Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner 5 years won't buy a house with me but says I should buy on my own...

314 replies

spinandspaghetti · 05/04/2023 16:06

This is the first time I've posted but this is a question that is really starting to affect me and I'd love some perspective on whether I'm being overly sensitive/unreasonable or if something really is up here...

Sorry in advance for the long post!

We are in a very fortunate position in that we are now in a financial position to buy a flat. My parents can loan us some money, I have savings for a deposit and we both work full time so we can get the mortgage we need for a half decent place. I am keen to buy somewhere together for both financial and emotional reasons. We are both in our early 30s and I am fed up after 10 years of expensive and insecure renting. Our mortgage repayments would be less than our current rent and of course we’d be contributing towards something tangible. I would also love to choose our own place together, decorate and build a home as partners - somewhere we could start a family. I don’t feel particularly settled in London whereas he grew up here and I think having a place of our own would really help me to feel more secure and grounded.

He on the other hand doesn’t want to buy a place. He’s happy renting and keeping our finances separate. He says he would prefer to save up some more and get a better place a few years down the line. He thinks buying is risky and likes the flexibility of renting. These reasons don’t really make sense to me - we aren't after flexibility, we’re not looking to move around as we both have career commitments here that will last minimum 3 years and even if house prices drop, we'll have saved by not renting? I’m also not getting any younger and would like to start a family in the not too distant future. His response to this is always just, “I’ve made my position clear” which is really frustrating...

I wonder whether the real reason is he’s worried about long-term commitment with me or doesn’t like the idea of taking my parent’s money. He assures me these aren’t the reasons and has encouraged me to buy on my own because he can see how much I’m beginning to resent renting. We have now found ourselves in a weird position where I am buying a place (with a smaller budget) on my own and he will be renting from me. I understand how we’ve got here because it seems to be a compromise - he’s still renting, I’m still buying - but I just feel really confused, alone and sad about the whole thing. He would rather rent from me and have no stake in the flat than buy as partners? He also says he wants to get married but wants to make sure we’ve done everything we can to “reduce the risk” first as he’s concerned with the statistics around divorce being among the most stressful life events. He never brings that conversation up though and I’ve stopped asking what ‘reduce the risk’ actually looks like.

What should I do? Do I let this all go and try to be happy with the compromise we’ve taken or is this a sign of bigger problems to come?

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 06/04/2023 06:46

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

This along with your comment that he is from London and feels grounded there makes more sense to me. I genuinely don't think the house thing necessarily has anything to do with not wanting to commit to you (seems there may be wider issues there though). As someone who grew up in social housing in London, I also understand him not wanting to rush into the stress of home ownership in London. I think it shows a disconnect in your backgrounds in you thinking that him "growing up around wealth" would make him more interested in buying... buying a flat in London, while horrendously expensive, isn't a real delineator between rich and poor in London (there are plenty of rich people who rent and even some poor people who own) and I can understand him wanting to prioritise disposable income with that background. There will always be housing available to you both if you are doing well but everyday cashflow can be hit by unexpected expenses (tripley moreover if you own a flat in London).
I'm not saying he's right but I can see his POV on the housing situation given i have a similar background and ubderstand his higher priority of other financial goals as opposed to buying somewhere as a sign of wealth and "putting down roots" when you clearly are not struggling for housing. It might not make sense to a lot of people who had family houses growing up, and there is clear financial benefit long term to owning.... but I can understand his position.

MouseMama · 06/04/2023 06:42

You’re getting a lot of frank advice about moving on and finding someone else because so many of us have been in your shoes. I was 28 and in a long term relationship with arbitrary reasons and hoops to jump through before the guy would commit. Someone unhelpfully told me that if I ditched him, I’d be left “on the shelf”. I told my brother that and he scoffed that it’s a ton better to be on a shelf than in a trolley going nowhere 😂

I did ditch the guy and fell in love with someone else. It was such a different feeling being with someone who was equally committed. Getting engaged and buying a home together just happened naturally, we both wanted it.

After five years with your guy I think you’re entitled to ask if that trolley is going anywhere and some movement towards buying a home or getting engaged. If you’re basically at the same stage you were 5 years ago then it’s been fun but it’s probably now time to find a life partner.

LicoriceComfit · 06/04/2023 06:38

You want a family, security, and are in your 30s - he’s stringing you along. Sorry

Inthesamesinkingboat · 06/04/2023 06:37

My ex was always ‘I want kids, but not right now’ or ‘yes a few years down the line’. When I was 37 and we’d been together 7 years he was still saying that and I realised I’d spent 7 years of my life with a man who was just keeping me on the hook.

we owned out place together so if took months to unpick as we stayed living together whilst the property was sold.

this guy sounds like his stringing you along, so maybe not tying yourself to him financially isn’t such a bad thing. But really do speak with a good solicitor about protecting the house as yours only, make sure he doesn’t have a claim and that you can evict him with relative ease in the future should things go south.

you do not want him paying rent to you for two years and then trying to claw some of that back if he leaves or claiming he needs proper notice to go.

if you do buy somewhere together in the future, I assume at that point you will be able to put in more because of this and you’ve got on the ladder earlier, again protect your stake- don’t be dragged into any ‘but we did it together’ or ‘it was me paying you rent that allowed you to get there’

also if he is taking a purely selfish approach and making the best financial decisions for him, you make the best for you. Buying is sensible, it gives you security, allows you to pay into something, and stops property inflation running away from you. Don’t for a second be put off because of him

Aprilx · 06/04/2023 06:34

tara66 · 06/04/2023 06:27

He can make a claim to any property you buy if he lives in it for over 2 years anyway - you know that ? He may know it too. So he does not have to buy any house with you.

Where did you dream that? Honest you read some nonsense on here.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 06/04/2023 06:31

Yes. Frankly, I'd get my ducks in a row, move out when he's at work and leave a note saying "It's just not working. Good luck." with my half of the next month's rent. 🤷‍♀️

tara66 · 06/04/2023 06:27

He can make a claim to any property you buy if he lives in it for over 2 years anyway - you know that ? He may know it too. So he does not have to buy any house with you.

olympicsrock · 06/04/2023 06:14

Oh OP , I’ve been the white atheist girlfriend of a black doctor with the Christian background. Everyone loved him , such a ‘good guy’. It turns out that I was the placemarker, the convenient sex and company until he found the right black christian girl to marry and have a family with ( he told me arranged marriage) and it happened very quickly after he broke up with me. He also never promised committment and so morally he felt that he hadn’t done anything wrong.

I’m going to make a huge generalization , but if he’s nigerian there is a culture for dodgy ‘business’ dealings alongside medicine. Money is hugely important to this group of men.

Listen when he tells you who he is - he has made his position clear , he does not want to commit his future with you. So sorry…

Goodread1 · 06/04/2023 06:07

He just like security of having someone like you in his life,
He doesn't want to give that Aspect of being in a relationship up that quickly,
He is very comfortable with this arrangement,
As he hasn't losed anything , as he still renting,

I think he could just be stringing you along till something better comes along

Goodread1 · 06/04/2023 05:59

He has either got shafted financially before in some significant way for e.g through a relationship that didn't work out, but he is keeping you in the Dark, about this,
Or
Has some financiall issues he doesn't want you to know about,

Or
He just not as into you, as you are, hoping he would be , in a way involves being with you in which starting a family etc entails this,

Or
He is commit phobic, through past experiences or otherwise, he has seriously cold feet about commits about major life events such as moving into a new place, getting officially engaged married and children,,

He is just happy / content (satisfied though just to coast along, for things to stay just as they are, not progress in any way,

sadlp · 06/04/2023 05:47

It sounds as if you are slightly in denial. The lack of acceptance from his mother is probably holding him back to be honest.
He is a doctor but at which stage of training? Salaries are not very high!
Also kids in a few years??? That doesn’t sound too convincing. Please consider your age in the decision that you make. As you know, there is a ticking clock when it comes to fertility and after 5 years together, he should be able to give you a more concrete answer.
What I have learned about men over the years is: If they want to, they will not hesitate.
probably wouldn’t go as far as saying that he is bad news but you clearly aren’t on the same page.

ZirihePevzig · 06/04/2023 05:42

Don't marry him and don't get pregnant by him.

but most especially don't get pregnant by him without marrying him.

this guy is bad news and you can't fix him. you want different things and he is canny enough to make sure you are the one shafted and he can be risk free.

if you get pg then when the going gets tough (as it always does sooner or later but grownups who make commitments work through it and find a new balance) he will be commitment free and able to walk away leaving you with childcare arrangements you can't manage on your own and unable to square the circle with your mortgage payment no longer affordable on your own because so much of your salary is going on childcare.

avoid. dump. find a grownup whose life is on the same page as yours.

JacobsCrackersCheeseFogg · 06/04/2023 05:35

He's hiding something about his finances. My spidey senses are tingling.

LBFseBrom · 06/04/2023 05:27

MeMyBooksAndMyCats · 05/04/2023 16:25

I would end the relationship, he's keeping his options open.

Yes. He wants no ties. If he is renting he can go when he feels like it, not so easy when you jointly own a property.

Snugglemonkey · 06/04/2023 05:26

I am sorry everyone is so negative op, I appreciate it is hard to hear. Please do hear it though because you are not his partner. He is not willing to partner you. You are his girlfriend and he does not want to commit. You are in danger of wasting your fertile years, while he can sit until being with you becomes too stressful because you are wanting more. Then he will leave and do all the things you want, with someone his mother approves of. You may have lost your chance to have children by then.

Tradeup · 06/04/2023 05:20

Buy a flat and do NOT move him in.

chopc · 06/04/2023 04:47

OP almost everyone in this thread is telling you to run. Hopefully once you have had time to process you will be able to make your position clear to him.

Having been in a similar relationship I can tell you he is not a keeper. The fact you haven't met his mum after five years suggest you may never do so

Pattydale · 06/04/2023 04:44

Wnikat · 05/04/2023 16:38

He’ll string you along until you’re 39 then dump you, then six months later you’ll find out he’s having a baby with someone else

Sorry to say but I've seen this before too many times for it to be just a cliche.

JocelynBurnell · 06/04/2023 04:39

Bloodyhellisthisit · 05/04/2023 19:36

This is very good advice ^^

You can look at this situation two ways…

  1. He is being clear and honest about what he wants right now. He is helping to make sure that his current desires do not trump yours - you still get to buy and have the security you are craving. He’s not creating an ultimatum, he is proposing a reasonable compromise - he perceives this as a step towards something more concrete in future, but he isn’t at the stage of committing to that future yet. This is a reasonable interim measure and it’s great to be with someone who is honest and doesn’t want to hold you back but in fact supports your dreams and your personal financial security and well being. Who knows what the future brings but this seems like a good way forward right now.
  2. He has no intention of staying with you long term, isn’t that into you, has persuaded you to buy alone so he can walk out the door whenever he wants and fully intends to do so. He just suggested you buy alone to stop you going on about this situation. You should immediately dump him because what you want right now isn’t what he wants right now.

The truth is probably a bit more nuanced than the above but what is true is that buying as a single woman DOES put you in an incredibly strong position in the rest of your life. The fact that he supports this suggests he does care about your well-being and whether you end up spending the rest of your life with him or not, you will look back on this as a watershed moment for your independence. Being with someone who supports that is nothing to be sniffed at whatever the eventual outcome.

He is not ready to commit and once you’ve found your flat you should talk about that honestly and you need to put a clock (whether shared or not) on how long you’ll give the situation before you reassess the relationship. Maybe he just needs a bit of time - 30 is still quite young. But if you get to 32, say, and he’s still not committed then he probably isn’t going to and you don’t want to waste your time yadda yadda.

Most importantly right now, do the following. Stress test your mortgage payment so you know you could manage if he wasn’t paying rent.
GET LEGAL ADVICE. Make sure you sign a legal agreement regarding your arrangement and his financial entitlement (if any) if he moves in and pay rent and then you split up. My understanding is that this is more complex than you might imagine - it’s not like having a flatmate. Don’t just wing this on the advice of the internet - go to a solicitor, with your parents ideally or a trusted and smart friend, and figure out the best way for your folks to protect their gift to you in the long term and the best way for you to protect the asset as well. (This might include ring fencing it if you marry, but you should certainly be ringfencing everything your parents have put in and your own investment)

This issue, of how not to get ultimately clobbered by mistake, is one reason that single women often end up letting their partners live rent free - because the idea of being stuck with a court case/massive bill when you split up is just too much to risk. So DO NOT SKIP THIS STEP. That also applies if you split up and you ever consider moving a different boyfriend in. Legal advice and paperwork EVERY time please!!

Be glad you found a guy who, while he might now want the same thing as you right now (and may turn out never to want it), is reasonable and does care about you enough to help make sure you get yourself in a secure position you can build on, regardless of your relationship status.

Know your own worth and what you want. Try and be honest with your boyfriend and yourself in future if your plans diverge.

Congratulate yourself on being able to buy your own flat!! 🍾🎉🥳 Thank your parents and your lucky stars that you’re in this position!!

(And think VERY carefully in future if you are ever tempted to give up this piece of independence. If you don’t understand why, then just search mumsnet threads on people wanting to leave their partners and observe how many are hamstrung by having nowhere to go/living in their partners’ home/not being able to afford to go it alone once they have children. There are thousands of cautionary tales on here and most people don’t have the luxury of creating some protection for themselves)

Good luck!

Best advice on this thread by a country mile.

landbeforegrime · 06/04/2023 04:30

It's difficult because i don't think he's necessarily stringing you along deliberately and he probably justifies to himself that it's not the right time / i need more money to make sure my children have stability etc. but the reality is that he's not committing to you or your future and that is because he's not ready or does not think it is right. there's no guarantee he will ever change or feel ready and i do think that if he wanted this he would know and work towards making it happen. he shouldn't feel comfortable being a lodger in your home, he should want to make it a home jointly. he doesn't appear to know what he wants and that could very well mean that he doesn't know if he wants you. he may not realise that but his actions are showing a lack of commitment. sadly if you want children time is not on your side and you can't really afford to sit around and wait to see if and when he changes his tune so honestly, i think you need to put yourself first and move on so you can find someone who knows they want to have a future with you and is able to act on it. i think the right person for you would be making more solid plans with you at this point.

Guavafish1 · 06/04/2023 04:27

I won't risk your fertility years on your current partner. 5 years is enough time to buy a place, marry and have children.

Definitely buy your own place, it will help you in the long run with property ladder.

Unfortunately your expectations are not line together currently. You'll have to wait.. but it's a risk.

Appleblum · 06/04/2023 04:06

It sounds like he doesn't think he'll marry you, especially after your update about his family/mom.

HomeTheatreSystem · 06/04/2023 03:53

OP, be very careful that you don't end up losing money to this guy in the event your relationship doesn't work out. You are in a very good position now but you are at risk of losing quite a bit if he lives with you and contributes towards the house. Please get proper legal advice to protect yourself here. Also, he doesn't want to go against his mum's wishes hence the steep savings goals: he's keeping himself free to walk away from you easily as and when needed.

evuscha · 06/04/2023 03:42

I have to agree with the majority here, he doesn’t see a future with you. For someone risk averse it’s unlikely he would marry a “white atheist” when his mother doesn’t approve. The fact she hasn’t met you also doesn’t look good. I’m sorry, I know it’s hard to leave an otherwise pleasant relationship but if you’re in your 30’s then you don’t want to waste any more time.

JavaQ · 06/04/2023 03:36

LT(B)
Do NOT rent to him as he will be a cocklodger before you know it

Buy your own place.

Dont live your life on someone else’s terms!!
You can buy your own flowers…

Swipe left for the next trending thread