Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for space and ventilation on crowded trains.

133 replies

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 13:15

I am going backward and forward to hospital having chemotherapy, and the medical advice is to sit away from other passengers and keep the windows open. Some trains are standing room only, and I have to ask for space to be left near me when there are no other seats. Most people are kind and understanding, but I have had chemotherapy today, and both going in and coming out, I have had people ignore my requests.

On my way in, on a crowded rush hour train, a man insisted on moving my bag and sitting on the seat next to me, even though I had paid an extra ticket for my bag, and explained to him about the chemo.

On the way back, another man insisted on closing all the windows in the carriage, because he "felt cold" even though an infection could kill me

It is quite obvious I am undergoing chemotherapy, as I am bald, wearing a mask, and have a sunflower lanyard around my neck with "Chemotherapy patient needing social distancing and ventilation" written on it quite clearly. - The hospital gives this to patients who have to travel to chemotherapy by public transport.

Most people are lovely, but today was quite upsetting. The worst thing that has ever happened to me on these trips was a well dressed young woman in a business suit physically kicking me out of the way because I couldn't move fast enough for her, then acting as if she was the one hard done by, being forced to touch me with her precious shoe.

Thank you to all those people who do listen and understand , and give me space though. Which is most people

OP posts:
Malarandras · 05/04/2023 13:52

It’s public transport so I do think your expectations are unreasonable. You may think your situation is obvious but people don’t often pay that much attention to those they don't know. Even if they do notice they are likely to think that as they have also paid for their ticket they are as entitled to be there as you. So I don’t think you can rely on other people’s thoughtfulness or support here. If the train is such a risk for you then maybe you should speak to your clinical team to check if alternatives could be arranged?

5128gap · 05/04/2023 13:47

If there really is no alternative then you could:
Consider travelling first class, possibly cheaper than buying two standard tickets in the hope no one will use your extra seat.
Contacting the train company to ask if you can use the first class carriage ( if you don't ask you don't get!) Alternatively just sitting in first class and throwing yourself on the ticket inspector's mercy.
Asking for appointments that enable you to travel off peak.
Getting a heavy duty mask.
Becoming extremely assertive when asking for space when it's clearly possible. Most people would be shamed into complying if the conversation is loud and public.

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 13:46

Beantag · 05/04/2023 13:42

Have you spoken to the train company OP? My friend had similar and she was able to have her tickets upgraded to first class for no additional cost, she did have to provide a letter and proof of appointments though. A lot do this for pregnant women as well so it might be something others do if it's generally seen that some people for medical reasons require more space etc? Worth an ask at least, or to see if they can suggest anything else?

I am definitely going to speak to the train company

OP posts:
Arightoldcarryabag · 05/04/2023 13:46

Unfortunately people are selfish.
My only advice would be to try and find someone who can accompany you as an advocate or even giving you a lift. There may be local cancer charities who can provide support.
I'm sorry that in your situation, where I'm sure my suggestions are likely going to be fruitless, that people are such intolerable arseholes.

FlamingoQueen · 05/04/2023 13:45

Chemo is bad enough without the stress of the train. I agree with the person that said about contacting the train company. They may even send you to first class! Some people are so ignorant. I would be saying to people that I hope your mother/sister/daughter (or male, of course!) never has to suffer this harassment on their way for cancer treatment. Good luck x

Paloma66 · 05/04/2023 13:43

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 05/04/2023 13:41

Instead of using the money to buy an extra seat in standard, buy a first class seat. Select "not a table" and there's a good chance it will be one of the single seats. If it isn't, ask someone to swap - assuming the carriage is full, which it often isn't.

I guess this will depend on the train company and route. On my commuter trains there is no first class.

Beantag · 05/04/2023 13:42

Have you spoken to the train company OP? My friend had similar and she was able to have her tickets upgraded to first class for no additional cost, she did have to provide a letter and proof of appointments though. A lot do this for pregnant women as well so it might be something others do if it's generally seen that some people for medical reasons require more space etc? Worth an ask at least, or to see if they can suggest anything else?

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 13:41

Whataretheodds · 05/04/2023 13:38

Can you (or someone on your behalf) speak to the train company to get assistance for you on your journey - IF there's no joy from any of the other suggestions.

This is something I haven't tried. Maybe I could speak to the train company. I will look into this.

OP posts:
Fallulah · 05/04/2023 13:41

Use the grant to pay for a taxi? 2 seats on a train are probably more expensive than a taxi?

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 05/04/2023 13:41

Instead of using the money to buy an extra seat in standard, buy a first class seat. Select "not a table" and there's a good chance it will be one of the single seats. If it isn't, ask someone to swap - assuming the carriage is full, which it often isn't.

Paloma66 · 05/04/2023 13:40

I really feel for you as it's a very difficult situation. Unfortunately having a ticket doesn't guarantee you a seat on the train so buying an extra ticket for your bag is a waste of money. If you're travelling during rush hour then trains are going to be busy and people won't be able to avoid being near you and won't stand if there are seats available. The windows issue is probably less of an issue than the volume of people on the train.

Are you well enough to stand for the journey? If so it might be a better option to stand by the doors so that you get fresh air when the train stops and doors open. And if you get close to the door and stand facing it then you will be facing away from others.

I don't think there is an easy answer other than to avoid travelling in rush hour as much as possible.

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 13:39

Fallulah · 05/04/2023 13:33

Your GP or socialist nurse should be able to arrange hospital transport for this. They were very happy to offer it for my dad for chemo and my mum was offered it all the way to a London hospital recently as the only other option was public transport.

MacMillan could help with finances - checking you’re getting all you’re entitled to so that you can afford to get a taxi?

I can’t believe getting a train is your only option when it’s so important that you keep your risk of infection low.

I have a grant from McMillian, that is what pays the train fare, and they said to buy an extra ticket for my bag, so I can have an empty seat next to me.

There is no other option, and it isn't only one person, that the hospital could possibly accommodate on their transport, it is many of us, and the available transport takes less than 1 in 10.

So it is train, only. There is nothing else

OP posts:
Whataretheodds · 05/04/2023 13:38

Can you (or someone on your behalf) speak to the train company to get assistance for you on your journey - IF there's no joy from any of the other suggestions.

Whatabouterry · 05/04/2023 13:38

I really feel for you. But trains are often over crowded and I think if someone has paid for a seat then they can reasonably expect to sit down.

Wha · 05/04/2023 13:37

Wow I’m so sorry about the cancer and hope the chemo goes well.

You can’t change the world, only live in it. Public transport brings out the worst in people, and many people are assholes anyway. So asking for space / ventilation isn’t going to work well. 😔 Doesn’t matter whether or not it should work, it just isn’t going to.

So. Turn your mind and energy to other options. Can you get a loan / borrow money from family to either get a taxi or rent a room in a b&b near the hospital for the treatment week? Have you approached every charity / volunteer network you can find? I’ve done volunteer driving pretty randomly simply because someone asked on our Facebook Mum’s group and I felt sorry for them and I had the free time. Could you try asking local Facebook and Church networks for help / advice? Vicars are actually quite good at this sort of thing and even if you are not a Christian, to your local vicar yoh are still part of his “flock” that he looks after.

(Ps if you do accept volunteer drifer help, do offer petrol money - I stopped doing it because it was getting expensive).

I hope you find a solution and that the chemo goes well.

Ylvamoon · 05/04/2023 13:37

Does your hospital have a volunteer group?
Our hospital has volunteer drivers, where for a small fee to cover petrol costs they will take/ collect you for appointments.
(usually £2 -£5 depending on distance)
Or can you speak to your team and have appointments for quieter times?

I agree, public transport during busy periods is carnage. So no helpful advice.

bananaboats · 05/04/2023 13:37

Unfortunately I don't think what your expecting is really feasible on packed public transport. In your situation I would be prioritising money for taxis/paying someone petrol money to drive me if there really is no other option.

dietcokelime · 05/04/2023 13:37

Is there the option to travel in a different carriage class?

Unfortunately it's a crowded commuter train, space is a premium and there are other people trying to travel too. Closing windows in cold weather (whilst you might need ventilation) is sensible for probably most people on there, other people might be struggling with the cold.

Is there no taxis or anything at all? Or patient transport?

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 13:36

Albiboba · 05/04/2023 13:32

I’m sorry but it’s just unrealistic, it’s public transport.
You have my sympathies as I have quite a few close relatives are currently going through chemo.

If you can’t afford a taxi/ can’t get a lift with anyone for some of the journeys then I second the PP about looking into grants etc.

Honestly most people initial thought to the sunflower lanyard will be the people who us it as an anti mask point.
I doubt anyone who walks too close to you is trying to cause you harm but they are just trying to get home. Someone walking behind you isn’t going to know you you’ve just come back from chemo. It sounds like it was an accident rather than ‘physically kicking you out of the way’.

no, it was deliberate, I assure you, absolutely no accident, yelling at me to move out of the way as they approached me, then when I couldn't move fast enough, heavy sigh, pained expression, and repeated hard kicks. No mistaking it for an accident - it was the whole expression of "OMG look what I am having to do to clear the crap out of the way so that I can walk as fast as I need to". This woman seriously thought SHE was the one being wronged.

OP posts:
HairyMolly1 · 05/04/2023 13:35

On a practical level for when it's impossible to sit away from people, have you thought about FFP3 masks? We wore them at work (in hospital) all through the pandemic. It might give you some peace of mind.

Fallulah · 05/04/2023 13:34

*specialist nurse, sorry!

(I think, like a lot of things when dealing with cancer, chemo etc, you might need to do some jumping up and down about getting assistance. Sorry, it’s a shit time to have to worry about this, I know.)

FlounderingFruitcake · 05/04/2023 13:34

Sounds stressful but you can’t expect social distancing on a packed standing room only train. People are going to get on where there’s space and will want to sit on seats that don’t have a person sitting on them, it’s totally reasonable. It’s public transport for the masses not for the specific needs of 1 person. Sorry you’re in this position and I hope treatment goes well but I think you need to sort private transport.

SouthCountryGirl · 05/04/2023 13:33

First class should be less crowded?

Fallulah · 05/04/2023 13:33

Your GP or socialist nurse should be able to arrange hospital transport for this. They were very happy to offer it for my dad for chemo and my mum was offered it all the way to a London hospital recently as the only other option was public transport.

MacMillan could help with finances - checking you’re getting all you’re entitled to so that you can afford to get a taxi?

I can’t believe getting a train is your only option when it’s so important that you keep your risk of infection low.

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 13:33

Viviennemary · 05/04/2023 13:30

No I don't think this is feasible. Private transport is the way forward. Good idea to ask if there is any help available. Some neighbourhoods have a scheme to take folk to and from hospital. You might be entitled to subsidised taxi fares.

no, there is no alternative to travelling by train, I have already investigated every possibility.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread