Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for space and ventilation on crowded trains.

133 replies

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 13:15

I am going backward and forward to hospital having chemotherapy, and the medical advice is to sit away from other passengers and keep the windows open. Some trains are standing room only, and I have to ask for space to be left near me when there are no other seats. Most people are kind and understanding, but I have had chemotherapy today, and both going in and coming out, I have had people ignore my requests.

On my way in, on a crowded rush hour train, a man insisted on moving my bag and sitting on the seat next to me, even though I had paid an extra ticket for my bag, and explained to him about the chemo.

On the way back, another man insisted on closing all the windows in the carriage, because he "felt cold" even though an infection could kill me

It is quite obvious I am undergoing chemotherapy, as I am bald, wearing a mask, and have a sunflower lanyard around my neck with "Chemotherapy patient needing social distancing and ventilation" written on it quite clearly. - The hospital gives this to patients who have to travel to chemotherapy by public transport.

Most people are lovely, but today was quite upsetting. The worst thing that has ever happened to me on these trips was a well dressed young woman in a business suit physically kicking me out of the way because I couldn't move fast enough for her, then acting as if she was the one hard done by, being forced to touch me with her precious shoe.

Thank you to all those people who do listen and understand , and give me space though. Which is most people

OP posts:
Anetra · 05/04/2023 18:26

Btw if you put your area in you never know some kind soul of mn might be able to help you out. I certainly will if you are near my area x

Anetra · 05/04/2023 18:24

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 15:07

I don't have any choice but to travel to chemo on a crowded train. It is all very well saying I "shouldn't" - but that is the only way to get to hospital!

I am not requesting space and ventilation because I am anxious, either, I am requesting it because that is the medical advice I have been given. I have been instructed to make sure I am socially distanced, and have the windows open.

You may have been instructed to social distance and have windows open but this is totally unrealistic on public transport. Somebody else might have been instructed to make sure they don’t stand too long for a medical reason. Somebody else might have an ear infection and need the window closed to avoid the pain of cold air blasting through at train speed.

The “instructions” you have been given are unrealistic and unenforceable on public transport.
As for putting your bag on a seat - of course someone else who might have a need just as great as yours and may wish to have that seat.

Public transport is a shared space and I think you are being very black and white about the instructions you’ve been given. You can try to follow those instructions but other people, strangers on a packed train with their own set of problems and needs can’t be expected to follow them.

If public transport is that risky for you then you and your healthcare team need to explore other options.

I wish you well with your treatment and recovery but you’ll drive yourself mad trying to enforce the advice you’ve been given in any shared space tbh.

Caffeineislife · 05/04/2023 17:56

Is there absolutely no volunteer services/ help the vulnerable/ citizens advice near you? Patient transport to hospital is the type of help many of them provide for free/ very small charge. You would definitely qualify at our local volunteer action service. Whilst many of the drivers are available mon-fri 9-5, I do know that our local action service has a deal with a local taxi firm and with notice can arrange transport via local taxi firm for patients outside these times. I say citizens advice because they often know the contact info for voluntary patient transport schemes. So should your local council. Work an ask on Facebook too as many people are good at signposting local services like the driving schemes.

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 17:49

Bottlesofhot · 05/04/2023 17:42

OP have you spoken with the cashier's office at the hospital about reimbursement for your travel? They usually have a page on the hospital website which will list the benefits that are eligible to have their travel refunded or partially refunded. You have to keep all receipts. This might help you with some of the financial burden.

I am not aware of this. I will look into this. Thank you

I started this for a bit of a moan, but have had several constructive ideas I hadn't thought of, so thank you for that.

OP posts:
Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 17:47

TheOrigRights · 05/04/2023 17:44

Are the hospital aware of just how difficult travel is for you i.e. are they making any attempt to accommodate different times (sorry I don't know anything about chemo so maybe it has to start at 9am)?

When they must send you home with so much info on how to look after yourself to maximise your chance of a positive outcome, it seems bizarre that there is literally NOTHING to be done about the transport situation which is risking your health.

Don't you have any friends or colleagues?

O yes, the hospital staff are well aware of the problems facing many patients. They do try and vary our times, so no one always gets the rush hour appointments, and they just tell us to make sure we are as socially distanced as possible, and to keep the windows open.

Some of my appointments start later, and there is no real problem then. Today was just particularly bad. I feel like I am in a no win situation, when I just cant follow the medical instructions. Most of the time people are nice and understanding about it, and do give me space. Like I said, today was just particularly horrible.

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 05/04/2023 17:44

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 17:35

no, not really, if chemo starts at 9, I have to travel before 9, and all the trains are full before 9, even the first one ( actually especially the first one...)

Are the hospital aware of just how difficult travel is for you i.e. are they making any attempt to accommodate different times (sorry I don't know anything about chemo so maybe it has to start at 9am)?

When they must send you home with so much info on how to look after yourself to maximise your chance of a positive outcome, it seems bizarre that there is literally NOTHING to be done about the transport situation which is risking your health.

Don't you have any friends or colleagues?

Bottlesofhot · 05/04/2023 17:42

OP have you spoken with the cashier's office at the hospital about reimbursement for your travel? They usually have a page on the hospital website which will list the benefits that are eligible to have their travel refunded or partially refunded. You have to keep all receipts. This might help you with some of the financial burden.

thegrain · 05/04/2023 17:41

If you were deliberately kicked please tell the police- they can view the cctv footage

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 17:35

BlueHeelers · 05/04/2023 17:21

Can you avoid rush hour?

Without wanting to minimise the cruelty you’ve experienced, rush hour commuting is brutal day in, day out. And commuters are so exhausted by the overcrowded, having to stand in a crush, the early start etc.

Can you travel later or earlier or by a more private way?

no, not really, if chemo starts at 9, I have to travel before 9, and all the trains are full before 9, even the first one ( actually especially the first one...)

OP posts:
BlueHeelers · 05/04/2023 17:21

Can you avoid rush hour?

Without wanting to minimise the cruelty you’ve experienced, rush hour commuting is brutal day in, day out. And commuters are so exhausted by the overcrowded, having to stand in a crush, the early start etc.

Can you travel later or earlier or by a more private way?

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 17:09

QuimIsASwearWord · 05/04/2023 17:05

No it wasn't deliberate. If it was you would have called the police.

I am dreadfully sorry for your situation OP - it's got to be horrendous. Unfortunately you're asking for something completely unreasonable, and seem to have lost the plot a bit.

Surely the OP who actually there and saw the attitude and demeanour of the woman who kicked her knows if it was deliberate better than you?

Op has cancer, she sounds scared, like many people with cancer are.

She won't get space on public transport but it doesn't mean she's lying about being kicked or lost the plot for trying to reduce risks to herself.

My brother was kicked by a drunk on the way home from a night out and he didnt phone the police. He's had thing wellies off his head by idiots at the back of the bus many times and his wife who works for the police says fuck all will happen.

I have family who drive public transport for a living and who have been attacked and get threatened almost daily, and there's very few arrests.

Ive been smacked in the back by a drunk woman, also didn't phone the police. I know a few women who have sexually assaulted on public transport, didn't phone the police.

Doesn't mean they weren't deliberate acts.

Thank you

OP posts:
QuimIsASwearWord · 05/04/2023 17:05

No it wasn't deliberate. If it was you would have called the police.

I am dreadfully sorry for your situation OP - it's got to be horrendous. Unfortunately you're asking for something completely unreasonable, and seem to have lost the plot a bit.

Surely the OP who actually there and saw the attitude and demeanour of the woman who kicked her knows if it was deliberate better than you?

Op has cancer, she sounds scared, like many people with cancer are.

She won't get space on public transport but it doesn't mean she's lying about being kicked or lost the plot for trying to reduce risks to herself.

My brother was kicked by a drunk on the way home from a night out and he didnt phone the police. He's had thing wellies off his head by idiots at the back of the bus many times and his wife who works for the police says fuck all will happen.

I have family who drive public transport for a living and who have been attacked and get threatened almost daily, and there's very few arrests.

Ive been smacked in the back by a drunk woman, also didn't phone the police. I know a few women who have sexually assaulted on public transport, didn't phone the police.

Doesn't mean they weren't deliberate acts.

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 17:00

ClaudiaWankleman · 05/04/2023 15:57

No it wasn't deliberate. If it was you would have called the police.

I am dreadfully sorry for your situation OP - it's got to be horrendous. Unfortunately you're asking for something completely unreasonable, and seem to have lost the plot a bit.

It absolutely was deliberate, I can assure you, and no, I have not in any way, lost any plot.

OP posts:
donttellmehesalive · 05/04/2023 15:57

onefinemess · 05/04/2023 14:31

Just one of those things OP.

It's unrealistic to think that complete strangers would care about you or your illness.

This is really sad. Decent people should care about even a stranger's illness. They are not being asked to rub her back or give her a foot massage, just to let her keep a window open and use the two seats she's booked and paid for. I'd do that much for anyone.

And I'm not buying 'other people have needs too' either. If they did, they'd say. When op said 'actually I've paid for a second seat because I am on my way back from chemo' they'd reply 'sorry but I do really need to sit down as I feel ill myself' or whatever.

OP, I think first class or an official 'I've paid for both seats' sign as pp have suggested is the way to go. I hope you make a full recovery.

ClaudiaWankleman · 05/04/2023 15:57

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 13:36

no, it was deliberate, I assure you, absolutely no accident, yelling at me to move out of the way as they approached me, then when I couldn't move fast enough, heavy sigh, pained expression, and repeated hard kicks. No mistaking it for an accident - it was the whole expression of "OMG look what I am having to do to clear the crap out of the way so that I can walk as fast as I need to". This woman seriously thought SHE was the one being wronged.

No it wasn't deliberate. If it was you would have called the police.

I am dreadfully sorry for your situation OP - it's got to be horrendous. Unfortunately you're asking for something completely unreasonable, and seem to have lost the plot a bit.

Siepie · 05/04/2023 15:55

ArcticBells · 05/04/2023 15:09

I travel on commuter trains. OP if you have paid for two seats, you need to have an A5 notice with "I have paid for 2 seats" clearly written on it and placed on the spare seat.

You don't pay for seats on trains, but for tickets. All the people standing also have a ticket, just like OP's bag does.

OP it's not a good situation but I don't think it's possible to make anything change. I'm on permanent treatment that affects my immune system (not as severely as chemo, luckily). Even in the middle of the pandemic, when everyone was "supposed" to be social distancing, it just wasn't possible on public transport.

Paloma66 · 05/04/2023 15:31

ArcticBells · 05/04/2023 15:09

I travel on commuter trains. OP if you have paid for two seats, you need to have an A5 notice with "I have paid for 2 seats" clearly written on it and placed on the spare seat.

It depends. I travel on commuter trains. My ticket does not entitle me to a seat. There are no seat reservations.

ArcticBells · 05/04/2023 15:28

Sorry, I thought the seats were booked!

JenniferBarkley · 05/04/2023 15:15

ArcticBells · 05/04/2023 15:09

I travel on commuter trains. OP if you have paid for two seats, you need to have an A5 notice with "I have paid for 2 seats" clearly written on it and placed on the spare seat.

The problem is she likely hasn't paid for two seats, she's paid for two tickets. A ticket doesn't entitle you to a seat on most commuter trains.

DumbPrinceAndHisStupidWife · 05/04/2023 15:14

I think even with distancing, it really makes very little distance on a busy train. The ventilation is going to be poor anyway, they are so crowded. It's probably why many people won't bother.

I'm sorry that the train is your only option- this thread brings it home again how poor healthcare is. That's what springs out at me, more than anything about the other passengers. Public transport shouldn't be your only option.

If it's possible, I'd go first class in your circumstances. Speak to the train company or the staff on the train. They should upgrade you to first class.

Wishing you all the best with your treatment and a speedy recovery, OP.

thegrain · 05/04/2023 15:12

Radical idea but could you try saying the hospital have advised me to keep my distance from people. And then make it seem like they are at risk from you? I know that's backwards but some people are utterly selfish. You could cough and people will automatically give you space these days.

thegrain · 05/04/2023 15:11

ArcticBells · 05/04/2023 15:09

I travel on commuter trains. OP if you have paid for two seats, you need to have an A5 notice with "I have paid for 2 seats" clearly written on it and placed on the spare seat.

I think that only works if OP books a seat

thegrain · 05/04/2023 15:10

TheOrigRights · 05/04/2023 14:49

What a state our society is in.

This reminds me of my solicitor suggesting I lock myself in my garden office to protect myself from my abusive ex.
Have a think before you type speak.

I wasn't saying OP should have to! I'm just trying to think of possible ways to get the space.

Booblessbeauty · 05/04/2023 15:09

StripyHorse · 05/04/2023 15:05

It's tricky with the social distancing issue on a crowded train. Especially if the person wanting to sit down has disabilities or mobility issues (I appreciate most people are just being selfish though). YANBU to want (need) the space but at the same time, public transport is not geared towards that. I know you can't just switch chemo days / times to avoid peak times too so you can't avoid the situation.

I definitely am with you on the shutting the window being unreasonable! Unless there are minus temps outside, it is not going to get THAT cold that people can't cope with the window open for 1/2 hr.

You said you wear a mask - I assume this is at least FFP2 (if not, consider upgrading). You can also buy portable HEPA filters could help with ventilation. It won't be the same as a properly ventilated space but is better then nothing https://amzn.eu/d/2FxSJs1

All the best with the treatment.

I am using FFP2 masks at the moment. I will look into this filter. Thank you

OP posts:
ArcticBells · 05/04/2023 15:09

I travel on commuter trains. OP if you have paid for two seats, you need to have an A5 notice with "I have paid for 2 seats" clearly written on it and placed on the spare seat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread