Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Transgender 'athletes'

440 replies

HappyHippo1234 · 06/04/2023 00:38

To start off - I have no issue with trans people at all. The only issue I have is transgender females (male to female) competing in women sports.

Yes, they may have been taking hormones and they have lost some muscle and gained some fat. But, they have stronger bones and bigger spines, hands, feet, lungs and hearts. Basically trans females have an advantage over biological females.

What I absolutely HATE about the situation, it the trans athletes attitude, it honestly disgusts me. Did they never take biology as teenagers or learn about puberty?
For them to sit there with their wins and say that they have no advantage just p*sses me off. Are they stupid or ignorant? There's no way they don't know they have an advantage. Do they not realise they are taking wins away from girls and woman who have spent their whole lives training for a sport only for it to be taken away from someone who was a mediocre male.

Look at Lia Thomas, she was somewhere in the 400-500th best college male swimmer or something like that. She is now trans and BAM she is number 1 and winning everything.

It just annoys me to no end. Especially the trans woman who you can tell that they KNOW they have a major advantage and are cheating the system and then sit there with a SMUG GRIN on their faces. I mean every Caitlyn Jenner said it's wrong.

Sorry for the rant. My DD15 has been upset all week as on the weekend another girl beat all the girls by a huge stretch in her cross country meet (her team is usually 1st but were bumped to 2nd). At first everyone thought this girl was great, until one mom heard the group the girl was with discussing the results and how it was great for the team that this girl came out as trans and was boosting their results etc! Fair to say that news travelled quickly and there were MANY parents complaining to officials. But surprise surprise nothing was done about it. So at the award giving ceremony everyone waited as everything up to 1st place was given out and as soon as they got to the 1st team, I would say 95% of people walked away. It felt harsh but necessary!
(Also the girl was 16 and had only recently transitioned from what we could gather and when you actually looked at her you could tell she had gone through at least some portion of male puberty). Again nothing against the girl just don't think she could compete.

And to get around all these discrimination lawsuits, I think they should change the categories! Have an XX category and an XY category, that why there is no debate and no 'discrimination' as you can't identify as XY if you are XX! (And then also have an open category where trans, non-binary etc. can compete).

SORRY THAT WAS SO LONG. NOW FOR THE VOTE:

YABU - Trans (XX) women are woman and should be allowed to compete with XY women, even though they scientifically have an advantage.

YANBU - They will always have an advantage and so should not compete with XY women.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
knittingaddict · 06/04/2023 10:48

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:12

Society today prioritises inclusion. When it's SEND kids and kids with ADHD in mainstream classrooms, the MN massive takes a very different view on what 'fairness' is.

If societal rule number one is that every individual should be able to compete in their chosen sport somewhere (the inclusion principle).
And societal and environmental factors mean that there are currently only two divisions within which an adult can compete - men's or women's.
Then the judgment should really be, in which division is it most fair for that individual to compete in?
I don't see why it should be so outrageous for the medical and sporting experts who make these assessments to decide that sometimes that means people born in one sex should compete alongside people born in the other.
In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).
That'd see men and women competing together in many divisions, but also it would be more nuanced, and more fair - right?

If you want perfect fairness, then sure, let's have 7 billion categories and we can all have a gold medal. That's the illogical end point of intersectionality. But every single point before that absurd outcome requires some choice or judgment of how you define fairness - and that definition will result in some people not getting 'their' gold.

If you take a hard line, ultra competitive, winner-takes-all approach, then there should just be one category - an open one. But the people justifying women's sports as a separate division are loathe to acknowledge that it is having a very limited and specific definition of 'fairness' that creates this issue in the first place.

And the hypocrisy is rank. The same people will also argue that women should be paid the same for winning a best of three sets tennis match (watched by about a million people) than a man winning a best of five sets tennis match (watched by 3 million people). I guess fairness means something different when you're looking to smash the glass ceiling than it does when you are punching down to someone who is mentally ill and struggling to find their place in the world.

You do not understand biology or if you do you are conveniently ignoring it.

Bláthannabuí · 06/04/2023 10:48

https://4w.pub/fetish-footballer-policy/

YANBU this man in Ireland who in the article says he is completely "comfortable with his genitals" but under the Gender Recognition Act identifies as a woman. "Giulia Genitals" now has full permission & plays with a ladies football team.
UK look & learn from Ireland. Don't let this happen on your watch.

Trans Fetish Enthusiast Reportedly Advising Irish Policy on Men in Women’s Sport

An interview in the Guardian claims 'Giulia' Valentino has been consulted as part of a policy review into inclusion of males in Irish women's football

https://4w.pub/fetish-footballer-policy

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:48

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 10:45

Goodchat

With respect I disagree. There is plenty of it occurring on this thread. Posters are concerned and angry at what is happening in womens sport and we're accused of paranoia, told it's really not that big an issue.

It's my post that was quoted and claimed I was gaslighting which clearly wasn't the case. That's what I took offence to.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 10:45

Goodchat

With respect I disagree. There is plenty of it occurring on this thread. Posters are concerned and angry at what is happening in womens sport and we're accused of paranoia, told it's really not that big an issue.

MarshaBradyo · 06/04/2023 10:45

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:42

@MarshaBradyo read the first post you quoted. Jesus Christ.

What are you angry at?

All I can see is you raging at someone telling them to shut up.

Are you a TRA or pro segregating men and women in sport?

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 10:44

Not a men's rights activist
Understand rationale behind female sports
Don't think mixed sports is best way to meet societal objectives in all cases
Don't think mixed sports is necessarily an aberration in other cases
Think it should be left to sporting associations to decide
Understand that discrimination is an ongoing issue
Understand difference between equality and equity. Don't accept that equity is not political. Don't think anyone has monopoly on defining 'fairness'.
Believe that sex matters, and has always mattered
Believe that this holds true in many settings - sports, but also the workplace.
Charge of hypocrisy still stands - Second wave had it (broadly) right. Third wave went off track. The backlash and ensuing GC movement is dominated by rabid, ill-informed and hate-filled rhetoric. Trans issues are mental health issues. Treating them as women's rights issues is, in my view, a strategic mistake.

RosaBonheur · 06/04/2023 10:42

YANBU.

If it weren't already obvious, we know trans women/girls aren't actually women/girls, because if they were, nobody would care about their feelings or identities, and society wouldn't be bending over backwards to accommodate them.

Sport is such a clear example of this.

Transgender MtF athletes are allowed to compete in female categories after suppressing their testosterone for a year or two, even though they still have a far higher testosterone level than any female athlete, and even though this doesn't remove the physical advantages of having gone through male privilege.

Meanwhile, transgender FtM athletes who are on testosterone cannot compete in either male or female categories, despite the fact that the testosterone still doesn't give them an advantage over male athletes, because synthetic testosterone is a banned substance.

So transgender MtF athletes get to have their cake and eat it (hormones AND validation AND competing in women's sports despite having a clear unfair advantage) whereas transgender FtM athletes have to choose between hormones and sport even though there would be no unfair advantage to them competing in men's categories.

Regardless of how anyone identifies or what terminology they use to describe themselves, it's always the ones who were born with a penis who get all the privilege. And that should tell you all you need to know about this so-called rights movement.

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:42

@MarshaBradyo read the first post you quoted. Jesus Christ.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 10:41

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 09:29

For anyone who thinks males should compete in female sports categories, do you understand why there is a female sport’s category? It is only to allow female sports people to have fair competition.

Think about what other category boundaries you would be happy to accept

A 25 year old competing against a 10 year old?

A 25 year old competing against a 85 year old?

A person who had 90% vision competing with someone with 5% vision ?

A person who was a professional standard athlete competing in a novice only event ?

A bicycle with an electric engine competing against a 100% human powered bicycle in the Tour de France?

If you have said yes to any of these, why? if you have said no, then why would you accept a male with pubertal advantages in a female sports category?

Helle you are an absolute force of nature in these discussions and incredibly articulate with it.

I don't think even you can get some posters to engage and see the injustice of this.

MarshaBradyo · 06/04/2023 10:41

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:39

@MarshaBradyo because they're making unfounded accusations, that's why Confused

What’s unfounded?

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:40

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 10:39

Both the Gender Recognition Act and The Equality Act recognise sports as a sex affected activity, and protect single sex sports.
This isn't a conversation we should need to have.

That's why Kemi's trying to change the wording to include 'biological', so people can stop pretending they're a woman.

Thelnebriati · 06/04/2023 10:39

Both the Gender Recognition Act and The Equality Act recognise sports as a sex affected activity, and protect single sex sports.
This isn't a conversation we should need to have.

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:39

@MarshaBradyo because they're making unfounded accusations, that's why Confused

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 10:39

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 09:22

@ReneBumsWombats sorry but you are paranoid. No one can ask any kind of question and they are treated with suspicion and anger. This is precisely why people are fearful of asking anything because there is always aggression. It's like you're having an imaginary argument in your heads constantly and think people are trying to catch you out. Siege mentality. No one on this thread has called anyone far right or suggested anyone is anti trans..

I think there have been several posts claiming MN is anti trans, hate etc

SquidwardBound · 06/04/2023 10:38

If societal rule number one is that every individual should be able to compete in their chosen sport somewhere (the inclusion principle).

And male people CAN compete in male competitions.

It’s just that they WANT to be allowed to compete against women - even knowing they have an unfair advantage.

It’s not hard to understand. They’re not being excluded. They can still compete. They just don’t get to dictate the terms under which they compete.

As for pretending this is about inclusion. 🙄 what about all the women and girls pushed out because men and boys would rather win in the female category?

ReneBumsWombats · 06/04/2023 10:38

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:28

Can you tell me a male tennis player that had to make the decision about whether to carry their pregnancy or not?

"In fact, there's a strong case to say that some sports should have classes by testosterone levels, measured before each event (like weigh-ins at boxing).
That'd see men and women competing together in many divisions, but also it would be more nuanced, and more fair - right?
"

Your rhetoric here is intent on allowing harm to female athletes based on your own lack of information.

The punch power difference is one of those advantages that is very clear to remain very high after testosterone suppression. It is about leverage. It is about muscle type. It is about bone density. It is also about female brains and how they are prone to damage because of fragile brain fibres.

You are ludicrously repeated unsubstantiated trope from somewhere else on the internet. And you are spreading misinformation that is harmful to all females.

He is fully in favour of sea lions competing in sports...

MarshaBradyo · 06/04/2023 10:37

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:35

Shut up, there's no gaslighting. Stop misusing the term.

Shut up?

Women stop speaking. Why?

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:36

This is from the Hilton & Lundberg study.

"Recently, sexual dimorphism in arm force and power was investigated in a punch motion in moderately-trained individuals 50]. The power produced during a punch was 162% greater in males than in females, and the least powerful man produced more power than the most powerful woman. This highlights that sex differences in parameters such as mass, strength and speed may combine to produce even larger sex differences in sport-specific actions, which often are a product of how various physical capacities combine. For example, power production is the product of force and velocity, and momentum is defined as mass multiplied by velocity."

This might be interesting to some who are discussing mixed sex sports too.

" Indeed, already at 17 years of age, the average male throws a ball further than 99% of 17-year-old females 51], despite no single variable (arm length, muscle mass etc.) reaching this numerical advantage."

As it has been said by some excellently researched women sport's advocates, 'you cannot unboil an egg'. Once puberty has started, there is no way to wind back on the advantages it gives to male bodies over female bodies.

If mixed sex sports are wanted, then rules need to be adapted to protect the female bodies players. It is dangerous in many contact or even low contact sports to have males playing with female players without protecting the female players.

Transgender Women in the Female Category of Sport: Perspectives on Testosterone Suppression and Performance Advantage - Sports Medicine

Males enjoy physical performance advantages over females within competitive sport. The sex-based segregation into male and female sporting categories does not account for transgender persons who experience incongruence between their biological sex and...

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3#ref-CR50

Animalsoffartingwood · 06/04/2023 10:35

She also uses accessible toilets as she says she understand why woman would feel uncomfortable with someone of male sex in woman's only spaces.

Well I am afraid I don't applaud this. It's just asking a different group to be pushed aside (disabled) instead of women.

Men who dress as women have two options.

  1. Remain in their own sex category and expand the bandwidth of what it means to be male. Ditto changing rooms, toilets and prisons.

  2. If they can't accept that they belong in male spaces or feel 'scared' they can campaign for third spaces and in the meantime self exclude and get the true experience of what it's like to be a woman, urinary leash, missing out on sports, government not listening to them or providing for them. How affirming.

Everything else is unfair to woman and girls at best and a gift to sexual predators and men who want to humiliate women at worst.

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:35

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 10:34

Is a biological boy in sport one of those things that should never even happen in the first place? Of course it is. But Op didn't even know it was a boy until their parent bragged.

//

So sneaky as well as cheaty Confused

Gaslighting women and girls is ok because sometimes life isn't fair.

Can someone tell me why girls should suck this up but the "unfairness " of telling a trans person they must compete in their birth sex category is an unacceptable injustice?

Shut up, there's no gaslighting. Stop misusing the term.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 10:34

Is a biological boy in sport one of those things that should never even happen in the first place? Of course it is. But Op didn't even know it was a boy until their parent bragged.

//

So sneaky as well as cheaty Confused

Gaslighting women and girls is ok because sometimes life isn't fair.

Can someone tell me why girls should suck this up but the "unfairness " of telling a trans person they must compete in their birth sex category is an unacceptable injustice?

SoupDragon · 06/04/2023 10:34

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 10:03

Yeah you're probably right to be fair @SoupDragon, because she did say once they knew it was fairly obvious.

It's funny that's it's rarely women transitioning to men who compete in high level sports...

It's blindingly obvious why it's "rarely" trans men competing in high level sport... I've tried in the past to think of an example of a sport where a woman has a physical advantage over a man and I can't. Are there any trans men competing in high level sport?

(maybe a woman might have an advantage in diving due to a smaller frame...?)

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:30

Helleofabore · 06/04/2023 10:07

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33289906/

This above is the review of 13 studies from Dr Emma Hilton and Tommy Lundberg.

bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2021/02/28/bjsports-2020-103106

And Harper's study that reached similar conclusions to Hilton and Lundberg.

Here you go @Mark19735.

Read these. I have even included Harper's for you. Harper is, of course, trans themselves. And even Harper disagrees that males should be boxing against females....

MarshaBradyo · 06/04/2023 10:30

Also to same poster are you male?

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/04/2023 10:29

Lamplit · 06/04/2023 08:39

So once trans women have accepted that they cannot compete fairly in races with biological women, that they cannot enter protected spaces solely for the use of biological women like bathrooms, changing spaces and domestic abuse refuges etc (all perfectly reasonable) are we happy or at least accepting enough to call them by their chosen female name, respect their choice to present superficially as a woman (whatever that means) ? Not all trans folk are rapists, violent, fetishists are they ? Surely if you know and like the trans person or they are a random person you meet for a second there's nothing wrong with going along with their wishes and addressing them as she...or are people wholly opposed to the idea of trans people and have no intention of going along with it all ?

But they will never accept those boundaries.

I think being happy to cheat and trample on female boundaries is a much worse character trait than refusal to use pronouns.