Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having a 'chemistry check' with future colleagues as part of the job interview process - AIBU?

119 replies

5678ugh · 04/04/2023 20:43

My employer has recently started incorporating a 'chemistry check' as part of the final stages of the interview process. This is for the entry-level graduate positions. It's a hybrid role where we work in teams, so it is important to be someone who can generally get along well with others and work as a team.

However, I really don't like the idea, but I'm not sure if I'm thinking too much into it. The company is very middle-class full of Oxbridge graduates (not me) and to me this 'chemistry check' almost seems designed to keep it that way, it doesn't feel very inclusive.

AIBU or is this becoming a standard part of recruitment now?

OP posts:
Biscuitlover456 · 05/04/2023 06:29

Lengokengo · 05/04/2023 06:24

having once joined a completely dysfunctional team, which became very evident very quickly, I think it can actually be a good thing.

i overlooked red flags in the interview process in my eagerness to get a job after a long gap. Seeing the team in situ might have further shown up the red flags. Instead, I accepted the job, and by lunchtime on my first day, I was regretting this bitterly.

This is a good point. These types of checks may be valuable for the candidate to see if the company seems like somewhere they want to work. It can be really difficult to know and depending on the interview process this might not include much information about the working culture

Tockomtele · 05/04/2023 06:28

Well, I'd have not accepted two jobs if I was given the opportunity to meet everyone. One I left after 1 day, the other one I hated after a week but stuck out for about 7-8 months.
I think it's a very good idea.

lookingforaholiday · 05/04/2023 06:26

We do this at our firm but don't call it a chemistry check. It's an opportunity for the candidate to meet some more of the team and vice versa. An opportunity for the candidate to ask questions and for us as interviewers to have an opinion from other team members on the candidate's fit with the team. Team dynamics is very important to us but that's not to say we want clones of our existing team members! I think it's very narrow minded to think all Oxford grads are the same!

Lengokengo · 05/04/2023 06:24

having once joined a completely dysfunctional team, which became very evident very quickly, I think it can actually be a good thing.

i overlooked red flags in the interview process in my eagerness to get a job after a long gap. Seeing the team in situ might have further shown up the red flags. Instead, I accepted the job, and by lunchtime on my first day, I was regretting this bitterly.

Phoebo · 05/04/2023 06:17

It's a good way to get buy in from the staff too as they're part of the process. I remember our preferred candidate turned out to be a complete dud and we then realised that it's not always easy to spot them!

DowningStreetParty · 05/04/2023 06:15

YANBU these not incisive and are tokenism because staff views aren’t equal to panel views. if interview panel likes the person but the staff group don’t, the person still gets appointed. This has happened recently in my experience and has created bad feeling in the staff. why ask for their views if they won’t be acted on etc.

As a candidate with experience of having done these staff meets, straight after a formal panel interview they are awful and fake at a time you are already exhausted from the interview. Not informal however relaxed they are dressed up as and actually really a horrible experience and ambiguous to the candidate of how seriously to take them. Sets up a discomfort among a larger group of peers than the panel members in future if the job isn’t offered to you. That. Doesn’t help networks flourish. Companies could put off good candidates or alienate them for a future role that they would be a good fit for.

As a staff member I would resent being asked to be on one of these feedback groups. Put me on the interview panel, or don’t.

Jagoda · 05/04/2023 06:10

This is standard practice in my sector (legal) and we have a very diverse workforce.

From my experience it’s more about “is this person an arsehole who has pulled the wool over HR eyes”

I can remember one bloke who asked if he would be able to get a taxi to the nearest pub and back at lunchtime (greenfield site) as he couldn’t get through the day without two pints. A woman who had applied for a job in Finance who admitted she was terrified of numbers, and of course, the usual know it alls.

If you think it’s discrimination then you are effectively accusing your colleagues of being racist/sexist/homophobic. If that’s what you believe, I would be looking for another job.

MangoBiscuit · 05/04/2023 06:08

@Berklilly I had very similar in my job application. Just a final round of meeting a few more people from the team, not just those I'd be reporting to, having an informal chat, making sure we got well enough. We're a fairly diverse team, and I certainly don't fit the mold for a stereotypical software dev, but I got the job.

I don't think having a chemistry check is a bad thing in itself, although I can see the possibility of it being abused and used to discriminate if management aren't careful. I think it depends very much on the implementation.

YukoandHiro · 05/04/2023 06:03

Is there an HR team? I would take your concerns to them re: diversity as this is terrible practice.

Are they a big firm/known brand? If so I'd leak it to a business journalist tbh. This kind of insidious stuff needs getting rid of.

Berklilly · 05/04/2023 05:44

We did something similar in my previous team, and it was received very positively.

The candidates would meet the team (2-3 ppl) for 30 min at the end of their assessment center. It was an informal chat rather than a formal interview or "check", and the candidates usually used this opportunity to ask questions about the role/company/team that they didn't feel they could ask HR or the hiring manager.

For us it was a way to flag anyone that would clearly clash with the team - usually those with ego issues ignoring us completely or spending that time bragging.

I'm not sure how people here interpret this kind of meeting as "conscious discrimination". Surely this is all about your company culture, how they frame the meeting and how they brief you. Any type of interview can be biased and discriminatory if that's what the hiring manager or company wants.

Equalitea · 05/04/2023 05:15

It isn’t common in all sectors but I have heard of it in others. It doesn’t sound very inclusive at all but in the long term it may be beneficial for the candidates in not wasting their time.

There would likely be an excuse from the company as to why the candidate didn’t pass probation and wasn’t being afforded a permanent contract if the chemistry didn’t fit anyway.

Useruser1 · 04/04/2023 23:28

Reugny · 04/04/2023 20:57

This is called "team fit" and another way to discriminate against people who don't look and sound like them.

Funny thing is diverse teams actually produce better work and higher profits for a company.

I would make a big fuss and tell your bosses that they are likely to be sued under the Equality Act if they go ahead with this bs.

Is there any decent evidence of this "diverse team" format making more money for the company? Please share it would be great to share with my colleagues!

Phoebo · 04/04/2023 23:10

Reugny · 04/04/2023 20:57

This is called "team fit" and another way to discriminate against people who don't look and sound like them.

Funny thing is diverse teams actually produce better work and higher profits for a company.

I would make a big fuss and tell your bosses that they are likely to be sued under the Equality Act if they go ahead with this bs.

Hardly. You don't need to do this to ascertain that, if that was your goal you'd be able to eliminate those people in the first interview

Phoebo · 04/04/2023 23:09

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 04/04/2023 21:21

I would lump this with the while ‘they must fit in with the team’s personalities’ nonsense. Just another way of saying “We want to employ people just like us”. A real win for anti-diversity

Not at all, a great team gets along well and usually have differing opinions and strengths so they complement each other. The only people who are anti this are the ones who struggle to get on with others and they are the ones you want to weed out. Nothing worse than someone with two right skills that no one can stand, worked with many of those.

deeplybaffled · 04/04/2023 22:34

It applies where I work, and is done before formal interviews. I personally think it wastes a lot of time for not much benefit, as candidates only meet one team member and around 80-90% go through to the next round but am happy to be told I’m a Luddite.

Hbh17 · 04/04/2023 22:28

It sounds very old-fashioned actually - many workplaces used to do similar, but called it "trial by sherry"!

Agapornis · 04/04/2023 22:26

Please name the company so I can make sure to avoid them. After an offer sure, but before? Applicants will say anything to pretend to fit in. The potential for bias/discrimination is huge, and it's a massive waste of applicants' time.

OMGitsnotgood · 04/04/2023 22:26

This is called "team fit" and another way to discriminate against people who don't look and sound like them.
Only if the process does indeed discriminate against those people. You're making a massive assumption that they will.. If they are exploring whether the candidates' values and qualities are a good match then it's not a bad thing.

Funny thing is diverse teams actually produce better work and higher profits for a company.
Indeed (although the same research says it can take longer for diverse teams to gel, but once they do it will produce superior results).

I would make a big fuss and tell your bosses that they are likely to be sued under the Equality Act if they go ahead with this bs.
The candidate would have to be able to prove that they were discriminated against for reasons related to a protected characteristic. If they haven't demonstrated a good fit with eg values of the organisation, or didn't act with commitment and integrity during the process (or whatever criteria they are assessing on), and a fair decision has been made on that basis, the Equality Act wouldn't help them . Unless of course they could prove that someone who was an equally poor fit was hired.
Rather than make 'a big fuss' and saying 'they will be sued', OP could. make a professional approach to an appropriate manager, express their concerns about the potential for discrimination. Ask to understand more about how the process will be executed and ask what safeguards are in place to ensure it's not an opportunity to appoint people who all 'look and sound the same.'
It might be that there is cause for concern. But it may well not. OP doesn't seem to know enough about it yet. Many organisations who are very committed to diversity and inclusion use these sorts of approaches successfully without using it as another vehicle for discrimination.

I think the OP is right to voice her concerns , but needs to understand more about the process before going in all guns blazing shouting about the Equality Act. In my experience most people who do this or suggest others do this. don't understand the legislation well enough, and that does their own credibility no favours whatsoever.

whenshallwethreemeet · 04/04/2023 21:52

City law firms used to do this for post-qualification roles but after they'd offered you the job. So it was:

  • interviews 1/2/3
  • offer
  • out with immediate team, usually with no bosses there
  • accept (or not)
Doing this led to me changing my mind about which firm to move to as one team were really supportive of each other, commented on some downsides of the firm but were generally positive whilst the other group were constantly bitching and sniping about others in the team and made it sound like a horrible environment
OMGitsnotgood · 04/04/2023 21:52

Curiosity101 · 04/04/2023 21:06

We have 4 part interviews. 2 test technical skills, 1 is business fit and 1 is team fit. We have had a huge amount of training on diversity, inclusion and bias.

For us business fit doesn't mean "Are you like us". It's more like there are a broad set of soft skills we look for as a business and it's assessing that. Are you highly motivated, friendly, good problem solver etc.

Team fit takes into account the personalities and interests etc of the team the person is going into. Building a highly effective team is a bit of an artform. Thinking about the team I work in we are a relatively diverse set of people from different backgrounds, ethnicities, ages etc. But there are a few clear themes and values that are shared between us both in professional and personal matters. This helps us to work together well whilst still bringing a diverse set of perspectives to the table.

If your 'chemistry check' is like our team fit then I'd see no issues with it if you all need to work and collaborate closely.

I was going to write something very similar.
It sounds like a positive thing to me with the right training of those assessing

Queenofscones · 04/04/2023 21:50

I was driven out of my last office-based job (years ago) when an extraordinarily anti-social, manipulative, narcissistic individual was appointed to my team by my manager. He had good skills but refused to be managed and was unpleasant to colleagues. Difficult to pin him down, but he'd lie and do everything he could to be difficult and uncooperative. It was intentional and malicious. Two members of my team left within six months of his arrival. They were angry with me that I couldn't get him fired or moved on. Sickness rates went up, productivity declined and the atmosphere in the office soured. HR were aware of the situation and agreed that his behaviour was bordering bullying and abusive but like my manager kept insisting that I find a way to make it work because he was good at what he did. It got to the stage where I couldn't bear to be anywhere near him and left to set up my own business.

I currently employ three people. They're all good at what they do and we work well together. When I recruit I'm concerned that people have the skills and qualifications I need — but above all that comes the question about whether they'll be a good fit with my team. Because if I make a bad choice on that front I put all our livelihoods and contentment in jeopardy.

ooherrmissus14 · 04/04/2023 21:28

They need to look up the concept of group think which is when the views and values of a group can be too similar which leads to a lack of critical thinking and poor decision making

DonnaRix · 04/04/2023 21:23

theodozya · 04/04/2023 20:59

I agree that it’s not very inclusive. But in my sector we use the ‘gold standard’ everything-blind competency-based recruitment where there is no test of team fit before you’ve already hired someone and sometimes that does create really shit situations on all sides. It would be nice to be able to recruit in a way that was inclusive while recognising culture and chemistry as important.

Thissss

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 04/04/2023 21:21

I would lump this with the while ‘they must fit in with the team’s personalities’ nonsense. Just another way of saying “We want to employ people just like us”. A real win for anti-diversity

Swipe left for the next trending thread