Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL and boundaries

39 replies

Greenwichresident · 04/04/2023 22:19

A little bit scared to post on here, but would really love to hear your honest opinions. I really dislike confrontation, I'm terrible at asserting myself and this is the first time I've ever really spoken up my MIL in 7 years. I've been spending the last few days feeling guilty about it and I'm not sure if that's just me really struggling to be comfortable with asserting myself, or if I am being unreasonable.

Background - MIL has found it quite hard to take a step back from DS and allow him to be an adult. He's a very capable, independent man. Her anxiety takes over - she often needs to know what we're doing, and will get very upset if she isn't updated. We are both in our 30s, we have a DS (4), and frankly I often find it stifling.
She messages most days and expects to see us regularly- in an ideal world she would see us on a weekly basis if she could. The longest we've managed to leave it is 3 weeks, and she's been quick to let DH know that she was very unhappy and disappointed with this. I've tried very hard to reach her high expectations over the past few years, often at the expense of my own feelings. I really do it to keep the peace- I never complain or make a fuss. During my maternity leave I visited her on a weekly basis, often without DH there.... this is despite her being fairly quick to point out pretty insignificant things I was doing wrong from a parenting stand point. I've been pushed into going on their annual family holiday each year- including one year when I was 6 weeks post partum, when I really just wanted time alone, as a 3, to adjust. Each time we've said no she's made us feel unbelievably bad, and weeks later has managed to guilt trip us into going. It's not my husband who caves in - it's often me, because her guilt tripping is pretty effective.

Last week myself, my DH and my DS went on holiday alone. I was so looking forward to time alone- as a 3. I was pretty run down and ill, and I just needed a break. Yet my MIL messaged us every day, often several times a day - to see how we were, what we were up to - how our DS is etc. etc.. We're in a group chat, so I responded on day 1 with a really warm message, but ending with "have a great week! :)" - just so I could relax and know that I could put my phone away for the week. I just wanted to take a step back and enjoy the rare break.

DH continued to reply to the messages, mainly to avoid a drama, and to enable me to go phone free. Nothing went unanswered- but despite this, on Day 3 she messaged me directly to see if I was ok, as she'd noticed I'd been quiet and wanted to see if there was a problem. I replied and said "yes all good thank you! having a great time! Just taking a break from my phone and really trying to be present with DS". She replied saying that she understood and that being present is a good thing to do - and I thought that was it and the matter was closed. I shared some photos of DS with her to reassure her, and went back to taking a phone break. The messaging continued between MIL and DH, and we return home.

We then received a message over the weekend to ask what we're doing next weekend- DH replies to say that unfortunately we're busy (we're actually seeing my family, who I haven't seen in months, alongside the standard kids activities for our DS). At 11:30pm that evening she texted to say that she was very upset and disappointed that she wouldn't be seeing him over easter, and that we've both been ignoring her all week.

DH called her the next morning to say that we absolutely weren't ignoring them, but that her expectations are unreasonable and that we all have our own lives too - including our DS who has a right to do activities or playdates, and not just spend every weekend with family. I could hear on on the phone that his parents were very defensive and clearly don't really understand how stifling her behaviour is. After this conversation I felt still pretty deflated - I kept thinking about all of the moments that I haven't stood up for myself and have regretted it.

So I sent her a message, and it started with empathy, but I expressed that I was hurt that she doesn't seem to appreciate that there is a much bigger picture - DS has his own activities that he wants to do, and that I also have a family, who I would like to see more, but we rarely do. I wrote that if the person who sees us the most is still disappointed, what more should we sacrifice to accomodate that? Finally, I called out that I had only been silent for 3 days but I've heard that she called my silence 'strange', and that I wish she'd had a little more empathy for the fact that I could just be trying to spend time with my DS.

This is the first time I've ever really asserted myself. Was I unreasonable? p.s. so sorry for the long message!

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 05/04/2023 00:32

Truthfully? I think you've made a mountain out of a molehill.

She cares and yes, maybe messages too much for your liking, but nothing you've said is worth falling out over.

This IS a mountain, and her MIL has ensured that it is. She texted them at 11:30 at night to whinge and bitch that she wasn't getting everything her way. She is a manipulative, self-absorbed cow. She has guilt tripped them for years just for having the audacity to live their own lives. The op should have set her straight years ago.

SkyandSurf · 05/04/2023 00:38

@Greenwichresident

Your story reminds me of the early days with my in laws. They were incredibly possessive and the emotional black mail can be really controlling and suffocating.

I also felt I was constantly ignoring what I wanted to cater to their fixed ideas of what we owed them. They were incredibly jealous of my family and I would have to deal with pouting and complaining every time I had the audacity to see my own family with the baby. There was a lot of score keeping and it was ridiculous.

As other posters have said- set your boundaries and stick to them. This is your family and you make the rules. You're also allowed to change the rules.

As your child grows they have will their own friends and hobbies. This isn't sustainable.

Work out what suits you and your husband and child. There will always be some compromise with family but nothing on this scale.

You shouldn't incur a 'time debt' for going on holiday that needs to be repaid. That's ridiculous.

Greenwichresident · 05/04/2023 00:41

And as @KettrickenSmiled said- the issue really was never about how much is too much / not enough.

It's the repercussions for not being able to sustain the level of contact she wants.

I've been asked twice on this thread to consider how I'd feel in 30 years, if my DS' partner spoke to me as I did.

Frankly, I would hope that they would need to. And that I'm a sensitive enough person to never make my DS' partner feel that way.

I know it's easier said than done, and I know it'll be a painful adjustment - but I truly hope that see my DS' independence as a sign of success, and not something to be resented. I wouldn't dream of making him feel guilty for having his own life, and not sending me multiple messages a day.

OP posts:
Greenwichresident · 05/04/2023 00:45

Apologies that should say *wouldn't need to

Thank you @Aquamarine1029 Flowers

Thanks so much for sharing your experience @SkyandSurf it's really, really reassuring to hear from someone who has been through similar.

OP posts:
Greenwichresident · 05/04/2023 00:51

Thanks @BeckyBeehive - really appreciate your comments. You're so right, I am very relieved that my DH is on the same page and feel very lucky for that. It's made this whole thing much much easier.

OP posts:
SkyandSurf · 05/04/2023 00:51

@Greenwichresident

Happy to, I feel like I could have written your post a few years ago.

The phrase we kept coming back to was that PIL needed to 'adjust their expectations.'

Otherwise when you're speaking to them you'll go around in circles talking about their feelings 'we feel hurt, we feel excluded, we missed you' etc. and you can't argue with their feelings. Just acknowledge them, but say the weekly contact isn't sustainable now that DS is older and has his own friends and hobbies- and you have decided that you need to spend more time with your own family. They will need to adjust their expectations around the amount of time and contact but that doesn't mean you don't love them blah blah blah.

And keep offering for them to collect DS from nursery if that's something that suits you. It's not like you're saying they cant see DS - it just can't be all on their terms.

You're being more than reasonable. Stick to your guns.

CremeEggQueen · 05/04/2023 01:10

Werehalfwaythere · 04/04/2023 22:37

Truthfully? I think you've made a mountain out of a molehill.

She cares and yes, maybe messages too much for your liking, but nothing you've said is worth falling out over.

Seeing family weekly is normal for me. My kids have a really close bond to my parents due to this. It's lovely. We still have plenty of time for playdates and activities.

Either there's more to the story, or you've been reading too many MIL bashing posts.

Just remember one thing; you have a son too and one day he will find a partner and settle down. Will you be ok if his partner talks to you like you have?

Just roll your eyes to yourself and move on. The drama just isn't necessary when she's only trying to show she cares about you all (from what I've read).

Said by someone who clearly hasn't experienced this themselves!
OP, you sound so like me, but where I was 10 years ago 🙂
I'd ring at least once a week just to say hello, see how she is, despite we see her daily
Always got off the phone feeling shit though through emotional blackmail.stuff so stopped.
Always undermined what felt like every parenting decision, also would say something in front of the kids that "I was going to do so and so with you but mummy says no" umm... yes, because we have something else on, it's nothing personal! Why needlessly try and shit stir and upset them?!
If you can't go out for the day with her for any reason it's "you're letting your kids down."
Er no we're not.
I'm the least confrontational person ever but you have to put boundaries in place for your own sanity and relations, however much you're shaking when you first do it.
Unless you've been through it yourself you dont have a clue, sotry.

CremeEggQueen · 05/04/2023 01:17

At least now I think I know how to be a perfect MIL in future (I hope 😁)
I want to be there for any future grandkids and my DIL, but I'm popping round for visits if it's convenient and not laying any guilt trips on if not, and never accuse DS and DIL of not doing what's right for their kids just because they can't go out with me for the day 😬
I'll be there for them but appreciate they have other stuff on too, and that's ok

CremeEggQueen · 05/04/2023 01:23

Greenwichresident · 05/04/2023 00:41

And as @KettrickenSmiled said- the issue really was never about how much is too much / not enough.

It's the repercussions for not being able to sustain the level of contact she wants.

I've been asked twice on this thread to consider how I'd feel in 30 years, if my DS' partner spoke to me as I did.

Frankly, I would hope that they would need to. And that I'm a sensitive enough person to never make my DS' partner feel that way.

I know it's easier said than done, and I know it'll be a painful adjustment - but I truly hope that see my DS' independence as a sign of success, and not something to be resented. I wouldn't dream of making him feel guilty for having his own life, and not sending me multiple messages a day.

I truly hope that see my DS' independence as a sign of success, and not something to be resented. I wouldn't dream of making him feel guilty for having his own life, and not sending me multiple messages a day
Same - my DS recently moved out, and I'm happy and excited for his next chapter (yep that sounds wanky lol) but hope you get what I mean.
I can't imagine trying to make him feel guilty if for some reason he and his girlfriend can't come out with me etc

BlueLavender1 · 05/04/2023 01:31

Could she pick DS up from school/nursery once a week and look after him whilst you're both at work?
If she says she wants to see all of you, say that's fine but you will have to cut the weekly visits with just DS back to monthly with all of you. I'm sure she might soon think differently.

In terms of seeing all of you, once a fortnight could you have her over for dinner on Sunday? Lets says they arrive at 4pm, you all have dinner and then they leave when DS gets ready for bed around 7/8. And that sets time boundaries. It doesn't have to be something fancy either, could just be pasta etc, or whatever you normally have!

BungleandGeorge · 05/04/2023 01:44

CremeEggQueen · 05/04/2023 01:17

At least now I think I know how to be a perfect MIL in future (I hope 😁)
I want to be there for any future grandkids and my DIL, but I'm popping round for visits if it's convenient and not laying any guilt trips on if not, and never accuse DS and DIL of not doing what's right for their kids just because they can't go out with me for the day 😬
I'll be there for them but appreciate they have other stuff on too, and that's ok

What happens when they only want to see you every 4 weeks or less?
I think it’s all very well to say you wouldn’t be bothered or you’ll be happy for your kids to do
this but in reality it’s pretty usual to see grandparents who live close by every week or two. When it stretches to weeks people start getting upset and controlling
OP can you compromise and maybe she has your son for tea once a week? Or watches him at an activity? Or set a regular fortnightly time to
have a meal or a visit? If you live close by it doesn’t have to be a weekend.

SpringHasSprung23 · 05/04/2023 01:58

@Greenwichresident

DH is of the opinion that she treats me that way because she thinks she can

ok, so he sees it, but hadn't disabused her of the notion? Why not?

DH isn't doing enough to put her back in her box!!

you did well. Maintain your boundaries & let her throw tantrums. She'll get over it.

also, I definitely wouldn't encourage her to pick DS up from nursery. I'd be pleased she wasn't keen on having him in her own. The constant drip in his ear wouldn't be good for in (or you)!!

SkyandSurf · 05/04/2023 03:55

CremeEggQueen · 05/04/2023 01:17

At least now I think I know how to be a perfect MIL in future (I hope 😁)
I want to be there for any future grandkids and my DIL, but I'm popping round for visits if it's convenient and not laying any guilt trips on if not, and never accuse DS and DIL of not doing what's right for their kids just because they can't go out with me for the day 😬
I'll be there for them but appreciate they have other stuff on too, and that's ok

Smile I'm sure I won't be a perfect MIL either, butmy MIL was a Masterclass in what-not-to-do.

I will be glad that my children are grown and independent

I will have my own life and interests and not rely on my grown children to entertain me and fill my days.

The only opinions I will express to my DIL will be positive ones.

I have a clear sense of where I end and others begin.

Good relationships need boundaries and I've never accepted that I have to take an unlimited amount of crap from my MIL to prevent some kind of karmic retribution from my own fictional DILs.

olympicsrock · 05/04/2023 04:08

She sounds awful. And you sound super reasonable. Thank god for a sane DH. Channel @SkyandSurf and talk about them adjusting expectations Luke a broken record.
good luck! X

New posts on this thread. Refresh page