Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL and boundaries

39 replies

Greenwichresident · 04/04/2023 22:19

A little bit scared to post on here, but would really love to hear your honest opinions. I really dislike confrontation, I'm terrible at asserting myself and this is the first time I've ever really spoken up my MIL in 7 years. I've been spending the last few days feeling guilty about it and I'm not sure if that's just me really struggling to be comfortable with asserting myself, or if I am being unreasonable.

Background - MIL has found it quite hard to take a step back from DS and allow him to be an adult. He's a very capable, independent man. Her anxiety takes over - she often needs to know what we're doing, and will get very upset if she isn't updated. We are both in our 30s, we have a DS (4), and frankly I often find it stifling.
She messages most days and expects to see us regularly- in an ideal world she would see us on a weekly basis if she could. The longest we've managed to leave it is 3 weeks, and she's been quick to let DH know that she was very unhappy and disappointed with this. I've tried very hard to reach her high expectations over the past few years, often at the expense of my own feelings. I really do it to keep the peace- I never complain or make a fuss. During my maternity leave I visited her on a weekly basis, often without DH there.... this is despite her being fairly quick to point out pretty insignificant things I was doing wrong from a parenting stand point. I've been pushed into going on their annual family holiday each year- including one year when I was 6 weeks post partum, when I really just wanted time alone, as a 3, to adjust. Each time we've said no she's made us feel unbelievably bad, and weeks later has managed to guilt trip us into going. It's not my husband who caves in - it's often me, because her guilt tripping is pretty effective.

Last week myself, my DH and my DS went on holiday alone. I was so looking forward to time alone- as a 3. I was pretty run down and ill, and I just needed a break. Yet my MIL messaged us every day, often several times a day - to see how we were, what we were up to - how our DS is etc. etc.. We're in a group chat, so I responded on day 1 with a really warm message, but ending with "have a great week! :)" - just so I could relax and know that I could put my phone away for the week. I just wanted to take a step back and enjoy the rare break.

DH continued to reply to the messages, mainly to avoid a drama, and to enable me to go phone free. Nothing went unanswered- but despite this, on Day 3 she messaged me directly to see if I was ok, as she'd noticed I'd been quiet and wanted to see if there was a problem. I replied and said "yes all good thank you! having a great time! Just taking a break from my phone and really trying to be present with DS". She replied saying that she understood and that being present is a good thing to do - and I thought that was it and the matter was closed. I shared some photos of DS with her to reassure her, and went back to taking a phone break. The messaging continued between MIL and DH, and we return home.

We then received a message over the weekend to ask what we're doing next weekend- DH replies to say that unfortunately we're busy (we're actually seeing my family, who I haven't seen in months, alongside the standard kids activities for our DS). At 11:30pm that evening she texted to say that she was very upset and disappointed that she wouldn't be seeing him over easter, and that we've both been ignoring her all week.

DH called her the next morning to say that we absolutely weren't ignoring them, but that her expectations are unreasonable and that we all have our own lives too - including our DS who has a right to do activities or playdates, and not just spend every weekend with family. I could hear on on the phone that his parents were very defensive and clearly don't really understand how stifling her behaviour is. After this conversation I felt still pretty deflated - I kept thinking about all of the moments that I haven't stood up for myself and have regretted it.

So I sent her a message, and it started with empathy, but I expressed that I was hurt that she doesn't seem to appreciate that there is a much bigger picture - DS has his own activities that he wants to do, and that I also have a family, who I would like to see more, but we rarely do. I wrote that if the person who sees us the most is still disappointed, what more should we sacrifice to accomodate that? Finally, I called out that I had only been silent for 3 days but I've heard that she called my silence 'strange', and that I wish she'd had a little more empathy for the fact that I could just be trying to spend time with my DS.

This is the first time I've ever really asserted myself. Was I unreasonable? p.s. so sorry for the long message!

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 04/04/2023 23:08

Truthfully? I think you've made a mountain out of a molehill.
It's been going on for years.
It IS a mountain.

She cares and yes, maybe messages too much for your liking, but nothing you've said is worth falling out over.
Obviously it is, to OP.
The alternative is to suck it up, comply, & be coerced into communicating every day & sacrificing DC activities & OP's own parents in order to appea MiL.

Seeing family weekly is normal for me. My kids have a really close bond to my parents due to this. It's lovely. We still have plenty of time for playdates and activities.
Lovely for you.
OP is not you, MiL is not your parents, & OP is feeling suffocated.
Your close relationship with your parents is no reason for OP to continue to tolerate MiL's enmeshment.

Either there's more to the story, or you've been reading too many MIL bashing posts.
Is it beyond the scope of your imagination that OP is simply recouting facts, there is no "more" to the story to justify ML;'s over-stepping, & that OP is an adult who is capable of distinguishing her own life from other posters'?

Just remember one thing; you have a son too and one day he will find a partner and settle down. Will you be ok if his partner talks to you like you have?
OP's son's future partner wont need to fend her off, because she wont be demanding daily access to their lives & a running commentary on what they are doing.

Just roll your eyes to yourself and move on. The drama just isn't necessary when she's only trying to show she cares about you all (from what I've read).
Read harder.
OP isn't creating drama, she's trying her best to distance herself from it.
The drama comes from MiL expressing upset & disappointment, manipulating her son & DiL into giving more access into their lives than they want to.
She's fed up with MiL pushing into her life, & having to dance attendance on her when she rarely gets to see her own parents.

This isn't caring behaviour, it's overbearing entitlement.

Cats23 · 04/04/2023 22:59

Just start messaging the group chat once a week, dont go to visit every time Dh does.
You have a life, your family has a life, it doesnt revolve around MIl being in the loop almost daily.

Izzy24 · 04/04/2023 22:50

Werehalfwaythere · 04/04/2023 22:37

Truthfully? I think you've made a mountain out of a molehill.

She cares and yes, maybe messages too much for your liking, but nothing you've said is worth falling out over.

Seeing family weekly is normal for me. My kids have a really close bond to my parents due to this. It's lovely. We still have plenty of time for playdates and activities.

Either there's more to the story, or you've been reading too many MIL bashing posts.

Just remember one thing; you have a son too and one day he will find a partner and settle down. Will you be ok if his partner talks to you like you have?

Just roll your eyes to yourself and move on. The drama just isn't necessary when she's only trying to show she cares about you all (from what I've read).

This .

mdinbc · 04/04/2023 22:47

Coming from a grandmother, she seems a bit needy. Do you live in the same town, so visiting is convenient? It sounds like you handled it politely but firmly, and I hope she gets the point.

I used to see my in-town GC weekly, while they were pre-school, but now they are in activities etc, it doesn't happen every week, and I'm certainly not texting and calling daily. If they go away, i like a text saying they are home from travelling, that's it.

tiredpuppymum · 04/04/2023 22:45

She sounds very intense. Can you leave the group chat? Or atleast mute it?

IScreamAtMichaelangelos · 04/04/2023 22:43

You are completely not being unreasonable. She will try to tell you you are, but you're not. Brace yourself for the inevitable defensiveness/guilt trip and hopefully you'll be less susceptible to it when it comes!

Maybe put together a bingo card of key guilt trip topics/phrases to expect? "I'm suddenly ill" is very popular, as is "random household emergency" or "distant relative roped in to berate you". The above is not meant to be cruel and certainly not meant to be shared with her, but may give you the emotional distance needed to cope with her unreasonable demands.

You say you give in, not your DH. He sounds like he has her measure more than you do, which will actually help in holding the line and ending up with an outcome everyone can live with.

Greenwichresident · 04/04/2023 22:42

Holy shit @PlantagenetEmbassy - your experience sounds awful! seriously well done on being so strong and thank you for sharing your experience- it helped so much to reach about the approaches you've taken and that long term, they do work.

Thank you so much @Werehalfwaythere and @Seas164 for the really words of encouragement

OP posts:
Seas164 · 04/04/2023 22:38

Either you're going to be upset, or she is. It's not your job to prevent your MIL from upset, buy accommodating her every whim for contact.

Deep down you know it's unreasonable, try to connect with that knowledge when you deal with her, and back yourself up from now on.

Werehalfwaythere · 04/04/2023 22:37

Truthfully? I think you've made a mountain out of a molehill.

She cares and yes, maybe messages too much for your liking, but nothing you've said is worth falling out over.

Seeing family weekly is normal for me. My kids have a really close bond to my parents due to this. It's lovely. We still have plenty of time for playdates and activities.

Either there's more to the story, or you've been reading too many MIL bashing posts.

Just remember one thing; you have a son too and one day he will find a partner and settle down. Will you be ok if his partner talks to you like you have?

Just roll your eyes to yourself and move on. The drama just isn't necessary when she's only trying to show she cares about you all (from what I've read).

Greenwichresident · 04/04/2023 22:36

Thanks so much @HappyHolidays22 and @Hbh17

Great advice. Honestly I think part of my issue has been not knowing if this is 'normal' behaviour from an in law. I know deep down that it's unreasonable, and that the only way forward is by asserting strong boundaries and disengaging.

We've never proactively shared information, it's usually reactive to the constant stream of questions, to avoid upset. But actually sometimes upset is necessary and at this point I think we just need to be ok with that.

OP posts:
Walterwhiteswifey · 04/04/2023 22:35

Well done for standing your ground. You need to be strong and assertive whilst remaining polite. Sounds like you've done just that.

PlantagenetEmbassy · 04/04/2023 22:33

You have to do one-handed clapping with people like this. Just let her flap flap flap at nothing. Stop feeding her. At the moment when you reply and send pictures and try to pretend you're fine she's getting what she wants and she learns that this shitty behaviour leads to a reward - attention.

We have a MIL like this although ours also lies and manipulates and shit stirs so we really don't like talking to her.

First I blocked her everywhere. And SIL who is just as bad (flying monkey). I made it so that she HAD to communicate only with DH for everything and anything. None of it was my problem and I refused to let her take up space in my brain. Second, we do grey rock. Which is DH tells her the bare minimum.

He replies to her messages about once a week, usually a Friday, and every couple of weeks he has a video call where we mostly get horrendously interrogated by her and FIL (and SIL if she's round their house which she usually is, they're terribly enmeshed), we answer a bunch of rapidfire questions, take all the criticism on the nose, then it's over for another two weeks. DH doesn't reply to every message she sends.

At first she acted out, tried to raise the stakes and get the attention she was craving. She called his workplace and even wrote to them! She didn't get a response. She called and texted DH over and over, and emailed. She didn't get a response. She then phoned MY family and put it about that she thought we were missing! They then gave her a bit of attention and went out of their way (worried by her stupidity because they didn't know she was lying to get attention) to contact me. I replied to them only and pointed out we had been in contact with MIL literally two weeks earlier.

After 3 years of this she is finally accepting that this is it. This is all the contact she gets. She no longer gets to book DH his doctor's appointments and she doesn't get photos of every stage of the children's lives because she brought it on herself by suffocating us and lying and creating drama where there didn't need to be any.

Now we don't get harassed. It takes a long time but even the most apron-strings MIL can be grey rocked.

HappyHolidays22 · 04/04/2023 22:30

This ^

although I totally see why you feel bad, I am such a peacekeeper too and hate arguments BUT this is not your fault and you have every right to a life without your MIL being involved.

try to put her out of your mind. Be normal and pleasant with her going forward but start to adhere to boundaries you set for yourself (you can’t control what she does so this is about how much you engage and exchange with her). Good luck

Hbh17 · 04/04/2023 22:24

YANBU and boh of you need to stop engaging with her so much. For example, stick to a sensible limit of one phone call per week and one meeting per month - which is still quite a lot for a busy family, to be fair.
Also, stop telling her everything you do! She has no right to know where you are, what you're doing etc, so both of you have to be more assertive.