Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having a 'chemistry check' with future colleagues as part of the job interview process - AIBU?

119 replies

5678ugh · 04/04/2023 20:43

My employer has recently started incorporating a 'chemistry check' as part of the final stages of the interview process. This is for the entry-level graduate positions. It's a hybrid role where we work in teams, so it is important to be someone who can generally get along well with others and work as a team.

However, I really don't like the idea, but I'm not sure if I'm thinking too much into it. The company is very middle-class full of Oxbridge graduates (not me) and to me this 'chemistry check' almost seems designed to keep it that way, it doesn't feel very inclusive.

AIBU or is this becoming a standard part of recruitment now?

OP posts:
ConcordeOoter · 05/04/2023 08:18

Yeah, I don't know about this, I have seen people exhibit all sorts of nasty little behaviours because of their "personal dislikes" that are inappropriate to the workplace. Ideally you can shut it down or deprive it of oxygen, the employee gets the message and it doesn't blossom into a problem. Sometimes it becomes clear after misconduct has occurred.

This process sounds nice, but seems like a great way to give people the power to act out their unprofessional prejudices in secret, with the company able to wash their hands of it.

SeaInelegans · 05/04/2023 08:12

I think this can be either a good or a bad thing, depending on how it’s implemented.

In my industry it is very common for candidates to one on one meet with some members of the team, hear about their projects and chat on an informal basis. This of benefit to the candidates as it gives the candidate a chance to meet some of the people they will be working with and ask questions that they may not feel able to ask in the main interview. And while the boss normally does ask for feedback it is only taken in consideration to weed out any arseholes.

greenbackers · 05/04/2023 08:10

My organisation has started doing this for senior jobs only and it is making a signifiant difference.

Instead of Billy Big Balls coming in and throwing his weight around trying to change everything tomorrow, the incoming management are valuing what there is and working out how to build on it while brining people along.

Interestingly the management team is becoming much more diverse as a result.

AngelDelightUK · 05/04/2023 08:02

I think it would depend on what it involved, and if it was a two way thing. I know I would never have accepted one of my previous jobs if I’d known what my colleagues were like!!

Mamaneedsadrink · 05/04/2023 08:00

Aprilx · 05/04/2023 07:52

I have been in workforce for thirty years, multinational corporate type companies and I have literally never heard of that ever. It isn’t what OP describes either.

I have too and this has been done almost everywhere I have worked

VivX · 05/04/2023 07:58

I have noticed in the last few years that some organisations increasingly included what they referred to as "cultural fit" interviews before offer stage.

In one company that did it - everyone (without fail) was a graduate, mostly Russell Group and a higher proportion were also Oxbridge. With that said, they didn't need a cultural fit interview to determine educational background.

One charity had a client/service user on their panel and another had one of the people that the successful candidate would actually line manage.

In previously times, the same effect might have been achieved by asking the person who greeted the candidates or showed them to the interview room what they thought.
For one job that I got when I was just starting out, they deliberately had a relatively senior member of staff (she just introduced herself by name not job title) do the meet and greet and escorting the candidates to another building for the interview.

Aprilx · 05/04/2023 07:52

Badbudgeter · 05/04/2023 07:48

Surely this has been a thing for years. After final interview they take you round the workplace and introduce you to your potential colleagues. You then decide if the company / colleagues are a good fit for you.

I have been in workforce for thirty years, multinational corporate type companies and I have literally never heard of that ever. It isn’t what OP describes either.

HipHipWhoRay · 05/04/2023 07:52

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 05/04/2023 07:46

This is not good news at all for people who are no good at chatting socially to people they don't know.

Yet that type of person might be an excellent worker, and even a good 'social' fit with the team once they have settled in.

This is true, but also many jobs also involve a ‘front of house’ role, building a rapport with clients or people you don’t know socially. So in many ways this could be a role play for the job. I agree not relevant for other jobs and difficult for introverts.

GOODCAT · 05/04/2023 07:52

We do this. It is to weed out the nutters or the ones that show an attitude problem. The times we have made bad hires is when the choice has been made by people outside the team.

We have increased our diversity in most teams as most people enjoy dealing with different people and don't want a carbon copy of themselves.

People spend a lot of time with their colleagues and it matters that they get on.

It also helps develop the existing team and includes them in the process if they are trusted to meet potential new colleagues and give their view. It also means that if we get it wrong, it is partly on them so there is no blaming someone else.

Badbudgeter · 05/04/2023 07:48

Surely this has been a thing for years. After final interview they take you round the workplace and introduce you to your potential colleagues. You then decide if the company / colleagues are a good fit for you.

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 05/04/2023 07:46

This is not good news at all for people who are no good at chatting socially to people they don't know.

Yet that type of person might be an excellent worker, and even a good 'social' fit with the team once they have settled in.

Aprilx · 05/04/2023 07:43

No I would not say that is becoming a standard in recruitment. If anything it sounds very much outdated and any company keeping up with best practice would be looking to eliminate this kind of bias in recruitment not encourage it.

YouJustDoYou · 05/04/2023 07:43

Being not slim, young and pretty, I would've failed that test instantly had they implemented it at one of my old jobs.

QuertyGirl · 05/04/2023 07:40

That's anybody ND out the door immediately.

You're going to end up in court eventually

Tarantella6 · 05/04/2023 07:39

I agree with PP who say it isn't necessarily an awful idea as long as you and your colleagues understand team fit doesn't mean "carbon copy of me". If you're not very diverse at the moment the biggest risk is candidates who don't fit your current profile will turn you down before you get a chance to make a decision!

LeFeu · 05/04/2023 07:37

Sounds like a get out to ditch candidates that have done well on merit that they just don’t like tbh. Is there a history of misogyny/racism where you work??

palelavender · 05/04/2023 07:36

In my generation, smart working class people with professional qualifications soon learned to jettison working class markers as fast as they could. I thought I might have overdone it when a client once volunteered that I looked like the sort of person who had grown up with a pony! We were so poor that we didn't have a telephone and had to use a callbox for any urgent calls. There was absolutely no pony or any possibility of one.

Hillrunning · 05/04/2023 07:32

Thoes of you saying that aiming to hire candidates that fit in with the existing team will lead to no diversity - this sounds much more like a YOU problem. Are you really unable to build professional rapport with someone who isn't a carbon copy of you? If so, perhaps you are the ones who need to learn about diversity and inclusion.

Just like any stage if interviewing, if done incorrectly it can be bad but why do so many of you believe that you and your colleagues will do it incorrectly? The question being examined at such checks is simply, is there anything glaringly negative about this person's behaviour that could make working with them very difficult. In one's I have attended we ruled out, a woman who was exceptionally rude to our receptionist, a man who started telling 'the boys' about his last trip to Amsterdam's red light district (in an organisation linked to protecting women) and another man who went through each of his current colleagues telling us all their failings and gossip no matter how hard we tried to move the conversation on. We approved a man who cheered loudly when someone mentioned that they had just passed a training exam and asked encouraging follow up questions (suggested he was supportive), a woman who said she preferred to be a background person in big social situations so didn't say much but followed up with individuals as we walked back from lunch (shows she is both self aware and confident in voicing it) and someone who had no particular good or bad behaviours during the session.

eurochick · 05/04/2023 07:28

The best team I worked in did "third interview drinks" with the team as the final recruitment stage. Everyone, no matter how junior, could give a view afterwards. And candidates often let their guard down in an informal environment. We ended up with a great, close and diverse team.

NeedToChangeName · 05/04/2023 07:17

Informal meet up with staff AFTER offering the job sounds like a great idea

Peekingovertheparapet · 05/04/2023 06:58

I really like to involve my team in recruitment and this is one great way to do it. It doesn’t have to mean that you are looking for people just like them, it’s not really to do with the diversity angle to be honest (I have that covered, I like to hire people whose skillset/experience overlaps with but is fundamentally different to the rest of the team).

I do team fit sessions because it allows all parties a chance to get to know each other. It’s good for the candidate in terms of knowing a little bit about some of their colleagues ahead of their first day, but it also gives the team a glimpse of the skills that are coming in. I can think of one occasion where the team session didn’t go so well and the candidate declined and in hindsight I had some reservations. Another example where I was a panel member but not the manager, the candidate was an arse, the team could see he was an arse, the manager hired anyway and had a big problem (it was definitely the candidate and not the team). If the manager had listened to the team things would have been very different.

in my mind the team session is about getting a feel for how the candidate interacts with others in a less formal and more realistic setting. I quite often send them for lunch together. In my mind it’s not another re-interview, it’s about knowing whether this person is polite, courteous, and going to value the existing team.

KatherineJaneway · 05/04/2023 06:51

I don't think looking at 'fit' is a bad thing. To me it can mean two things. Firstly does the candidate have skills that nicely round out the team. E.g. the team are good at X but have more limited skills in Y and the new candidate has Y in abundance so would suit the team well.

Secondly I do think meeting who you will be working with day in and day out is important. All you have to do is read the threads on here about personality clashes, introverts versus extroverts at work etc to see that fitting into a team is important for both the candidate and the team.

Judgyjudgy · 05/04/2023 06:49

I found this helped me too, I had one job interview where I met the rest of the team, it put me off completely. It goes both ways and is beneficial to both parties ime

Judgyjudgy · 05/04/2023 06:47

magicthree · 05/04/2023 06:45

I wouldn't do it as a recruiter, skills are far more important than fit. Diversity of thought is more welcomed in the workplace now than it was 15 years ago I think.

That's interesting as I have heard the opposite, that it is more important that someone fit in with the rest of the team rather than be hired based on skills. I have worked with some no doubt talented people but they were hopeless at getting along with others, and it really affects the workplace.

Agree with this 💯
I also find it odd that people are thinking 'fit' means the same, it doesn't.

magicthree · 05/04/2023 06:45

I wouldn't do it as a recruiter, skills are far more important than fit. Diversity of thought is more welcomed in the workplace now than it was 15 years ago I think.

That's interesting as I have heard the opposite, that it is more important that someone fit in with the rest of the team rather than be hired based on skills. I have worked with some no doubt talented people but they were hopeless at getting along with others, and it really affects the workplace.

Swipe left for the next trending thread