Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Over paying Mortgages

464 replies

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 14:06

AIBU to find those that over pay their mortgages smug?
Moat people can just about afford or want to pay the standard monthly payments. Let alone want to use any more money/ savings on it !!
Why worry about paying off when in 20 years your probably get some form of lump sum anyway

OP posts:
daisychain01 · 06/04/2023 11:04

I can't believe all the mortgage horror stories on here. We booked a consultation / review of our mortgage with our provider and they gave us a full health check including our projected end date based on our monthly payments including any overpayments and also whether there were any more advantageous offers available compared to our variable rate. All free advice and really well communicated.

Why do these people make such disastrous clueless and inept financial decisions when this information is available through the mortgage provider is beyond me. It's in the bank's best interests to ensure their customers can afford their payment.

BMW6 · 06/04/2023 10:56

Back in the early 90's a sibling took out an endowment mortgage on their first property. Was going on about suckers who take on repayment mortgages when they'll have enough to pay off the capital PLUS a massive amount of £££ as well..... .

I pointed out that it was a gamble on the endowment portfolio being as golden as projected and they sneered at me.

I refrained from commenting when years later they realised the full extent of the shortfall, they nearly went under and of course had to take out a repayment mortgage.

They lost thousands and thousands compared to what they would have paid under a repayment mortgage in the first place.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 06/04/2023 10:22

ZombieMumEB · 06/04/2023 08:00

The OP reminds me of a poster I came across during the global financial crisis, and interest were high in Australia, This poster was all smug and she would often boast about how smart she was (yet her spelling was quite bad - eg used pritty instead of pretty).

They locked in for 5 years of fixed interest rates when the rates were at their highest- and she actually believed that higher interest rates meant she would pay her mortgage off faster. She loved giving everyone on the forum financial advice.

She also believed that paying extra money on the mortgage just meant the bank kept more money.

About 12 months after her house purchase - when interest rates dropped a fair bit, she needed to sell her house as her DP had lost his job - she was shocked that they'd have to pay around $60K in break costs when they sold their house - so she was in a lot of debt if they sold.

We never heard from her again.

Yiiiiiiiikes

TheOGCCL · 06/04/2023 10:08

I think it's just that some people including me value financial security above all else. A mortgage is a debt. The recent interest rate chaos hasn't been pleasant, imagine just not needing to worry about any of that.

Wenfy · 06/04/2023 09:47

Talia99 · 06/04/2023 08:46

This is where someone pretends to be the owner and ‘sells’ the house out from under the actual owner. It’s easier without a mortgage as it means there is no oversight from the mortgage company and the fraudsters have fewer documents to intercept / forge.

It’s very, very rare and putting an alert on your own address with the land registry offers much the same protection (basically if someone starts doing searches against your house when you aren’t selling it, it’s time to worry).

I work in banking. There has been an uptick in fraud related to selling properties with mortgages with fake conveyancing companies.!The impact to the owner is the same - they lose their property & have to wait for a refund. But that refund comes from the bank rather than than Land Registry and so it takes longer.

VikingsandDragons · 06/04/2023 09:42

Hohofortherobbers · 05/04/2023 14:52

Cheers, me too. We can be smug together, anyone else want to join us in the smug corner Grin

8 years early here, any advance on 8 years early?

Joining in the land of smug. 14 years early. Still in the first house we bought when we got married, our income has more than tripled since we bought though so we were able to massively overpay. Saved more than £110k in interest by doing so and have complete security that no matter what happens in the future we don't have to worry about our home.

dew141 · 06/04/2023 09:02

Absolutely but the info must come from properly trained people. My uncle teaches and said he had done some classes, telling students all investing is risky gambling, isa must be locked away for years and so on

Crikey, that's a bit concerning. In an effort to give something back. I run money management and investing courses for teenagers. It's really rewarding (on the whole!) and I hope some of those skills will help them make good financial decisions in life.

I think part of the issue is the preconception that financial matters are too hard and complex for most people to understand. Teenagers tend to have more confidence and they've produced some excellent analysis of shares and worked out income tax calculations, the best mortgage deals etc.

Mark19735 · 06/04/2023 09:01

To address the lump sum issue - many endowment mortgages had an option where a mandatory life insurance policy paid out a fixed sum during the term if you died, and also at the end of the term if you didn't. So the life insurance pays for the capital repayment.

They were more expensive than just life cover alone, and after the endowment mortgage mis-selling scandals they got withdrawn by most lenders, and they were never quite as popular as other products so it's not surprising that people don't know about them. I actually have one - committed to pay £70 / month to the life insurance company for 25 years and will get £30k in a couple of years' time. I actually overpaid the mortgage it was linked with long ago ... so this lump sum is basically free money.

Makesense12 · 06/04/2023 08:52

Uncle is least investing money savvy person I know.

Makesense12 · 06/04/2023 08:52

@mmoossee @TBOM

Absolutely but the info must come from properly trained people. My uncle teaches and said he had done some classes, telling students all investing is risky gambling, isa must be locked away for years and so on.

Talia99 · 06/04/2023 08:46

Makesense12 · 06/04/2023 08:43

@Youngishone

Could you clarify "it also reduces the chances of someone stealing your house please

This is where someone pretends to be the owner and ‘sells’ the house out from under the actual owner. It’s easier without a mortgage as it means there is no oversight from the mortgage company and the fraudsters have fewer documents to intercept / forge.

It’s very, very rare and putting an alert on your own address with the land registry offers much the same protection (basically if someone starts doing searches against your house when you aren’t selling it, it’s time to worry).

Makesense12 · 06/04/2023 08:43

First direct allows you to over pay as much as you want

Makesense12 · 06/04/2023 08:43

@Youngishone

Could you clarify "it also reduces the chances of someone stealing your house please

Talia99 · 06/04/2023 08:40

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 22:35

How did you go from 30 to 13?
Lump sum ?

If interest rates drop, you pay less each month. If you are prepared to keep paying the same amount each month, you can pay off the amount owed in a shorter period.

If you are also prepared to have a higher monthly payment, the time needed to repay is even shorter.

The above describes what @Cafog says she’s done. I’m not sure where you got a lump sum being required from her specifically saying why a lump sum wasn’t needed.

Regular overpayments do the same - the difference is that you can stop overpayments if your circumstances change. However, some mortgages don’t allow overpayments at all and most limit how much can be overpaid so it can be better to shorten the term and have a higher fixed payment.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 06/04/2023 08:11

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 22:35

How did you go from 30 to 13?
Lump sum ?

Why do you keep on going on about lump sums?

You clearly just do not understand what overpaying means or how it works.

As a pp said above, have a look at the calculator and see how it works.

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 08:01

Ourladycheesusedatum · 05/04/2023 19:56

Well yes ok saving money in a high interest account is better monetarily. But life is about more than money.
The relief I felt paying off my mortgage was huge.

Until very recently interest rates were a pittance unless you locked your money away, still to keep those rates you'd have to move the money around every year. Easy access to the savings can be very tempting, if the money is already paid towards the mortgage, theres no getting it back.

There are downsides with investing, depending how much interest you earn, the HMRC takes some, having it out of reach when you need it. It can take up a lot of time to maybe gain a few quid. Depending on what you invest in you can lose the lot. Other things that I currently cant think of.

I don't want to be pedantic, but you can pay off your mortgage with the money you save/ the interest you make from it. This would lead you to pay your mortgage off faster, currently.

I am not having a go, I'm just pointing out that overpaying mortgages seems to be considered some kind of gold standard of financial planning, when actually if you work the numbers it's not always the case and people who don't know that ought to be told that so they can make informed decisions. They are of course entitled to do exactly as they like.

ZombieMumEB · 06/04/2023 08:00

The OP reminds me of a poster I came across during the global financial crisis, and interest were high in Australia, This poster was all smug and she would often boast about how smart she was (yet her spelling was quite bad - eg used pritty instead of pretty).

They locked in for 5 years of fixed interest rates when the rates were at their highest- and she actually believed that higher interest rates meant she would pay her mortgage off faster. She loved giving everyone on the forum financial advice.

She also believed that paying extra money on the mortgage just meant the bank kept more money.

About 12 months after her house purchase - when interest rates dropped a fair bit, she needed to sell her house as her DP had lost his job - she was shocked that they'd have to pay around $60K in break costs when they sold their house - so she was in a lot of debt if they sold.

We never heard from her again.

SazCat · 06/04/2023 07:52

HealthConcerns · 06/04/2023 07:06

Not smug at all. We have a fixed rate mortgage on quite a low rate. Granted we have it for another 6 years or so but my husband has worked out how much more we will need to pay a month if rates stay as they are.

He was going to over pay by this each month but our mortgage provider told him any overpayment won't come off the term automatically but will stay in a pot and come off at the end of the fixed term. So rather than having the provider have our money somewhere where we get no interest he's been putting it into premium bonds and we've had around 2,000 in different wins the last few years. By then paying this lump sum off at the end of our fixed term we will shave around 5 years off our mortgage term. So will probably only need a 5 year fixed and then be mortgage free before we are 50

This is similar to us, we took out a 10 Yr fixed in 2019 on a low rate, so we've been over paying. Hopefully when we get to the end of the fixed in 6 years we'll be almost clear, before we're 50 (original end date is 2034).

I hadn't thought about what you're doing though, makes sense!

Talia99 · 06/04/2023 07:47

mycoffeecup · 06/04/2023 07:18

Not necessarily. We took 10 years off the mortgage term on our first house by putting whatever extra we could scrape together into the mortgage. £100 here, £50 there etc. It all adds up.

Same with me. My first mortgage was for 25 years. When I remortgaged 3 years later, it was for 20 years, shaving two years off the term.

I did the same again 3 years later, remortgaging for 15 years, again taking two years off the term.

I can’t remember if my payment increased or if interest rates dropping meant I paid the same but I had no difficulties making the payments.

I’ve done the same in my current property - knocking several years off the term each time I remortgaged. It’s an easy way to save money on interest if you can afford it.

I’ve been overpaying all along which also helps keep the monthly payment the same when taking years off the term (because I was paying on a lower amount owed).

Obviously, some people can’t afford to overpay, particularly those living in the South.

mycoffeecup · 06/04/2023 07:18

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 22:35

How did you go from 30 to 13?
Lump sum ?

Not necessarily. We took 10 years off the mortgage term on our first house by putting whatever extra we could scrape together into the mortgage. £100 here, £50 there etc. It all adds up.

HealthConcerns · 06/04/2023 07:06

Not smug at all. We have a fixed rate mortgage on quite a low rate. Granted we have it for another 6 years or so but my husband has worked out how much more we will need to pay a month if rates stay as they are.

He was going to over pay by this each month but our mortgage provider told him any overpayment won't come off the term automatically but will stay in a pot and come off at the end of the fixed term. So rather than having the provider have our money somewhere where we get no interest he's been putting it into premium bonds and we've had around 2,000 in different wins the last few years. By then paying this lump sum off at the end of our fixed term we will shave around 5 years off our mortgage term. So will probably only need a 5 year fixed and then be mortgage free before we are 50

Talia99 · 06/04/2023 06:59

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 05/04/2023 23:24

But borrowing 160k over 35 years at say an average interest rate of 5% (generous as historically been much higher) they’ll have repaid 280k in interest and still owe 160k

if they had repaid it over 20years at 5% they’d have paid 93k in interest and owe nothing

I know which one makes more economic sense to me @Aquarius1234

This. At these figures, people the OP is talking about would have paid £280,000 at 5% and would still owe £160,000. They will also, if they don’t have a £160,000 lump sum, have to sell when the mortgage comes to an end.

With overpayments they would have paid £253,000 (£160,000 cost of house plus £93,000 interest) and owned the house free and clear.

There can be good financial reasons not to overpay - as others have said, it may be possible to get a better rate of interest on your money elsewhere - but a belief it means you pay the bank more for the house (which seems to be what the OP thinks) is not one of them.

Also, people don’t always make financial decisions just based on the money. I am currently overpaying my mortgage and hope to pay it off this year. I would have been financially better off to save the money in a high interest account (and I am somewhat - ready to pay off a lump sum when my low rate expires) or put it in my pension but that doesn’t take into the account the satisfaction of being mortgage free or of watching the amount owed drop month by month.

Simonjt · 06/04/2023 05:37

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 14:11

Your just giving the bank more money.

We over pay, the only time we didn’t was during adoption leave as we weren’t bringing as much money in. Our over payments so far have reduced our mortgage term by seven years, this also cuts out seven years worth of interest, which means we will be giving the bank far less money.

Carlycat · 06/04/2023 01:20

I worked my bollocks off for several years so I could overpay my mortgage. The feeling of paying that last instalment several years early was indescribable 😍
Must add that I'm child free with disposable income. Yep, I'm smug 😉

Cafog · 05/04/2023 23:30

Sorry j don't know ow how to quote you to reply OP. No lump sums here nor will there be. Every time my fixed rate was up for renewal I used a mortgage advisor (free, the lender pays him for sorting) to find the best deals. With interest rates lowering and my loan to value ratio increasing (loan reducing whilst house value increasing- better ratios mean better rates) we could afford to take a few years off each time. Bear in mind if we hadn't done that our term would he 20 years now but we've shaved off 7 years for very little increase in our repayment. Can't see us being so lucky in the future though I'll we happy just to have it paid off in 13.

Swipe left for the next trending thread