Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Over paying Mortgages

464 replies

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 14:06

AIBU to find those that over pay their mortgages smug?
Moat people can just about afford or want to pay the standard monthly payments. Let alone want to use any more money/ savings on it !!
Why worry about paying off when in 20 years your probably get some form of lump sum anyway

OP posts:
Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 05/04/2023 23:24

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 17:48

Example that I know.. they purchased interest only mortgage house worth 160k maybe 35 years ago.
Not paid a penny just interest.. but house is now worth 800k or more.
Had more money to lead a certain lifestyle and not be hard up in years gone by.

But borrowing 160k over 35 years at say an average interest rate of 5% (generous as historically been much higher) they’ll have repaid 280k in interest and still owe 160k

if they had repaid it over 20years at 5% they’d have paid 93k in interest and owe nothing

I know which one makes more economic sense to me @Aquarius1234

Curiosity101 · 05/04/2023 22:53

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 22:35

How did you go from 30 to 13?
Lump sum ?

Presumably through lower interest rates whilst maintaining the same monthly amount. So effectively overpaying without calling it overpaying? Ordinarily if you don't change anything and the interest rate drops then your monthly payments drop, but if you shorten the term with a lower interest rate then your monthly payments have to increase (but only to the same as they were before if you adjust your mortgage term appropriately).

Personally we choose to keep our term the same and keep overpaying instead with the theory that if our finances change massively then we can always cancel the overpayment. Where as renewing with a shorter term (so effectively tying yourself into overpayments) means you don't have that flexibility.

Have you ever looked at overpayment calculators OP? https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/mortgages/mortgage-overpayment-calculator/

Even if you use the default values on there you'll see that with those example numbers a £200 monthly overpayment drops the overall mortgage term by over 8 years. Even £50 extra a month drops it by over 2 years. At the end of the day people decide what they want to prioritise their spending on. But I don't see why it's smug if you have 'extra' money and use it to overpay a mortgage vs spending that money on holidays/things now.

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 22:35

Cafog · 05/04/2023 22:27

So am I smug? I don't overpay but every time my fixed rate ends and I look for new deal I try and shave a few extra years off. So 10 years ago my mortgage term was 30years, now it's 13. Payments roughtly £100 more than they were back then. Interest rates went our way. Will be much more difficult to do the same when when this deal ends in a years time. Not high earners at all.

How did you go from 30 to 13?
Lump sum ?

OP posts:
Saniflo · 05/04/2023 22:30

I pay an extra £75 a week. I am not smug as who else would know I am paying it? Not something I discuss at work or down the pub.

Cafog · 05/04/2023 22:27

So am I smug? I don't overpay but every time my fixed rate ends and I look for new deal I try and shave a few extra years off. So 10 years ago my mortgage term was 30years, now it's 13. Payments roughtly £100 more than they were back then. Interest rates went our way. Will be much more difficult to do the same when when this deal ends in a years time. Not high earners at all.

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 21:29

mmoossee · 05/04/2023 20:57

The interest rate won't change, but the amount of interest you pay will reduce. You can reduce the monthly payments if you pay off larger amounts of the mortgage, but then you won't get the benefit of shortening the term of the mortgage and reducing the amount of interest you pay overall.

To get the real benefit of overpaying, you need to keep the payment the same and reduce the term.

Right okay slowly getting there.

OP posts:
FilthyforFirth · 05/04/2023 20:58

This is the same OP who thinks everyone in a couple is automtically smug. They are jealous of absolutely everyone, I wouldnt waste your time!

mmoossee · 05/04/2023 20:57

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 18:45

If you've already agreed and signed to a new interest rate and monthly repayment.
Does that mean it can't change even if you over pay something.

The interest rate won't change, but the amount of interest you pay will reduce. You can reduce the monthly payments if you pay off larger amounts of the mortgage, but then you won't get the benefit of shortening the term of the mortgage and reducing the amount of interest you pay overall.

To get the real benefit of overpaying, you need to keep the payment the same and reduce the term.

LT2 · 05/04/2023 20:56

Also, we first started overpaying years ago with the intention for me to be a SAHM, or to be comfortable enough for me to work Part-time. That was before any children came along. Now the first child is here I'm happy we've done that as part-time work is working out nicely for me as i'm still working and at home with my little boy! Best of both worlds. You really haven't thought of all the 'whys' as to overpaying. There are lots of different reasons and circumstances. Mine was to be at home with my children and see them grow up.

mmoossee · 05/04/2023 20:51

TBOM · 05/04/2023 18:01

OMG nobody can possibly actually be this thick????? Because if they are, we really need to get better at teaching children about finances in school.

On a serious note, we do actually need to get better at teaching finances at school. When I was at school, they only gave any finance/life skills training to the teenagers who weren't seen as able to take GCSE History/Geography as part of that option, it was called Life Skills and taken alongside a certificate in history/geography or something similar. Everyone should learn life skills, as the starting point for this thread demonstrates.

newbiebewbie · 05/04/2023 20:50

We overpay but actually it’s nothing to be smug about for us because it means we still live in our first house because we’ve not been successful in trying to buy a new house which is big enough for us so our mortgage payment is stupidly small compared to our income.

ladybug93 · 05/04/2023 20:49

Some people also just have more money so more to spend, more to save or invest and more to pay off their mortgage with!

LT2 · 05/04/2023 20:48

We still live our life - go on holiday, get takeaways, buy alcohol and other luxuries. We are tight in other areas. I'd agree that you should still live your life happily first. We do both that and overpay here. And, yes, just average paying jobs!

dew141 · 05/04/2023 20:48

I guess you do know that the maximum interest tax-free earned below the higher rate taxpayer is on £1000 pounds maximum? And higher rate it is 500 pounds maximum

I do know that, I was trying not to make it too complicated.

Mine is in a stocks and shares ISA so is income and capital gains tax free. If you don't like investing in equities, you're a higher rate tax payer and used up your savings allowance, you'd have to weigh up your mortgage interest rate v a cash ISA (which are typically lower rates than the leading savings rates).

My only point was that people don't seem to factor in the lost potential return on the overpayment money. They're doing a one-sided calculation which is less interest paid = better.

In answer to the repayment mortgage question, I'm not sure. I'm guessing the interest rate is still the key factor but I'm not particularly au fait with how that affects the capital repayment part of those mortgages.

LT2 · 05/04/2023 20:46

YABU

We are overpaying ours off for our own benefit, not for anybody else, so no, no smugness here. It surely differs what size everybody's home is anyway. Ours is a mid-terrace (in an expensive area, mind) so therefore would be easier to pay off than if it were a large 4 bed detached. It isn't likely to be our last mortgage either. We are saving all those years of interest, so of course it is a brilliant thing to do.

Emigratingimmigrant · 05/04/2023 20:36

You can live your life while overpaying mortgage if you make sure your mortgage is small.

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 20:35

Youngishone · 05/04/2023 20:21

Having a small mortgage can be helpful for credit rating and also reduces the chance of someone stealing your house so paying it off completely doesn't have to be a priority. It's also likely that new mortgage holders won't be able to pay it off due to longer mortgage terms. With a poorer healthcare system and older retirement age it might be new mortgage holders won't get a happy retirement so I can see why people might want to prioritise other things. OTOH banks are used to people making overpayments and have mechanisms in place so should be ok op

Indeed. No point waiting years before living the life you want.
Things aren't what they used to be in the past.
Loads will work till late 60s early 70s now.

OP posts:
Youngishone · 05/04/2023 20:21

Having a small mortgage can be helpful for credit rating and also reduces the chance of someone stealing your house so paying it off completely doesn't have to be a priority. It's also likely that new mortgage holders won't be able to pay it off due to longer mortgage terms. With a poorer healthcare system and older retirement age it might be new mortgage holders won't get a happy retirement so I can see why people might want to prioritise other things. OTOH banks are used to people making overpayments and have mechanisms in place so should be ok op

ladybug93 · 05/04/2023 20:05

OP has to be a troll or just a bit of a numpty.

anythinginapinch · 05/04/2023 20:04

I wonder if the OP could advise me on what to do with my savings account?

Ourladycheesusedatum · 05/04/2023 19:56

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:30

There's a few posters on here who seem to still maintain pverpaying is better regardless.

Well yes ok saving money in a high interest account is better monetarily. But life is about more than money.
The relief I felt paying off my mortgage was huge.

Until very recently interest rates were a pittance unless you locked your money away, still to keep those rates you'd have to move the money around every year. Easy access to the savings can be very tempting, if the money is already paid towards the mortgage, theres no getting it back.

There are downsides with investing, depending how much interest you earn, the HMRC takes some, having it out of reach when you need it. It can take up a lot of time to maybe gain a few quid. Depending on what you invest in you can lose the lot. Other things that I currently cant think of.

TBOM · 05/04/2023 19:29

Porkandbeans1 · 05/04/2023 19:22

Oh do shut up OP!

You constantly contradict yourself and make very little sense at times. There are plenty of good and free resources out there, I would suggest you educate yourself. The MSE website has guides on most topics including mortgages, overpayments, LTV etc.

Indeed. Totally contradicting herself about spending money on nice things vs boring frugal people and then not having enough money to save. But I fear this comes from really simple lack of understanding of basic financial management. The OPs children will one day be posting on here asking for advice about their mother who has no savings, no retirement income and no way of paying down their mortgage because they kept extending it.

HeyItsPickleRick · 05/04/2023 19:28

I think it’s clear from your posts you don’t really understand mortgages at all. I personally don’t overpay mine and instead invest either inside or outside of my pension instead. I’ll worry random internet people thinking I’m a dull frugal type when I’ve retired early ☺️

Wishawisha · 05/04/2023 19:28

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 18:51

It's a fact of live not everyone can afford to save. Whether on 25k a year or 60k.
And some choose to spend over saving.
Not talking about me. I could only save when I lived with parents for ages.

This misses the point that household finances change over the decades that most mortgages take to pay off.

I know a few families who were financially sinking 5- 10 years a go - childcare costs were crippling and they were borrowing money from relatives just to pay for essentials. Now they are better off and able to save money and have a few more treats. They are slightly further on in their careers at 40 then they were at 30 and childcare costs are close to zero. Life changes over the years.

Just because people are comfortable and overpaying doesn’t mean they were always so comfortable. And just because you aren’t able to save money now doesn’t mean you won’t be one day.

Porkandbeans1 · 05/04/2023 19:22

Oh do shut up OP!

You constantly contradict yourself and make very little sense at times. There are plenty of good and free resources out there, I would suggest you educate yourself. The MSE website has guides on most topics including mortgages, overpayments, LTV etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread