Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Threatening police, have I done anything wrong?

707 replies

Salemtrust · 04/04/2023 19:20

I've taken Dd and some of her friends(10-12) away for the week. Unfortunately I've had family emergency come up today and am going to have to leave tomorrow to help. Dsd (23) and her bf have offered to come and take over. The girls all seen more than happy with this, they have an event on Thursday which was the whole reason for the trip and want to stay.
I've called the other parents to let them know and one parent was furious and said that they don't want someone else looking after their child and that I need to either stay or bring their child home.
I've said they are welcome to come and get their child (4hour drive) and I'm happy to arrange and pay to send her home on public transport but I can't stay or bring her home so if not she will come home Friday as planned. They are now threatening to call the police saying its kidnap and endangerment and I've changed the terms they agreed to send their child on.
Have I do a anything wrong? Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 05/04/2023 09:17

I am surprised at all of the parents who would ‘never let the OP look after their children again’ like it’s some sort of privilege. I doubt the OP will ever take on such a task in future.

Hahaha exactly.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 05/04/2023 09:14

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 07:21

I don’t understand all the people saying what if the parents don’t drive etc… who lets their child go miles away with another family without any means to get them back in an emergency?! It’s madness!

Well exactly. If my child goes away, I make sure I could get there to get him if an emergency arose. This is an em emergency for OP, but what would these parents have done if there was an emergency their end and they needed their child back?

maranella · 05/04/2023 09:14

I think you're being unreasonable to leave - you made a commitment to these girls and their families and should stick to it. And you'd put a 10-12-year-old on public transport alone for a 4-hour journey? Also unreasonable. I have a DC that age and there is no way he'd be safe doing that on his own. They're obviously also being unreasonable to accuse you of kidnap. In other words, you're all being unreasonable, but particularly you.

Fuckityfuckfuck123 · 05/04/2023 09:13

TBH I'd not want my child to stay with the change in who's around, and taking care of them, however....kidnap? Endangerment? .
Theyre off their fucking rockers. Tell them to arrange collecting their child.
And distance from them in future.

MumOf2workOptions · 05/04/2023 09:12

DoIWantThis · 04/04/2023 19:36

If they don't want her to stay they need to collect her

This
Infact I'd pre-empt any trouble and phone the police yourself and log this accusation to make things clear and ask them to go and speak to her!!

nomoremerlot · 05/04/2023 09:12

starfishmummy · 05/04/2023 08:48

Clearly not that much of an emergency if the OP isnt leaving until the next day . Definitely gone about it in the wrong way. I'd have contacted the various parents with some alternatives.

I would have said something like 'my dsd and her bf are coming to take over looking after my dd for the rest of the holiday. Friend a's mum is happy for her to stay too, but it's up to you whether you are OK with your dc staying. If not then we need to discuss getting her home'.

Clearly got massive comprehension issues!

OP has made two posts.

Read them?

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 05/04/2023 09:05

starfishmummy · 05/04/2023 08:48

Clearly not that much of an emergency if the OP isnt leaving until the next day . Definitely gone about it in the wrong way. I'd have contacted the various parents with some alternatives.

I would have said something like 'my dsd and her bf are coming to take over looking after my dd for the rest of the holiday. Friend a's mum is happy for her to stay too, but it's up to you whether you are OK with your dc staying. If not then we need to discuss getting her home'.

That is what OP did though. From the update it appears that 2 friends their families are happy for them to stay. OP though couldn't leave them at the location to take friend 4 home because the dsd wasn't there at that point.

It is a little like OP lives in Birmingham, taken friends up to Manchester for concert on Thursday. OP's grandson rushed into hospital in Newcastle OP's daughter needs OP to look after her granddaughter who is currently at a neighbour's house overnight but cannot stay. OP can't leave her dd and friends alone in Manchester until DSD comes up from London to take over. All places could be entirely different of course.

As I said before I would not have sent my child at that age without being confident that I could not retrieve them if needed. Not sure I would have left her with DSD and BF but I would either collect myself or go and join them up there. I would not be ringing the police on OP who has enough of a family crisis going on.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 09:04

I think you were being unreasonable to abandon the trip without taking the kids home if the parents weren't happy with your arrangements. I would not have been happy with two young adults I had no idea who were supervising my child on a trip 4 hours away, and the proper thing to do would be to tell the parents of the circumstances and offer to take any kids back that weren't allowed to stay on that basis. No way could my 10 year old manage a 4 hr car trip on public transport, and I would seriously consider your judgement if you considered that appropriate.

they were of course ridiculous to threaten the police.

ChocChipHandbag · 05/04/2023 09:03

My post crossed with yours. Did you actually tell the annoyed parents what the emergency was, or were you just vague? If you did not give details, that will not have helped things.

Separately, though, aren’t medical professionals the ones who should be dealing with medical emergencies?

Coffeetree · 05/04/2023 09:03

I'm sorry to hear about your emergency OP.

It's not kidnapping of course but I'm not clear on why the daughter of the concerned parents couldn't come home with you!

If I were one of the parents, I might be okay with DSD assuming duty of care, but why the hell does her boyfriend need to come along? Does he not feel a bit weird joining in to stay with a bunch of random pre-teen girls? It shows a lack of judgement on his part and everyone else's.

MattDillonsEyebrows · 05/04/2023 09:01

starfishmummy · 05/04/2023 08:48

Clearly not that much of an emergency if the OP isnt leaving until the next day . Definitely gone about it in the wrong way. I'd have contacted the various parents with some alternatives.

I would have said something like 'my dsd and her bf are coming to take over looking after my dd for the rest of the holiday. Friend a's mum is happy for her to stay too, but it's up to you whether you are OK with your dc staying. If not then we need to discuss getting her home'.

That’s exactly what the OP did do.

it’s just that one parent wasn’t happy with the alternatives.

The debate seems to be about whether the OP should have spoilt all the girls trip, by bringing them all home, or expected the parents of this child to have their own contingency put in place in the event of an emergency.

olympicsrock · 05/04/2023 08:59

I’m sorry that your family member has an emergency but I do think you have behaved badly here.
You made a committment to take your own child and her friends away and presumably they all bought tickets. I have an 11 year old and would not be happy for them to be looked after by someone I had never met or put on public transport without a supervising adult.
It is not reasonable to expect the parents to come and collect their child at significant expense with no notice because you chose to help someone else’s emergency. . Presumably you were looking after your relatives other children because you know them better.
Honestly it’s mind boggling that you can’t see the other family’s point of view.

You had several reasonable choices - either to take the child home yourself/ or the parents might offer a half way meet or ask DSD to help with the family emergency .

starfishmummy · 05/04/2023 08:48

Clearly not that much of an emergency if the OP isnt leaving until the next day . Definitely gone about it in the wrong way. I'd have contacted the various parents with some alternatives.

I would have said something like 'my dsd and her bf are coming to take over looking after my dd for the rest of the holiday. Friend a's mum is happy for her to stay too, but it's up to you whether you are OK with your dc staying. If not then we need to discuss getting her home'.

Hardtopickaname · 05/04/2023 08:47

diddl · 05/04/2023 08:43

they all were more than happy to stay with dsd,

Of course they were as they don't want to miss out!

It's not their call though.

Do the other parents know your step daughter?

The next line she states the parents were happy for them to stay.

diddl · 05/04/2023 08:45

the trip should have been cut short for all of the children.

I think that tbh.

Or maybe another parent take over?

diddl · 05/04/2023 08:43

they all were more than happy to stay with dsd,

Of course they were as they don't want to miss out!

It's not their call though.

Do the other parents know your step daughter?

ChocChipHandbag · 05/04/2023 08:42

I don’t think it’s possible to comment without knowing what the emergency is. If the OP has not told the other parents specifics then they Donny have enough context to evaluate the reasonableness of her actions.

If she has told them specifics then it is either obviously not something that merits dropping her commitment to look after the girls, or it is and they are being unreasonable.

Emergencies that would make me, as the parent, sympathetic and willing to accept a non-ideal situation:

OP’s immediate family member- child, sibling, spouse/partner, parent - critically ill in hospital and at risk of dying.

Sudden death of the above.
House has burnt down or flooded.

OP’s other minor child arrested.

I can’t really think if anything else that couldn’t wait a couple of days.

MayThe4th · 05/04/2023 08:42

I haven’t read through all 16 pages. But:

The instant there was a family emergency the trip should have been cut short for all of the children. I do think that if e.g. it was the need to go to a hospital to be with someone with a serious injury for instance that a middle ground could be for the DSD to bring the children home, that wouldn’t be unreasonable,

There does need to be contingency on both sides, any parent should be able to fetch their child from wherever it is they’ve gone to, but equally if there is an emergency meaning the host can no longer accommodate the children, those children need to be returned to their parents.

Threats of the police seem OTT, but essentially, you have their children and are refusing to return them. And that is the basis they will use to call the police.

Either the OP, or the DSD needs to return all of the children. Public transport is not a reasonable compromise.

Salemtrust · 05/04/2023 08:38

Sorry for disappearing. I've left now and dsd arrived in the night, they are sending someone else to collect their daughter today who is obviously extremely upset at having to leave her friends and not get to go to the event as are the other girls about her leaving.
So I guess it's been resolved now, there will probably be a fall out to deal with when I get home though.
To answer some of the main questions. The emergency involves a single parent family members younger children and a medical emergency that no one else can help with. This is my side of the family and a sensitive situations and I wouldn't expect or ask dsd to go and help instead. She's more than capable and comfortable with looking after her sister and her friends though which she has done before with different friends.
If any of the children were distressed I would arrange for them to travel home either by public transport or getting someone to come and collect them but they all were more than happy to stay with dsd, the two other parents are also more than happy for their kids to stay.
I obviously wasn't going to put their child on public transport without their consent, I just offered to cover the cost of that's the option they wanted.

OP posts:
ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 05/04/2023 08:37

dogsdogsdogs1 · 05/04/2023 08:31

For those of you doubters, you may want to look up contract law… a contract was formed by the op offering to take the other parents’ dd away and look after her. The contract has been broken by the op when she has changed the terms of the contract after they had been agreed…

Seriously? You’d be so hard up for empathy that this would be your go to?

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 05/04/2023 08:36

ThomasinaLivesHere · 04/04/2023 22:18

I disagree about assuming it’s about life or death. People often say “family emergency” to make something sound more serious than it is. It’s one of those things people can say where they know people can’t question it as it’s private. And what proper emergency gives you warning of a day to prepare for it?

Member of family is ill in hospital and you’ve been told to come asap. Someone’s had a fall and needs care setting up after hospital discharge. Child’s relationship has broken down and they need their mum because they’re distraught and have nowhere to stay, family member is having a mental health crisis and needs you there. Any number of things. It’s not hard to use the imagination.

Dotjones · 05/04/2023 08:36

Yes YABU because the DSD and BF are unknown quantities, as far as the other parents know there could be a history of sexual offences.

As for sending a 10-12yo on public transport if you mean send them alone that's not acceptable - a child of that age can't be trusted to travel alone and is at extreme risk of a sexual predator.

If you meant you offered to accompany them home on the train then that's fine, the other parent is batshit if they have a problem with that, but you can't just pack them off on their own.

Whattt44 · 05/04/2023 08:33

Just drive the kids home and then drive to the emergency. Where's the op ?

BeachBlondey · 05/04/2023 08:31

16 pages and the Op hasn't been back.

dogsdogsdogs1 · 05/04/2023 08:31

For those of you doubters, you may want to look up contract law… a contract was formed by the op offering to take the other parents’ dd away and look after her. The contract has been broken by the op when she has changed the terms of the contract after they had been agreed…