Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Threatening police, have I done anything wrong?

707 replies

Salemtrust · 04/04/2023 19:20

I've taken Dd and some of her friends(10-12) away for the week. Unfortunately I've had family emergency come up today and am going to have to leave tomorrow to help. Dsd (23) and her bf have offered to come and take over. The girls all seen more than happy with this, they have an event on Thursday which was the whole reason for the trip and want to stay.
I've called the other parents to let them know and one parent was furious and said that they don't want someone else looking after their child and that I need to either stay or bring their child home.
I've said they are welcome to come and get their child (4hour drive) and I'm happy to arrange and pay to send her home on public transport but I can't stay or bring her home so if not she will come home Friday as planned. They are now threatening to call the police saying its kidnap and endangerment and I've changed the terms they agreed to send their child on.
Have I do a anything wrong? Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
ChickenDhansak82 · 04/04/2023 20:27

You are giving parents the choice of leaving their child with a 23 year old and her boyfriend that they don't know, getting their child dumped on public transport, or parents needing to do an 8 hour round trip to get them, and you wonder why they're kicking off?!?!?

I would be beyond furious!

Regardless of the emergency, you have a duty of responsibility and have massively failed here.

This better be a darn good emergency, although if you had time to post on here it can't be that serious!

Bimblybomeyelash · 04/04/2023 20:26

I’d be highly pissed off if it was my 10 year old. I’d be happy for them to spend a week away with the parent of a friend. But it would be a big deal and I’d still worry about them and I know they’d miss me. They wouldn’t be happy if that parent up’d and left and was replaced with a 23 year old. And neither would I! It’s a shame that you have an emergency to deal with, but offering to send a child home on public transport isn’t a reasonable solution, and it is totally understandable that the parent may also be unhappy with the 23 year old sibling solution. Them calling the police is disproportionate, but you should still be acknowledging their concern and apologising.

Persipan · 04/04/2023 20:26

I think we all agree that the police thing is clearly nonsense. Leaving that aside, though, I do think you're being unreasonable here. Of course the group of children are all perfectly happy with this arrangement, but really I think the only appropriate options here, as others have suggested, would be another trusted parent from the group taking over for you, or you taking all the girls home and heading off to your emergency afterwards. I get that you don't want to disappoint them, and I get that your stepdaughter isn't some rando to you, so I can see that you've tried to sort things out for everyone and 'fix' the problem, but unilaterally deciding that she (and her boyfriend) are taking over for you was an overreach. And you are not being reasonable expecting an unaccompanied child to make a lengthy, unfamiliar trip on public transport.

jaqueandjill · 04/04/2023 20:26

Talk of kidnapping and the police is OTT, but I'd be so pissed off. I wouldn't want my DD being looked after by some random bloke, and I wouldn't want her travelling on public transport for several hours either. Which would leave me no alternative but to collect her myself.

ShandaLear · 04/04/2023 20:26

No, they’re in your charge. You bring them back with you. I’m quite relaxed about parenting, but I wouldn’t want 23 year olds I’ve never met looking after my primary school aged kids a 2/4 hour drive away. Not a chance.

SnackSizeRaisin · 04/04/2023 20:25

Dixiechickonhols · 04/04/2023 20:13

I assume Op is dashing off to emergency and not returning home so can’t take child home.
It sounds like Op has done them a favour and taken child away for a week. Obviously emergencies can happen eg if Op had been rushed to hospital.
I can understand them not wanting child looked after by a stranger (dsd and bf) so if not they should accept offer of transport or if they don’t want to use public transport collect.

OP isn't rushing off anywhere - she could perfectly well take the girls home tonight and go to her emergency tomorrow, it wouldn't make any difference.

I think she doesn't want to disappoint her own daughter and that's why she has arranged for them all to stay. And now she's made arrangements she doesn't want to change them.

She should have checked with the parents before making arrangements with the step daughter. What a ten year old wants is not really relevant - they are too young and naive to realise why it might not be a great idea.

Putting a 10 year old on a 4 hour train journey alone probably would risk a charge of endangerment.

Xarrie · 04/04/2023 20:25

I would expect you to bring her home. YABVU

trythisforsize · 04/04/2023 20:24

I wouldn't want my 10-12 year old daughter to be at the other end of the country and suddenly be looked after by your 22 year old stepdaughter and her boyfriend that I've never met.

Safeguarding issues right there.

FilthyforFirth · 04/04/2023 20:24

I would come and collect my child, but I would be livid and you would never be in charge of my child again. Sorry but I would be distancing myself from you going forward. No way I would want some random and her boyfriend looking after my child.

AnonymousA1 · 04/04/2023 20:24

Newusernameaug · 04/04/2023 19:51

Public transport is NOT safe, especially for a young girl that age.
just walk down a street with a young girl and see how many disgusting pervs there are about!

Dramatic.

Smoky1107 · 04/04/2023 20:23

Do they know the lady your leaving them in charge of? I'd be concerned too you've changed the plans albeit not your fault.

samqueens · 04/04/2023 20:22

Also will say it’s really nice of your DSD & her boyfriend to take over and that would definitely make me think well of them!

LadyLapsang · 04/04/2023 20:22

I think my reaction would depend on how well I knew you and your DSD and the nature of your emergency. You are in loco parentis and have a responsibility to act in the best interests of the children in your care. If I didn’t know you well and / or I didn’t think the nature of your emergency warranted you leaving them in the care of potential strangers, then I think I would be rather wary in the future. If, however, it was a genuine emergency, e.g. your DP or parents in a life threatening condition in intensive care, then I would come to collect my child and try to help you.

cansu · 04/04/2023 20:22

We don't know the nature of the emergency but you could drive them home tonight and then go and do what you have to. I think I would be annoyed at a long drive at such short notice.

DonnaRix · 04/04/2023 20:22

Equinoxsox · 04/04/2023 20:20

If I was letting someone else take my child on holiday I'm pretty sure the thought would have briefly crossed my mind that there's a small possibility I'd have to collect them in an emergency or illness etc and I would have factored that in to my decision to let them go.
Yanbu. If they don't like your 2 offers of alternative arrangements due to an unforessen family emergency they need to come and collect their child.

Yeah see I totally agree with this. If I couldn’t get to her myself, I wouldn’t have let her go.

NumberTheory · 04/04/2023 20:21

I can see why parents might be unhappy with your solution. I think whether I was or not would depend on a whole host of factors.

But regardless, you are not proposing anything illegal. If they go to the police and tell them what you've written here the police will tell them to go and collect their child if they don't want the kid to stay with your Dsd.

All the best with your family emergency. I hope it's resolved quickly and with little harm. Flowers

samqueens · 04/04/2023 20:20

Why aren’t any of them volunteering to come and help cover your absence or add additional hands in the circumstances?!

YANBU (and I says that as someone who probably wouldn’t want someone I didn’t know looking after my DD in that situation, but also as someone who would help out/collect if I was unhappy)

Equinoxsox · 04/04/2023 20:20

If I was letting someone else take my child on holiday I'm pretty sure the thought would have briefly crossed my mind that there's a small possibility I'd have to collect them in an emergency or illness etc and I would have factored that in to my decision to let them go.
Yanbu. If they don't like your 2 offers of alternative arrangements due to an unforessen family emergency they need to come and collect their child.

Nowthenhere · 04/04/2023 20:20

That's a terrible position to put some children in and their parents!
You put those children at risk of being vulnerable and have made decisions without involving their parents.
What happens if the boyfriend and your step daughter fall out/have an argument and the children are distressed about this?
Have the parents met the boyfriend? Have they made the decision that they are happy for their 10 year old child to be in his care overnight?

What an awful situation to throw this family into.

Redebs · 04/04/2023 20:20

romdowa · 04/04/2023 19:43

Nah sorry but you took them away, so its your responsibility to bring them back or to take care of them. You've assumed a duty of care to these children and you can't just pawn them off on someone else without their parents permission.

Definitely this.

Bring all the children home if you gave an emergency.
And putting 10 yr olds on public transport alone? Ridiculous!

PrincessScarlett · 04/04/2023 20:20

Sorry OP but you are responsible for these children and if one parent is not happy with the new arrangement then you need to take that child home first before you go off to your 'emergency' tomorrow.

WonderingWanda · 04/04/2023 20:19

The parents are being very dramatic with the language of kidnapping etc. However, I think they do have a right to be a little upset. In the event of a very sudden emergency e.g your child being rushed into hospital then emergency childcare from people not know to the other parents would have to be fine.
It sounds like your emergency might not be quite as urgent as the word emergency suggests if you don't need to leave immediately. However, urgent situations come up and can't be helped (I hope everything is ok). You've decided to leave some very young adults unknown to these parents in charge of their children rather than bring them all home and that isn't what the parents signed up for sp I think they do have a right to be a bit worried. Is the child in question is 10, 11 or 12? This makes a big difference as to whether sending them home on public transport is an option. My 10 year old doesn't even walk home on her own yet and certainly couldn't cope with public transport. I wouldn't be thrilled at some unknown 20 somethings looking after a group of kids and taking them to an event but I would probably just come and get them myself. I assume the cross and overdramatic parents don't have that option.

SnackSizeRaisin · 04/04/2023 20:18

IForgotMyUsernameAgain · 04/04/2023 20:10

It's pretty weird that so many people are focused on the fact that DSD is 23. Lots of 23 year olds have children. And it's not like 10 year olds need constant supervision like a toddler.

I think it is perfectly reasonable for OP to ask a family member to step in during an emergency. If the other parents don't like it, they can come and collect their kid.

A 23 year old may have a child themselves but that is their own child. I wouldn't leave my child with a 23 year old I didn't know - especially one that didn't have children!
Anyway I don't think it's better if they are being left with a 50 year old maiden aunt and her unknown boyfriend either really...

GrasstrackGirl · 04/04/2023 20:17

YABU, it's your responsibility.

jeaux90 · 04/04/2023 20:16

YABU no way I'd be happy with this, my daughter staying with a random bloke i don't know, no.

My daughter travelling back on public transport, no.

The only option would be to drive down and pick her up, which quite rightly would piss off any parent too.