow that speed. Height differences so that when that male body hits that female head, it hits and the female athlete's head has nowhere to go to mitigate that impact. Average punch strength is a huge difference between male and female bodies and is not reduced to matching average female punch strength.

Unfortunately, there are many people out there who think that weight matching between male and female bodies is a step towards 'fairness'. It is not.

Never mind the fact that female athletes deal with periods and pregnancy

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 09:59

Naunet · 06/04/2023 09:57

What a load of shit excuses for handing womens hard fought for sports over to men. Get a grip, at least be honest about what you’re arguing for.

I'm familiar with the username.

Don't feed...

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:58

Here is a tweet from a sport's scientist about body shapes.

Ross Tucker Jun 29th 2020,

Something keeps coming up in the discussions about women’s sport, fairness and advantages for transwomen. It’s that there is an overlap in the physiology affecting performance between males & females, which some say makes arguments about unfairness irrelevant. Here’s a thread (1/

First, the start point is saying that physiological attributes that drive performance overlap between M & F. This is definitely true - many women are stronger, faster, more powerful, muscular, leaner etc, than many men. Nobody would dispute this - just join a race to find out (2/

Next, this observation - a spectrum for the secondary sex characteristics - is used to argue against a sex binary, which is disingenuous. They’re different things. But it evolves into saying that because there is overlap and because sport is all about “natural advantages”, the...

…issue of fairness is moot - just as Fast twitch fibres or bigger lungs give people advantages, why should we care if those who get testosterone’s effects on physiology win women’s sports events? Theirs is a “natural advantage”. That’s the part that needs discussion. (4/)

Take the 100m Olympic title. We crown two champions - Bolt and Frasey-Pryce. Why do we do this? Because Bolt, and hundreds like him, are 10% faster than FP. That’s the effect of androgens on physiology. If we didn’t crown a women’s champ, only men would win anything in sport

The thing about them is that Bolt and FP are already exceptional within their respective groups as different, which is the very thing that sport is trying to do - it wants to find exceptional athleticism. In some sports that means FT fibres, biochemistry, neurophysiology etc

In other sports it’s about endurance (heart, lungs, mitochondria), in others it’s power/strength/biochemistry etc. Thing is, sport tries to find exceptionalism, that’s why it’s great. But the key here is that Bolt & FP are basically IDENTICAL in all these physiological respects

The system that allows Bolt to reach the Olympic podium is the same as the one that ‘finds’ FP atop hers. The point is that they have emerged from their respective populations with the best possible combinations to make them both champions. Equal. But different. By 10 - 15%. Why?

That difference is where biological reality of being male comes in. The effect of androgens, from early development through puberty and into adulthood creates such profound differences that 2 people who possess the same “important” physiology in a given sport are 10-15% different

In fact, the T effect is so powerful that a huge number of biological males who have ‘inferior physiology’ compared to Usain Bolt are still vastly superior to Fraser-Pryce, with her “optimal” physiology. They are 1% - 11% worse than Bolt but still faster than her. This is the key

There is no other physiological attribute that does this. The effect is so powerful that thousands of men who lack ‘perfect combinations’ of attributes are faster than the best woman. That doesn’t happen for big feet, long arms, high LT or whatever ‘advantaged’ group you compare

The beauty of sport is that it rewards exceptionalism, but ONLY IN ELEMENTS THAT ACTUALLY MATTER TO THE SPORT. That’s why we have age & weight categories. They protect integrity and safety of the ‘disadvantaged’ groups (young or light) to allow us to celebrate boxing (eg) prowess

If we allowed biological sex to become one of the elements sport rewards, it would mean rewarding ONLY people with functioning androgen physiology. The champions in EVERY SINGLE event would be male. In fact, the top 3000 (at least) would be. That’s not how it’s meant to be.

So we have this category for females, because the BIOLOGICAL implications of NOT having T contribute to development are so enormous that we realise that without this separate category, sport would not have meaning for that whole group. It doesn’t matter than FP is faster than me

It doesn’t matter that Serena Williams would hammer 90% of men at tennis or that Katie Ledecky swims better than almost everyone I know. What matters is that within a matched group (elite, club, state, high school), the best females have NO chance against identical/matched males

And so if you need to reach down and find inferior males to compare to the very best females within each band, then you’re deliberately distorting the meaning and value of sport in order to make the argument. It’s irrelevant though, because FP isn’t competing against me!

All this said, a biological argument that writes T out of performance determinism in sport needs to end. It has no value for the debate, it’s frankly stupid and/or dishonest. A human rights arguments I get, but we can’t deny biological reality for the sake of a desired position

Naunet · 06/04/2023 09:57

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 09:35

In most sports where there is clear physiological advantage from some criterion, that sport is competed for by category.

Combat sports are divided into weight classes. There are 17 divisions in boxing. You'd never match a flyweight with a heavyweight.
Many sports are divided into age classes. You'd never put a 9-yr old gymnast up against a 16-yr old.
For a long time, many sports were split into 2 categories. Men and Non-Men (aka Women). Then, in 1960 the inaugural Paralympic games added new categories for many Olympic sports and there are now 10 categories of disability with hundreds of sub-categories depending on the sport and the nature of the impairment. All of these new categories were in addition to the existing one - Non-men (the original special category created to allow more fair participation by half the human population who were disadvantaged by their biology from competing in an 'Open' category).

None of these divisions are perfectly fair. Even within existing divisions there are latent advantages for particular characteristics. Most rowers tend to have a similar body shape. As do most jockeys. People without that body shape are unlikely to progress to elite levels, regardless of how hard they train.

Sometimes a sport's rules and scoring methodologies change and this results in a visible change in body shape of the competitors who podium (e.g. gymnasts - Simone Biles has a very different body shape than Nadia Comaneci, and it's only partly explained by training. Banning the skills that relied on hyper-extension and scoring more highly skills that emphasise power and strength also helped drive this change). Sometimes societal changes do the same. Access and participation by sectors of society that were historically excluded from sports have seen phenomenal changes in the physical appearance of elite athletes. Compare and contrast Margaret Court with Serena Williams.

Bleating that 'it's not fair because athletes born male are heavier' misses the point. Half the athletes born female are also heavier than the other half. What is needed to address this issue is for each sport's governing association to consider what the fairest way to divide the human population is, to ensure their sport remains accessible, and competitive, and safe, for the greatest number of participants. That is pretty much what they are all trying to do.
This will involve many factors - economic, social, legal, as well as sex. It's really not just about sex. And yes, along the way, there'll be some instances where the outcomes will be ones that society doesn't like - and things will evolve.

What a load of shit excuses for handing womens hard fought for sports over to men. Get a grip, at least be honest about what you’re arguing for.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 09:57

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:55

Triathlon already does and I'd imagine that's exactly what will happen over time.

Sounds absolutely fine.

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:55

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/04/2023 09:50

Don’t know why they can’t extend categories, have separate ones for trans people 🤷‍♀️

Triathlon already does and I'd imagine that's exactly what will happen over time.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:55

Another question for those who believe that males should compete in female sports categories.

What other male group would you include who has a lowered athletic performance through medical treatment or even just their choice to change their body shape?

A male deliberately reduces their athletic performance and maybe their own health by reducing or removing testosterone from their body and expects to be able to compete with women who are in peak fitness and consider this fair?

Or a male deliberately shapes their body, as J Harper has stated happens, by losing muscle mass and focusing on enhancing what they consider the 'feminine' body shape, and yet expect that to be a reason to compete with female athletes? Female athletes who cannot win a competition just by trying to get a more 'male' body shape as that would be doping, and there is no way of being competitive without doping. Female bodies simply do not have the advantages that male bodies do!

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/04/2023 09:50

Don’t know why they can’t extend categories, have separate ones for trans people 🤷‍♀️

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:49

By the way, those who believe that males should be included in female sports for any reason, how do you overcome the disadvantages that females have because of their menstrual cycle?

Something a male athlete has never had to deal with in their lives.

Changeau · 06/04/2023 09:48

KittiesInsane · 06/04/2023 09:42

Ah, thanks. I’m out of touch (mine were never much into football).

It was always seen as a good thing to be in a mixed team as playing with and against boys improved girls football. This isn't so much the case now as there are more talented girls teams.

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:47

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 09:35

In most sports where there is clear physiological advantage from some criterion, that sport is competed for by category.

Combat sports are divided into weight classes. There are 17 divisions in boxing. You'd never match a flyweight with a heavyweight.
Many sports are divided into age classes. You'd never put a 9-yr old gymnast up against a 16-yr old.
For a long time, many sports were split into 2 categories. Men and Non-Men (aka Women). Then, in 1960 the inaugural Paralympic games added new categories for many Olympic sports and there are now 10 categories of disability with hundreds of sub-categories depending on the sport and the nature of the impairment. All of these new categories were in addition to the existing one - Non-men (the original special category created to allow more fair participation by half the human population who were disadvantaged by their biology from competing in an 'Open' category).

None of these divisions are perfectly fair. Even within existing divisions there are latent advantages for particular characteristics. Most rowers tend to have a similar body shape. As do most jockeys. People without that body shape are unlikely to progress to elite levels, regardless of how hard they train.

Sometimes a sport's rules and scoring methodologies change and this results in a visible change in body shape of the competitors who podium (e.g. gymnasts - Simone Biles has a very different body shape than Nadia Comaneci, and it's only partly explained by training. Banning the skills that relied on hyper-extension and scoring more highly skills that emphasise power and strength also helped drive this change). Sometimes societal changes do the same. Access and participation by sectors of society that were historically excluded from sports have seen phenomenal changes in the physical appearance of elite athletes. Compare and contrast Margaret Court with Serena Williams.

Bleating that 'it's not fair because athletes born male are heavier' misses the point. Half the athletes born female are also heavier than the other half. What is needed to address this issue is for each sport's governing association to consider what the fairest way to divide the human population is, to ensure their sport remains accessible, and competitive, and safe, for the greatest number of participants. That is pretty much what they are all trying to do.
This will involve many factors - economic, social, legal, as well as sex. It's really not just about sex. And yes, along the way, there'll be some instances where the outcomes will be ones that society doesn't like - and things will evolve.

"Half the athletes born female are also heavier than the other half. "

There are many advantages that a male of a similar weight will have over a female of a similar weight. For instance a male's grip strength, which is pertinent in many sports. A male in the lowest 25% for grip strength will still have a stronger grip than 90% of female people.

Then there are skeletal advantages. Higher bone density, different leverage points. Including Q angles in hips that create a difference. Then there are the different muscles. The list goes on.

Let's not forget that female brains have more delicate brain fibres and that makes them more prone to damage. Imagine the damage that is done by impact with a male body part that has come at that head with all the advantages that male bodies have. Speed due to length of leg, due to different muscle types that allow that speed. Height differences so that when that male body hits that female head, it hits and the female athlete's head has nowhere to go to mitigate that impact. Average punch strength is a huge difference between male and female bodies and is not reduced to matching average female punch strength.

Unfortunately, there are many people out there who think that weight matching between male and female bodies is a step towards 'fairness'. It is not.