Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my bank shouldn’t be able to stop me?

237 replies

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 18:22

I’ve been trying to make a purchase for the last two months from Dior. It’s a one off treat that costs £600ish.

Every single time I’ve gone to buy it my payment gets declined. I’ve contacted my bank numerous times to ask if there was a block. After a month they finally admitted they had been blocking the payment. Confirmed block lifted but I’m still being declined.

I’ve now been told today that they will never allow me to purchase from Dior as I could say it’s fraud and sell the item on at full price. Surely if I have the money then I can spend it how I want??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BillyAteMyChips · 18/04/2023 17:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Morningcoffeeview · 18/04/2023 09:39

Jadviga · 06/04/2023 02:42

"Some people think credit cards are for those who can't handle their finances- in fact it's the opposite."

Not true.

People who handle their finances well don't need a credit card. It's the system that demands you get one anyway to "prove" that you pay your debts - but a look at your bank statements would tell a bank everything they need to know about your spending habits anyway.

I've honestly never understood this system where you get rewarded for constantly being in debt, rather than saving for whatever it is you wish to buy.

But obviously it benefits credit card companies as having a credit card is an invitation to over spend and this is where they make their profit, when people can't pay the card in time and are stuck paying outrageous rates. In that sense I agree that people who can't manage their finances shouldn't have credit cards (and people who can shouldn't need them).

Exactly. I don’t have a credit card and don’t want the hassle of one. it’s another admin exercise I don’t need. When I was skint I had one and juggled the same £1k on and off it each month!

Morningcoffeeview · 18/04/2023 09:34

Since this post I have heard of so many instances of this and my card has been randomly declining transactions too. I have two debit cards - my current account and an old one that I’ve just never closed but never use with about £50 in it. So I don’t have loads of options when my current account gets declined. It’s been for £6 or £30 in the Co-op and a chinese takeaway too. Ring and they say they have no explanation. Never had this trouble before.

Colleague said there seems to be some bank to bank feuds going on - her credit card provider rejecting payments from her debit account, but accepting them from another account.

But in the meantime she has incurred late payment fees. But she’s PAID they’ve rejected it for no reason! She has spotted a trend with which banks don’t like the others. All extremely bizarre. She told them she hasn’t paid late they have chosen to reject the payment and that’s an issue between the banks - not her. To which I agree.

What is going on?

Coulditreallybe · 16/04/2023 23:22

Did you get it @MovinginCircless ? Hope so!

Ourshoddyhouse · 12/04/2023 20:24

I've not read the full thread so apologies; but open a Chase account (done pretty much instantly and you get a digital debit card to use) transfer the money over and at least you'll get 1% of the purchase price as cashback.

Then switch NatWest to one of accounts offering a switch incentive

https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/banking/compare-best-bank-accounts/

Multiconfused · 12/04/2023 18:28

Hi I have these types of problems. Which bank is it? I now have 2-3 accounts and thinking of another online.

Reugny · 06/04/2023 20:46

Jadviga · 06/04/2023 02:42

"Some people think credit cards are for those who can't handle their finances- in fact it's the opposite."

Not true.

People who handle their finances well don't need a credit card. It's the system that demands you get one anyway to "prove" that you pay your debts - but a look at your bank statements would tell a bank everything they need to know about your spending habits anyway.

I've honestly never understood this system where you get rewarded for constantly being in debt, rather than saving for whatever it is you wish to buy.

But obviously it benefits credit card companies as having a credit card is an invitation to over spend and this is where they make their profit, when people can't pay the card in time and are stuck paying outrageous rates. In that sense I agree that people who can't manage their finances shouldn't have credit cards (and people who can shouldn't need them).

Section 75 means if a retailer goes bust you get your money back

With a debit card it is more time limited.

19lottie82 · 06/04/2023 20:35

this might sound strange but where you requesting delivery to the address the card was registered to?

I bought a bag from LV and the order kept getting rejected. I eventually worked out that the delivery address had to be the one that was registered to my card (home), but I was requesting delivery to my workplace.

it could be something similar?

Reugny · 06/04/2023 20:30

Morningcoffeeview · 05/04/2023 21:49

Did you ever find out the motive? This is all so bizarre.

The first excuse is that they had fraud with laptops. I pointed out I work in IT and have previously bought 2 laptops and a phone outright with their credit card. This was from online only retailers. Then they just wouldn't give me answers and kept telling me to go into a branch with ID to verify it was me. I went into my local branch the first time and the staff politely said they had no idea why I was sent to them as they couldn't help.

When I complained to the financial ombudsman service. I spoke to a guy on the phone and was told it was like pulling teeth getting information from them but eventually they admitted no one wanted to deal with the issue so they made up stuff.

Thing is at the time Nationwide had more information about my income and profession than Barclaycard who had no issue approving the transaction.

The fraud on my Barclaycard was smaller more everyday transactions e.g. the type of transactions I do with a debit card.

VanGoghsDog · 06/04/2023 12:24

This happened to me, not with the same brand. I think the issue was less around who the retailer was and more around what their payment request looked like to the bank. Which you cannot see.
I also spoke to fraud etc to "unblock" it but had it declined again.

From working for a bank, I can tell you that the people who answer the phone will have very little idea why it's been blocked. It won't be in case you sell it "at full price" (they wouldn't know the value of the item anyway), they just made that up.

If I were you, I would open a second bank account, one of the app based ones. I use Monzo, but there's also Starling and some others. Transfer the money to there and use that card to buy it.

It's always worth having a second bank account anyway I think, in case something happens - card gets swallowed; card stops working; app down etc. I've found it very useful to have Monzo as a spare.

Xenia · 06/04/2023 10:57

It can be quite strange why banks query one thing and not another. Eg I have paid huge sums at times for things £15k etc and no query and then I will do something quite small and it will be rejected so I then pay another way - one reason to have different cards. I have no problems with money so never had a problem having a credit card on which there is never anything bought on credit - I just choose to pay it off right away.

WarmButteryCrumpets · 06/04/2023 10:38

He told me twice about buying high end goods to resell at full value .. which for some reason maybe they think I would do

Is this illegal though? Surely loads of people do this on eBay!

Definitely switch to a new account which won't try this nonsense with you!

Blessedbethefknfruit · 06/04/2023 09:21

@MovinginCircless I'd love to know what it is you're trying to buy, just to satisfy my own nosey curiosity.

pleasehelpwi3 · 06/04/2023 08:49

C8H10N4O2 · 06/04/2023 08:22

This kind of loyalty is exactly what the big banks rely on. We are more likely to divorce our partners than our banks.

Read all your own posts in this thread and then tell me - if this were not your bank would you seriously consider staying with them?

The bank fraud analytics systems are not there to protect customers they are there to protect the banks. They know perfectly well that customer loyalty in banking is so entrenched they can treat customers appallingly and we still go back for more.

Change your bank and make the complaint. Make it clear that you understand entirely the need to check a transaction but its not acceptable for them to dictate to you what you can spend your money on and waste hours of your time in the process.

Every word in this reply is spot on.
You can earn £200 by changing banks- it's so easy to do.
Put it another way- why are you in effect paying £200 to stay with a bank that's treating you like shit?

I never understood why my parents have stuck with Barclays forever- they were bankers for the apartheid government in South Africa in the 70s and 80s.
Barclays- not my parents!

pleasehelpwi3 · 06/04/2023 08:44

Jadviga · 06/04/2023 02:42

"Some people think credit cards are for those who can't handle their finances- in fact it's the opposite."

Not true.

People who handle their finances well don't need a credit card. It's the system that demands you get one anyway to "prove" that you pay your debts - but a look at your bank statements would tell a bank everything they need to know about your spending habits anyway.

I've honestly never understood this system where you get rewarded for constantly being in debt, rather than saving for whatever it is you wish to buy.

But obviously it benefits credit card companies as having a credit card is an invitation to over spend and this is where they make their profit, when people can't pay the card in time and are stuck paying outrageous rates. In that sense I agree that people who can't manage their finances shouldn't have credit cards (and people who can shouldn't need them).

I agree with you that the system is a bit perverse- however, that is the system the banks have set up, so it's bad advice to tell people not to get a credit card because:

  1. Section 75- covered extensively on moneysaving expert- but basically if you pay by CREDIT card (not debit card) for anything over £100, you are legally protected if the retailer goes bankrupt, the item breaks early, or the service you've paid doesn't happen/is faulty. And the beauty is, you can go straight to the credit card company and complain to them if 'Dodgy Dave at the the garage' is arguing he did fix the breaks on your car, and you know he didn't. You don't even need to put all the bill on the card. MSE have an example of a couple who put £10 or something on a credit card to pay for a £32k kitchen which turned into a horror story. They were refunded the full amount ie £32k or whatever is was by the credit card company by sticking to their guns and knowing their rights. I have a young colleague who is going on holiday to Tenerife this summer- she is paying for it by monthly direct debit from her bank account. I've pleaded with her to get a credit card- even if she pays just one instalment with it she will be covered for the full amount if the holiday company goes bankrupt- and quicker than ABTA.
  2. On my Amex card, I quite often get offers that save a me a hundred a year or so (Shop Small) etc. Most cards offer these. The big one however is the Avios voucher- we got a free flight to Bermuda for this summer using it, all for buying things I would have spent on anyway.

I totally agree with the poster I'm quoting about some people not using credit cards if they have problems with debt/don't quite understand how they work. I know Amex charge high transaction rates to retailers. Indeed I only ever spend cash in charity shops and my hairdresser to save them those costs.

The most important thing is to pay off the bill by direct debit in full every month. I realise not everyone can afford to do this- we can as we don't usually buy anything too out of the ordinary- and trip to Bermuda aside- live within our means.
If you are stuck with a high balance on a high interest rate, then look at moneysavingexpert to find a good deal on a balance transfer to a lower rate card.

As a much earlier poster said, I should have put FOS and not FCA when I was referring to the ombudsman- but all my advice is good and saves money. Reading some of the complaints people have had with banks on this thread, I've just been seeing £ signs as to how much compensation people could get if they had complained formally and stuck with it. Here are some selected examples of complaints I've made:

HSBC: cashier closed screen on me at front of queue, saying it was lunch time. The opened another till screen to talk to a customer she knew: £75 compensation
Halifax: Not accepting Jersey banknotes despite doing so on an earlier occasion : £60
Amex: 5000 avios points due to wrong wording on statement
RBS: refund of all overdraft charges as a student as they sent all my statements to French Guiana during my year abroad.....in Paris (!)
Barclays: Around £500 for multiple mix ups when trying to use my Euro account (nothing fancy, it has about six euros in it but it's a pain to use)
Natwest: £75 and free CIFAS membership for a year after they allowed someone to open an account in my name and blow a £5k overdraft without seeing me or my ID docs- they covered the overdraft of course but it was scary and they really didn't want to pay a penny compensation.
Punjab National Bank: £50 for a GDPR breach

And the list goes on, probably up to a few grand.

I know not everyone can be arsed to complain, but it can be worth it.
And credit cards are so important for the legal protection.

No I'm not Martin Lewis. And no, he's not right about everything- ULEZ in particular.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/04/2023 08:22

MovinginCircless · 05/04/2023 18:52

Thank you, I’m currently waiting for their security fraud team to contact me. It’s a shame to leave as I’ve been a customer since my mum opened me a savings account as a child.

They also wouldn’t care if I left but yeah

This kind of loyalty is exactly what the big banks rely on. We are more likely to divorce our partners than our banks.

Read all your own posts in this thread and then tell me - if this were not your bank would you seriously consider staying with them?

The bank fraud analytics systems are not there to protect customers they are there to protect the banks. They know perfectly well that customer loyalty in banking is so entrenched they can treat customers appallingly and we still go back for more.

Change your bank and make the complaint. Make it clear that you understand entirely the need to check a transaction but its not acceptable for them to dictate to you what you can spend your money on and waste hours of your time in the process.

unsync · 06/04/2023 07:36

I can recommend Starling when you change accounts. They are a modern bank who know how to deal with online purchasing.

User639762456 · 06/04/2023 06:31

BarbaraofSeville · 06/04/2023 04:21

It is true, you're wrong.

Lots of reasons to have a credit card that are nothing to do with getting into debt.

But MN is weird about credit cards, people say they don't need them, yet describe endless problems that would never have arisen if they had a credit card.....

I can't understand the MN weirdness about credit cards either, I never use my bank accounts for general shopping and just pay the credit cards off each month, also credit cards have perks like cashback or points for vouchers which bank accounts don't have so much so you gain more

User639762456 · 06/04/2023 06:19

I would get a second bank account and a couple of credit card that you pay off each month, DH and I have 3 different bank accounts and 5 credit cards between us so if stuff is ever refused we just use a different account. People seem to want to go cash free but this really isn't sensible if you hope to rely on 1 bank account in the family. I only ever shop using a credit card as it lessens the risk of my bank accounts being compromised and use different credit cards for Amazon and PayPal as they are left on the accounts

Jagoda · 06/04/2023 05:50

Are you sure it’s a legit site?

Would they still have blocked it if you had bought via Browns or Dover Street Market?

Zebedee55 · 06/04/2023 04:36

I can't understand this. We've banked with NW for years, and bought expensive stuff from loads of place, including Dior.

Never had a single problem. They sometimes ask if I'm sure this isn't a scam, I click proceed, and the payment is allowed.

There must be more to this.🤔

BarbaraofSeville · 06/04/2023 04:21

Jadviga · 06/04/2023 02:42

"Some people think credit cards are for those who can't handle their finances- in fact it's the opposite."

Not true.

People who handle their finances well don't need a credit card. It's the system that demands you get one anyway to "prove" that you pay your debts - but a look at your bank statements would tell a bank everything they need to know about your spending habits anyway.

I've honestly never understood this system where you get rewarded for constantly being in debt, rather than saving for whatever it is you wish to buy.

But obviously it benefits credit card companies as having a credit card is an invitation to over spend and this is where they make their profit, when people can't pay the card in time and are stuck paying outrageous rates. In that sense I agree that people who can't manage their finances shouldn't have credit cards (and people who can shouldn't need them).

It is true, you're wrong.

Lots of reasons to have a credit card that are nothing to do with getting into debt.

But MN is weird about credit cards, people say they don't need them, yet describe endless problems that would never have arisen if they had a credit card.....

OldFan · 06/04/2023 03:00

It sounds really unpleasant OP. Sad

but it feels tainted now. They’ve taken a nice thing and shit all over it.

Aww try and reframe it as you'll feel a massive sense of victory when you do eventually get it. x

Jadviga · 06/04/2023 02:44

Just to add - I do understand some people can't face big expenses and it is useful to them to be able to pay a new car/dishwasher/washing machine, etc, over several months despite the terrible interest rates. But that's hardly the sign of a healthy financial situation.

Brokendaughter · 06/04/2023 02:43

Nat West for months last year absolutely refused to let me pay money into my account at the Royal Mint.

I could spend ten times the amount I was trying to pay in there in any other shop, even if it was in the USA or Aus & they were fine, but not even a fiver would they let me pay the RM on my card.
My debit card worked everywhere else.

I'd been transferring money into my RM account that way for ages at that point, so it wasn't an unusual transaction.

I had to move money with Bank Transfers to get it to the Mint, then wait for them to update my account instead of the instant debit card transfers that happened automatically.

They randomly decided to let my card work there again this year.

It's not like they can say the Royal Mint is some dodgy company they've never heard of.

They are a nightmare.