Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Threatening police, have I done anything wrong?

707 replies

Salemtrust · 04/04/2023 19:20

I've taken Dd and some of her friends(10-12) away for the week. Unfortunately I've had family emergency come up today and am going to have to leave tomorrow to help. Dsd (23) and her bf have offered to come and take over. The girls all seen more than happy with this, they have an event on Thursday which was the whole reason for the trip and want to stay.
I've called the other parents to let them know and one parent was furious and said that they don't want someone else looking after their child and that I need to either stay or bring their child home.
I've said they are welcome to come and get their child (4hour drive) and I'm happy to arrange and pay to send her home on public transport but I can't stay or bring her home so if not she will come home Friday as planned. They are now threatening to call the police saying its kidnap and endangerment and I've changed the terms they agreed to send their child on.
Have I do a anything wrong? Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
TheBiologyStupid · 05/04/2023 18:00

Fatkittythinkitty · 04/04/2023 19:52

Surely it depends on the emergency?

I would do whatever I could to help if a mum in charge of my kid had a family emergency in the sense I'm thinking of - eg a parent having a heart attack or something.

I absolutely would not expect them to drive my kid home.

Absolutely this.

Noangelbuthavingfun · 05/04/2023 18:00

You haven't done anything wrong per se as you sorted an alternative - but you are being unreasonable. A 23yr old and bf us hardly the right solution for a group of 10 to 12 year old. If anything happened to them how would you feel for putting your SD and the kids in that situation? I'd be fuming if I was the other parent at the situation itself - but I would come and collect my kid so as to be sure its all ok. I would also understand it can't be helped - but ideally you would have brought her back as you are in charge of their care.

EMUKE · 05/04/2023 17:59

I’m sorry but you need to sort out the child being taken back to the care of their parents. I agree with other posts, you have taken the responsibility to take these CHILDREN away. The parents agreed on certain conditions. The conditions have changed for what ever reason. The children can not and should not be being looked after by young adults. You need to care for the children the moment they are in your care till they are back in the parents care. It’s as simple as that. God forbid anything was to happen to any of them while you was away. You are the grown up and I’m sorry but I wouldn’t trust a 23 years old to look after children. If the emergency is that bad you all go back simple. DO NOT LEAVE THEM! You took on a duty of care! I would call the police too.

Mumwomansisterdaughter · 05/04/2023 17:59

Yes calling the police is exaggerated . But I think you are very irresponsible too . You are leaving a bunch of pre tens with young people that parents do not know and haven’t even had a criminal record checked .
Personally I would drive that child home , I think expecting a 10 year old do go on public transport on what I assume is over 4 hours is extremely irresponsible and you will be putting her in serious danger . The reality is those children are 100% under your responsibility so leaving before they leave is not ok at all .

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 17:57

Jackiewoo · 05/04/2023 17:30

surely one of the first things to consider before you let your kid sleep somewhere (anywhere) else is ‘could I collect them at 3am if there is an emergency?! If the answer is no because of any reason then you don’t let them go! it wasn't an emergency for the OP, it was someone else's emergency she decided to be the hero of. Of course you let them go, you just don't expect the person you've entrusted them with to fuck off to do something else.

@Jackiewoo no you don’t expect them to just fuck off but you do plan for there to be any kind of emergency concerning your child. In this case the emergency was needing to suddenly collect your child because the op had decided to leave- rightly or wrongly- they should have had a plan.

I’m not saying it isn’t annoying, inconvenient etc and possibly the op is unreasonable in this case, but 100 things can go wrong in these situations so parents need a plan!

Noangelbuthavingfun · 05/04/2023 17:56

You haven't done anythingvanythingvw

Zazazoolly · 05/04/2023 17:55

Why don’t you preempt them and call the police yourself to find out where you stand. Better to know the legal facts

Bekstar · 05/04/2023 17:54

No you've done othing wrong your not preventing her leaving if they want to be like that tell them you rang the police and they are happy to send social services to collect her. This is effectively what the police would do or ask that the parents collect her. You have provided alternative care, and offer of sending home via local transport. Honestly you've done no wrong. Ring the police on 101 they will advise you this. They'll also tell you the options or I form the other parent of said options.

Mumof32017 · 05/04/2023 17:52

They are idiots

Northbright · 05/04/2023 17:49

Couldyounot · 04/04/2023 19:45

They sound extraordinarily hard work and rather silly. Can't be arsed to drive 4 hours? Let's call the police!

This!!

Hunter2501 · 05/04/2023 17:48

Can’t be trusted??? She had an emergency and now she’s being told she can’t be trusted.
I really hope the other parents tried to help or at least showed a shred of sympathy for the situation

Hunter2501 · 05/04/2023 17:47

People on here genuinely scare me! So the OP has kindly taken a group away and is now getting the parent brigade offering all types of ludicrous advice of what she should’ve done. As for “you took them away they’re your responsibility”, well if that’s the attitude of the parents I wouldn’t be taking them again!
She had a family emergency! Did any of the other parents offer to come and take over? No thought not, happy to palm their child off but then get abuse when life events happen!

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 05/04/2023 17:43

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 17:11

@MRex surely one of the first things to consider before you let your kid sleep somewhere (anywhere) else is ‘could I collect them at 3am if there is an emergency?! If the answer is no because of any reason then you don’t let them go!

Exactly @ConstableGoody the children remain your children and your responsibility whether you have had a drink, fancied a few child free days, would prefer not to drive 4hrs to collect them etc. These though are all things responsible parents consider before agreeing to let their child go away. We also are assuming it is the 10yr old being put on a train. It could be the 12yr old, an age at which many children commute by train/tube to secondary school and some children travel internationally alone to go to school. Again not choices I've made myself but many do. If a direct train, being put on at stop X and being collected at stop Y is something many 11/12 year olds could manage.

It is clear that 2/3 families had no problem with the change in arrangements but those who did needed to do whatever they had planned to do in an emergency.

MRex · 05/04/2023 17:40

No, you don't need to always make sure you can collect your child within an hour at 3am, you need to make sure your child is only left in the care of someone you can trust to look after them until you get back to them. Sadly OP has proven she isn't one of those people who can be trusted. A tricky way for the parents and kids to learn that, but they now know for the future and will undoubtedly be more careful to check contingency plans in future.

Jackiewoo · 05/04/2023 17:30

surely one of the first things to consider before you let your kid sleep somewhere (anywhere) else is ‘could I collect them at 3am if there is an emergency?! If the answer is no because of any reason then you don’t let them go! it wasn't an emergency for the OP, it was someone else's emergency she decided to be the hero of. Of course you let them go, you just don't expect the person you've entrusted them with to fuck off to do something else.

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 17:23

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 17:17

I think it's a bit ridiculous to say that unless you can get to your child at a moment's notice in the event of any change of plans then you should send them. By that logic you could never be more than 30 miles from your children. The fact is that you in some circumstances leave them in the care of others that you trust to look after them - whether that's school, a club or another adult. As a result that other person or entity has a duty of care to your children.

Obviously in a genuine emergency, let's say OP had a heart attack or got hit by a bus, that's different. In that case you'd presumably expect the authorities to keep an eye on them untill you could get to them. Running off to look after someone else's children when you have already committed to that duty of care to someone else isn't ok. Especially when the alternative is a huge public transport mission late in the evening. And the parents did come, but they were pissed off - and rightly so.

@Itsbytheby well obviously it won’t be a moments notice to get to the child unless they are sleeping over next door, but being able to leave in a timely manner (eg, not being too drunk to drive, knowing you have petrol or bus money, having a plan for other kids etc) is just common sense.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 17:17

I think it's a bit ridiculous to say that unless you can get to your child at a moment's notice in the event of any change of plans then you should send them. By that logic you could never be more than 30 miles from your children. The fact is that you in some circumstances leave them in the care of others that you trust to look after them - whether that's school, a club or another adult. As a result that other person or entity has a duty of care to your children.

Obviously in a genuine emergency, let's say OP had a heart attack or got hit by a bus, that's different. In that case you'd presumably expect the authorities to keep an eye on them untill you could get to them. Running off to look after someone else's children when you have already committed to that duty of care to someone else isn't ok. Especially when the alternative is a huge public transport mission late in the evening. And the parents did come, but they were pissed off - and rightly so.

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 17:11

MRex · 05/04/2023 16:19

Some of you seem to be missing that OP decided at 7.30pm to leave the girls, and left them at least by 8.30am, possibly earlier. Saying "but emergency" doesn't mean they can warp time to get there with an hour, it means there needs to be collection. Basics to sort any other kids or pets, plus a 4 hour drive or unknown travel time by public transport plus taxis. Driving 8 hours straight at night after a normal day is unsafe (still driving at 4am thanks to OP's "plan"!), even driving until midnight might be hard depending on the day but if they can then that means accommodation to book, which might be tricky so late at night. If not or no car then they need to get to station and get tickets, which may make the journey impossible in the same evening and certainly very unlikely they could make it back again so that's accommodation to book again. Even throwing money at the issue on regular fare of £1.20-£3/ mile for a taxi over 200 miles, you'd struggle to get a driver to agree to go that far and back overnight. Earliest trains will be 5.30am, so they can't arrive by 8am that way either.

Put it all together, the parents said they will collect, but you have to look at what's involved to see that they couldn't reasonably do it before OP has already run away abandoning their 10-12yo kid. A kid she said she would look after before she took them away. It isn't a true emergency with her in hospital and police / social services keeping them safe overnight, it's all happened because she's agreed to help someone out with their childcare AFTER she already had the kids in her care, instead of arranging to drop off the child on her way / meet them part-way / wait until they can arrive at 11 / or any of the many other possible solutions that wouldn't have involved leaving their child.

@MRex surely one of the first things to consider before you let your kid sleep somewhere (anywhere) else is ‘could I collect them at 3am if there is an emergency?! If the answer is no because of any reason then you don’t let them go!

PinkStarAtNight · 05/04/2023 17:02

MRex · 05/04/2023 16:19

Some of you seem to be missing that OP decided at 7.30pm to leave the girls, and left them at least by 8.30am, possibly earlier. Saying "but emergency" doesn't mean they can warp time to get there with an hour, it means there needs to be collection. Basics to sort any other kids or pets, plus a 4 hour drive or unknown travel time by public transport plus taxis. Driving 8 hours straight at night after a normal day is unsafe (still driving at 4am thanks to OP's "plan"!), even driving until midnight might be hard depending on the day but if they can then that means accommodation to book, which might be tricky so late at night. If not or no car then they need to get to station and get tickets, which may make the journey impossible in the same evening and certainly very unlikely they could make it back again so that's accommodation to book again. Even throwing money at the issue on regular fare of £1.20-£3/ mile for a taxi over 200 miles, you'd struggle to get a driver to agree to go that far and back overnight. Earliest trains will be 5.30am, so they can't arrive by 8am that way either.

Put it all together, the parents said they will collect, but you have to look at what's involved to see that they couldn't reasonably do it before OP has already run away abandoning their 10-12yo kid. A kid she said she would look after before she took them away. It isn't a true emergency with her in hospital and police / social services keeping them safe overnight, it's all happened because she's agreed to help someone out with their childcare AFTER she already had the kids in her care, instead of arranging to drop off the child on her way / meet them part-way / wait until they can arrive at 11 / or any of the many other possible solutions that wouldn't have involved leaving their child.

This

Lavendersquare · 05/04/2023 16:34

I'm sorry but YABVU you took a group of young pre-teens away for a week and their parents entrusted their children care to you. Whatever family emergency that you have, you cannot just palm them off onto a 23yr old and her boyfriend.

There are just so many red flags, I'd be absolutely fuming if this was my daughter, and I'm sorry offering to put a young unaccompanied child onto public transport for a 4 hour journey is also extremely risky and not something any parent would agree to.

I'm also struggling to work out what on earth can have happened that means that you can't stay and look after your young chargers and need to leave them with people the parents weren't aware would be looking after their children.

Jackiewoo · 05/04/2023 16:23

the other parent is being overdramatic with talk of kidnap and police but taking a group of 10-12 year olds on a trip then bailing on them is bloody irresponsible. The reason for leaving doesn't matter, OPs priority was to those DC & their parents, not to sort out another adult's emergency. And not even offering to return the DC, just shove them on a 4 hour public transport journey if the parents don't like it FFS.

Whether DSD is OK with it is neither here nor there, unless DSD & BF are well known to the other parents & they were all fine about it in advance, which at least one of them isn't.

If someone had taken my DC on a trip 4 hours away then bailed and left them with someone/anyone else, then told me if I didn't like it my DC would be shoved alone on a 4 hour train ride I'd have been incandescent. I'd have gone and either collected DC or stayed with them myself and accompanied the DC to whatever event it is because my DC are ultimately my responsibility wherever they are, but the friendship with the OP's family would be firmly at an end.

MRex · 05/04/2023 16:19

Some of you seem to be missing that OP decided at 7.30pm to leave the girls, and left them at least by 8.30am, possibly earlier. Saying "but emergency" doesn't mean they can warp time to get there with an hour, it means there needs to be collection. Basics to sort any other kids or pets, plus a 4 hour drive or unknown travel time by public transport plus taxis. Driving 8 hours straight at night after a normal day is unsafe (still driving at 4am thanks to OP's "plan"!), even driving until midnight might be hard depending on the day but if they can then that means accommodation to book, which might be tricky so late at night. If not or no car then they need to get to station and get tickets, which may make the journey impossible in the same evening and certainly very unlikely they could make it back again so that's accommodation to book again. Even throwing money at the issue on regular fare of £1.20-£3/ mile for a taxi over 200 miles, you'd struggle to get a driver to agree to go that far and back overnight. Earliest trains will be 5.30am, so they can't arrive by 8am that way either.

Put it all together, the parents said they will collect, but you have to look at what's involved to see that they couldn't reasonably do it before OP has already run away abandoning their 10-12yo kid. A kid she said she would look after before she took them away. It isn't a true emergency with her in hospital and police / social services keeping them safe overnight, it's all happened because she's agreed to help someone out with their childcare AFTER she already had the kids in her care, instead of arranging to drop off the child on her way / meet them part-way / wait until they can arrive at 11 / or any of the many other possible solutions that wouldn't have involved leaving their child.

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 15:45

SerafinasGoose · 05/04/2023 15:41

Absolutely so. It's quite alarming how many people with full parental responsibility on this thread apparently to think this belongs elsewhere, merely because they've entrusted someone else with their child's temporary care. What's the betting these are also the ones who think educators are there for childcare?

My child is my responsibility. If issues arise under that jurisdiction I would expect to be informed of them - as OP has done - and if I don't like their solutions I will take these upon myself. If unexpected circumstances arise, the wellbeing over my child will always take precedence over work.

As to what would qualify as an unavoidable emergency, determining whether I'd be annoyed or sympathetic about their behaviour, this much the OP hasn't divulged. The question posed by the thread - 'have I done anything wrong' - is therefore moot.

Entertaining thread, all the same!

@SerafinasGoose exactly. I would have been prepared for this situation (especially one adult taking multiple kids- almost bound to go wrong somewhere). I would be irritated because it’s a pain and I would definitely not let my child stay/get the train so I would grumble to myself and set off to get my kid!

SerafinasGoose · 05/04/2023 15:41

DonnaRix · 05/04/2023 14:49

People can and do let you down. Rightly or wrongly. You’re still the parent. It’s still up to you to rescue them.

Absolutely so. It's quite alarming how many people with full parental responsibility on this thread apparently to think this belongs elsewhere, merely because they've entrusted someone else with their child's temporary care. What's the betting these are also the ones who think educators are there for childcare?

My child is my responsibility. If issues arise under that jurisdiction I would expect to be informed of them - as OP has done - and if I don't like their solutions I will take these upon myself. If unexpected circumstances arise, the wellbeing over my child will always take precedence over work.

As to what would qualify as an unavoidable emergency, determining whether I'd be annoyed or sympathetic about their behaviour, this much the OP hasn't divulged. The question posed by the thread - 'have I done anything wrong' - is therefore moot.

Entertaining thread, all the same!

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 15:29

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 15:14

If you'd be raging at having to look after a sick child at night, don't ever host sleepovers.
It could be anything, maybe I can't get there at 2am because I don't have a car, or my DH is at work with the car, or I'm a carer for an elderly parent who can't be left, or my phone ran out of battery and I don't get your call.....

It's YOUR responsibilty to look after children you have chosen to host. No buts. If you don't get that, don't ever host any children.

You have it backwards- if you have reasons you can’t fulfil your responsibility as a parent if they are at a sleepover (ie have transport/money/time/availability to collect them at any time in the night) then you need to make sure your kids never go to sleepovers.

So so entitled.

Swipe left for the next trending thread