Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was IBU? Train give up seat for a child situation

369 replies

FriendsObsessed · 05/04/2023 19:09

So I was on the way home today. Busy train, full of commuters.
i managed to get a seat, one of those 3 that are on the side of the carriage and can be flipped up if needed.

An older couple got on with their (I assume) grandchildren.
The women next to me offered her seat to one of the kids. The grandfather came back saying at yes if they could sit together that would be lovely (keeping eye contact with the woman). She was like ‘I can only offer you my seat’. I didn’t move… he sat down with the child on his lap.

someone else got up and offered the seat to the other child. Same thing happened the grandmother sat down with the other child on her knees (kind of)

i tried to just chill (as I always do on the train) but I kept feeling very uncomfortable and sensed a bit of a death stare. The kids were pretty annoying, and weren’t told to just sit and keep kicking other people’s bags, seats and stop complaining. When I got off the train I could hear the grandfather saying, now you sit here finally.

I’m just so annoyed at folks travelling on train with kids expecting that others should move/give up seats for them. AIBU?

ps the children were approx 4 and 6 yo

OP posts:
Okunevo · 08/04/2023 19:31

AlltheFs · 08/04/2023 19:15

They are expected to give up their seat to sit on the lap of the adult they are with. There is no expectation that small children stand themselves.

Two on a lap would be tricky. Particularly if one is a baby. How do you safely hold a three or four year old on your lap when you already have your baby in a carrier?

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 19:20

Well mum dad and grandma there you go. 8 seats taken, 5 occupied by children. For a nice long journey at peak time. Just out of spite.

Jesus.Confused

Tellmethespoiler · 08/04/2023 19:18

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 19:15

I hope a family with quintuplets, all under 5 use the National Railway, and buy their kids a heavily discounted ticket. Just to see some posters' heads blow at the "audacity".

You can’t do that. It’s only two under-five children that can travel for free (per paying adult).

JaneFondue · 08/04/2023 19:16

I find it odd not to. Was on the Tube today..Packed to the brim with people carrying shopping, food and backpacks, while little kids were getting whacked around the head by all the flying bags. I gave up my seat to one tiny kid..Don't think I was creating an entitled brat by doing that.

AlltheFs · 08/04/2023 19:15

Tellmethespoiler · 08/04/2023 19:10

No, that’s not true. Non-fare-paying children must give up a seat in favour of an adult. The adult doesn’t need to ask. It doesn’t need to be an assigned seat. It’s basic good manners that the conductor shouldn’t need to enforce.

They are expected to give up their seat to sit on the lap of the adult they are with. There is no expectation that small children stand themselves.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 19:15

I hope a family with quintuplets, all under 5 use the National Railway, and buy their kids a heavily discounted ticket. Just to see some posters' heads blow at the "audacity".

Tellmethespoiler · 08/04/2023 19:14

When people buy train tickets, it’s very clear that children under five travel for free and they are not entitled to a seat. Don’t travel by train if you’re going to be a CF

juice92 · 08/04/2023 19:12

I would not give up a seat for a child. Presuming no disability, they are no more in need of a seat than me.
To be honest when I was a child I would have been expected to give up my seat for an adult. I wouldn't expect it now, but I do find the expectation of giving up a seat for a child a bit odd.

Tellmethespoiler · 08/04/2023 19:10

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 19:04

Also they only have to move if it's required, for example if someone has an assigned seat(that 's the most common situation) or a standing adult actually asks/needs it. It's not a case of all seats full, an adult gets on ,child jumps!

Plus , in my experience most people would balk at being offered a seat by an under 5/their parent.

No, that’s not true. Non-fare-paying children must give up a seat in favour of an adult. The adult doesn’t need to ask. It doesn’t need to be an assigned seat. It’s basic good manners that the conductor shouldn’t need to enforce.

Tellmethespoiler · 08/04/2023 19:07

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 19:01

@Tellmethespoiler by your own quote, that's only children under 5, so not all children.

Yes, of course. Children under five. But people on this thread are insisting that these are the very children who do need a seat. Obviously, that’s rubbish.

GlassBunion · 08/04/2023 19:06

Nope. I never give kids my seat.

If they're little they can sit on a lap .

If they're bigger, they can stand .

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 19:04

Also they only have to move if it's required, for example if someone has an assigned seat(that 's the most common situation) or a standing adult actually asks/needs it. It's not a case of all seats full, an adult gets on ,child jumps!

Plus , in my experience most people would balk at being offered a seat by an under 5/their parent.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 19:01

@Tellmethespoiler by your own quote, that's only children under 5, so not all children.

Tellmethespoiler · 08/04/2023 18:58

Kanaloa · 08/04/2023 16:48

Well give it a go. Let me know if you find a conductor who will make a three year old stand up on a moving train so that a healthy and able bodied adult can sit down.

No, the conductor would say the child has to sit on parent’s knee. The conductor will know the conditions of carriage better than anyone, and that means that a (non-fare-paying) child can’t occupy a seat if an adult is standing.

DelphiniumBlue · 08/04/2023 17:18

I reckon a 4 year old would be fine either on the lap of grandparent or standing between their legs. Or the children could have shared a seat. Or if the GP were that bothered, they could have stood and the GC could have sat. Certainly the children's balance would have been good enough to stand on a train if they were able to hold on to something, same as most adults.
It was unpleasant for the OP to have to put up with hostility from the GP.
I'll mention here, I have taken literally hundreds of children on trips in the tube , am currently grandparent age, and have an adult DS with a hidden disability who struggles with expectations of sitting/ standing on public transport. My advice would be to do what you can to be kind and help other people, and if you aren't able to, then don't give it another thought. If some one is giving you hostile glares, do the same back. Their opinion is not your problem.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 17:18

I still don't get what this wrong message that kids get is. That people can be nice?

BlueHeelers · 08/04/2023 17:09

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 05/04/2023 19:11

Adults should never give up their seat for a child, unless it is a parent carrying a baby or toddler. It sends the wrong message to kids and they are perfectly capable of standing, much more than many adults who have had a long hard day at work.

Basically, this.

But then when I was a child, if you had a discounted child or student’s ticket, you were required to give up your seat to a full fare paying adult passenger.

And 4 & 6 are OK to perch on adults’ knees.

Kanaloa · 08/04/2023 16:48

SinnerBoy · 08/04/2023 16:30

Kanaloa Today 15:44

If you were determined, you probably could get the conductor to support you.

Well give it a go. Let me know if you find a conductor who will make a three year old stand up on a moving train so that a healthy and able bodied adult can sit down.

SinnerBoy · 08/04/2023 16:30

Kanaloa Today 15:44

If you were determined, you probably could get the conductor to support you.

Tellmethespoiler · 08/04/2023 16:27

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 12:30

Not the case for TFL. Also, it only states children under 5 presumably because they can be in a pram or safely in an adult's lap.

Yes, but the OP is on a train, not TFL.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 15:59

@Okunevo I have no idea. I was replying to PP saying children must stand up for adults. Turns out that's only for national railway and only kids under 5.

Tbh it takes a special type of person to demand a seat off a child, regardless of their age.

Jonei · 08/04/2023 15:56

Kanaloa · 08/04/2023 15:44

If it’s a condition of carriage then you’re of course welcome to go and find an employee and try to make them force a 3 year old to stand so you can sit. I think you’d struggle though.

I can just imagine the sort of person who would actually go up to the parent of a 3 year old, and telling them to move their child so they could sit down.

Kanaloa · 08/04/2023 15:44

SinnerBoy · 08/04/2023 14:37

LadyCreampuff · Today 09:38

You are not more entitled to my child's seat because you are an adult.

What if it's a condition of carriage? I mean, anyone can sit in the disabled seats on the Metro, but must give it up for someone who is entitled to it.

(I'm not suggesting that you'd do that and refuse to move!)

If it’s a condition of carriage then you’re of course welcome to go and find an employee and try to make them force a 3 year old to stand so you can sit. I think you’d struggle though.

SinnerBoy · 08/04/2023 14:37

LadyCreampuff · Today 09:38

You are not more entitled to my child's seat because you are an adult.

What if it's a condition of carriage? I mean, anyone can sit in the disabled seats on the Metro, but must give it up for someone who is entitled to it.

(I'm not suggesting that you'd do that and refuse to move!)

Okunevo · 08/04/2023 14:17

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 12:30

Not the case for TFL. Also, it only states children under 5 presumably because they can be in a pram or safely in an adult's lap.

What do you do if you have two under 5? Make a 3 or 4 year old stand while able bodied adults sit as you already have a baby/toddler on your lap?