Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think it’s cruel to encourage my toddler to eat her vegetables?

38 replies

SapphireSunday · 05/04/2023 18:13

My daughter is 20 months. She used to eat anything and everything but the last 6 weeks or so has become a bit fussier - basically doesn’t want fruit or veg or anything healthy. She will pick at the carby bits of her dinner but eat virtually nothing and then ask for a yoghurt.

I’ve never forced her to eat anything, so if she tells me she is done she is allowed a yoghurt but I feel it’s getting to a ridiculous point now where she is just refusing absolutely everything and every mealtime feels like a failure.

Nursery say she eats great, and our parents never have any trouble when they look after her so it’s just with us.

Tonight I was trying to convince her to eat some vegetables, tried turning it into a little game ‘you feed mummy and then mummy feeds you’ some, telling her how yummy they were, but DH told me it was cruel of me to force her (forcing and encouraging are different though aren’t they?!) and gave her a slice of ham from the fridge and then a yoghurt.

Apart from feeling undermined I feel completely confused! Is it cruel to make her eat things she doesn’t want to? If so, how the flip do I get her to start eating a balanced diet? I feel like everything I do is getting it wrong, and I don’t want my daughter to end up with food issues because of something I’ve done 😣

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yazo · 26/01/2024 19:26

I'd encourage, of course. We've tried it all. I have one so who is very fussy and another who will eat literally anything and loves his food. The problem is, if I only had my second child I'd think I was a very clever parent and food choices and attitudes were down to my great cooking and parenting but having both my boys I know that most of what they think about food comes from them, often sensory attitudes to food and all I can do is work with it. I don't force my son to eat things he doesn't like but I do find fruit and veg that he likes and give him that. Even if it's literally just cucumber and apple. He hates potato (all types) but likes pasta, so he has pasta. He's growing up very fit and healthy as a young man now and I think will be adventurous in his own time. Fussiness is common and not caused by parenting so see what your daughter enjoys and go from there.

Hp23334556 · 26/01/2024 19:06

My four year old eats no vegetables at all and hasn’t done for a couple of years. I just gave up I still put them on the side but they’ll never get eaten. I just give him loads of fruit. I wouldn’t use food as a reward for eating dinner , just plate everything up an don’t say anything , talk about something else completely and don’t stress about what they eat, I’ve realised there’s just no point.

Blueberries7 · 26/01/2024 18:58

I have one a wee bit older and she is similar and I try to be as hands off as I can. It turned into a battle with DS that is still going on (due to other family members ignoring advice) and he is 5 now.

I don't think gentle encouragement is an issue.
I never deny DD her yoghurt because she needs the fat/calcium at her age.

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/01/2024 18:42

It's not forcing, but 'encouraging' can just add more pressure which backfires and makes it a big deal.

Just offer a range of foods, mostly what you know she will eat, the odd other thing and let her eat what she wants of it.

Don't make foods 'rewards' either, or 'treats' - if a meal of X, Y and Z is balanced and healthy, does it matter if she eats X first or Z first?

Stick it all on the table, in suitable portions and let her eat, if she wants to eat her yoghurt first, so what.

I have never understood the insistence on withholding 'pudding' if the child hasn't eaten all their main course.

If the meal was sufficient calories as main/side/pudding, how is it better to withhold pudding if main/side were not eaten? You end up teaching kids to eat MORE than they need in order to get to pudding, or making puddings a huge issue and mealtimes a massive stress.

birdglasspen · 26/01/2024 18:28

It’s not cruel but very quickly get yourself a book of getting the little blighters to eat or follow fussy eaters on fb. Most kids eat great when young, then need less food and are more aware and start getting fussy. How you deal with this stage is important. Your child will soon realise they can control you by what they will and won’t eat. Make sure your DH reads the book too. It’s very tiny and very useful!

ReachForTheMars · 26/06/2023 14:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Tinybrother · 22/06/2023 11:01

Cruel no, but I never bothered. Just made stuff available. Mine eat more veg sometimes and less at others and it evens out in the end. They are NT and healthy, so I am fortunate not to need to worry.

notforonesecond · 22/06/2023 10:56

It sounds like you’re doing a great job. It’s really hard to sit back and not say anything when you’ve put effort into cooking something that they just won’t eat it. I think everyone finds themselves falling into the “just have 3 more bites” trap every now and again. That’s ok - the next meal is the next meal and you can try again to stay chill.

I once put my hands on my hips and announced “no you can’t have any ice cream until you’ve finished your pizza!” - and then realised what a twat I was being.

Both my kids are a bit older now and eat pretty well. You’ll get there. Everything’s a phase you just have to wait to pass.

Oblomov23 · 22/06/2023 10:10

Don't give youghurts.

Abouttimemum · 22/06/2023 10:09

I’d just shove it all on the plate together, yoghurt included, and let her go at it. Nothing else after.

When everything available to eat is on the plate in one go she might be less inclined to be holding out for dessert. It’s always worked for my son, even if he eats his biscuit first he still eats everything else on his plate.

Get rid of the food hierarchy.

Sulkyatforty · 22/06/2023 10:02

Definitely not cruel - responsible I would say! My friends kids have to ‘try’ everything on their plate which is possibly a better rule. I wouldn’t reward with pudding / treats tho. If they are hungry they get the meal that they left. This is what we did with my DD as a toddler and she’s great now

HollyBookBlue · 16/06/2023 21:51

I don't think you're being cruel, but you're setting yourself up for a battle of wills that you're never going to win. Stop buying yogurt. Don't do puddings. Then serve whatever you have for tea and eat together as a family and don't mention the food at all. Talk about anything else, put the radio on, Do not look as if you care what she eats. But don't offer any alternatives.

Spottypineapple · 16/06/2023 21:32

That's not forcing at all. That's a good strategy for encouraging toddlers to try foods. I also do 'mummies carrot makes a crunchy sound, can you make a crunchy sound with yours? How many peas can you get on your fork? Etc (check out Solid Starts for ideas)

Also at 20 months I wouldnt worry especially if she's eating veg elsewhere, which indicates she's a good eater. Likely a phase she'll get through, so dont make a problem where there isn't one! (Not saying you are, but I mean don't get too hung up on it)

Whyohwhyohwhy123 · 16/06/2023 21:13

I often put my children’s lunch in one of those plastic boxes with three compartments. Sandwiches crisps fruit homemade biscuit and often a couple of sweets go in. They can eat it in whatever order they like but nothing else is given until it’s empty. The lid is often replaced for a bit but it’s usually all gone by mid afternoon.

NotCopingWell1 · 05/04/2023 20:43

This is why I've never done pudding. They don't need it.

Yellowrosesmakemehappy · 05/04/2023 20:27

Do you have Instagram? Follow Charlotte Stirling Reed- she is a child nutritionist and her book “How to feed your toddler” is amazing.

Also had a website which is the bible - https://www.srnutrition.co.uk/

The Baby & Child Nutritionist | Charlotte Stirling-Reed | SR Nutrition

Award winning Nutritionist Charlotte Stirling Reed of SR Nutrition, The Baby & Child Nutritionist. For advice on weaning advice, baby & child nutrition

https://www.srnutrition.co.uk/

Season0fTheWitch · 05/04/2023 20:02

I'd suggest blending some veg into sauces (hidden veg pasta sauce recipes are popular) and just continue offering her veg. New shapes, new colours etc. And explain to DH what your goal is, so he doesn't undermine you again. No more yoghurt offerings either, only what's on her plate.

FurAndFeathers · 05/04/2023 19:54

fairywhale · 05/04/2023 18:57

How would you feel forced to eat something you don't want? Of course it's cruel. Try it on yourself.
Mumsnet can be ridiculous - force feeding a child is okay (as long as nobody is arguing - just look at the other thread going).

Mumsnet really is a Mecca for folk with zero skills in reading comprehension!

SnackSizeRaisin · 05/04/2023 19:36

I don't think there's anything wrong with encouragement to eat vegetables. We have encouraged our very fussy toddler to try things and she does try things and eats a wider variety than she did before. We have tried serving the veg first or before the meal, while they are hungry and more likely to try. Also providing a dip to go with them such as balsamic vinegar or houmus.

The only 2 things to remember is that ultimately you don't care whether they eat any particular food. Never let it become a battle of wills. It should be more "try this broccoli, it's really delicious, mmmm" not "please please eat this broc", I just eat it off their plate myself if they don't. Secondly there should never be a food reward for eating any other food. If you give yogurt it should be regardless of veg (or just don't give it at all for a while to reduce the expectation).

Overall though I don't think it's worth worrying about. If she won't eat veg get her to eat more fruit instead.

DragonflyLady · 05/04/2023 19:35

we started putting everything on the table family style so she could take what she felt she could eat and had control. Sometimes the not eating certain things is a way of trying to assert their own control. Dessert was usually Greek yoghurt and, as a previous poster has described, she’d often eat that whilst eating her main. What she usually did was eat a bit of main, then the yoghurt, then more of the main. If she didn’t want to eat the main, that was fine - she could eat fruit and more yoghurt. Please don’t fall into the trap of punishing or rewarding your child through food.

qpmz · 05/04/2023 19:21

Yoghurt is not a desert, it's just another food. Assuming it's Greek/natural.

The fact she's eating ok elsewhere means she'll be getting her nutrients so I wouldn't focus attention on her home food too much, it will be a phase.

SummerHouse · 05/04/2023 19:01

It's really hard.

You are doing a really good job.

I think you need to have a conversation with your partner. I don't think either of you is wrong in the food approach but to call you cruel and overrule you is not good.

fairywhale · 05/04/2023 18:57

How would you feel forced to eat something you don't want? Of course it's cruel. Try it on yourself.
Mumsnet can be ridiculous - force feeding a child is okay (as long as nobody is arguing - just look at the other thread going).

Caiti19 · 05/04/2023 18:53

Are these yoghurts the kind containing sugar? If so, stop buying them.

Your husband should have discussed it with you afterwards though. Him going to fridge to give her whatever he felt like is not showing great partnership with you. Nip that in the bud.

Swipe left for the next trending thread