Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my bank shouldn’t be able to stop me?

237 replies

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 18:22

I’ve been trying to make a purchase for the last two months from Dior. It’s a one off treat that costs £600ish.

Every single time I’ve gone to buy it my payment gets declined. I’ve contacted my bank numerous times to ask if there was a block. After a month they finally admitted they had been blocking the payment. Confirmed block lifted but I’m still being declined.

I’ve now been told today that they will never allow me to purchase from Dior as I could say it’s fraud and sell the item on at full price. Surely if I have the money then I can spend it how I want??

OP posts:
DogInATent · 05/04/2023 19:32

@MovinginCircless when the bank first blocked the transaction they did not know the item you were trying to buy. They knew very few things about the transaction, the most important being:

  • who you are (your account details)
  • who you were trying to pay (their account details)
  • the amount you were trying to pay
Which of these do you think triggered the warning flag?

They perhaps cannot tell you the specifics, but they're dropping a bloody big hint. This is not an account that they want (or are possibly allowed) to transfer money to.

Think about it for a minute, it's not about you.

GoodChat · 05/04/2023 19:32

OP I'm assuming that they are blocking the purchase now because you've attempted it so many times - as that will show as suspected fraud even though they've removed the purchase block.

I'd open an account elsewhere. Lloyds do an online account that's really easy to set up.

Assertivepower · 05/04/2023 19:31

So they’ve profiled you somehow and decided you can’t buy dior ???!!!!

You shouldn’t have to think about using a cc or different debit card - you have a right to spend your money as you wish ! This is ridiculous!
Do you have Twitter ? Try there as they won’t like negative feedback.

GoodChat · 05/04/2023 19:30

CockSpadget · 05/04/2023 19:02

So yeah, there wasn’t a £99 contactless limit in 2017, back then it was £40. So you didn’t have a £198 claim.

There was. It's £100 now but then you could make £30 purchases up to the value of £99 and then you had to put your pin in.

Kingsize · 05/04/2023 19:30

You really do not need a credit card to have a good credit score. Its one option, not the only one!

pleasehelpwi3 · 05/04/2023 19:27

Lots of good advice on previous posts.
I'm a financial nerd- I make from a few hundred to several hundred pounds a year by both changing bank accounts and complaining to banks (sounds sad I'll admit.) You really need to:

  1. get a credit card. Not only do you get points/cashback/bonuses etc but even better than that, you get valuable Section 75 protection which protects you as a consumer. Debit cards and cash don't offer this. Indeed, you really should be buying a £600 Dior bag on credit card to protect yourself.

  2. You build up and improve your credit score. Want a mortgage- well a bank will want to see you can pay off a bill. Some people think credit cards are for those who can't handle their finances- in fact it's the opposite.

  3. Complain, and complain, and complain again. Do it formally. Ask for a reference number. The way you've been treated is not acceptable. Threaten to take to FCA. I'd love this to happen to me- I'd earn at least £75 and probably £100 from my complaint about this.

  4. Change bank accounts- and get the bonus. Can be up to £200. It's really easy- and automatic.

All of the above is on Money Saving Expert. Do it! You'll make money and gain valuable protection.

Good Luck!

JeannieAlogy · 05/04/2023 19:27

They said that when a card gets stolen that it’s very likely to be used to purchase high end goods and sell on at full price
This I understand but you have clarified that the card is not stolen "I said that’s fine and I’d understand the block initially BUT I’m telling you that it’s me buying it."

They said it didn’t matter and it’s in their t&cs that they don’t have to let me purchase something.
This is utterly ridiculous. I would be all over Twitter with this asking them how this is helping or supporting their customers particularly when you have clarified that a) it's you and b) there's no coercion.

This sort of idiotic nonsense would make me move banks pronto.

Justalittlebitduckling · 05/04/2023 19:24

I had this when we moved and we were trying to buy a fridge and a washing machine. It took a week to get it sorted! I was getting so frustrated because IT’S MY MONEY and sometimes you need to make big purchases. Try credit card?

Boomboom22 · 05/04/2023 19:24

You need a current credit card with a balance of unused credit to have good credit, even when paid off fully. If you close a card your score goes down.

MoreHairyThanScary · 05/04/2023 19:22

Takes look at money saving expert regarding improving your credit score, like others have suggested you need a variety of factors not just not being in debt.

Also do you only have the1 bank card, this is risky if you hav3 a problem with the bank. Open another account pronto!

Flowerblooms · 05/04/2023 19:20

Open another bank account with someone else then transfer the money over and buy it.
Then slowly move away from NatWest altogether.
im with NatWest and thinking of changing to Metro.

Coffeellama · 05/04/2023 19:20

Regularsizedrudy · 05/04/2023 19:19

If you’ve never had a credit card you might not have good credit. Good credit doesn’t mean “not in debt” it means “in debt and pays on time”

I’m with NatWest and have purchased from Dior several times. Are you using PayPal or just typing card details straight in? That’s more risky.

She’s had 2 loans and paid them off though so she will have credit.

euthanatothrow · 05/04/2023 19:19

Open a monzo account (for free).
Bank transfer the money from NW to Monzo.
Use the Monzo account to buy the thing

Fairyliz · 05/04/2023 19:19

Leftbutcameback · 05/04/2023 18:50

I’ve had similar issues with NatWest trying to move money to savings and them insisting I speak to the fraud team who were never available. I also find they want to validate far too many transactions on the app (like car parking payments)

Yes me too, I tried to move money into a Nationwide savings account that I had made regular payments to over the last five years.

I made 48 calls to their fraud line hanging on for about 20 minutes each time and when I finally got through they still didn’t sort it. It was urgent because it was for a house purchase.

It was finally sorted when I emailed their ceo.
Think it’s another company where everyone is wfh so they don’t learn how to do their jobs.

Regularsizedrudy · 05/04/2023 19:19

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 18:51

That’s ridiculous. I have good credit and you’re talking like I need the credit. I have funds and I want to use my money to make a purchase, I don’t think the bank should be able to prevent anyone access to their own money when they’ve passed all identification checks and have confirmed everything is legitimate.

If you’ve never had a credit card you might not have good credit. Good credit doesn’t mean “not in debt” it means “in debt and pays on time”

I’m with NatWest and have purchased from Dior several times. Are you using PayPal or just typing card details straight in? That’s more risky.

gogohmm · 05/04/2023 19:18

I'm wondering if it's a legitimate Dior website or they have had issues with it - they may not be able to disclose why if there's an ongoing investigation. I'm with NatWest and buy from all kinds of places without issue so I'm guessing it's quite specific why it's blocking

Roselilly36 · 05/04/2023 19:15

Sounds strange, do they not text your mobile a code to enter that ensures it’s you trying to make a purchase?

Disneyblueeyes · 05/04/2023 19:14

How ridiculous.
I'm with Barclays and when I sent a payment for some therapy sessions they blocked the payment. When I phoned them about it, it only took a 5 minute conversation them asking questions about it and they were fine with it all, and the payment went out later that day.

My DH has had similar problems with Santander. Constant blocking.

Makes me appreciate how good Barclays is to be honest.

Mañanarama · 05/04/2023 19:12

I assume OP means the contactless card was used multiple times until it reached £99 worth of spends and required a PIN.

OP this sounds batshit and I’d be looking to purchase from a store like Selfridges or Harvey Nichols (where you get 10% off first orders by the way!) and then taking the bank complaint to the Ombudsman. I can only think your account still has the historic fraud markers on it and computer just says no.

Morningcoffeeview · 05/04/2023 19:10

My DH tried to withdraw 10k once, said he was buying a car (he wasn’t but that wasn’t their business) he had to jump through absolute hoops. We had a well into 6 figure sum in there so don’t know what the issue was.

Eyerollcentral · 05/04/2023 19:10

Have you got the app on your phone OP? Usually NatWest just ask you to approve on the app. Download the app and approve it on there and the fraud team won’t be involved at all

Morningcoffeeview · 05/04/2023 19:09

Wtf? What are their requirements for allowing someone to purchase from Dior?

RichardMarxisinnocent · 05/04/2023 19:08

CockSpadget · 05/04/2023 19:02

So yeah, there wasn’t a £99 contactless limit in 2017, back then it was £40. So you didn’t have a £198 claim.

I assumed OP meant her card was used for several smaller contactless payments, but when after £99 worth of those it then asked for a PIN, the person who had it couldn't spend any more.

MrsAvocet · 05/04/2023 19:06

I was given an interrogation by my bank (also NatWest) last week. I had an investment plan mature a few months ago and the money has been sitting around in my savings account whilst I mulled over what to do with it. But I did decide, and obviously needed to move the money. I knew it would be bound to cause problems if I tried to do it online so I actually went into the bank in person, with photographic ID thinking that would be straightforward. Only it wasn't!
To be fair to them, I think I accidentally panicked the woman I was first dealing with by mentioning that I was cutting it a bit fine and really did need the money to leave my account on the same day. This was only because I was putting some of it into a new ISA and wanted to be able to use all my allowance from the 2022/3 tax year but before I knew it I was in the manager's office being quizzed over what I was investing in, was I being pressured, where did the money I was moving come from etc etc. I suppose it is good that they check this things, but honestly I felt it was a bit excessive. I was in there over an hour, just trying to move some of my own money! And to add insult to injury it took so long that I'd got a parking ticket when I got back to my car.
Previously I have been asked a couple of questions about big transactions but it's been straightforward so I wonder if something has changed policy making them more suspicious than usual?

trulyunruly01 · 05/04/2023 19:04

As a pp said, pay off the credit card as soon as the charge appears on it. I make weekly payments to mine, not interested in the 6 sky's interest free or whatever.