Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was IBU? Train give up seat for a child situation

369 replies

FriendsObsessed · 05/04/2023 19:09

So I was on the way home today. Busy train, full of commuters.
i managed to get a seat, one of those 3 that are on the side of the carriage and can be flipped up if needed.

An older couple got on with their (I assume) grandchildren.
The women next to me offered her seat to one of the kids. The grandfather came back saying at yes if they could sit together that would be lovely (keeping eye contact with the woman). She was like ‘I can only offer you my seat’. I didn’t move… he sat down with the child on his lap.

someone else got up and offered the seat to the other child. Same thing happened the grandmother sat down with the other child on her knees (kind of)

i tried to just chill (as I always do on the train) but I kept feeling very uncomfortable and sensed a bit of a death stare. The kids were pretty annoying, and weren’t told to just sit and keep kicking other people’s bags, seats and stop complaining. When I got off the train I could hear the grandfather saying, now you sit here finally.

I’m just so annoyed at folks travelling on train with kids expecting that others should move/give up seats for them. AIBU?

ps the children were approx 4 and 6 yo

OP posts:
CantBeArsedOrAsked · 06/04/2023 09:30

FriendsObsessed · 05/04/2023 19:17

@Littlebluebird123 of course, if it was just a swap around so they can sit together I would certainly move. But this was very much of a case of me giving up on my seat for a child.

But they didn't ask you to give up your seat.
It's not their fault that you felt uncomfortable. As for them staring at you, you must have been looking at them to notice. Perhaps they were wondering why you were glaring at them!

MRex · 06/04/2023 09:22

Everybody wanted a seat, but a grand total of nobody asked for nor took my seat. What a non event.

DS will sit on my lap when it's crowded or on a seat otherwise, it isn't safe standing because adults trample little ones even when they can safely hold on. Those with all the opinions about children and seats, you wouldn't notice hypermobility causing a child pain and needing to rest, so it's useful to spare half a thought that others might have reasons for things they do even if you don't know those reasons.

SecretVictoria · 06/04/2023 09:03

ancientgran · 06/04/2023 08:49

School run, medical appointments, getting to work via childcare. I expect their are loads of reasons.

I think kids can have a long hard day, nurseries open at 7.30 round here and close at 6, some kids are there for over 10 hrs and then have travel to nursery and home again at the end of the day. It's a longer day than many working people do. I think wrap around care is similar for school aged children.

When you bounced out of school was it 3.30?

Would have been around that time, yes.

ancientgran · 06/04/2023 08:49

SecretVictoria · 05/04/2023 21:21

The four year old will have been travelling for free. I don’t understand (and I experienced it many times as a commuter) why people travelling with kids choose the rush hour. Tickets are generally cheaper before and after.

Preschool and school is really not ‘a long, hard day’. Don’t know where this comes from on MN; when I used to pick my DN up and indeed when I went to school
myself, we’d bounce out. No notion of ‘tired after a day at school’.

School run, medical appointments, getting to work via childcare. I expect their are loads of reasons.

I think kids can have a long hard day, nurseries open at 7.30 round here and close at 6, some kids are there for over 10 hrs and then have travel to nursery and home again at the end of the day. It's a longer day than many working people do. I think wrap around care is similar for school aged children.

When you bounced out of school was it 3.30?

Saschka · 06/04/2023 00:40

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 05/04/2023 19:11

Adults should never give up their seat for a child, unless it is a parent carrying a baby or toddler. It sends the wrong message to kids and they are perfectly capable of standing, much more than many adults who have had a long hard day at work.

TBF the four year old might have trouble standing on a packed train, as there is nothing at child-height for them to hang onto, and people may be bashing into them as the train rocks.

I do often put DS in a seat while I stand, because I am more able to stand than him. I’d let DM or another older person sit first though.

But if the child is already sitting on somebody’s lap, no problem at all! Everyone is seated, no four year old needs their own personal seat.

Kaibashira · 06/04/2023 00:22

Katrinawaves · 05/04/2023 20:45

Google tells me the average age of a first time grandparent is 50. Its unlikely though of course not impossible that both the grandparents and the parents had their children at 40+ as some have suggested.

That's the US.
In the UK, the latest data the ONS has (which is 5 years old) gives 63 as the average.

northeasrer · 05/04/2023 23:30

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 05/04/2023 19:11

Adults should never give up their seat for a child, unless it is a parent carrying a baby or toddler. It sends the wrong message to kids and they are perfectly capable of standing, much more than many adults who have had a long hard day at work.

For safety reasons I would rather kids were on knees etc than on a crowded train

WandaWonder · 05/04/2023 22:13

I have given up seats for kids but this was my choice, I would not be made to give up one

But op this is not your problem

Yellowdays · 05/04/2023 22:09

FourTeaFallOut · 05/04/2023 19:12

Nobody asked you to move. How have you turned this into a problem for you?

This. If we feel uncomfortable, that is our own problem. Nobody "majesty" us feel anything. We do.

Albiboba · 05/04/2023 22:05

Katrinawaves · 05/04/2023 21:11

Even 69 is only 3 years post official retirement age so not exactly decrepit!

No one said they were? Is that your bar for who needs a seat?

It’s much more likely the other people on the train offered their seats to the near 70 yo grandparents wrangling two young children.

They sat down, kids on knee, not a word to the OP. Total non issue.

Cosyblankets · 05/04/2023 22:05

Kpo58 · 05/04/2023 19:17

I'd assume it's because young children are less likely to be stable on their legs and tire quicker than fully grown adults.

They can sit on adult's lap.
Perfectly safe

Albiboba · 05/04/2023 22:02

@SecretVictoria I don’t understand (and I experienced it many times as a commuter) why people travelling with kids choose the rush hour. Tickets are generally cheaper before and after.

You’re right, I’m sure people with young children just travel around on public transport at rush hour for the fun of it. Probably just doing a loop and then back home.

Kanaloa · 05/04/2023 22:02

SecretVictoria · 05/04/2023 21:59

Of course. I have moved so a parent and child can sit together and generally would. If there were other seats available but not together, I’d have expected the GPS to take a kid each and sit separately. Very often guards/train managers can find seats so that people can sit together.

I still sometimes wish DN had got the memo about being tired after school! I’ve quite often nodded off after collecting her to have tea at ours.

Which is exactly what the grandparents did! They each sat with one grandchild. Neither of them asked the OP to give her seat up for any of their family. OP wanted a seat. She had a seat. She remained (unchallenged) in that seat. She then felt uncomfortable because she felt that someone else may have wanted that seat. Literally nobody asked her to move for a child or anybody else.

SecretVictoria · 05/04/2023 21:59

Kanaloa · 05/04/2023 21:49

Neither is some people’s work days. Many people travel for free - disabled people often do on a card. That doesn’t make them less entitled to a seat, they are offered free travel by the company.

Of course. I have moved so a parent and child can sit together and generally would. If there were other seats available but not together, I’d have expected the GPS to take a kid each and sit separately. Very often guards/train managers can find seats so that people can sit together.

I still sometimes wish DN had got the memo about being tired after school! I’ve quite often nodded off after collecting her to have tea at ours.

Kanaloa · 05/04/2023 21:49

SecretVictoria · 05/04/2023 21:21

The four year old will have been travelling for free. I don’t understand (and I experienced it many times as a commuter) why people travelling with kids choose the rush hour. Tickets are generally cheaper before and after.

Preschool and school is really not ‘a long, hard day’. Don’t know where this comes from on MN; when I used to pick my DN up and indeed when I went to school
myself, we’d bounce out. No notion of ‘tired after a day at school’.

Neither is some people’s work days. Many people travel for free - disabled people often do on a card. That doesn’t make them less entitled to a seat, they are offered free travel by the company.

funinthesun19 · 05/04/2023 21:42

I am an able bodied adult and I would expect a child to give up their seat for me, just as I would make my children stand for an adult. It’s the way I was brought up. A child sitting when an adult is standing is the height of bad manners.
But so many people today have different ideas so I am not surprised at the mumsnet response. So you just let the children learn to disrespect adults and become selfish. Karma will out in the end.

I’m an able bodied adult too, and wouldn’t expect a child to stand for me. I think it’s bad manners to expect it to be honest.
I’ve quickly popped my 4 year old on my lap before so that someone can sit down on a busy bus as that seems logical so that someone can have a seat, but I definitely wouldn’t make her stand for anyone.

If it’s packed then she takes a seat before I do, and if I can’t put her on my lap because I’m standing then it’s tough. Able bodied adult getting on the bus can stand.

Swiftbushome · 05/04/2023 21:34

But I do only mean little kids. I wouldn't stand for an average 10 year old

Swiftbushome · 05/04/2023 21:33

I don't understand the view that small kids should give up their seats for an adult at all. Why?? They are way more vulnerable than the average adult. Obviously if they can they should sit on a lap but honestly I've travelled on the tube with my twins when they were little and it was awful if we were all standing. They don't hold on properly and end up falling into people but worse than that they're little and below standing adults eye line which means they end up getting crushed and smacked into! I'd always give my seat to a young child if they weren't able to sit on an adults lap (so if an adult out with 3 young kids for example)

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 05/04/2023 21:28

THisbackwithavengeance · 05/04/2023 21:06

This thread is strange.

No one is saying that kids are not entitled to a seat any less than an adult.

But the converse is also true and hence why would the OP have given up her seat to a child? She was sat in it first.

Different of course if the person without a seat were disabled, elderly or pregnant.

It might have been a nice idea to give up a seat so the family could've sat together as a group IF there were free seats elsewhere in the train.

But no, I would not have moved for a 4 year old either.

But no one asked her to move or give up her seat? For a child or otherwise.

Tellmethespoiler · 05/04/2023 21:28

SecretVictoria · 05/04/2023 21:21

The four year old will have been travelling for free. I don’t understand (and I experienced it many times as a commuter) why people travelling with kids choose the rush hour. Tickets are generally cheaper before and after.

Preschool and school is really not ‘a long, hard day’. Don’t know where this comes from on MN; when I used to pick my DN up and indeed when I went to school
myself, we’d bounce out. No notion of ‘tired after a day at school’.

Most people travelling with children won’t have a choice when they travel. I’m sure they aren’t choosing to travel in rush hour for the fun of it.

darjeelingrose · 05/04/2023 21:24

ShirleyPhallus · 05/04/2023 19:33

Exactly. Why do MNers manage to centre themselves in absolute non events?

I don't, do you?
Honestly how do some poster not see the utter stupidity of telling "mumsnet" that "mumsnet" thinks this that and the other, as if they themselves hadn't created an account and as if they had nothing to do with mumsnet? It's weird.

SecretVictoria · 05/04/2023 21:21

Kanaloa · 05/04/2023 19:29

I would have probably given up my seat for a four year old. To be honest I don’t like the attitude on mumsnet that kids should be entitled to no comfort etc. I see no reason why a small child should spring out of their seat for an healthy and able bodied adult who can safely stand. Adults should sit because they’ve had a ‘long, hard day at work.‘ Most four year olds are probably tired after a long hard day of reception or preschool. And as an adult I’m more capable of standing safely than a four year old child.

However, you didn’t want to give up your seat, and you did not give up your seat. So there really isn’t an issue. You wanted to sit down and you did sit down.

The four year old will have been travelling for free. I don’t understand (and I experienced it many times as a commuter) why people travelling with kids choose the rush hour. Tickets are generally cheaper before and after.

Preschool and school is really not ‘a long, hard day’. Don’t know where this comes from on MN; when I used to pick my DN up and indeed when I went to school
myself, we’d bounce out. No notion of ‘tired after a day at school’.

KickHimInTheCrotch · 05/04/2023 21:16

I probably wouldn't give up my seat if the children had laps to sit on but I wouldn't particularly want to see a 4yo fly down the aisle head first if they happened to let go while standing when the train suddenly set off. And then have to listen to them cry for the rest of the journey. Small children are safer sat down.

fairywhale · 05/04/2023 21:16

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 05/04/2023 19:15

Why?

Because they are small tired children that developmentally do not have the stamina or patience for a train journey and could hurt themselves falling.
As if you are talking about 15 year olds.

JaneFondue · 05/04/2023 21:11

MotherOfCrocodiles · 05/04/2023 21:08

I'd have been with you pre kids

Now seeing how my 4 yo has no sense, will fall over when the train stops, is so vulnerable standing next to adults who are massive compared to him and bags are at face height for him, and empathising with how that might feel...

I'd give a kid that age my seat. I've got to say I'm sure my mum would too, despite being nearly 80 and quite wobbly

Indeed. A lot of fuss over very little. Actually I would have given grandpa or grandma my seat and then one of the kids could have sat on their laps.

Swipe left for the next trending thread