Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you really think it's the death of the high street?

163 replies

HannahDee · 04/04/2023 18:48

I've just heard that a local Barclays is closing and a much loved department store. Do you think death of the high street is really happening or are we making too much of it?

OP posts:
gogohmm · 05/04/2023 08:30

@sixfoot as is Clifton. We are not too far, in a town and it's very busy on the high street, independent shops, cafes, restaurants and charity shops all thriving

Maray1967 · 05/04/2023 08:21

Rubygrapefruitwithchilli · 04/04/2023 19:19

I always think that where possible high streets could be adapted for elderly residents : so that they can have adapted housing, shops, hairdressers, launderettes, vets, dentists all in one easily accessible place. And then set out table and chairs in town squares for older folk to socialise in summer, just like in some other European countries.

That is an excellent plan. You need to be a local council planning officer.

GettingStuffed · 05/04/2023 08:10

Our local high street is full of barbers, hairdressers and charity shops. We used to have all the main banks but only Lloyds is left. There a few other shops and when I was in town 2 of the units gave new retailer coming soon.

Lazarusshazarus · 05/04/2023 08:02

@Feuillemille23 presumably Bolton ?
Agreed that somehow Bury reinvented itself, not sure how, maybe redevelopment of the rock, who knows...
The council, whatever its political hue, currently Conservative, has had to deal with massive cuts to public spending and still is. Also it has to contend with high levels of deprivation (unlike Bury to a degree). Unfortunately it's not got the calibre of leaders required to deal with these issues and there have been some questionable business dealings..

Florenz · 05/04/2023 07:21

They need to contract a lot of high streets/town centres since there isn't enough viable shops. Instead of leaving units empty just close a number of units at the edges and turn them into housing.

TodayInahurry · 05/04/2023 07:18

The small market town near me has lost loads of shops, including a small but useful M&S it is very run down, the council are trying hard but the shopping centre really struggles. Ten miles down the road we have a lovely large village with butcher, Hoxton bakery, greengrocer, cafes, etc. Really busy much more affluent customer base, large Waitrose up the road.

QuintanaRoo · 05/04/2023 07:15

I agree that retail will be mainly online with some out of town stuff. But even the out of town stuff is being affected by shops closing and empty units.

town centres are becoming more like leisure areas, so restaurants and bars mainly. With some charity shops, vaping shops and tattoo shops scattered about. Sad really.

Badbudgeter · 05/04/2023 07:09

Needmorelego · 05/04/2023 00:34

@thimblewomgee247 for swimming costumes I would try Sports Direct, JD Sports, Decathlon plus all the supermarkets.
@Badbudgeter wellies - places like Mountain Warehouse, Shoe Zone (they always have loads) and the supermarkets.

It was shoe zone I tried first! That store has now shut down. Then Asda/ Tesco I’d clearly missed the boat as they only had odd sizes left. Then I parked and went into town and still nada.

By the time I paid for petrol and the wasted time and stress of going to various shops with the dc it really put me off shopping in person with children. Ever since I buy lightweight wellies with liners from Amazon

youhavenoshameonyourface · 05/04/2023 01:21

The ridiculous parking charges have wiped out parts of out town. There's no point paying 1.50 to park for 20 minutes to spend £1.20 on a sausage roll, or to nip into superdrug for a tube of toothpaste.

Supermarkets have free parking and sell everything. Town centres are expensive to park and sell less. Supermarkets killed town centres - but everyone knows that really.

Partyandbullshit · 05/04/2023 01:04

Free parking would help - but lots of cars in town centers isn’t good.

High Streets need to be full of places people go because they need to do things in person: doctor, dentist, optician, Post Office, parcel drop off/pick up, cafes, bars, restaurants, libraries, community center, law courts, council offices, dry cleaner, pharmacy, beautification, hairdresser, barber, mini-supermarket for last minute pint of milk etc. They’d be bustling hubs if they had these amenities and service providers. But parking and public transport just doesn’t allow for it. It’s such disjointed thinking. The space is there, it’s just not being used properly.

Feuillemille23 · 05/04/2023 01:04

We moved to one of the north west ex mill towns beginning with B mentioned last summer for work and have been astonished at the bizarre way the council, er, run things compared to everywhere else we've lived. We were warned before we moved but we're still bewildered by the reality...my partner has suggested one of the reasons the council might actually not really want to be a city (rumour has it that this time round paperwork wasn't submitted on time) is because the accounts and goings on would be under a bit more scrutiny - it's a very plausible explanation. Meanwhile nearby Bury might be a bit rough and ready but it's certainly not dead....

PogoThePunk · 05/04/2023 00:55

My local town centre is dying a death due to the council ramping the rent and rates up to an unaffordable amount for the smaller retailer.
We used to have a fabulous large market, indoors and outdoors, but the council ramped the rent up for those too, again making it unaffordable to the smaller retailer.
So they closed their doors.
Then the larger retailers such as Debenhams and John Lewis closed their doors and that was that.
Not to mention the price of parking.
I had cause to go into the town centre last week and the cheapest car park was £3.50 for a minimum of 30 minutes, rising £1 per hour after that!
Now the council are sat scratching their heads wondering how to attract businesses and customers.

Needmorelego · 05/04/2023 00:53

@mariaantonia I find that when I am visiting family in the Midlands - it's literally like 5.30pm, shutters down, doors locked, town is CLOSED.
You'd think there was a curfew because the werewolves or zombies are coming out or something.

mariaantonia · 05/04/2023 00:41

Why does everything on the high street has to be closed by 5pm though? ISo people getting out of work walk past dozen of shuttered shops, can't sit down for a coffee or something to eat after work, can't shop for anything unless they go to a supermarket. The high street hasn't moved on from the times customers were mostly stay at home mothers. Even in touristy places in the summer, the high street shuts at 5pm, why? I get that people working in shops have always done it this way, but when your industry is dying it might be worth trying something new. I don't know, on the continent 5 to 7 is the busiest time in shops.

Needmorelego · 05/04/2023 00:34

@thimblewomgee247 for swimming costumes I would try Sports Direct, JD Sports, Decathlon plus all the supermarkets.
@Badbudgeter wellies - places like Mountain Warehouse, Shoe Zone (they always have loads) and the supermarkets.

Badbudgeter · 05/04/2023 00:00

thimblewomgee247 · 04/04/2023 20:08

It's annoying. I try and use the high street but it's very hard. I wanted some kids swim suits, H&M, M&S. next. All nothing (not limited choice). Had to order online

I found this when hunting for kids wellies one October. Drove to town multiple shops. Met with shrugs and we don't know when/ if stock will come in and if it will include wellies. Gave up, bought online, have never attempted to buy wellies in town since.

Lazarusshazarus · 04/04/2023 23:54

Maybe. Pre covid it was generally fairly busy. I suspect it was a target even then. Sadly it's the only reason most people went in town and now stores like waterstones which is directly opposite (our only bookshop) will no doubt shut too.

DeeCeeCherry · 04/04/2023 23:54

Online shopping killed the High Street years ago. I don't bother now the clothes are horrendous and you can never get the household items you want either. I'd love a return to a High Street full of independent shops and not fast fashion crap.

Needmorelego · 04/04/2023 23:51

@Lazarusshazarus I do agree that lack of decent public transport in a lot of places hasn't helped a lot of towns either.
If people can't get there....they can't shop there.

Needmorelego · 04/04/2023 23:50

@Lazarusshazarus the thing with M+S is they have closed branches down even when they actually own the building and there's no rent to pay.
The Food Hall side of M+S is doing ok but in general the company isn't doing very well.
Every town that has an M+S close always has loads of people saying things like "Such a shame/Heart and Soul of the town/I remember shopping here with my Nan in 1974...." but clearly not enough people were actually shopping there.
There's only so much a council can do but if people aren't using a shop it's gonna die.

youhavenoshameonyourface · 04/04/2023 23:49

SunshineGeorgie · 04/04/2023 18:55

It's all poundshops and vape shops here

Same.

And plastic shoes shops.

I really need some new shoes but if I buy them online they're always wrong. Please for the love of Geoff someone open a chain of decent high street shoe shops!

Lazarusshazarus · 04/04/2023 23:39

The impression I got off someone involved was that the council refused to compromise just like they did when they declined extending the manchester tram network as far as our town. Bury thrived (and was previously the poor cousin), Bolton saw a huge decline.

Lazarusshazarus · 04/04/2023 23:35

@Needmorelego the council were in talks with M and S re renegociating their rent.
We are literally a town of >300,000 people without even a largish town centre shop now.
We aren't in the leafy home counties. We have the worst empty shop ratio in the country (when I last looked).

Exl · 04/04/2023 22:45

It’s very real. Whenever I go to an actual shop the staff usually suggest I look at their stuff online.

Our high street has lost so many clothes shops. They’re being replaced with coffee shops which is fine with me 😁

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 04/04/2023 22:29

Yes, whilst town centre parking charges are high like they are in most places. It's why retail parks are much more convenient, if you have a car at least.

Even some retail parks are their own worst enemies. There's a really good one in a town near to us that is sadly spoiled by a 2-hour limit in the (very large) car park.

There are stores like Currys, Halford's and a couple of large furniture and carpet shops - plus several others too - not the kind of shops that you nip in and out of having spent a tenner, but where you buy big-ticket items that you want to take plenty of time looking at, asking questions about, planning, thinking and then maybe arranging finance for.

Two hours is ridiculously short for just one of them, let alone if you'd managed to get a day off and wanted to use it productively getting a new laptop, new three-piece suite and new bikes for the kids! Whereas you can do your online shopping and research all day and all night on a Sunday sitting on your sofa, if you want to.