Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my bank shouldn’t be able to stop me?

237 replies

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 18:22

I’ve been trying to make a purchase for the last two months from Dior. It’s a one off treat that costs £600ish.

Every single time I’ve gone to buy it my payment gets declined. I’ve contacted my bank numerous times to ask if there was a block. After a month they finally admitted they had been blocking the payment. Confirmed block lifted but I’m still being declined.

I’ve now been told today that they will never allow me to purchase from Dior as I could say it’s fraud and sell the item on at full price. Surely if I have the money then I can spend it how I want??

OP posts:
Jadviga · 06/04/2023 02:42

pleasehelpwi3 · 05/04/2023 19:27

Lots of good advice on previous posts.
I'm a financial nerd- I make from a few hundred to several hundred pounds a year by both changing bank accounts and complaining to banks (sounds sad I'll admit.) You really need to:

  1. get a credit card. Not only do you get points/cashback/bonuses etc but even better than that, you get valuable Section 75 protection which protects you as a consumer. Debit cards and cash don't offer this. Indeed, you really should be buying a £600 Dior bag on credit card to protect yourself.

  2. You build up and improve your credit score. Want a mortgage- well a bank will want to see you can pay off a bill. Some people think credit cards are for those who can't handle their finances- in fact it's the opposite.

  3. Complain, and complain, and complain again. Do it formally. Ask for a reference number. The way you've been treated is not acceptable. Threaten to take to FCA. I'd love this to happen to me- I'd earn at least £75 and probably £100 from my complaint about this.

  4. Change bank accounts- and get the bonus. Can be up to £200. It's really easy- and automatic.

All of the above is on Money Saving Expert. Do it! You'll make money and gain valuable protection.

Good Luck!

"Some people think credit cards are for those who can't handle their finances- in fact it's the opposite."

Not true.

People who handle their finances well don't need a credit card. It's the system that demands you get one anyway to "prove" that you pay your debts - but a look at your bank statements would tell a bank everything they need to know about your spending habits anyway.

I've honestly never understood this system where you get rewarded for constantly being in debt, rather than saving for whatever it is you wish to buy.

But obviously it benefits credit card companies as having a credit card is an invitation to over spend and this is where they make their profit, when people can't pay the card in time and are stuck paying outrageous rates. In that sense I agree that people who can't manage their finances shouldn't have credit cards (and people who can shouldn't need them).

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 06/04/2023 02:30

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 18:30

Debit Card - I don’t have and have never had a credit card.

Use paypal. Transfer the money to paypal and off you go.

notangelinajolie · 06/04/2023 01:39

Nat West doesn’t surprise me. I tried 3 times (unsuccessfully) to pay for some Virgin Atlantic flights. Yes, I know the amount was in the thousands but I was paying for 5 long haul return flights at peak time of year.
By the time I’d juggled payment using other bank accounts the price had gone up.
I called and spoke to them, answered all their security questions but each time payment was blocked.

readbooksdrinktea · 06/04/2023 01:22

That's completely unacceptable. I'd tell them that when I moved my accounts to another bank.

Dibbydoos · 06/04/2023 01:00

How absolutely unacceptable.

Send a formal complaint in.

-Just because they perceive a risk doesn't mean that risk will arise.

  • How dare they suggest you will defraud them.

And, I'd change banks. No way would NatWest get a second more of my time! Look at money-saving expert and switch to a bank that'll give you £ to move and do the full switch for you.

Good luck

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 06/04/2023 00:30

I reckon a formal complaint would get this sorted pretty quick.

AllIeveknewonlyou · 06/04/2023 00:27

Nedmund · 06/04/2023 00:25

If this is correct and there's not more to the story, you need to see someone in person at your bank. Ask for a manager to explain. If it doesn't solve it, you need a written complaint asking for a reasonable explanation.

They should not be able to block you from making a purchase but may block you from buying somewhere that looks like Dior's website and isn't.

Not sure if this has been answered but can you not buy it in person on your card so it's not an online purchase? Surely they would have no justification for blocking that.

Think OP said it's not near her.

This is utter madness though.

Nedmund · 06/04/2023 00:25

If this is correct and there's not more to the story, you need to see someone in person at your bank. Ask for a manager to explain. If it doesn't solve it, you need a written complaint asking for a reasonable explanation.

They should not be able to block you from making a purchase but may block you from buying somewhere that looks like Dior's website and isn't.

Not sure if this has been answered but can you not buy it in person on your card so it's not an online purchase? Surely they would have no justification for blocking that.

AllIeveknewonlyou · 06/04/2023 00:23

PousseyNotMoira · 06/04/2023 00:16

Doesn’t solve the problem (the fact that you’ve got a mad bank), but for this purchase, set up a PayPal and just use that?

Mad NatWest 🤣

I'm sorry OP but that did make me laugh

PousseyNotMoira · 06/04/2023 00:16

Doesn’t solve the problem (the fact that you’ve got a mad bank), but for this purchase, set up a PayPal and just use that?

AllIeveknewonlyou · 06/04/2023 00:07

This does sound a bit crazy. I'd be highly indignant if my bank stopped me accessing my money.

I completely get feeling attached to an old account, open up a separate one with another bank, shift some money and make the purchase?

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 23:58

Noodlehen · 05/04/2023 23:41

This is shocking, I’d move banks. But they have to have some form of flag on your file.

I moved to England last year, opened an account with NatWest, transferred a large sum from € obviously into £ immediately once acc was open and then spent it all within a month on designer / frivolous purchases (just before our wedding) and from memory they didn’t block a single payment. Not even with the text “is this you?” thing. I wonder their criteria for what flags.

I‘m starting to think that maybe they do put certain retailers on a high risk alert if they’ve had multiple fraud claims made against the same company.

Perhaps you only qualify if you regularly purchase from there or similar retailers. Or maybe you have to be earning a consistent wage threshold.

Regardless I’ve told them it’s genuine so how could I then make a fraud claim. It’s just absolutely disgusting they’ve blamed it on me, blamed it on Dior, made me speak to so many people etc when I was never going to get the item at any point.

OP posts:
Noodlehen · 05/04/2023 23:41

This is shocking, I’d move banks. But they have to have some form of flag on your file.

I moved to England last year, opened an account with NatWest, transferred a large sum from € obviously into £ immediately once acc was open and then spent it all within a month on designer / frivolous purchases (just before our wedding) and from memory they didn’t block a single payment. Not even with the text “is this you?” thing. I wonder their criteria for what flags.

MoreSleepPleasee · 05/04/2023 23:41

My bank did this to me but with much less than what you are trying to spend. After an extremely pissed off phone call about how the 'fraud alert' thing has gone insane on my account it's never happened again. They literally blocked my tesco shop, soft play, takeaway etc. at one point.

Teenagehorrorbag · 05/04/2023 23:35

My bank is Lloyds and I had something a bit similar. My personal card started being declined every time I tried to buy anything online, It worked in shops fine, but not for internet purchases. The first few times I thought it was a glitch, then realised there was a pattern. I had to keep using my other Lloyds card which is for our joint account, and that was fine (although annoying, as I had to keep transferring money across).

I went into the bank and they phoned up their fraud dept - or wherever - and said I must have tried to do some sort of unusual transaction back in January, and the account had been blocked (for online transactions only) ever since. I'm not aware of doing anything unusual - and of course I would expect that normally to be verified via my phone. I produced ID and spoke to the person on the phone, and she said my account was now unblocked.

Tried to make a purchase last night - nope! Still blocked!

Sorry OP - this isn't helpful to you, and I sympathise as it's massively annoying! But you aren't alone.

Can you pay on a different card?

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 23:21

And also here’s part of the complaint I received last month:

Following our fraud teams process, they unfortunately do not make customers aware of the blocks that have been applied to the account. The transaction will decline which would prompt our customers to call us and should then be told by the agent that there is a block. I appreciate on this occasion you were told there were no blocks however as the fraud team have confirmed they do not contacted the customers regarding these blocks I am unable to agree any error has occurred.

How ridiculous. If the fraudster was actually attempting to use my card then the fraud team wouldn’t notify me because it’s up to me to let them know about a payment I didn’t know about was declined??

OP posts:
ShiteInNiningArmour · 05/04/2023 23:09

I tried to switch to NatWest some years ago when they offered their switch bonus. As they couldn’t even accomplish a basic account migration I didn’t have much faith in them being able to manage my banking and pulled the plug.

I stayed with First Direct and to be fair they have been great over the years with cloned cards etc and halting a 3am Waitrose shop during covid as they knew it was out of my pattern (I couldn’t sleep, found a coveted slot and did manage to use PayPal). The only thing that’s always pissed me off with FD is their welcome bonuses etc that never filter down to actual customers who’ve been with them for 25 years.

Mumwomansisterdaughter · 05/04/2023 23:08

Can I suggest you open a bank account with revolut , you can use a virtual card straight away from vem before the physical one arrives . It’s bonkers that they prevent a buy

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 05/04/2023 23:06

I refuse to be loyal to any bank because it's never reciprocated. In fact I've just changed to Nat West for the £200 bonus. Luckily (?) I can't afford Dior. Check out money saving expert and swap to a bank offering a bonus.

roseapothecary · 05/04/2023 23:05

I had an issue with Natwest blocking me from paying for childcare. I had to pay with my husband's card for the same account! I complained and they did not care at all.

MintJulia · 05/04/2023 23:01

I've never had a transaction refused (hsbc) but I spent an hour on the phone persuading them to release £10k to buy a car.

I'd warned them of the transaction the day before and it was through a main dealer. I couldn't understand the fuss. I've never claimed any fraud on any account ever.

It was frustrating but we got there in the end. The car dealer seemed to think it was fairly normal for banks to be difficult.

Aussiegirl123456 · 05/04/2023 22:55

I’d just set up a new account, put $600 into it and then buy whatever it is you want from Dior.
Or see if Selfridges/Harrods or elsewhere have the item.
Or use paypal.
Or get someone else to make the purchase and give them the cash.

I wouldn’t be fucking around talking to fraud teams.

And the PPs who have said Natwest aren’t allowing the purchase because you don’t have a credit card are crackers! Cash is king and all that! Credit cards are poison.
I have never had a credit card but make high end purchases regularly with no problem. Got a mortgage with no issue - just like you and many others have. I’m a devout Dave Ramsey follower though so that’s likely why I feel so anticredit, but honestly, not having a credit card will not and does not justify Natwest having authority on what you buy with your money.
The only reason they would be within their rights to prevent the purchase is if the website was flagged up as not being legitimate.

thenightsky · 05/04/2023 22:46

spuddel · 05/04/2023 19:55

Banks are heading towards total digital currency, hence the branch closures. Everything online and trackable and that sounds fine but even at this stage, before total digital money, your online purchase is being blocked. Now imagine you want to buy something after criticising the government...

Didn't protesters in Canada get their bank accounts frozen recently? I can't remember the details though.

PCPurpleHelmet · 05/04/2023 22:45

FWIW @MovinginCircless, I'd feel the same about your nice purchase being shat on, and I would change banks and buy yourself something different but just as nice as a reward.

PCPurpleHelmet · 05/04/2023 22:43

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 21:29

You’re right sadly. They lied about my new mortgage rate not going through when I applied so I either had the choice at that point of fixing at a much higher rate or going on flexible and hoping to fix if the rates ever came down - my mortgage tripled at one point.

I went to the ombudsman and they confirmed that Barclays had noted it was their system error and they were made to give me the original rate and around £700 compensation (which they took months to send)

I think I’m just bad luck

OP, you have all my sympathy. Barclays are complete and utter bastards.

Swipe left for the next trending thread