Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner 5 years won't buy a house with me but says I should buy on my own...

314 replies

spinandspaghetti · 05/04/2023 16:06

This is the first time I've posted but this is a question that is really starting to affect me and I'd love some perspective on whether I'm being overly sensitive/unreasonable or if something really is up here...

Sorry in advance for the long post!

We are in a very fortunate position in that we are now in a financial position to buy a flat. My parents can loan us some money, I have savings for a deposit and we both work full time so we can get the mortgage we need for a half decent place. I am keen to buy somewhere together for both financial and emotional reasons. We are both in our early 30s and I am fed up after 10 years of expensive and insecure renting. Our mortgage repayments would be less than our current rent and of course we’d be contributing towards something tangible. I would also love to choose our own place together, decorate and build a home as partners - somewhere we could start a family. I don’t feel particularly settled in London whereas he grew up here and I think having a place of our own would really help me to feel more secure and grounded.

He on the other hand doesn’t want to buy a place. He’s happy renting and keeping our finances separate. He says he would prefer to save up some more and get a better place a few years down the line. He thinks buying is risky and likes the flexibility of renting. These reasons don’t really make sense to me - we aren't after flexibility, we’re not looking to move around as we both have career commitments here that will last minimum 3 years and even if house prices drop, we'll have saved by not renting? I’m also not getting any younger and would like to start a family in the not too distant future. His response to this is always just, “I’ve made my position clear” which is really frustrating...

I wonder whether the real reason is he’s worried about long-term commitment with me or doesn’t like the idea of taking my parent’s money. He assures me these aren’t the reasons and has encouraged me to buy on my own because he can see how much I’m beginning to resent renting. We have now found ourselves in a weird position where I am buying a place (with a smaller budget) on my own and he will be renting from me. I understand how we’ve got here because it seems to be a compromise - he’s still renting, I’m still buying - but I just feel really confused, alone and sad about the whole thing. He would rather rent from me and have no stake in the flat than buy as partners? He also says he wants to get married but wants to make sure we’ve done everything we can to “reduce the risk” first as he’s concerned with the statistics around divorce being among the most stressful life events. He never brings that conversation up though and I’ve stopped asking what ‘reduce the risk’ actually looks like.

What should I do? Do I let this all go and try to be happy with the compromise we’ve taken or is this a sign of bigger problems to come?

OP posts:
Raindropsonuebells · 06/04/2023 12:17

I hope you are OK OP . These threads are tough , there are lots of ladies on here with at lot of life experience who have seen this scenario play out again and again . It’s your life though and your emotions and it hurts . I hope though that what ever you decide that you are a little more cute in your dealings with him and more forceful about what you want from your future . It is not all about what he wants .

DemonSpawn · 06/04/2023 10:57

When he wants kids and marriage he will find someone of his own race/colour imho.

DemonSpawn · 06/04/2023 10:54

He just sees you as a short term girlfriend I’m afraid. No future.

Merryoldgoat · 06/04/2023 10:45

This is a disaster waiting to happen frankly.

You’ll have kids, his mother will want to build bridges and then you’ll have a life of bollocks trying to manage the toxicity.

SmallAngryPenguinWoman · 06/04/2023 10:38

I really hope you listen to the wise ones of MN @spinandspaghetti. One day he'll leave you and marry a woman his mother does approve of, who he has been dating for 6 months. If you want children, don't waste your precious fertile years on him, waiting for him to "be ready".

Hankunamatata · 06/04/2023 09:56

Ypu want children then I'd discuss time line with him. That you start trying in the next year or its over.

Goldenbear · 06/04/2023 09:51

I am 10 years older than you (at least) so things may be different now but I would say his statement to you says it all and his actions back that up.

I have been lambasted for this on other threads but love and passion for a relationship that drives the will to commit to someone and want babies is imperative for this to happen. My DH and I met and had our first baby within 2 years, he was 25 when my son was born and still finishing his part III to become an Architect. DH was the one driving this and was the one who sorted buying our first property, i.e he couldn't move out of the rented market quick enough. Like you we did have parental help. We didn't marry straight away but that wasn't hesitation on his part, it was about lack of money after our second DC and wanting to move to a house from a flat rather than paying for a wedding. We then had enough for a wedding we wanted with quite a few guests. I was engaged though.

Onegingerhead · 06/04/2023 09:48

While I fully agree the man isn’t into OP, keeping his options open and is very, very, very unlikely to ever commit to her, do people really think she is going to dump him because the collective mind of MN told her to do so?
It is sad tho, but I don’t think the man will get a boot. We (women) tend to hold on to a hope.

greenel · 06/04/2023 09:43

Ah the mother not accepting you is the issue, no matter what he says.

When he says it isn't the reason, he means the opinion doesn't bother him enough to break up, but it bothers him enough to not make a big financial or emotional commitment.

My DP' mum didn't like me and despite what he said I know it was the reason he dragged his feet on commitment. Until I made a bit of effort with her and we reached a truce for his sake, then he magically speeded up the whole process. We didn't have religious issues though, just personality clash so it was easier. And I do understand it, when you're younger it's easier to thumb family, for some men with age they care more about the repercussions.

Unless his mum accepts you and he makes an effort to build that truce between you, he won't commit. The fact it's cultural, I can't see her changing her mind given she won't even meet you. And deep down there is probably a part of him wondering if choosing someone from his own culture (who presumably wouldn't divorce for religious reasons) is a safer bet than an aetheist who might. I know how the more conservative cultures think.

If you've not resolved these problems in 5 years, it's unlikely you ever will. Buy your flat, do it up for yourself then find a partner who is excited and eager to commit to you.

moveoverye · 06/04/2023 09:35

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/04/2023 16:11

Also you’re probably better off buying on your own anyway. You get to keep everything.

Be careful and check this is the case. Probably a good idea to get legal advice. Somebody told me recently that you no longer have to be married in order to benefit in the case of a split.
I don’t know how true that is, but check.

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 06/04/2023 09:34

Honestly, you sound like you're his convenient relationship. There's nothing wrong with you, but you're not the woman he'd marry and have children with.

5 years on and he's still purposefully stringing you along.

If you're happy to be in a relationship of convenience but no long term commitment then continue with your plans to buy a property and have him pay rent like a lodger

If you want your future to have the chance of marriage and children I think you'd be better off buying a property and ending the relationship.

Azerothi · 06/04/2023 09:29

I think your boyfriend is doing exactly the right thing by you. He doesn't want to marry or share any commitment and has made his position clear. If you stay with this current boyfriend he will never allow you to have children with him and he definitely won't marry you as he doesn't see a future with you by his side.

You need to think about your real options, do you want to remain his girlfriend with no commitment, either emotional or financial, or children for the rest of your life?

Stravaig · 06/04/2023 09:15

Finances. Can you cover the mortgage on your own? Or will you have to rent to someone? Do you have a room to rent? Are you happy to share your home with a lodger?

Relationship. I wouldn't 'rent' to your partner. All that does is add a landlord-lodger power dynamic to an already murky and mismatched relationship, where he wants a girlfriend and housemate and you want a husband and father for your children. It will skew every relationship interaction, and make it harder to end the relationship cleanly. He loses his home; you, your ability to pay the mortgage: this will not promote clear decision making.

Decision time. Are you happy to continue the relationship whilst living apart from your partner, after renting together for 4 years? Or is it time to accept that what you have now is all there is, it is the truth of the two of you together. You need to move on if you want more.

Hillary17 · 06/04/2023 09:07

I’m really sorry to say this, but he’s never going to marry you. This man doesn’t imagine his future with you or he wouldn’t be considering risks and how to get out. I’d buy the flat but absolutely do not let him live with you. Why should he benefit from your financial decisions if he’s not willing to commit?

anyolddinosaur · 06/04/2023 09:06

Does black = asian? They only introduce you to their mother when they are thinking marriage. You havent met his mother, he is not planning to stay with you for life.

Sorry to join the chorus but this is not going to end as you want and you are wasting your fertile years on him. Move on, dont let him move in.

moomoomoo27 · 06/04/2023 09:05

You don't want to buy in a place you don't feel settled and don't want to live.

The price drops are irrelevant - they will drop more, but as you say it's cheaper than rent and also in the long term they will be up.

Are you sure you'd get approved for a mortgage on your own? As banks much prefer couples so there's a higher threshold to meet if it's just you. Also got to factor in all the extra costs of owning leasehold if it's a flat.

It's also not forever, you could sell in 5 years and do what you want.

Don't have kids with the wrong person - there are very viable options available to women today. Frozen eggs often have a 90% success rate if you have enough done and you don't have fertility problems. And that way you're adding probably a decade on to your time if not more. If you're early 30s ideally you want to do it before 36, but even that probably gives you a few more years than what you were originally thinking.

Scottishgirl85 · 06/04/2023 09:05

I'd be very wary. He can't commit to a house in your early 30s. How the heck will he commit to kids? I suspect you'll get to mid-30s and he'll still be asking for just a few more years....

easterbunnysbum · 06/04/2023 09:04

I think it's sensible to not financially tie yourself to someone.

There's always a change you could split up. People who are in love, get married, have a family, live together another 10 years after the children are grown up, still split up at some point (yes people also stay together but the possibility is always there that something will change)

Even if he loves you now, you could change, he could change, your needs or wants could change as could his.

He's sensible to know this. And I do mean "know" because that is true, it could always happen.

At that point if it does he doesn't want to be having to hire lawyers, reportage, find money to buy you out, prolong agony, and why would he?

And he shouldn't have to.

nopayagain · 06/04/2023 09:00

So he wants you to buy and presumably for him to move there? He sounds like a 20 year old with his non committal attitude to both you and life. I would be reassessing my relationship with him.

Makesense12 · 06/04/2023 08:57

Op, it may sound callous of me but just enjoy what you have.
The perfect lodger for "now" and I hope you charge him full rent incl bills and make the most of that financial input!

Do not let him skimp and live off you. You gave him the opportunity to share this investment and he turned it down.

madamovaries · 06/04/2023 08:55

You have been together 5 years - he should know by now if you are the right person for him. This will be really hard, but I think you should break up with him. He just isn't sufficiently committed to a future with you. Frankly, you deserve better.

I would buy the flat, rent out the second room (if there is one) to someone else, and when you're ready, start dating again. I was really worried about being single at 30 (and stayed too long in a relationship that wasn't working out for this reason), but it's not a big deal. I am now 38, married to an amazing man, with a son and a second on the way. Please don't waste your 30s on someone who doesn't value your time.

ForestOfTea · 06/04/2023 08:55

He’s a doctor. Does this mean he also works funny shifts and has a ready made excuse whenever he doesn’t want to do something (or wants to do something without you?)

This career, along with having not met his mum after 5 yrs, makes alarm bells ring for me.

sorry OP, I’m with the run fast and run far group.

SittingNextToIt · 06/04/2023 08:52

SittingNextToIt · 06/04/2023 08:50

This must be very hard to read and even harder to genuinely accept.

but -

  1. His mother will never accept a white woman as her daughter in law.
  2. his mother will never accept mixed-race grandchildren
  3. He will ultimately, and very suddenly, one day, “in a few years time” dump you and find an alternative that keeps mum happy. Men have done this since time immemorial.
  4. At that point “in a few years time” your fertility will have declined rapidly possibly.

It’s a sunk investment scenario isn’t it - you feel you’ve already invested X and Y - why not stay/change his mind - otherwise X and Y have been such a waste.

But you haven’t wasted your tomorrow. Yet. Your tomorrow is still all yours. Please act now.

And if you notice I haven’t mentioned house buying once in my reply to you. My instincts didn’t even get to the house issue. Do you see what that tells you? The house issue is immaterial except for being a huge flashing red sign asking you to turn around now
.

don’t give up your tomorrow.

SittingNextToIt · 06/04/2023 08:50

spinandspaghetti · 05/04/2023 18:00

They aren't super close though he is close to his siblings who seem supportive. He will visit her on mother's day and her birthday and call to check in but from what I've overheard they have a very polite relationship - the way I might speak to a great aunt or something. She's never met me so I'm not taking the rejection personally!

This must be very hard to read and even harder to genuinely accept.

but -

  1. His mother will never accept a white woman as her daughter in law.
  2. his mother will never accept mixed-race grandchildren
  3. He will ultimately, and very suddenly, one day, “in a few years time” dump you and find an alternative that keeps mum happy. Men have done this since time immemorial.
  4. At that point “in a few years time” your fertility will have declined rapidly possibly.

It’s a sunk investment scenario isn’t it - you feel you’ve already invested X and Y - why not stay/change his mind - otherwise X and Y have been such a waste.

But you haven’t wasted your tomorrow. Yet. Your tomorrow is still all yours. Please act now.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 06/04/2023 08:50

You say the issue is just the buying of the place and that he wants to have children in a few years but the issue of children is not something you’re addressing now like the buying of property. I’ll bet in a few years things will change with children and there will be more reasons (and years added) as to why you can’t have them.