Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you really think it's the death of the high street?

163 replies

HannahDee · 04/04/2023 18:48

I've just heard that a local Barclays is closing and a much loved department store. Do you think death of the high street is really happening or are we making too much of it?

OP posts:
mamabear715 · 05/04/2023 14:47

@Needmorelego I do agree - but you have to add on the cost of travel / parking too.

EffortlessDesmond · 05/04/2023 14:47

My small local town appears to be prosperous and thriving with a very strong food retail offer, several nice independent boutiques (aimed at quite middle-aged people), a Boots, Superdrug, WH Smith and a lively indoor market. Further out, there are three supermarkets, a farmer's merchant, dry cleaner etc, all with free parking. There are several town car parks but they are small, cheapish, short stay, or all day a bit further out for £2. And there's free on street parking around the compact centre of town, although the council would like to impose charges. It is possible to buy most things needed for everyday life, although I'd shop online for specialist items or a wider choice of clothing.

Needmorelego · 05/04/2023 14:45

@mamabear715 to be honest things like towels or potato peelers are products easily bought from the high street from shops like Wilkos, B+M, Home Bargains, Poundstretchers, Poundland (it's not all £1 cheap stuff - their Pep and Co range is reasonable quality).
The fact people will buy a potato peelers online is exactly why the High Street is dying.

MojoMoon · 05/04/2023 14:38

I don't think I've been in a bank branch for at least seven years.

Does anyone use them regularly barring the very elderly or those with significant special needs? Presumably if you can post on Mumsnet, you can use internet banking so so I would assume not.

I'm not sure you can expect private businesses like banks to maintain expensive real estate for a tiny number of customers with additional needs. Ideally they'd be a state owned bank at a state owned Royal Mail post office that perhaps the govt could support to stay open in more areas where people need more in-bank assistance.

*My parents are 74 and fairly sure they've not been to a bank branch for years either - so not saying all retired people are incapable of using online banking.

mamabear715 · 05/04/2023 14:32

@taxguru Your posts were spot on.
In the large city where I live, retail has been nudged to one area, & the other area which was SO vibrant when I was younger, will probably finish up as housing & attractive planted areas. Which is good, it will just take some time & meanwhile looks sad & run down.
The massive mall nearby is, as others have said, free parking - I personally don't drive (which also cuts down the many out-of-town centres I can get to) but why wouldn't drivers park for free? As a PP mentioned, city / town centres are still being operated as though we're still in the 80's. Back to the mall - I only really go to return goods bought online (eg New Look, Next) as all the shops are full of things you might want, but not need.. as another PP said, Pound shops to Chanel.. I used to like a browse around BHS, for example.. all gone.
I don't want / need £200 trainers, posh bath fizzers (omg, the stench of those shops!) new phones etc.. or cheap tat from shops with intruiging names so you get the impression they are 'high end'.. ;-)
If I want towels or a potato peeler, it's going to be online..

woodhill · 05/04/2023 14:00

There was an M&S food locally and it was well used and popular

Sometimes they shut shops even if they are an asset as there is some national policy itms

SmartHome · 05/04/2023 12:09

Tipping point

I also much prefer trying things on at home as well, where you can try with other clothes, shoes etc instead of hot, stuffy, smelly changing rooms with inadequate lighting and mirrors.

SmartHome · 05/04/2023 12:08

I agree.

It will be painful in the interim and the local councils need to be forced by the electorate to address it properly.

I personally have not shopped for clothes, swimming costumes, handbags in store for some years now. There was a ripping point where it wasn't worth it for the returns hassle but most retailers have made that much more palatable now. I often order 4 or 5 sizes, after checking whether they offer free returns, which most reputable places do now, and send all or any back. I am lucky that I live near multiple places where I can easily do this either with Evri returns in local garages, or Amazon lockers, in local garages, the pharmacy, the supermarket. I do have a printer at home to print the bar code but you don't even need that anymore, you can scan them from your phone and get labels etc at the location. I just drop things on my way to work or when filling up with petrol.

I can't remember the time I last had to go into a bank, though I do appreciate for some their disappearance from the high street is annoying.

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/04/2023 11:03

I don’t think it’s dying, rather evolving.

RaraRachael · 05/04/2023 11:00

I can't stand online shopping. Even though I don't work any more I still can't be arsed with returning stuff that looked nice but either doesn't fit or is poor quality. I was trying to order swimwear recently and gave up as there was nowhere to buy locally and nothing suitable online - after about 10 attempts.
I don't know how people who work can find time to be taking stuff back.
I used to like a day out in Aberdeen to the big shops but even that's shite now.

Ifailed · 05/04/2023 10:53

I've just heard that a local Barclays is closing and a much loved department store.

Presumably they are both closing because they didn't have enough customers to justify staying open? The problem, if there is one, lies at the hands (or feet) of the people in the town.

girlfriend44 · 05/04/2023 10:51

SunshineGeorgie · 04/04/2023 18:55

It's all poundshops and vape shops here

No.pound shops here. They can't make a profit anymore on things costing a pound.

maddening · 05/04/2023 10:50

Florenz · 05/04/2023 07:21

They need to contract a lot of high streets/town centres since there isn't enough viable shops. Instead of leaving units empty just close a number of units at the edges and turn them into housing.

Totally agree - people living in the centre keep it alive.

Elphame · 05/04/2023 10:49

Yes I would say so. My local one is now full of coffee shops, places to have your nails done and cheap discounters selling overstock and short dated groceries.

If I head into the city, many shops are empty and those that are left have poor stock levels and Im frequently told if I want my size (10/12 so nothing out of the ordinary) I can order for pick up the next day. I’m not going to go to that inconvenience nor pay another parking charge.

Generally I come home empty handed and do order online. I very rarely bother now. Can’t remember the last time I went shopping in the city tbh.

Knullrufs · 05/04/2023 10:48

I think it's stratifying (is that the right word?) and has been for 20 years.

Eventually it'll be pound shops and Chanel, with not much in-between.

The shift to online has been gathering pace for 15 years or so now, that's where the bulk of trade is going to happen over the next few decades.

I think city centres and high streets need to rethink what they're for. Edinburgh (Princes Street in particular) is looking a bit sad of late. At least half the shops on Princes Street are shuttered up. Even Multrees Walk is looking gappy these days. (Although there's a Genesis showroom popping up soon which will help.) I wonder if in time, high streets will shift more to a mix of entertainment, living/accommodation and food/restaurants, with fewer shops in the mix.

RaraRachael · 05/04/2023 10:45

I was in our local big town (pop around 20 000) twice last week - Tuesday afternoon and Friday morning and it was like a complete ghost town. There's a smallish mall with just WH Smith, 2 phone shops and Argos in it. there used to be Monsoon, Dorothy Perkins, New Look, Superdrug etc. It's all so depressing and I can't see it getting any better.
There's an out of town retail park but a lot of people get the bus to the town and it doesn't go anywhere near the retail park.

QueefQueen80s · 05/04/2023 10:44

TheGuv1982 · 04/04/2023 18:49

I think it’s going through a period of change. My hope is that more independent shops pop up as the large chains retract. My fear as that as retail units become empty, they’re sold off for flats.

That's whats happening in Leeds, no other big stores or restaurants want the empty Debenhams, house of fraser etc do they are becoming student flats. Better than being empty I guess.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 05/04/2023 10:42

I love my town centre but all the self service tills are ruining it for me

icelolly12 · 05/04/2023 10:34

With more people working from home and hybrid working it's much more convenient now to order online and get it delivered. Many market towns seem to be mainly coffee shops now and tend to be busy enough with mainly the retired keeping them going!

However, bigger town centres are now dire to the point of feeling unsafe and it being a miserable experience going in to one. I think Primark is keeping a lot of towns open, if they switch to online orders that would have a catastrophic impact.

University cities tend to have more going on and more vibrancy, but the design of towns does needs a rethink as others have mentioned many are turning into nothing more than 'hanging out' spots for immigrants and homeless/drug addicts.

boboshmobo · 05/04/2023 10:29

I think next are taking it over , having taken over a few stores and are basically a department store by proxy now !

This and their credit account has kept it afloat !

Pretty genius tbh

thebellagio · 05/04/2023 10:18

It's a strange one. My local high street is decimated. There's literally 5 empty shops in between each open shop and parking is insanely expensive - we went to see a show at our local theatre recently, and it cost £7 to park for 3 hours.

Councils seem stuck in an 80s mindset of what a high street should look like.

When I've travelled to somewhere like a big shopping centre, it's vaguely price pointed, so John Lewis is with M&S, Joules, Fat Face, White Stuff (targeting the same demographic) and New Look is near Primark and River Island, so you feel like there's loads of shops to look in your budget. But in our town, each shop is about 15 min walk from one another, passing about 9 empty shops, so it feels much worse than it is.

Shops aren't helping themselves. They don't carry in many sizes - if you ask, you get told "you can order online" - well, there's no point in coming into your store is there?!

Our town also only open 9am-5pm Monday-Saturdays. So I cant nip in and get anything during the week, and now people are working from home, they've lost the lunchtime trade as well. On a weekend, a Saturday is taken up with DC activities, leaving only Sundays, which is when all the independent shops are shut. So even when I want to buy something, I literally can't.

Our town council are so against the out of town retail parks, that they put up huge barriers. It was well known that M&S wanted to look at moving into an old Toys R Us unit - a huge one, which could have been awesome for homewares and everything else. But our council literally bought the unit to prevent M&S from moving in and to keep them on the high street. M&S are now known to be closing stores - why the fuck would they choose to keep our store open when the council have literally prevented them from expanding?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 05/04/2023 09:26

Not to mention the price of parking.
I had cause to go into the town centre last week and the cheapest car park was £3.50 for a minimum of 30 minutes, rising £1 per hour after that!

Mad, isn't it? And although the cost of the parking is the main issue, it's also the hassle of having to queue to buy a ticket, have the right money or app, go back to your car to display it etc. With free parking, it doesn't just cost you no money, but it also costs you much less time, when you can pull into a space, get out and go straight to grab whatever you want to buy.

About 15 miles away from us, there is an extremely busy massive shopping centre, with loads of car parking. People go there specially, obviously likely to be there for hours, if not all day. They could make an absolute fortune if they charged for parking, but they don't: all of the parking is totally free. Unlike most local councils, the real professionals who run the centre understand just how much offering free parking ultimately adds to the balance sheet overall.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 05/04/2023 08:41

Staines has the right idea. There is a retail park with cinema etc. (plus shed loads of parking) but instead of being out of town it's directly behind the high street. A proper street market is held twice a week.
Car park is always heaving. Town centre is busy.
There has been a bit of contraction (e.g. Debenham closed) but it's actually holding up very well.

Itstillgoeson · 05/04/2023 08:39

taxguru · 04/04/2023 19:11

It's been happening for a few decades. Out of town supermarkets moved out first, leaving towns without supermarkets. Then retail parks started taking out other chain stores like Currys, Halfords, WHS, Clarks, M&S etc. Now department stores are closing because they're an outdated model.

Smaller towns were hit first but now it's affecting the bigger towns and cities too. Even before covid, there were lots of smaller towns where the High Street was just charity shops, betting shops, Greggs, etc. and nothing else. People are only waking up to it because it's starting to hit the city centres which were previously relatively unscathed.

There's no going back. Retail is now "out of town" or online. Yes, maybe some independents will move into the High Street, but there won't be many of them as people will buy most of what they want on the internet or in retail parks, so basically, just "niche" shops, along with a sprinkling of "leisure", cafes/restaurants, etc.

High Streets and town centres will inevitably have to be re-purposed for housing (like they were before the chain stores took over the High Street), so whether that's by demolition or by conversion, it will be the future. The High Street of the last few decades will never come back.

Unfortunately, I think this is one of the best descriptions. Hopefully there can be regulations to ensure that these repurposed areas are useful, safe and accessible - nice lighting that makes them safe at night, play areas, greenery, essential services if only on a small scale. This has happened in some countries. Too many UK town centres in places that are not touristy or in the SE seem to have become grim (including the place I grew up).

GlassBunion · 05/04/2023 08:36

There are many empty units in our high street but it's hard to see how small retailers and independents can move in as long as the rents remain sky high by greedy landlords.

I'm not sure how high streets can evolve unless this issue is addressed.