Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Threatening police, have I done anything wrong?

707 replies

Salemtrust · 04/04/2023 19:20

I've taken Dd and some of her friends(10-12) away for the week. Unfortunately I've had family emergency come up today and am going to have to leave tomorrow to help. Dsd (23) and her bf have offered to come and take over. The girls all seen more than happy with this, they have an event on Thursday which was the whole reason for the trip and want to stay.
I've called the other parents to let them know and one parent was furious and said that they don't want someone else looking after their child and that I need to either stay or bring their child home.
I've said they are welcome to come and get their child (4hour drive) and I'm happy to arrange and pay to send her home on public transport but I can't stay or bring her home so if not she will come home Friday as planned. They are now threatening to call the police saying its kidnap and endangerment and I've changed the terms they agreed to send their child on.
Have I do a anything wrong? Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
BellePeppa · 05/04/2023 15:23

Mirabai · 05/04/2023 10:43

The answer to could you help out with relative’s childcare was “no sorry I’ve taken a bunch of kids away for the week”. Really poor judgment.

One thing’s for sure, the OP is too flaky to be solely responsible for other people’s children for several days several hours away.

MysteryBelle · 05/04/2023 15:18

I wouldn’t put a child of 10 on public transport by herself. That’s just me. I don’t care what others do, I wouldn’t do it. Your emergency, the little you’ve described it in latest post, isn’t an excuse at all for bailing on your agreement to take charge of these children, accompany them on a four hour journey to and from this event, and take them to event.

Their well being is your number priority for that period of time. Keeping your word. You cannot be trusted, that is it in a nutshell.

Smugly telling parents out of the blue that their 10 year old will either be put on public transport by herself for 4 hrs, or be minded by a 23 yr old and a boyfriend neither the child nor the parents have ever met. Strangers, no idea what kind of people they are. That’s a non.

Very foolish of you, op. No sense whatsoever.

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 15:14

DonnaRix · 05/04/2023 15:12

of course I would take responsibility but I tell you what, I’d be raging if I had to deal with a sick and upset child overnight because you hadn’t put a plan in place for such an eventuality (for example, as you say, not drinking). I’d be going above and beyond for the child’s sake, but it would be your fault as the parent.

In this case the OP is for whatever reason unable to take the children back. She has suggested two (crap) alternatives but at the end of the day, the parents need to collect if the child needs to come home.

If you'd be raging at having to look after a sick child at night, don't ever host sleepovers.
It could be anything, maybe I can't get there at 2am because I don't have a car, or my DH is at work with the car, or I'm a carer for an elderly parent who can't be left, or my phone ran out of battery and I don't get your call.....

It's YOUR responsibilty to look after children you have chosen to host. No buts. If you don't get that, don't ever host any children.

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 15:14

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 13:03

I imagine they thought that in an emergency, OP wouldn't abandon their kids to either strangers or public transport alone. Who would imagine that?

I imagine they thought OP would take responsibility for the children in her care and not be so cavalier with their safety. They were wrong, obviously.

What would have happened if the op was ill if they didn’t have a back up to collect their kid?

DonnaRix · 05/04/2023 15:12

of course I would take responsibility but I tell you what, I’d be raging if I had to deal with a sick and upset child overnight because you hadn’t put a plan in place for such an eventuality (for example, as you say, not drinking). I’d be going above and beyond for the child’s sake, but it would be your fault as the parent.

In this case the OP is for whatever reason unable to take the children back. She has suggested two (crap) alternatives but at the end of the day, the parents need to collect if the child needs to come home.

nomoremerlot · 05/04/2023 15:12

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 14:53

@IamKlaus or, as I have had happen- everyone is ill including the adults who are then unable to drive everyone home/continue to supervise the children… would they then expect someone else again to do them yet another favour and collect their child?! (This was a guide trip where everyone got ill including the 3 leaders and everyone had to be collected asap)

Exactly!

But I guess this will be dismissed as not relevant.

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 15:06

DonnaRix · 05/04/2023 14:57

Ok how about this scenario

your child is at a sleepover at a friends house, say an hours drive away. At 1am you get a phone call - child has been sick. Friends mum is on her own with three other kids asleep in the house so she can’t drop your child off. But you’ve had a few drinks, so you can’t drive either.

who’s problem is that, in your view?

Daft comparison that doesnt work, but if you insist.....First, I wouldn't have a few drinks if my child was at sleepover an hour away, as I may need to collect.
But if for whatever reason I couldn't collect, I would expect the friends mum to take care of the sick child until I could have her collected.

And so would you, so you are actually agreeing with me. In your scenario OP would be offering to put the sick kid on a bus or send her to some other unknown person to look after her, both of which you know to be terrible suggestions.

If you had a child at a sleepover at your house, would you not agree it is your responsibility to deal with them in the absence of their parents? And that you can't just say "not my problem" and put them out in the garden?

MattDillonsEyebrows · 05/04/2023 14:57

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 14:50

@IamKlaus but those weren’t the only options- the parents have the option of going and getting the child themselves. The op is doing them a favour giving their child an opportunity. Sadly it hasn’t worked out and they aren’t happy so THEY need to collect the child THEY are responsible for!

What would these parents have done if their child was ill and wanted to go home? Expect the trip to be cancelled for everyone?!

Thanks @ConstableGoody this is exactly what I wanted to reply but I couldn’t be arsed with the hyperbolic rant back! 😂

DonnaRix · 05/04/2023 14:57

Ok how about this scenario

your child is at a sleepover at a friends house, say an hours drive away. At 1am you get a phone call - child has been sick. Friends mum is on her own with three other kids asleep in the house so she can’t drop your child off. But you’ve had a few drinks, so you can’t drive either.

who’s problem is that, in your view?

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 14:53

@IamKlaus or, as I have had happen- everyone is ill including the adults who are then unable to drive everyone home/continue to supervise the children… would they then expect someone else again to do them yet another favour and collect their child?! (This was a guide trip where everyone got ill including the 3 leaders and everyone had to be collected asap)

ConstableGoody · 05/04/2023 14:50

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 10:13

Entitlement? It's entitled to think if you take my child somewhere you will not abandon them to a choice of either going home alone at age TEN or staying overnight with an unknown man?

Are you on glue?

@IamKlaus but those weren’t the only options- the parents have the option of going and getting the child themselves. The op is doing them a favour giving their child an opportunity. Sadly it hasn’t worked out and they aren’t happy so THEY need to collect the child THEY are responsible for!

What would these parents have done if their child was ill and wanted to go home? Expect the trip to be cancelled for everyone?!

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 14:50

Maybe you and OP can. Most of us couldn't. Legally, you can't.

DonnaRix · 05/04/2023 14:49

People can and do let you down. Rightly or wrongly. You’re still the parent. It’s still up to you to rescue them.

DonnaRix · 05/04/2023 14:47

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 14:43

OP offered ludicrous options that no-one in their right mind would accept. Of course it doesn't absolve the parents responsibility, but you seem unable to grasp that OP took on a responsibilty as well. Which she completely failed to adhere to.

OBVIOUSLY any parent is ultimately responsible for their own child, but if you take someone elses child, for an hour or a day or a week, YOU are responsible for them. You can't just say tough shit, I am leaving them, won't bring them home, they are not my problem they are yours.

The fact that this needs explaining to parents is as astonishing as it is worrying.

Sure you can. You shouldn’t, it’s shitty. But you can. So the parents need to be prepared in case that happens.

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 14:43

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 05/04/2023 14:39

*It's not the bottom line because you're missing the point.

The discussion is about whether OP has done anything wrong. She has. You don't seem to understand what we are talking about.*

I'm really not. OP offered options. Parents need to be responsible for their kids. If you don't understand that your child being away with someone, doesn't absolve you of all responsibility, that's your choice as a parent.

OP offered ludicrous options that no-one in their right mind would accept. Of course it doesn't absolve the parents responsibility, but you seem unable to grasp that OP took on a responsibilty as well. Which she completely failed to adhere to.

OBVIOUSLY any parent is ultimately responsible for their own child, but if you take someone elses child, for an hour or a day or a week, YOU are responsible for them. You can't just say tough shit, I am leaving them, won't bring them home, they are not my problem they are yours.

The fact that this needs explaining to parents is as astonishing as it is worrying.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 05/04/2023 14:39

*It's not the bottom line because you're missing the point.

The discussion is about whether OP has done anything wrong. She has. You don't seem to understand what we are talking about.*

I'm really not. OP offered options. Parents need to be responsible for their kids. If you don't understand that your child being away with someone, doesn't absolve you of all responsibility, that's your choice as a parent.

Heronwatcher · 05/04/2023 14:36

I’d have been livid and yes I think you were being very U. There is no way I would expect someone else’s children to do a 2/4 hour journey on public transport at the age of 10. I also would absolutely not be happy to have a 23 yr old plus boyfriend left in charge. The minute you found out about the emergency you should have made a plan for all of the children, either another parent taking over or bringing them back (since it appears that you didn’t leave until the next day, why couldn’t you take them back straight away). In dealing with your own emergency you’ve created many more for other people. I would be willing to bet that most of the other parents have agreed with reluctance/ worry TBH and I’d be surprised if they were happy with this.

TorchwoodWho · 05/04/2023 14:25

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 05/04/2023 14:18

Not only a parent but a grandparent too!! 😱😱

Managed to get 4 kids to adulthood without any intervention from the police and they’re all very well adjusted (even with the younger 2 having their own challenges) - also supported various other kids with challenges through difficult times and into adulthood, so not sure how that makes me clueless. I know you’ll find it hard to believe but not everything has to be a massive drama and sometimes flexibility goes a long way.

The poster you are replying to seems to be out to insult others who don't completely agree and accuse them of not understanding, while not really answering most of the points made with anything substantial.
I'm sure they'll ironically condescend you soon by implying you "don't understand" the thread.

I agree that the other parent has made this a drama. Have they a right to be annoyed? Probably, they've been inconvenienced even if it can't be helped. Was threatening the police and mentioning kidnap a measured, reasonable response? Absolutely not, sounds like an adult throwing the dummy because they've had to do something unplanned.

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 05/04/2023 14:18

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 12:21

Worrying to think that people on here saying YANBU to the OP are actually parents. Clueless.

Not only a parent but a grandparent too!! 😱😱

Managed to get 4 kids to adulthood without any intervention from the police and they’re all very well adjusted (even with the younger 2 having their own challenges) - also supported various other kids with challenges through difficult times and into adulthood, so not sure how that makes me clueless. I know you’ll find it hard to believe but not everything has to be a massive drama and sometimes flexibility goes a long way.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/04/2023 14:02

Salemtrust · 05/04/2023 08:38

Sorry for disappearing. I've left now and dsd arrived in the night, they are sending someone else to collect their daughter today who is obviously extremely upset at having to leave her friends and not get to go to the event as are the other girls about her leaving.
So I guess it's been resolved now, there will probably be a fall out to deal with when I get home though.
To answer some of the main questions. The emergency involves a single parent family members younger children and a medical emergency that no one else can help with. This is my side of the family and a sensitive situations and I wouldn't expect or ask dsd to go and help instead. She's more than capable and comfortable with looking after her sister and her friends though which she has done before with different friends.
If any of the children were distressed I would arrange for them to travel home either by public transport or getting someone to come and collect them but they all were more than happy to stay with dsd, the two other parents are also more than happy for their kids to stay.
I obviously wasn't going to put their child on public transport without their consent, I just offered to cover the cost of that's the option they wanted.

"no one else can help with"

no one, including you, you are not available to help with this either, and it doesn't sound like an emergency that actually involved you as such

PinkStarAtNight · 05/04/2023 13:48

@SerafinasGoose
Another person's emergency shouldn't have to become my emergency. However, my child is involved, so this makes it mine. Work, caring, other commitments will have to be dropped whilst I go and get them

This is exactly the point though isn't it. The OP has made her emergency into the parent's emergency and imo thats unreasonable of her especially considering* *that we're clearly not talking about the heart attack of an immediate relative - OP had time to post on mumsnet, didn't have to leave until the next day and has now said it concerns the children of a relative. So, sounds like childcare. But the point is she was already in a childcaring role, looking after the group of girls in her care!

Yes, parents should always think about contingency plans and know that they can get to their child if needed. And yes, the accusations of kidnapping are OTT. But the OP asked if she had done anything wrong, to which the answer is yes. She took responsibility for a group of children, the children's parents trusted her to look after them but she then decided to palm them off on someone else unknown to the children and parents so that she could go look after a relative's children instead, presumably because she cares more about relatives children than the ones she agreed to care for. Even if you argue that its the parents responsibility to make sure they can get to their child/drop work/drop other commitments etc, its still bloody inconvenient, could cost them money/time that they can't really afford, cause all sorts of problems and the point is that this isn't what was agreed. The OP agreed to take care of those girls for the week and return them safely home.

The way I see it, the only way she can be forgiven for going back on that promise would be life threatening injury, natural disaster in which they get separated or the sudden or impending death of a very close family member. It doesn't sound like any of these things apply. So yes, she has done something wrong and she is unreasonable in this situation.

DonnaRix · 05/04/2023 13:43

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 13:28

It's not the bottom line because you're missing the point.

The discussion is about whether OP has done anything wrong. She has. You don't seem to understand what we are talking about.

Yeah the OP is in the wrong. But actually it doesn’t matter. Because the parent has ultimate responsibility. The parent needs to factor in bad behaviour from others and needs to be prepared to drop everything and go (or find someone who can). That’s the job.

IndianaJoanna · 05/04/2023 13:36

nomoremerlot · 05/04/2023 12:29

Like OP is taking notice of what you say!!

Even if you do use CAPITALS

GrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

Aren't you the smarmy one? I know your type and have nothing decent to say.

IamKlaus · 05/04/2023 13:28

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 05/04/2023 13:23

Whataboutery.

It's not though. OP family member has had an emergency that they need OP help for. The fact is all parents should have a back up plan in case of any emergencies. As you said Obviously its the parents responsibility to come and get their kid, no matter what.
That's the bottom line.

It's not the bottom line because you're missing the point.

The discussion is about whether OP has done anything wrong. She has. You don't seem to understand what we are talking about.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 05/04/2023 13:23

Whataboutery.

It's not though. OP family member has had an emergency that they need OP help for. The fact is all parents should have a back up plan in case of any emergencies. As you said Obviously its the parents responsibility to come and get their kid, no matter what.
That's the bottom line.

Swipe left for the next trending thread