Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move our family from a beautiful detached 4 bed to 3 bed semi for a better school catchment?

79 replies

Internationalwomendayheadquarters · 05/04/2023 17:04

Family of 5 here. We live in a large detached house, with a big garden. Rural. The only issue is that schools are not good in our area. We’re in a 3 tier system; the primary is outstanding, but the middle is very poor (and has been for a long time) and the high school is average.

Our original plan was to go private but we simply can’t do that now. We’ve got 3DC and our local very good indie has just announced a 10% fee increase. With the CofL what it is now, it’s out of reach.

I’ve been looking at an area 40 mins away from us with an outstanding secondary school and a good primary. House prices are much higher and realistically we’d be looking at a 3 bed semi (going to look at one tomorrow to get a feel).

Has anyone done this and would I be crazy to even consider it? Our DDs would have to share a bedroom (they are 5 years apart). However, we may be able to go a bit bigger in 5-7 years.

The area we’d be moving into is an area of outstanding beauty; there would be lots of outdoor space for kids, but our own garden would be much, much smaller.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
carriedout · 10/04/2023 21:46

Yes I'd move for that reason. Location location location.

Internationalwomendayheadquarters · 10/04/2023 21:44

TheWayTheLightFalls · 10/04/2023 20:29

You've said you're a teacher - does the private school you are priced out of offer staff discounts? Any leads that way?

TBH in your shoes, if it's only two years (?) of middle school, I'd grit my teeth and tutor / enrich in other ways.

Where do other kids from the primary end up? All over, because of the rural catchment?

Trying to explore my options as a teacher to go private with a discount. However, it’s not always that simple. Could mean I’m stuck in a job for a long time as I’d only be in it for my own DC. Also concerned about potential rise of 20% to fees with labour govt. (I spotted a separate thread on this today on MN)

The middle school is 4 years. My concern is that it’s a long time to be in a failing school.

Parents have started taking their kids out of the first school during Yr 3 before the official leaving year of Yr 4 to do in year transfers to nearby primary schools, thus avoiding the middle school. It’s having a detrimental affect to the First school, as they are struggling to manage numbers in Yr 4. Also, some of the other local primary schools are getting full. It’s a mess tbh and I’m getting quite stressed about it.

OP posts:
TheWayTheLightFalls · 10/04/2023 20:29

You've said you're a teacher - does the private school you are priced out of offer staff discounts? Any leads that way?

TBH in your shoes, if it's only two years (?) of middle school, I'd grit my teeth and tutor / enrich in other ways.

Where do other kids from the primary end up? All over, because of the rural catchment?

Ataliecalm · 10/04/2023 20:15

I'm surprised as well by some of these responses. If the schools were really that bad where I was living I would move if I could. I would try and find a three bed with an extra reception room to make another bedroom? You can always try and upgrade house in the future. A decent education would be my priority.

Whatonearth07957 · 10/04/2023 19:58

I'd move for better schools and less space. Look for how you may extend.

Sunshine275 · 07/04/2023 19:16

I wouldn’t change my home and life for a few years at school. I don’t think it makes an awful lot of difference they’ll do well if they work hard and have the capability to exceed in some areas they will.

Twiglets1 · 06/04/2023 17:37

I would move house to stop my children having to attend a school that requires improvement, definitely.

Whether you buy somewhere or whether you are able to rent strategically I would see these as the only 2 choices, personally.

Werehalfwaythere · 06/04/2023 17:31

YANBU.

I'd sacrifice a bedroom and garden space for better schooling. Most of the population survive in semi's just fine.

HermioneKipper · 06/04/2023 17:26

Any chance of getting a job at the independent as you’re a teacher?

reduced school fees!

Tockomtele · 06/04/2023 17:26

We were in a similar situation a few years ago. I really-really suggest you rent something for a few years and rent our your original house.
We only have two children and I hate the feel of our current house in the lovely area. My kids love their school, they made friends and are not bullied here (my eldest was in middle school). But they also miss their nice bedrooms.

Moorwoodsriver · 06/04/2023 17:19

Look for a middle ground OP . Look for an OFSTED ‘ good’ school with exam results above the National Average and supplement with tutoring if necessary and see if that improves the housing options.

I think siblings benefit from having space away from one another even if bedrooms are small or subdivided .

Ive been very happy with our local ‘good’ schools . There are many in our village spending out on school fees as our local school isn’t outstanding

JustMarriedBecca · 06/04/2023 16:55

Can you rent out your house now, move now into rented accommodation in your new area (quite frankly you often get more rented for your money) and then move back once eldest child is in school and you have the 40 minute commute? You'd need to do it sooner I suppose to evidence the fact you are making a permanent cough move for more rural living.

That is, of course, only on the basis that siblings rank higher than other pupils in catchment (they do at some of our local schools, not others).

Otherwise, if the issue is the middle school for two years, I'd probably sit tight with tutoring and go to a good high school.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 06/04/2023 16:53

I'm really on the fence here. As a child half your life is school and the other half home, so which do you prioritise?

I think the best compromise is to stay where you are and counteract the poor teaching at middle school with home learning and extra tutoring.

BUT if the problem with the middle school extends to rampant bullying, that would be a definite no no.

BananasinPyhamas · 06/04/2023 16:47

FlounderingFruitcake · 05/04/2023 17:13

It depends why the middle school is so bad but if the high school is average then I’d strongly consider staying put and doing tutors and extra curriculars (presuming there’s money for these since private was vaguely considered).

This. You'd be Nuts to move.

riotlady · 06/04/2023 16:45

We chose a 2 bed near an excellent school vs a 3 bed near a less good school. We’re hoping to extend into the loft before elders goes to high school but fortunately for us the previous owners also had 2 kids and put up a semi dividing wall in the biggest bedroom so both kids have their own private space (though not huge!) Could he an option for you? But yes I would prioritise schooling and look at extension options in a few years

Whippetlovely · 06/04/2023 16:37

What is the high school like? That is much more important than what the middle school is like IMO. When children are doing KS4 is the most important time. If that is a good school then I would stay where you are if my kids wanted to go to that school and have a bigger house. What do your children think? I let my child decide which senior school to go to, we looked at 4 , it is them that will need to go there and travel there so you should let them decide based on their own personalities and academic ability. I would look around the options and let them get a feel for it. Also speak to parents whose children go there not go by ofstead.

PeopleAreToads · 06/04/2023 16:28

If you're going to move, make sure you're 100% sure you'll get a place at the outstanding school if the catchment shrinks a bit.

We were looking to pay 30% more for a smaller house at the other end of our village because it was nearer a better school, but got gazumped and couldn't afford to match. Really glad we didn't spend the money now, because in last years admissions we wouldn't have got a place despite it being by far the closest school and being in catchment for previous years

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 06/04/2023 16:19

Internationalwomendayheadquarters · 06/04/2023 16:02

We are in the UK. Some areas still have a 3 tier system. First school ages 5-8, middle school ages 8-12, then high school 12-16.

I don’t think it’s that common anymore, but it’s the situation where we live. Our middle school is poor but we’re not in catchment for any of the full primary schools, which take them up to high school age. It’s a big issue here.

I think this is part of the issue for middle schools as well- they're uncommon, so heads/leadership teams/teachers don't know how to improve them, and they can be hard to recruit for.

VickyEadieofThigh · 06/04/2023 16:17

"The outstanding school in comparison is in a very affluent area, where parents are very invested in their kids’ education and has a Sixth Form"

OP, you and I as teachers both know that it is your first point - about the affluent area in which parents are very invested in their kids' education - which is the key factor in a school being designated "Outstanding" by Ofsted. Ofsted have admitted more than once that schools in less affluent areas will rarely get 'Outstanding' purely because of the disadvantages suffered by children in comparison.

I was one such disadvantaged child - I had to share a room with a much younger sibling until I was 16 and consequently had nowhere quiet to work - and the impact on my O level results was obvious. I got my own room just after starting L6th and my A levels were stellar. I can honestly say that having my own space to work in was extremely important in my A level success and - obviously - what happened to me thereafter.

My nieces went to a school that plummeted from 'Outstanding' to 'Inadequate' whilst they were there. The younger one took herself out to another one for A levels and interestingly - despite getting very good GCSEs - she has received better offers from all the (RG) universities to which she has applied purely because she went to a school in a category for GCSEs!

MrsKHunt · 06/04/2023 16:16

WildAloofRebel · 05/04/2023 17:16

They loved going to school with their friends around

Rurally though your friends ARENT around. Our school catchment was enormous and therefore friends lived between 10 and 30 min drive away for example.

Around as in at the same school @WildAloofRebel

toomuchlaundry · 06/04/2023 16:13

When were the last inspections?

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 06/04/2023 16:09

Internationalwomendayheadquarters · 06/04/2023 15:30

Quite surprised by some of the results here.

I’d have thought more people would prioritise a decent education over a big house. Thank you for replies- definitely got us thinking.

We viewed a smaller house in the perfect area today. There were lots of open spaces nearby for the kids to run around in, but I think winter could be less fun. Kitchen was teeny tiny.

We might have to go for a less desirable new build style property…

OP, you say you're a teacher, and I am too. I think most parents who aren't teachers don't get the situation in education right now. You can see it on a lot of the threads about teacher strikes too.

Academy conversion won't magically turn around a long term failing school, and in some cases can make things worse (staff turnover, etc). Schools can change a lot, quickly, in terms of getting worse, but it's getting harder and harder to improve schools with issues because it's hard to attract staff.

If you know the other school, and know it's a lot better, I would move.

If there's 5 years between your daughters, then likely the eldest will be at uni by the time the younger one is a teen? Or look for somewhere with potential to extend?

Internationalwomendayheadquarters · 06/04/2023 16:02

Whippetlovely · 06/04/2023 15:36

What is a middle school? I thought there was either infants and junior then senior schools or primary then senior or are you American?

We are in the UK. Some areas still have a 3 tier system. First school ages 5-8, middle school ages 8-12, then high school 12-16.

I don’t think it’s that common anymore, but it’s the situation where we live. Our middle school is poor but we’re not in catchment for any of the full primary schools, which take them up to high school age. It’s a big issue here.

OP posts:
upwefly · 06/04/2023 15:57

Family of 5 in a 3 bed semi? No I wouldn't do that. If the high school was bad maybe, but it's average and it's just the one school that's problematic, which I am sure you can make up for with tutoring etc if necessary. I would either move for the house AND the schools (as we did) or I would stay put in a comfortable house and invest where the school misses out on; extra curriculars etc. Don't underestimate the importance of a comfortable home for wellbeing etc, not to mention the upheaval on kids to move.

Tarantellah · 06/04/2023 15:50

I intend to move for school catchment in a few years. The secondary schools near me are dire and I don’t want my own kids to have the same terrible experience I had. I know first hand how a bad school experience affects your entire life. I still feel afraid of people who are dressed like my abusers, and I have a panic attack if I hear a sound like the alarm which used to wake me up for school.

Similar to you, we’ll be giving up a 4 bed with garden to move into a 3 bed semi. It’ll mean a 30 minute drive back to the primary school every day for the final year, so we’re in catchment to apply to secondary at the right time. As soon as both kids are established in the school we’ll probably move again, out of catchment to a bigger house.

Swipe left for the next trending thread