Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Over paying Mortgages

464 replies

Aquarius1234 · 05/04/2023 14:06

AIBU to find those that over pay their mortgages smug?
Moat people can just about afford or want to pay the standard monthly payments. Let alone want to use any more money/ savings on it !!
Why worry about paying off when in 20 years your probably get some form of lump sum anyway

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1471538283 · 08/04/2023 08:05

Even if it's a small amount it's worth overpaying your mortgage. By overpaying you save money because you pay less interest in the long run.

It's about long term giving the bank less money!

It's not smug. I've been in a position when I've only overpaid a very small amount but it all adds up!

DashboardConfessional · 08/04/2023 07:54

Also, "interest rates on loans" is too general. The interest rate on a non-mortgage loan/credit card is much higher. My credit card is 10.9%.

dew141 · 08/04/2023 07:35

PigletJohn · 08/04/2023 00:48

If interest rates paid on savings were greater than interest rates charged on loans, banks would not be making trillions in profits.

Except that's an over-simplification. (And many of the leading rate savings providers don't offer mortgages.)

People with a low loan-to-value, high income and good credit score will pay a lower rate of interest on their mortgage. They have a greater chance to play rate arbitrage as a result.

There's often timing opportunities on mortgages as people fix for 3-5 years. So some of us have a sub-1% fix but can get 3-4% on savings due to the base rate hike. This could go the other way but most of us look at interest rate forecasts as far as possible before deciding to fix.

And, as most of us have said, the better opportunity is in equity investments (in an ISA, LISA or SIPP) rather than savings in any case.

homeishere · 08/04/2023 07:33

Hey, OP, my mum died last year and left me some money. When my fixed term ends in 2024 I’m going to clear my entire mortgage in one go! 😀😍🤑🖕

is that the sort of bragging you’re on about?

Bunnycat101 · 08/04/2023 07:16

“If interest rates paid on savings were greater than interest rates charged on loans, banks would not be making trillions in profits.”

But it is true for a lot of people on low fixed rates. Mine is 2.2% for the next 10 years. You can easily get 4% now. Similarly someone could choose to pay into a pension or LISA instead to get the tax relief and be broadly up before any investment growth during that period. It’s obviously a very different proposition now for people on a higher rate but there are plenty of people around who still have older mortgage rates that were set before the more recent interest rises.

PigletJohn · 08/04/2023 00:48

If interest rates paid on savings were greater than interest rates charged on loans, banks would not be making trillions in profits.

Forgetaboutme · 08/04/2023 00:20

Ahh thanks to you both! That makes sense!

mast0650 · 07/04/2023 14:49

*Sorry to hijack but can I ask a question to posters?

I am currently on a low interest fixed deal which will end later this year. We have been overpaying our mortgage by about £150 per month. People are saying that its a better investment to save money in a savings account if the interest rate is higher than the mortgage rate. I don't really understand that? My thinking was that right now while my interest is low I can afford to overpay and it means that when the rate inevitably goes go up my balance will be lower and therefore I will benefit when the interest does go up. Is that not right? I'm unlikely to be in a position to overpay once it goes up*

Ideally you would put the money into a savings account as long as the interest rate is higher than the mortgage rate. Then immediately use the savings to overpay the mortgage as soon as the mortgage rate goes up to more than the savings rate (if it does...). Though doing that perfectly can be a bit tricky (depends on what your mortgage/savings allow you to do) and the amounts you are talking about are fairly small.

cantkeepawayforever · 07/04/2023 14:46

I was just going to mention offset mortgages, but I suspect that might blow op’s mind.

We have gained immensely over the years by setting our monthly repayment as if we have no savings and then offsetting the accounts with our income and savings in. It’s like having accessible savings crossed with paying down the mortgage. Particularly good if you are saving money for a big purchase - house improvement or large item - as the money works for you while it is accumulating and yet can be spent all at once without any issue.

Depends on relative mortgage rates vs savings, though - if the latter is higher, then offset isn’t worth it.

Wishawisha · 07/04/2023 14:33

Forgetaboutme · 07/04/2023 14:17

Sorry to hijack but can I ask a question to posters?

I am currently on a low interest fixed deal which will end later this year. We have been overpaying our mortgage by about £150 per month. People are saying that its a better investment to save money in a savings account if the interest rate is higher than the mortgage rate. I don't really understand that? My thinking was that right now while my interest is low I can afford to overpay and it means that when the rate inevitably goes go up my balance will be lower and therefore I will benefit when the interest does go up. Is that not right? I'm unlikely to be in a position to overpay once it goes up.

It just means if you are overpaying £150 a month you are saving your (let’s say) 1.5% interest on the £150. If you put the £150 in a savings account instead you would still have the £150 plus let’s say 4% interest. At the end of the term you’d then put that lump sum into the mortgage (plus the interest you’ve accrued) and you would have (very slightly) more off the capital than if you do it via overpaying.

There’s not much in it if you’re talking about less than a year and relatively low sums anyway. The difference for you is literally less than £20 so I’m not sure if it really matters. Plus it’s probably good sense to get used to the higher mortgage payments now and not be shocked later..

Forgetaboutme · 07/04/2023 14:17

Sorry to hijack but can I ask a question to posters?

I am currently on a low interest fixed deal which will end later this year. We have been overpaying our mortgage by about £150 per month. People are saying that its a better investment to save money in a savings account if the interest rate is higher than the mortgage rate. I don't really understand that? My thinking was that right now while my interest is low I can afford to overpay and it means that when the rate inevitably goes go up my balance will be lower and therefore I will benefit when the interest does go up. Is that not right? I'm unlikely to be in a position to overpay once it goes up.

PigletJohn · 07/04/2023 13:44

If you reduce your mortgage, you can probably reduce your payments later, if necessary.

I liked to do that just in case there was a downturn in business.

mast0650 · 07/04/2023 12:33

It's really not complicated. If you have some money that you can afford to save each month, then you have a choice between reducing your mortgage debt or increasing your investments. Let's assume that you have got enough saved in easy to access accounts that you don't need to worry about "rainy day" funds (obviously paying off the mortgage is no good for that as you can't easily get the money back to spend if need be!). Then it's simply a matter of comparing the interest rate you are paying on the mortgage versus returns available elsewhere. You need to take into account that paying off the mortgage will give an entirely risk-free return, whereas some other investments won't be. It is also effectively a tax-free return (but you can earn a lot of interest these days without paying tax so probably not an issue for most). But otherwise, that's it. Those people who are lucky enough to still be a good fixed rate details of 1-2% or thereabouts obviously will find it better to invest the money elsewhere. Those of us paying more than 3% might find that reducing mortgage debt is a very low-hassle way to get a risk-free, tax free return of over 3% on our savings. Likely to be better to pay off other debt first though!!

There's nothing special or magic about paying off your mortgage debt versus anything else.

Lovanna · 07/04/2023 11:52

Aquarius1234 · 06/04/2023 17:38

Interest rates were low for years until recently?
Guess you were unlucky. Yet lucky..

Interest rates were low for years until recently?

Age dependent.

My first mortgage had an interest rate of 15% .

taxguru · 07/04/2023 11:05

I think the problem is lack of financial/numerical literacy. People don't look as far as the monthly payment and can't seem to comprehend the total payments over the entire term of the mortgage.

I see the same regularly with car leases, unsecured bank loans, hire purchase, credit card debt, and even student loans. People are fixated on what it costs them every month and make decisions on the lowest possible monthly repayment, completely ignoring the total cost over the loan term.

The worst is when people come to paying off a loan, mortgage, lease or hire purchase and get excited when the monthly repayment is less, completely ignoring the term has increased by a few years, so in total terms, it's a ridiculously expensive way of doing it!

Simonjt · 07/04/2023 09:20

@Aquarius1234 I’ve just done a proper calculation for us.

We at the moment overpay our mortgage every month, if we continue to so this not only are we reducing the time it takes to pay it off, we will pay less in the long run. If we paid off the normal amount each month between now and paying it off assuming interest rates remain the same (2.7%) we would pay £122k in interest, our overpayments mean if interest rates remain the same we will only pay £63k in interest.

Thats a saving of almost £60k, why would you want to spend £60k when you don’t need to?

Simonjt · 07/04/2023 09:12

Aquarius1234 · 07/04/2023 00:37

That's a lot of money, for saving very little.

So you would rather pay £11.5k?

TheJanitor · 07/04/2023 08:51

I'm not on a high salary but i overpay the maximum I'm allowed which is 10%. I've set my monthly direct debit to be 10% more than the payment the bank set. It's a difference of about £70 a month. It'll save me thousands in interest and pay the mortgage off quicker. We tightened our belts and if things get really tight we can go back to the minimum payment. I'm not smug about it - nobody knows except me and dh.

DashboardConfessional · 07/04/2023 07:55

Aquarius1234 · 07/04/2023 00:37

That's a lot of money, for saving very little.

You're not paying £9k as some sort of fee to save £2.5k. You owe the money anyway.

The wasted money is the £2.5k interest you pay by taking longer to pay back that £9k. So that chunk of house, as a PP said, costs you £11.5k instead.

Jagoda · 07/04/2023 07:50

I overpay every month and bung a lump sum in when I can. I keep the monthly repayments as they are, and reduce the term.

Honestly OP, even though I really enjoy my job, it will be fabulous to be able to retire in four years instead of ten.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 07/04/2023 04:25

Aquarius1234 · 07/04/2023 00:37

That's a lot of money, for saving very little.

That's not "very little" - that's amazing.

I think the important thing you're missing OP is thinking about what happens next once the mortgage is paid off. The income doesn't disappear - you can build a tidy lump sum in the remaining years to retirement.

When you are approved for a mortgage your income is "stress tested" - they work out what level of repayments would get you into serious financial trouble and they don't lend you that much, because no one knows what interest rates and the economy will do over the next 25 years.

So generally if you are approved for a mortgage of 25 years with a monthly repayment of £800 with an initial 2 year fixed rate, it's because the bank reckons that if interest rates shoot up over the next 2 years, when that 2 year rate is over you'll still be able to afford your mortgage if your repayments are recalculated to £1000pm.

Of course you can spend the "spare" £200pm on a nicer lifestyle now. Or you could put some of it in savings (which may or may not outperform the effect of mortgage overpayments, there's too many variables to know).

But if you choose to put an just £90 extra into the mortgage as a regular overpayment, and actually interest rates stay stable, then instead of paying £240,000 over 25 years you end up paying the mortgage off 4 years early and have paid only £225,000 - but then the crucial thing is that if you then carry on putting aside that £890 per month for the remaining 4 years of the original mortgage term you then have a lump sum of about £45,000 at retirement as well as being mortgage free.

Whereas if instead of putting that £90 into mortgage repayments you just put it into a savings account, you'd still be mortgage free after 25 years but the savings pot (if you chose a risk-free option) would only be about £35,000 - so using mortgage overpayments instead of savings for that has made you £10,000 richer.

You can put the £90 per month into a different investment product which might, if the economy does well, get you even more than £45,000 - or it could and up being only £20,000 if the economy does badly.

Of course you can just spend the £90 on immediate luxuries every month, but if you get used to that level of lifestyle luxury then it hurts a lot more when interest rates do go up, because your lifestyle has to take a hit. Whereas if you are used to overpaying anyway, a hit in interest rates is fine. If monthly repayments go up from £800 to £880 but I am used to paying £890 anyway I can keep my payment static at £890 until such time as I get a pay rise and can choose a new repayment I feel I can afford.

OneFrenchEgg · 07/04/2023 02:08

shush yes I think so for now times - 1.14% fixed

DontMakeMeShushYou · 07/04/2023 01:30

Aquarius1234 · 07/04/2023 00:37

That's a lot of money, for saving very little.

Do explain?

Paying off £9K now would reduce my remaining total mortgage payments by over £11.5K. I'm surprised you find £9K a lot of money but £2.5K so little you can just throw it away.

In my case I'm talking about a fairly short period of time (less than 6 years to go as it is, less than 4 years if I was to pay off £9K). Perhaps that would make £2.5K seem like a more significant amount.

SarahDippity · 07/04/2023 00:45

GimmeSleep · 05/04/2023 15:19

I overpay by £400 p/month - I'm not smug, I'm skint because of it but I want to be mortgage free as soon as possible

This. I stretch myself every month to put a few extra quid into paying off the mortgage. I’m divorced and I will be in very real difficulty in my 60s if I don’t get the capital down as much as I can in my prime earning years.

Aquarius1234 · 07/04/2023 00:37

DontMakeMeShushYou · 07/04/2023 00:30

Is your mortgage on a particularly low interest rate?

I just checked to see what would happen if I paid £9K off my mortgage. I'd knock 22 months off the mortgage and save £2.5K.

That's a lot of money, for saving very little.

OP posts: