Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traffic lights at pedestrian crossing - who is at fault?

34 replies

EmotionalBruises · 05/04/2023 11:21

I was standing at a pedestrian crossing (not sure what type of crossing it's called, but there's an island in the middle), waiting to cross. I pressed the button and the traffic lights turned red, and the green man on the other side of the road shone. I crossed through the first part fine, and as I was walking through the second section, a driver blasted their horn at me before I had even made it to the other side of the road.

I looked at the traffic light, and it was flashing amber. It hadn't even turned green yet. The green man had disappeared (there's only one on either side of the crossings, so I only had one to look at), but it hadn't turned back to red.

AIBU in thinking that the driver should have waited for me to cross the road? It was flashing amber. I don't drive, but surely he should have waited for it to turn green? I can't stand the sound of cars beeping, so I gave him a dirty look.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
urbanbuddha · 05/04/2023 15:22

He's at fault, you're supposed to wait until pedestrians have cleared the crossing regardless of what colour the lights are on because running them over is frowned upon.

😃This.

Neededanewuserhandle · 05/04/2023 15:00

The flashing green man is a sign to pedestrians not to start crossing as they won’t have time to make it across.
Which 100% of pedestrians ignore rendering it a bit pointless.

jcyclops · 05/04/2023 14:37

ShirleyPhallus · 05/04/2023 14:14

re your last paragraph and photo, I’m not sure that’s right - surely if you’re driving the lights would show red on one lane to show the pedestrians crossing but would be showing green to continue driving until the pedestrians press that button to cross over?

No - on a straight crossing, all the lights for traffic are (and must be) synchronised and show the same colour at the same time - just as they would if there was no central island at all. If road planners want the lights to show green to traffic in one direction and red to traffic on the other side of the road, they have no choice but to install a staggered island.

If a pedestrian starts to cross a straight crossing on the green man and is only half way across the first carriageway when the amber lights start flashing, vehicles on both carriageways must wait until the pedestrian reaches the pavement on the other side (even if the lights go green before then)

As in the photo, you may see pedestrians waiting on the island on a straight crossing. This is because they may have crossed the first carriageway whilst the red man was showing because there was no traffic coming, or drivers on the second carriageway didn't know the rules and drove through the flashing amber when the pedestrians were still on the other side of the road.

Frabbits · 05/04/2023 14:28

Not necessarily. Plenty of cases where a crossing has an island in the middle but the lights go to red in both directions.

In this case as per HC once someone has started crossing traffic in both directions must wait until they are fully across the road or have reached the middle and are clearly giving way to traffic.

ShirleyPhallus · 05/04/2023 14:14

jcyclops · 05/04/2023 12:38

Some people seem to think that an island in the crossing and/or the presence of a pedestrian push-button on the island means it is two separate crossings. This is NOT true. Highway Code (196-198) states:

You MUST stop when the red light shows. When the amber light is flashing, you MUST give way to any pedestrians on the crossing. If the amber light is flashing and there are no pedestrians on the crossing, you may proceed with caution.
Give way to anyone still crossing after the signal for vehicles has changed to green. This advice applies to all crossings.
Pelican crossings which go straight across the road are one crossing, even when there is a central island. You MUST wait for pedestrians who are crossing from the other side of the island.

Most crossings with an island are staggered, and these are two separate crossings. Straight crossings are a single crossing, even if there is an island and buttons like the one below.

re your last paragraph and photo, I’m not sure that’s right - surely if you’re driving the lights would show red on one lane to show the pedestrians crossing but would be showing green to continue driving until the pedestrians press that button to cross over?

Hesma · 05/04/2023 12:39

You’re right OP. The flashing green man is a sign to pedestrians not to start crossing as they won’t have time to make it across. The flashing amber lights mean it is ok to proceed if the crossing is clear but you must wait for people on the crossing to finish crossing the road.

jcyclops · 05/04/2023 12:38

Some people seem to think that an island in the crossing and/or the presence of a pedestrian push-button on the island means it is two separate crossings. This is NOT true. Highway Code (196-198) states:

You MUST stop when the red light shows. When the amber light is flashing, you MUST give way to any pedestrians on the crossing. If the amber light is flashing and there are no pedestrians on the crossing, you may proceed with caution.
Give way to anyone still crossing after the signal for vehicles has changed to green. This advice applies to all crossings.
Pelican crossings which go straight across the road are one crossing, even when there is a central island. You MUST wait for pedestrians who are crossing from the other side of the island.

Most crossings with an island are staggered, and these are two separate crossings. Straight crossings are a single crossing, even if there is an island and buttons like the one below.

Traffic lights at pedestrian crossing - who is at fault?
dementedpixie · 05/04/2023 12:36

thegrain · 05/04/2023 12:24

No even if the light is green they shouldn't be moving forward if someone is crossing! That's basic driving.

I wasn't saying they could move forward if it was green and someone was crossing. Sorry if what I said implied that

thegrain · 05/04/2023 12:24

dementedpixie · 05/04/2023 12:04

The car is supposed to wait for the light to be green before moving forwards if someone is crossing so they are in the wrong.

No even if the light is green they shouldn't be moving forward if someone is crossing! That's basic driving.

EmotionalBruises · 05/04/2023 12:24

Thanks for all your responses. To be fair, there is another push button at the island, but there's only one green man, so it was green before I had even reached the island. I have used this crossing many times, and have never had any problems until now. As soon as the man had changed to green, I started crossing. I'm not sure when the man had disappeared, but it must have been after I had started crossing the island.

I was too shocked by the horn to see what type of car it was, but it was white. It definitely wasn't a friendly beep, though!

OP posts:
MsJD · 05/04/2023 12:23

Perhaps he fancied you?😉

Kazzyhoward · 05/04/2023 12:16

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 05/04/2023 12:09

You were 100% in the right. The driver should not be moving forward until his light is green, regardless of whether anyone was on the crossing. And you have right of way until you have finished crossing even if his light does go green before you reach the pavement.

Nope, the driver can proceed if no one is on the crossing when it starts flashing amber. Otherwise what's the point if you think drivers should wait until green - it's nonsensical having a flashing amber that means nothing!

Viviennemary · 05/04/2023 12:13

I agree that often on an island crossing their is another button to push for the second half. If so, strictly speaking you shouldnt have crossed. But driver was wrong too and shouldnt have acted in an agressive way and shouldnt have moved on flashing amber He should only have moved if the road was clear.

LlynTegid · 05/04/2023 12:11

As others have said, you were 100% right.

BMW or Audi car perhaps?

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 05/04/2023 12:09

You were 100% in the right. The driver should not be moving forward until his light is green, regardless of whether anyone was on the crossing. And you have right of way until you have finished crossing even if his light does go green before you reach the pavement.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 05/04/2023 12:08

He sounds like a twat

HurryShadow · 05/04/2023 12:07

From the BSM website - aimed at drivers:

"If the traffic lights are at a pedestrian crossing, the lights tend to flash amber before turning green. This means you can proceed if the crossing is clear. If pedestrians are still crossing, wait until it’s safe to go."

Basically, the only coloured light that means "go" is green. YANBU OP.

I hate pedestrian crossings that don't give you enough time to cross. There's one near me that even if I start the second the green man comes up I'm not at the other side by the time it goes off. I'm not exactly slow either. A less mobile person would really struggle.

dementedpixie · 05/04/2023 12:04

The car is supposed to wait for the light to be green before moving forwards if someone is crossing so they are in the wrong.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 05/04/2023 12:01

A pedestrian always has right of way if their feet are on the road, even if they have made a mistake and shouldn't be crossing, the driver would always be found at-fault in the event of an incident.

If there was a second button to press on the central island and the green person wasn't illuminated when you started the second half then you should have waited on the central island, but not if there wasn't another button.

the amber flashing light for cars means "you may proceed if all pedestrians have finished crossing". you had not finished crossing so it was wrong for him to object.

it is always wrong for any driver to beep the horn to express anger, frustration or objection to another person's actions. the horn is only to be used to attract attention to a hazard that another road user doesn't appear to be aware of.

Neededanewuserhandle · 05/04/2023 11:58

In theory the flashing amber is to allow pedestrians to complete a crossing they have started, so as a pedestrian you shouldn't set off across on a flashing amber. However everyone seems to ignore this and in any case Mr Twat was still being a Twat.

dietcokelime · 05/04/2023 11:53

Seeline · 05/04/2023 11:35

If there is an island in the middle, is there not a second button to push?
Usually an island in the middle of a crossing allows drivers to treat each side of the crossing separately.

Having said that a driver should always give way to a pedestrian already crossing the road, even if they are not using a crossing. They also cannot move off on a flashing amber light if a pedestrian is still crossing the road. So you were definitely not at fault and he should not have sounded his horn.

Under the latest Highway Code changes, a driver should give way to a pedestrian waiting to cross the road at any point, although I really cannot see how this can work if the pedestrian takes this literally and just walks straight onto the carriageway. Similarly if a driver is turning into a minor road from a main road with little visibility into the side road. Being both a pedestrian and a driver, I would try to avoid walking straight onto the carriageway as a pedestrian!

I agree on the island part! If there's an island in a crossing the second part is treated as a separate crossing.

I thought the new Highway Code meant drivers needed to give way to pedestrians crossing when turning from a main road to a side road? Not just give way at all times to any pedestrians trying to cross anywhere?

Regularsizedrudy · 05/04/2023 11:50

He was being a prick.

pickledandpuzzled · 05/04/2023 11:48

Was he tooting someone else? That happens. Sometimes I'm upset I've been rooted at but it was actually a greeting for someone else! There's no way of knowing!

Kazzyhoward · 05/04/2023 11:48

If there's an Island in the middle, it's likely that the traffic lights are separate, so you should have checked the lights on other half and stayed on the island if there was no green man, and pressed the button for the other half and waited.

Whether you're at fault or the driver depends on whether the lights were separate, so no one can say without knowing that.

Iam4eels · 05/04/2023 11:44

It's only a separate crossing if there is a second push-button on the island, some crossings have island about only one button at either side so it's one crossing. There's one near us.

Swipe left for the next trending thread